Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[alannalynn]

Go read the mafiascum wiki then if you don't understand a role. I would think that, being a LD before, you would have researched that role and it's counter. I personally would if I wasn't familiar.  I used to act confused as mafia when I didn't want a flub to be a scumtell.

As for picking up on the hints, someone mentioned the way Mish phrased her statement earlier in the game. I first got the notion there might be a LD when Des asked for the mason statement. I was happy to let the LD stay hidden, personally.

[Darthe]

^This.

[Krakalakachkn]

I googled silvertongue and mafiascum but didn't get a definition.  Why don't we not assume that everybody is less smart than everyone else.  I guarantee you I know how to use Google.

 

As for picking up on the hints, someone mentioned the way Mish phrased her statement earlier in the game. I first got the notion there might be a LD when Des asked for the mason statement. I was happy to let the LD stay hidden, personally.

 

Yeah, I was the first person to mention that and I was perfectly happy to let the LD stay hidden too.  Notice I was pushing for Mish to clarify her statement so the LD could check it (if there was one), not actually looking to out the LD.  Also, good job backhand complimenting yourself at my expense.

[alannalynn]

I googled silvertongue and mafiascum but didn't get a definition.  Why don't we not assume that everybody is less smart than everyone else.  I guarantee you I know how to use Google.

 

As for picking up on the hints, someone mentioned the way Mish phrased her statement earlier in the game. I first got the notion there might be a LD when Des asked for the mason statement. I was happy to let the LD stay hidden, personally.

 

Yeah, I was the first person to mention that and I was perfectly happy to let the LD stay hidden too.  Notice I was pushing for Mish to clarify her statement so the LD could check it (if there was one), not actually looking to out the LD.  Also, good job backhand complimenting yourself at my expense.

Thanks, I really do try.

[hazelkrs1]

Way too much for me to respond to ATM, but for now I feel confident in inviting, voting Krak.

 

He was already pinging to me, he hasn't cc'ed the LD claim which would have been the only explanation for the interaction between him and Mish, and his recent responses don't do anything for me.

 

I think its possible Wombat could be the ST, he still seems scummy to me and he seems prickly about the LD/ST role, could be possible distancing from the ST role itself.

 

Darthe is a complete tool, and prob scum. He should be lynched tomorrow IMO, or at the very least checked soon in some way.

 

Mish honey, that claim really wasnt necessary btw. Dont let yourself do something as big a deal as claiming early when youre a little upset (it seems thats what happened). Just wait a little and respond when youre more calm, or just ignore the pushing. Also, don't breadcrumb or role hint, ever. Helps out the mafia team WAY more than it'll help justify your claim later, and mafia can breadcrumb a fake claim too. Don't know why me asking if you were masons with Kaylee day 1 makes you suspicious of me btw. Both of you had defended each other day 1, that looks incredibly suspicious to me in any game.

 

Also dont think what Peace did was that bad per se. He was trying to push at someone he thought could be scum imo, just made the wrong guess as to who might have been LD.

[hazelkrs1]

I'm back at work tonight tho so I can respond to a lot of other stuff that I saw

[Krakalakachkn]

Way too much for me to respond to ATM, but for now I feel confident in inviting, voting Krak.

 

Of course not, because I'm not scum and you know it.

 

Darthe is a complete tool, and prob scum.

 

Wtf is wrong with you?

[WWWwombat]

unvote

Vote: Despo

 

I cannot tolerate this cretin any longer.

[Krakalakachkn]

Seriously, regardless of what alignment he is, he's bringing down the game by acting like a douchebag.

[michellem]

Don't try to buddy with me Des, and don't call me "honey". It's patronizing and uneccessary.

[Darthe]

im getting a lot of that lately...

[WWWwombat]

All aboard!

[WWWwombat]

im getting a lot of that lately...

Yeah but Des prides himself on being superior to the JN "riff raff."

[Darthe]

we aren't lynching him for something other than his play, so no.  i would rather krak, not bob, or vam

[Darthe]

 

im getting a lot of that lately...

Yeah but Des prides himself on being superior to the JN "riff raff."

 

 

you mean that group of people who D1's me every time for being me?

[Tigraine]

Popular tonight aren't you despo?

[WWWwombat]

we aren't lynching him for something other than his play, so no. i would rather krak, not bob, or vam

Not sure exactly what you mean by this but Des' play has been terrible. That last post of his alone had 85265 things wrong with it.

