Enter the Dragon Mafia [Basic] D5: Town Wins!!

[Tiinker]

Nolder, why are you so insistant learning what her claim is exactly? Maybe she has some reasons to keep that hidden.

It's a basic game so I wouldn't count on any elaborate role. The mafia obviously know her role now because they know who they've targeted. If it's not who they targeted then she's the cop. If it is then she's the doc. So if they know I don't get why she wouldn't want town to know. 

[csarmi]

I dunno. This is all confusing to me, I mean, how on earth could there be 0/2 night kills?

[michellem]

Csarmi, you didn't answer me. I want you to answer me.

[Nolder]

It matters because if she is mafia and she leaves it ambiguous she's not stepping on anyone's toes. If she claims doc or cop and is lying then we'll have a counter claim.

[csarmi]

Csarmi, you didn't answer me. I want you to answer me.

I didn't answer you about what?

[Hallia]

 

Nolder, why are you so insistant learning what her claim is exactly? Maybe she has some reasons to keep that hidden.

It's a basic game so I wouldn't count on any elaborate role. The mafia obviously know her role now because they know who they've targeted. If it's not who they targeted then she's the cop. If it is then she's the doc. So if they know I don't get why she wouldn't want town to know. 

 

 

You're right.  With an advanced game it'd be ok to keep it quiet, and they might not be sure, but they'll know anyways now, I saved 2 nights in a row. 

[michellem]

How do you clear players without the mafia knowing at some point? Hallia has three town; better she tells us now, than waits two more nights finding only townies, and then getting NKed before she can tell us anything.

 

What kind of WIFOM do you think the mafia can do from that post of yours, hm? I can think of at least two on the two first points.

[Tiinker]

I dunno. This is all confusing to me, I mean, how on earth could there be 0/2 night kills?

Doc doing a kickass job.

[csarmi]

How do you clear players without the mafia knowing at some point? Hallia has three town; better she tells us now, than waits two more nights finding only townies, and then getting NKed before she can tell us anything.

 

What kind of WIFOM do you think the mafia can do from that post of yours, hm? I can think of at least two on the two first points.

You mean this one? I asked you about the flavour of wine then you threw the question right back to me. Well, maybe you should answer it yourself.

[csarmi]

I will answer you though... I don't have a clue. That's why I asked you.

[csarmi]

Interesting. Now how do we confirm this?

[michellem]

Taking the easy way out... I think you're mafia together with Tsuki.

 

Well if you can't answer it, I'm not gonna give you the answer either and risk it getting thrown right back at me in a day or two. Honestly, I thought you'd been playing for years; you should be able to answer that...

[csarmi]

Hally, just to confirm:

 

As a doc, you have protected someone else but you each night and you believe that the maffia targeted those players for NK.

[Nolder]

 

 

Nolder, why are you so insistant learning what her claim is exactly? Maybe she has some reasons to keep that hidden.

It's a basic game so I wouldn't count on any elaborate role. The mafia obviously know her role now because they know who they've targeted. If it's not who they targeted then she's the cop. If it is then she's the doc. So if they know I don't get why she wouldn't want town to know. 

 

 

You're right.  With an advanced game it'd be ok to keep it quiet, and they might not be sure, but they'll know anyways now, I saved 2 nights in a row. 

 

Ok so you're claiming Doc. Who did you protect on which nights?

[csarmi]

Taking the easy way out... I think you're mafia together with Tsuki.

 

Well if you can't answer it, I'm not gonna give you the answer either and risk it getting thrown right back at me in a day or two. Honestly, I thought you'd been playing for years; you should be able to answer that...

Me taking the easy way out? I asked you a question, you refused to answer and threw it back to me and I'm the one with the easy way out. :)

 

Fine.

[Hallia]

I protected dap the first night, then Peace the second night.

[Hallia]

Interesting. Now how do we confirm this?

When I run out of self protects and get lynched? lol.

[Hallia]

Or killed rather

[dapianoplay3r]

Thank you hally

 

I hate dying so soon in games

[Nolder]

Why didn't you protect yourself either of those nights? Why did you choose to protect Peace after you already successfully protected Player? Why not continue protecting Player?

[michellem]

Csarmi: Me answering first would give you and your team opportunity to use that WIFOM right back against me. Not interested in giving you guys stuff for free.

 

 

 

Mafia team is big game hunting I see. Or at least attempting to.

[Tsukibana]

 

 

No, Mish hit it right with what quotes I was referencing.

If any role in this game has Power, it should be Lee. She claims that role,

then immediately talks about consolidating on her. There is NO WAY (of course, I could be wrong)

that any townie would say "go ahead, I've got power, but kill me anyway and take away from our abilities".

 

Of course, newb here, so maybe it made sense. But to me it means she made a clear false claim because she

was being targeted.

 

"Did you not understand that it seems like we are all Lee here? Except you apparently. What's up with that?"
 

 

Wow. A replacement comes in and the game gets busy. Cool.

 

A thousand images, a thousand Lees. We all made that claim. Except for a small few, back on day one. Some of us are just images, Decoys for the "real"

Lee. At least, that is what I believe. Out there, someone got additional info that made it clear that they are the real Lee. I believed that Mish was making that

claim, and I believed that the "real" Lee would be a Power. At the least, a Cop, able to discern which reflections are real, and which have enemies behind them.

It is clear that I misread the purpose behind the role, and it has cost me. Oh well. Hallia's not false claiming.

[Millon]

Is there ALWAYS A doc role with mafia? Is there a possibility hallia is protecting Dap and Peace by claiming they are all 3 town when, prior to that post, someone mentions in a game of 15 that there would likely be 3 mafia?

[Millon]

wait, maybe I am mixing up roles. What role would be able to see town and what would be able to protect someone? A doc protects and a cop can discern? Is that it? One way or the other lol could it be possible for Hallia to false claim to hid the scum? or even claim herself and one other scum and one town to help hide? I know it doesn;t sound clear lol (margaritas) so sorry.

[Nolder]

Is there ALWAYS A doc role with mafia? Is there a possibility hallia is protecting Dap and Peace by claiming they are all 3 town when, prior to that post, someone mentions in a game of 15 that there would likely be 3 mafia?

It's possible she is lying but unlikely both Player and Peace are both mafia if she is.