Hangar 18 [BASIC GAME] Game over! Scum win. Nolder & WBK.

[Nolder]

 

Darthe you actually make a good point here and I can't really explain it. Maybe it was a lapse in judgment or maybe your partner had other ideas? If I was you I would have killed me by now. Maybe that's egotistical of me but it's the truth. So yeah I dunno but the fact that I can't explain it doesn't make me want to lynch you any less sorry.

 

Wouldn't the odd thing be if you two were the mafia? O.o

Why do you think it would be odd?

[Hallia]

Or rather, I would find it funny if at the end you were were the mafia, and the going back and forth was all an act.

[Songstress]

 

Darthe you actually make a good point here and I can't really explain it. Maybe it was a lapse in judgment or maybe your partner had other ideas? If I was you I would have killed me by now. Maybe that's egotistical of me but it's the truth. So yeah I dunno but the fact that I can't explain it doesn't make me want to lynch you any less sorry.

 

Wouldn't the odd thing be if you two were the mafia? O.o

 

God, if those two are both mafia, I'm never playing again.  The gods of Random.org hate me.

[Darthe]

I recall doing that in a game with Lenlo.  We got lynched together after it went on for about two days.  I suppose in so short a game it could work but as Tress said, if that is the case then you guys are done for and really can't help it.  

 

Nol, I can't blame you for that response.  Hell, I wouldn't trust me any more than you do and I only trust you as much as I do because your play doesn't make sense as mafia.  Do me a solid and catch them?

[Darthe]

 

Darthe you actually make a good point here and I can't really explain it. Maybe it was a lapse in judgment or maybe your partner had other ideas? If I was you I would have killed me by now. Maybe that's egotistical of me but it's the truth. So yeah I dunno but the fact that I can't explain it doesn't make me want to lynch you any less sorry.

 

Wouldn't the odd thing be if you two were the mafia? O.o

 

For the hell of it I am going to point out that this is fear mongering and WIFOM.  We all do it but it's worth notice.  

[Nolder]

Or rather, I would find it funny if at the end you were were the mafia, and the going back and forth was all an act.

It happens. Some people put on a great show sometimes. I assure you that isn't the case here though.

[Nolder]

I recall doing that in a game with Lenlo.  We got lynched together after it went on for about two days.  I suppose in so short a game it could work but as Tress said, if that is the case then you guys are done for and really can't help it.  

 

Nol, I can't blame you for that response.  Hell, I wouldn't trust me any more than you do and I only trust you as much as I do because your play doesn't make sense as mafia.  Do me a solid and catch them?

Well after you I suspect everyone pretty much evenly so I'll try I guess.

[Darthe]

That is not promising.  My theory is that if I get lynched you're no longer valuable so you will get NK'd.  Of course, even stating this semi-WIFOMs it.

[Nolder]

Well TBH if mafia thinks there's a chance I'm willing to vote someone else and not them then they might choose someone else over me who seems more against them. I wouldn't mind being lynched or NK'd though. I hate making it to endgame. Too much pressure lol.

[Darthe]

I prefer it.  Who else can you trust to get it done the way you think it should be?

[michellem]

Tress Im not following anyone; I'm higly capable of making my own conclusions. It's very unlikely in a mafia game that noone ever has the same thoughts... You trying to spread doubt on my claim that way made this very easy for me now.

 

 

unvote vote Tress

[WolfbrotherKronos]

We have 4 trains and a deadline today.

 

unvote

 

I'll do a reread again and see if I can make any sense of things.

[Darthe]

I am guessing that the WBK train isn't going anywhere.  The three players I trust are myself, Mish, and Nol (sorta).  With a bit of WIFOM we can manage another day or two at this rate.  I will vote anywhere else though my reads are effing dead now.  

[peacesells]

Vote Count

 

Darthe (2): Nolder, , Songstress

Hallia (1): Cloud

Songstress (1): Mish

WBK (1): Darthe

 

Not Voting: Hal. WBK

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline is at 3PM MST Friday.

[Darthe]

You have all voiced suspicion of Cloud and WBK.  I want WBK.  Pick who you want and lynch.  Tress train isn't going anywhere any more than my train is.  

[_CLOUD]

You could stop playing from behind a veil of masked intentions and instead share yourself.  

 

Good tip. Thx. 

 

Aw hon it's nothing personal. People always find me scummy too. I think this is the first game where nobody's been going after me hard

 

 

Peace, I voted Hallia.

 

 

 

And seriously guys, we have a deadline tomorrow!

 

I never take Mafia games personal :) It's just a game. 

 

I don't take offense, I really appreciate the critique/opinions.  Without them we do not grow!  I am trying to decide who I should put my final vote on.

 

Unvote

 

You are right about that one. 

 

I'd prefer Darthe myself.  The way he switched away from pushing a lynch on Hallia while linking her with me (quite without warrant) and Nol (one of which ABSOLUTELY MUST be mafia according to him), then in the next breath decided she was town, was decidedly odd.

 

My next strongest read is on Kronos, but that's the direction Darthe is pushing now. 

 

Strangely, I'm actually beginning to wonder if the mafia team isn't Darthe and Mish.  Big risk for a small mafia team with a 50% chance of having a doc to counterclaim, but she's following right along with him now and I'm not comfortable with that.