[Vambram]

I have had a slight town read towards Despo for most of this game. However, his posts today have given me a totally different read on him. 

 

 

VOTE Despo

[Darthe]

 

we aren't lynching him for something other than his play, so no. i would rather krak, not bob, or vam

Not sure exactly what you mean by this but Des' play has been terrible. That last post of his alone had 85265 things wrong with it.

 

 

Some of his posts are off and I don't like him much this game, but I am trying to stay unbiased and it looks like he is actually scumhunting to me.  idk..

[peacesells]

I have had a slight town read towards Despo for most of this game. However, his posts today have given me a totally different read on him.

 

 

VOTE Despo

Please explain why you think this.

[WWWwombat]

Things Desp did wrong in his post:

 

1. Bandwagon vote on Krak with a good deal of words but no original reasoning.

 

2. Says I'm still scummy without elaboration on that and then tries to paint me as a silvertongue when I've been denouncing the LD role every chance I get for the last 3 years.

 

3. Gratuitous and baseless mudslinging at Darthe.

 

4. Mentoring/buddying attempt towards Mish.

 

5. La pièce de résistance. Defends Peace's garbage logic for rolefishing. I don't care if Peace had a scum read on Mish. He shouldn't have pushed her about the LD stuff unless he had an investigative result incriminating her. Not on D3 with the cop outed. Now the doc has to WIFOM for the foreseeable future because of Peace's buffoonery.

 

Despo and Peace need to die ASAP.

[WWWwombat]

Things Desp did wrong in his post:

 

1. Bandwagon vote on Krak with a good deal of words but no original reasoning.

 

2. Says I'm still scummy without elaboration on that and then tries to paint me as a silvertongue when I've been denouncing the LD role every chance I get for the last 3 years.

 

3. Gratuitous and baseless mudslinging at Darthe.

 

4. Mentoring/buddying attempt towards Mish.

 

5. La pièce de résistance. Defends Peace's garbage logic for rolefishing. I don't care if Peace had a scum read on Mish. He shouldn't have pushed her about the LD stuff unless he had an investigative result incriminating her. Not on D3 with the cop outed. Now the doc has to WIFOM for the foreseeable future because of Peace's buffoonery.

 

Despo and Peace need to die ASAP.

[wheeloftime13]

Official Vote Count 

Womby (1/9): Thorum
Thorum (1/9): Player
Vambram (3/9):  Hallia, peace, Razen

kraka (5/9): Mish, Bob, Tigraine, alannalynn, Despo

Despo (2/9): Womby, Vambram

deadline is Tuesday at 20:00 EST 
http://www.timeandda...lin Mafia Day 3

[Vambram]

What I disliked the most about Despo's posts today are the unnecessary insults to Darthe and the baldfaced patronizing towards Misheru. To me, stuff like that just screams scummy. I could be wrong, but that is the way that I see it.

 

 

Hmmm, I forgot to do an unvote.

 

 

UNVOTE Thorum

 

VOTE Despo

[hazelkrs1]

Meh, lynch away. I could give two craps and I've lost interest in this game anyways. So much bs that I keep trying to call others on and everyone ignores it.

 

Darthe us a tool because he thinks he "broke" the ST role with a far fetched ploy that wouldn't work IMO. And once again he'd rather try some ridiculous scheme to try and whittle down the list to scumhunt with, instead of just actually looking for svcummy behavior.

 

I had already explained my suspicions on Krak, I never parroted anyone. He tunneled on Basel day 1 for no reason, and I called him out for it. The recent LD/ST thing was just icing on the cake.

 

Wombat, I've stated quite clearly for some time now that I had a scumread on you. You're off your town meta (hyper aggressive instead of just prickly). Your cases have beenweak. You were on both trains which led to townie deaths. As NotBob pointed out, only 4 people were on it, one is a claimed LD who cleared on of the others (Mish, Thorum iI believe). That leaves you and Krak.

 

I'm pretty confident that Krak is scum, and Wombat and Darthe are my other big scumreads.

 

My only town reads are Mish, NotBob, and Peace. TG's last few posts also endeared me somewhat to his towniness as well.

 

As for the patronizing thing, I honestly felt kinda bad for Mish. I was scum in another game and helped railroad her, and partially exploited her emotional play there, and it looked like she got emotional and claimed early because of that as well. If y'all wanna lynch me for feeling bad for someone else, have fun. I'm town tho, not scum or third party or anything else, and I win with town.