Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[peacesells]

hmm

 

your only reason is cuz i mentioned a hypothetical situation, if you notice the many "IF"'s there  

 

No..read my post again. 

 

You state "if THE vig....blah blah blah" as if a vig's existence is known.  How would you know?  Then when questioned about it you state Krak mentioned there was a vig.  He did no such thing. 

 

Basically it looks like you are trying sew confusion on who committed the nk. 

[Tigraine]

 

 

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

This post is where Krak mentions the word Vig. He doesn't come close to implying there is one existing.

I was answering lolguy's question for Tiinker. That's why I didn't imply anything.

So it's not scummy when you answer a question meant for someone else but it IS when I do it?

[Thorum]

Roles can be used double/triple/... Characters cannot. Hence, a character reveal is a lot stronger, and very much preferable to town.

[Tigraine]

Rhea3, the red is not a threat, but a precaution/terrible joke.

 

Krak, if you agree that it`s a strange nightkill: why vote tigraine?

Apparently he has chosen to ignore this question cause I asked it too

 

Then he calls me out for something he had just done

[lolguy26]

 

hmm

 

your only reason is cuz i mentioned a hypothetical situation, if you notice the many "IF"'s there  

 

No..read my post again. 

 

You state "if THE vig....blah blah blah" as if a vig's existence is known.  How would you know?  Then when questioned about it you state Krak mentioned there was a vig.  He did no such thing. 

 

Basically it looks like you are trying sew confusion on who committed the nk. 

 

 

well honestly im pretty sure there's a vig this game, most advanced games have some sort of vig, so it isnt exactly an impossible suggestion 

[Krakalakachkn]

Rhea3, the red is not a threat, but a precaution/terrible joke.

 

Krak, if you agree that it`s a strange nightkill: why vote tigraine?

 

What she said and how she worded sounded to me like she was trying to come across as extremely town.  And before you say that everyone tries to come across as town, know that I know that.  The statements struck me as off, and so I voted.  

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

 

Vig is more likely to hit town, at least at first.

This post is where Krak mentions the word Vig. He doesn't come close to implying there is one existing.

I was answering lolguy's question for Tiinker. That's why I didn't imply anything.

So it's not scummy when you answer a question meant for someone else but it IS when I do it?

 

 

For the record, you asked the question, then responded to a follow-up question.  I actually interposed myself and answered a question lolguy asked of Tiinker.  

 

This kind of question noted above is relatively useless except in the he said/she said back and forth's so beloved by current U.S. political parties. Yes, it very well could be scummier for you to answer a question for someone else than if I did.  Or Wombat did.  Or anyone else.

[Tigraine]

I must be to daft to see how that makes sense

[WWWwombat]

Roles can be used double/triple/... Characters cannot. Hence, a character reveal is a lot stronger, and very much preferable to town.

You think there would be 2 or 3 cops in this game?

 

Also, we're all getting sidedtracked. TGlems is scum. We should lynch him.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Roles can be used double/triple/... Characters cannot. Hence, a character reveal is a lot stronger, and very much preferable to town.

You think there would be 2 or 3 cops in this game?

 

Also, we're all getting sidedtracked. TGlems is scum. We should lynch him.

 

 

Would you bet your life?

 

Also, what do you think about Tiinker?

[peacesells]

I must be to daft to see how that makes sense

 

It's because he is scum.

[Thorum]

In this game? Yes, there could be multiple doctors. Thogh probably not.

[Tiinker]

Okie dokie then....

 

I want Tiink to answer my question- what was his reasoning for voting Basel when he did and why didnt he ever explain?

 

vote Tiink

 

His vote placement, putting Basel up to a competing train, was a big move IMO. I'd STILL like to hear the explanation of what he though made Basel look scummy.

 

I came in and voted Basel because his own voting and his reasoning was fairly crap both times. Wombat explains it well enough for me here

 

 

Unvote, vote Hally. I've been pondering this for a while as it seems the Tiink train has derailed. Hally keeps pinging for me, though. I really don't like the buddying act.

This is crap imo btw. The Hallia suspicion didn't start in earnest until shortly before this post. If Basel was thinking of switching a vote because the Tiink train derailed, why would he be thinking about someone who had very little momentum at the time? My assessment is that Basel is trying to save his own skin and for some reason doesn't want to vote Kaylee.

 

I didn't fully agree with the second part but the bolded part was all true.

 

I didn't come in like I said I would because RL got in the way, so that's my bad.

[michellem]

well the doc would most likely protect hal, and since she claimed vig, a fairly new mafia would do their best to take out all the kills which they cant control, hence why its the most logical choice, and im not voting her for questioning it, its more cuz she's trying too hard for the confused townie..

 

 

 Someone very unexpected was nightkilled.