 

More likely either Kronos or Cloud.

 

I found this post very scummy. First Tress says that she wants to get Darthe lynched due to his odd play. Then she says that Kronos is her second pick, but if she believes that Darthe is scum it wouldn't be logical to follow him on his Kronos' train, for he will be guaranteed town. In the next line she wrote that she was beginning to doubt that Darthe and Mish are mafia, and she further brings doubt on Mish's doc claim. I think by this point we can safely assume that her doc claim is true. She ends her post with saying that me and Kronos are scum. After this whole post she still has her vote on Darthe though.

 

You have all voiced suspicion of Cloud and WBK.  I want WBK.  Pick who you want and lynch.  Tress train isn't going anywhere any more than my train is.  

 

Why wouldn't Tress' train go anywhere? Currently she has the same ammount of votes as Kronos and Hallia. Like I said before, I think that Tress is mafia, but now I'm unsure who her partner is. I think that Tress is a safe lynch for today. 

 

 

Unvote

 

Vote Tress

[Darthe]

Hmm... My thought was that a train on Tress gained little support earlier (essentially you would have to rely on Nol or WBK) so it probably won't now.  This could change with so little remaining time I suppose.

[peacesells]

Vote Count

Darthe (2): Nolder, , Songstress

Songstress (2): Mish, Cloud

WBK (1): Darthe

 

Not Voting: Hal. WBK

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline is at 3PM MST Friday.

[michellem]

Peace, exactly when is that for those of us not familiar with American time zones?

[Hallia]

So yes, we are getting close.  I

 

 

You could stop playing from behind a veil of masked intentions and instead share yourself.  

 

Good tip. Thx. 

 

>Aw hon it's nothing personal. People always find me scummy too. I think this is the first game where nobody's been going after me hard

 

 

Peace, I voted Hallia.

 

 

 

And seriously guys, we have a deadline tomorrow!

 

I never take Mafia games personal :) It's just a game. 

 

I don't take offense, I really appreciate the critique/opinions.  Without them we do not grow!  I am trying to decide who I should put my final vote on.

 

Unvote

 

You are right about that one. 

 

I'd prefer Darthe myself.  The way he switched away from pushing a lynch on Hallia while linking her with me (quite without warrant) and Nol (one of which ABSOLUTELY MUST be mafia according to him), then in the next breath decided she was town, was decidedly odd.

 

My next strongest read is on Kronos, but that's the direction Darthe is pushing now. 

 

Strangely, I'm actually beginning to wonder if the mafia team isn't Darthe and Mish.  Big risk for a small mafia team with a 50% chance of having a doc to counterclaim, but she's following right along with him now and I'm not comfortable with that.

 

More likely either Kronos or Cloud.

 

I found this post very scummy. First Tress says that she wants to get Darthe lynched due to his odd play. Then she says that Kronos is her second pick, but if she believes that Darthe is scum it wouldn't be logical to follow him on his Kronos' train, for he will be guaranteed town. In the next line she wrote that she was beginning to doubt that Darthe and Mish are mafia, and she further brings doubt on Mish's doc claim. I think by this point we can safely assume that her doc claim is true. She ends her post with saying that me and Kronos are scum. After this whole post she still has her vote on Darthe though.

 

You have all voiced suspicion of Cloud and WBK.  I want WBK.  Pick who you want and lynch.  Tress train isn't going anywhere any more than my train is.  

 

Why wouldn't Tress' train go anywhere? Currently she has the same ammount of votes as Kronos and Hallia. Like I said before, I think that Tress is mafia, but now I'm unsure who her partner is. I think that Tress is a safe lynch for today. 

 

 

Unvote

 

Vote Tress

 

I see what you mean cloud, and that is kind of interesting how she said you two were, but didn't change votes.  I haven't really got a read off of her this game, but it seems you guys are picking up on things I missed.  We're getting close to the deadline, so I'd rather us get someone than no one.

 

Vote Tress

[michellem]

Hallia, a tip, try to delete the part of the quote that's not relevant to what you're quoting, especially suge huge posts. It makes for very hard reading when these huge posts show up 2-3 times.

[Hallia]

Oh! My apologies, I will certainly do so.  I wasn't sure if that was considered editing or not.  I didn't wanna get in trouble.  Will do so from now on!

[Darthe]

Peace, exactly when is that for those of us not familiar with American time zones?

 

I believe it is about 6 hours off.  Don't really want to hammer tress but I feel like we are being left with little choice.  

[peacesells]

Vote Count

Darthe (2): Nolder, , Songstress

Songstress (3): Mish, Cloud, Hallia

 

WBK (1): Darthe

 

Not Voting: WBK

With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline is at 3PM MST Friday.  

 

Aproximately 6 1/2 hours from this post.

[michellem]

Well I'm feeling now that I can't see anythong because of the thick WIFOM-fog in this game; we need to get some answers one way or another, even if loosing a townie. And better too potentially lynch a townie and know it, then have a random lynch.

 

 

 

Plus I don't like the fact about Tress that she was posting after my claim, and didn't mention it once before I started pointing fingers at her. Then I was suddenly suspicious. I understand Nol's reaction to my claim; I epxpected more of you to do so. But the timing of Tress' suspicion just feels way off.