Lord of the Rings Mafia [Advanced Mafia] Town Wins!!!!

[dapianoplay3r]

Thought you might say that

regardless my vote stays

 

like you say the fewer unconfirmed the better. And a killing uncpnfirmed is a likly mafia

[csarmi]

Well, I killed Basel Night 1 and BG Night 3. According to the notes left to me, anyway.

 

I win with town, you can lynch me for information I suppose, we can afford that.

[csarmi]

Also that'd be doing me a favour, I don't have to do a full re-read then. :)

[dapianoplay3r]

So odd night Vig

 

And you shot a mason and the even night Vig?

[csarmi]

Yea I suppose the mason shot must have been to clear things up. That's the best reasoning I can attach to that anyway. We can but speculate.

As for the shot at night 1, I can't even do that.

 

I suppose I managed to continue this great series by shooting the cop. Sue me.

What stood out for me was the "Thorkin is an LLL" post he made.

[csarmi]

Anywqay, I'll be back in a few hours. It's morning time for me and I gotta get going. To work :(

[dapianoplay3r]

Yea I suppose the mason shot must have been to clear things up. That's the best reasoning I can attach to that anyway. We can but speculate.As for the shot at night 1, I can't even do that.I suppose I managed to continue this great series by shooting the cop. Sue me.What stood out for me was the "Thorkin is an LLL" post he made.

Why?

I would of said the exact same thing. I think I even quoted and liked that post

[csarmi]

I didn't have much to go on as a replacement.

I dunno, it just felt off to me. I thought he might know, not just guess. I took him for a likely maffia member.

 

I read the list about who is who, tried to figure out what's been going on and decided that I can't really go wrong with a safe kill. Dice looked like one, also my guts told me he was up to something.

[csarmi]

So...

 

[dapianoplay3r]

Yea it's more your replacements I have an issue with

 

But still can't take the chance you aren't mafia faking

[Talya]

It would be good to see the write of those kills. Can'tt on phone and won't be back until late.

[WWWwombat]

Csarmi's claim makes sense imo. His kill didn't as Dice was obviously hinting cop yesterday, but we all make mistakes from time to time.

[dapianoplay3r]

I can't think of a character for it

 

The claim fits with the even Vig. But that could just be clever mafia

[Turin Turambar]

There is no way killing BG on night three was a town move.

 

vote Csarmi

[lolguy26]

im dead 

 

[WWWwombat]

I can think of a character for csarmi's claim pretty easily. His role complements Basel's role. Look at Basel's character.

[WWWwombat]

I say we give csarmi another chance to prove his quality.

[WWWwombat]

Also, just reading the past couple pages, it looks like Nya is mafia. She had no read on Thorkin for a long time and then overexplained her vote on him (which was in a likely bus position btw) after Tigs guiltied him.

 

Vote: Nya

[Nyanna al'Meara]

Craap i missed night...

 

I didn't have much to go on as a replacement.

I dunno, it just felt off to me. I thought he might know, not just guess. I took him for a likely maffia member.

 

I read the list about who is who, tried to figure out what's been going on and decided that I can't really go wrong with a safe kill. Dice looked like one, also my guts told me he was up to something.

Cmon, plenty of discussion's gone on casting more suspiciousness on other players. Even I have been FoS'ed more than Dice. Feels to me like it's an attempt to brush off a townie kill as an accident using the fact you've just been replaced in as an excuse. Not good enuffs in my book :p

 

Vote Csarmi

 

im dead

 

...dem eyyyees...

 

Interesting, Womby. Not saying votes on me would be unusual, but you're coming across at trying hard to defend and distract from Csarmi...

[WWWwombat]

Missed night my foot.

 

Csarmi is town. I am sure of it.

[Nyanna al'Meara]

Yuh, ask Rand, I slept through deadline :/

 

XD not that its relevant right now

[Nyanna al'Meara]

You saying you know for certain?

[WWWwombat]

Assuming csarmi is not counterclaimed, then I'm 99% sure he is town. I do not say that lightly. I would bet the game on it without hesitation.

[csarmi]

Csarmi's claim makes sense imo. His kill didn't as Dice was obviously hinting cop yesterday, but we all make mistakes from time to time.

I don't believe that was a mistake TBH. Not mine, anyway.

You're right that it sounds like a cop hinting. Which makes zero sense at this point. I mean, what reason could Dice possibly have had not to speak up openly?

[csarmi]

Now about the Vig role and what to do with it.

 

Being the new kid on the block makes me a natural target for a lynch. As I've started midgame, you've got no read on my play at all.

IE, I got no history...

We got a saying in Hungary, it translates to "The guy coming from abroad can say whatever he wants to".

 

I don't think it's the correct play to lynch me. Player's got a good point - but the more unconfirmed people die, the better we're off and my Vig kills help that. While it's true that it should be quite a safe move to lynch me (we seem to have a lot of room for errors with so many confirmed players and so many scum caught), I don't see the reason why should we lose the Vig kill I can do on Night 7.

 

If you want to lynch me this day, go ahead. I'm not very deep in the game yet.

If you don't lynch me now, however, I do suggest that you wait until day 8.