 

 

i dont agree with that btw, it isnt unexpected, especially in an advanced game, its normal  

 

Bolded purple: And who do you propose that is the fairly new mafia? As far as I know, it's all pretty seasoned players in this game. That is just not thought through at all and feels like mafia trying to put the blame on the new ones (wich is always so easy to do), except... There are no new ones. Oops.

 

That combined with the other mess you're sprouting now...

 

Vote Chuckles

[lolguy26]

That's horrible reasoning mish, almost as bad as despo's

[michellem]

Well you are saying the most logical choice for a NK would be Kaylee if it was a fairly new mafia. But there are no fairly new players. So it's your logic that's horrible, not mine. And to me it looks like you're trying to distance yourself away from the mafia, with the idea of a new mafia, since you are not a new player.

[Krakalakachkn]

I must be to daft to see how that makes sense

 

The first or second part?

[Tigraine]

Okay tiink disagrees with chuckles and chuckles asks why then you came in with an answer. All I done was clarify what I thought you meant by your quoting kaylees post claiming vig.

 

 

I think the point he's tryin to make is that he isn't the one who first suggested a vig..it was kaylee claiming it that brought the idea to the discussion

 

See, now I know you're trying to be helpful, but that wasn't a great move. I goofed and have been called out and for you to come in and try to put words into my mouth, no matter how nice or helpful you're trying to be, can be bad for you (should I be lynched/killed and turn out scum). Also, if I were mafia and trying to come up with an excuse or parry, you gave me one just now that I could maybe roll with.

 

 

I must be to daft to see how that makes sense

The first or second part?

I don't understand ANY of it!!!

[Tigraine]

You have called me out 2 times. Once for saying I don't understand why the mafia would kill a claimed vig...still think it was a stupid move for the mafia. Then you, in a round about way, explain the very point I was trying to make.

 

2nd time you call me out for trying to clarify something you were making a halfhearted attempt to explain even though you were trying to clarify something for someone else. Call it OMGUS if you want but that's just scummy UNVOTE VOTE KRAK

[wheeloftime13]

Official Vote Count 

TG (1/10): Womby
Tiink (1/10): Bob
Tigraine (2/10): Kraka, Chuckles
Chuckles (3/10): Despo, peace, Mish
Womby (1/10): Thorum

Kraka (1/10): Tigraine

Deadline: Friday 20:00 EST http://www.timeandda...lin Mafia Day 2

[WWWwombat]

 

 

 

Roles can be used double/triple/... Characters cannot. Hence, a character reveal is a lot stronger, and very much preferable to town.

You think there would be 2 or 3 cops in this game?

 

Also, we're all getting sidedtracked. TGlems is scum. We should lynch him.

Would you bet your life?

 

Also, what do you think about Tiinker?

Not gonna answer the rolefishing.

 

Tiinker's one of the more pro-town players in this game imo. Which, since almost everyone is pretty damn scummy, means I have a slight town read on him.

[Thorum]

Is everyone here as experienced as mish wants us to believe?

 

Also, chuckles is very quiet about it, but he did EXACTLY the same thing as krak. Hence: unvote and vote chuckles.

[WWWwombat]

As far as I'm concerned, both Mish and Chuckles are "fairly new."

[WWWwombat]

1. Vambram - newish (been playing for a while but not very often)

2. Darthe - vet

3. Basel  Hunith, vanilla town, lynched Day 1 - vet

4. lolguy26 - new

5. Krakalakachkn - old but rusty

6. 鲍勃不是我的名字 - old

7. Hallia - new

8. Wwwombat - old

9. dapianoplay3r - oldish

10. Tigraine - old but rusty

11. peacesells - creaky bones, get off his lawn

12. Rhea - new

13. Tiinker - newish

14. alannalynn - oldish but rusty

15. Kaylee Nimueh, Serial Killer, killed Night 1 - new

16. TGlems - new

17. Despothera - vet

18. Mish - new

19. Razen - vet

20. Thorum - ancient

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

1. Vambram - newish (been playing for a while but not very often)

2. Darthe - vet

3. Basel  Hunith, vanilla town, lynched Day 1 - vet

4. lolguy26 - new

5. Krakalakachkn - old but rusty

6. 鲍勃不是我的名字 - old

7. Hallia - new

8. Wwwombat - old

9. dapianoplay3r - oldish

10. Tigraine - old but rusty

11. peacesells - creaky bones, get off his lawn

12. Rhea - new

13. Tiinker - newish

14. alannalynn - oldish but rusty

15. Kaylee Nimueh, Serial Killer, killed Night 1 - new

16. TGlems - new

17. Despothera - vet

18. Mish - new

19. Razen - vet

20. Thorum - ancient

 

 

I'm not old.  I'm well seasoned.  

 

Unvote, Vote WWWWombat