[Advanced] US Presidents Mafia - MAFIA WIN

[Basel Gill]

Okay, I've gone back to check the byplay between Mish and Peace because it smelled funny to me. I had this wild hunch that one of them would likely be scum. This is what I came up with.

Red, I'm not against pointing out suspecting president claims.  I'm suspect of you looking like you are bussing a team mate.  Most of your post I was talking about was against me yet you vote Rand.  You've posted like you are so sure that Nixon is scum.  If so, where is the vote to back up this surety.  Your case on Rand wasn't nearly as emphatic.
 
Typical linking play.  What gives?

Accuses Red of bussing Rand, which would mean Red and Rand have to both be scum. Both were town.
  

What do you have against peace?

Overreacting? Overdefensive?
 

wasn't a joke vote.

Except that later on, he says it was indeed a joke vote. See below.
 

Enjoy your donut.[/size]

 

I like donuts. Who wants Tim Horton's?

 
 

Joke vote, Darthe and I have been going after each other early game for several games.  He got it.  Why didn't you?

[Basel Gill]

Vote Peace.

[michellem]

vote mish

 

Night talk is anti-town. Always.

 

If that isn't one of the weakest reasons I've seen for a while... I will talk at night if I have something to say that I think town should known. Cause for all I knew, I would be day when day came. It's not the first time I've cased during the night and it won't be the last.

 

 

vote mish

 

Night talk is anti-town. Always.

 

Be careful, she's going to OMGUS you and say you did it first.

 

Wow RTE, just wow. Please show me where I've done that before tnx before throwing out accusations like that. You and Peace are so scummates together.

[Amadine]

I'm sticking to my original opinion. Nothing I have seen has changed my mind. Over defensiveness has just confirmed my suspicions.

 

VOTE PEACE

[michellem]

But Ama, why did you vote Peace in the first place on D1? You have still not given a reason for that.

[Hallia]

  She had a feeling, are the only two things I could find O.o

 

*shrugs* i figured from the start that electing = lynching. The basic premise of mafia is lynching players to try to win, i know DM mafia has taken on a life of it's own but it's still a mafia game.

 

As for my "niggly feelings" sometimes i get a feel for a player - not through one sentence or post or comment, but in general. I am not going to turn away from a gut feeling when there has been little else to go on so far.

 

 

Light Player! I have never seen you post so incomprehensibly! LOL

My apologies for quietness, we have just had our second flood in 3 weeks, and also we had no power at work for 36 hours over the weekend and still have no phone reception (the storms knocked out the tower). Usually I can check in on breaks at work but not at the moment so please bear with me.

I still have a niggly feeling about Peace, something just does not feel right there. Also Player, aside from his shocking spelling :p there is something going on there. I have not played for quite a few months but I have played a lot of games with Red, she tends to be difficult to meta as she plays just about the same way no matter her alignment - I am not getting a feeling one way or the other about her yet.

I think Nol may be town - he "feels" town his game which going by my past record on Nol, probably means he's scum lmao

VOTE PEACE FOR PRESIDENT

VOTE PLAYER FOR VICE PRESIDENT

[michellem]

Yes that was D2. But on D1 when she came in as replacement, she only posted vote, no reason, and didn't supply a reason later although several people asked for it.

[Hallia]

*nodnod* Yep, I could find nothing else :(

[Sakaea]

Peace claimed being Nixon....he was the Watergate pres....could totally be scum. Vote Peace

[michellem]

RTE, you got anything to say? I know you're online.

[Nolder]

Vote: Peace

[John Snow]

Night talk is 20x scummier than self voting.

Night talk helps maf pick their night target. If you and peace were both town, they could have killed one of you, setting up another townie death.

 

Very rarely does night talk help town more than mafia.

[michellem]

Thst might be; I'm not gonna change that anyhow. But of all the players in the game; of all the things that's happened, that's what you find most voteworthy? Really?

[michellem]

And what is it with all these people voting without a reason?!

[Nolder]

And what is it with all these people voting without a reason?!

I spent two or three game days trying to get Peace lynched. I'm taking today to be lazy.

[Nolder]

You want my reasons you can reread.

[hotpocket2006]

I think you and peace just need to settle your differences and look elsewhere Nolder. I'm going to do a reread so I can make my new suspicions legit.

[Nolder]

I think you and peace just need to settle your differences and look elsewhere Nolder. I'm going to do a reread so I can make my new suspicions legit.

Did I miss a cop claim in his defense or something If not I see no reason to look elsewhere. He's my best bet for scum with Hallia trailing in a close second atm.

[Nolder]

Missed a question mark there. Oh well.

[Amadine]

My bad, my pc ate my reply and I haven't had a chance to spend the time revisiting it.

 

Off the top of my head there was the electing thing, Peace asked "we're electing a president?" Which showed he had not read the opening game posts thoroughly, and a few minutes later there was a post stating he thought it was just flavour - first flip flop and ping.

 

There was a page 7ish joke vote, bit late on D1 for joke votes IMO.

 

He has been over defensive with everyone who has voted for him, and then the posts that have recently been quoted as well.

[ed2funy]

Probably can't do a VC at work today. We're shooting lasers.

[Hallia]

And I'm a close second because...?

[dapianoplay3r]

I need to reread but im nnot goibg to vote oeeace. But i amm feeling a scummmmy vibe frim Ama.. When iread the thread ill try pinpoinnt it

[Hallia]

I would sort of agree with you there Dap.  Just having "a feeling" with no real evidence doesn't help at all.

[dapianoplay3r]

Really? No evidence on my part and you agre?