[Advanced] Bloodlust Mafia Game Over!

[John E. Kelley]

I think that Mynd's lynch would tell us plenty, and afterwards we can examine the ones who defended and attacked him, and such, regardless of his alignment.

 

And at the same time, lose us access to his demonstrated superior scum-hunting techniques on Day One. That would certainly help one team more than the other says I.

[Blackhoof]

*double-post*

[Blackhoof]

I think that Mynd's lynch would tell us plenty, and afterwards we can examine the ones who defended and attacked him, and such, regardless of his alignment.

 

And at the same time, lose us access to his demonstrated superior scum-hunting techniques on Day One. That would certainly help one team more than the other says I.

 

well he is not even defending himself and calling for his own lynch.

 

how is that town behaviour? if he is town, then he KNOWS that he is town, and KNOWS that his loss would be damaging to the town, as every townie loss is.

 

and if he really believes that his lynch would give us so much information as to instantly bag at least 1 scum, or something, then why deny him his plan?

 

 

either, he is town and genuinely believes that his lynch would be beneficial (and he is experienced enough to make such a judgement, i think), or he is mafia trying to WIFOM his way out of a predicament.

 

Either way, if Mynd and his superior skills are to be trusted, it is a win-win situation.

[cosmicpanda]

Okay, it's late, and I'm tired. 

 

Des thinks I'm not playing to my meta. He based that on, what, two posts? But whatever, he can think what he wants. 

 

On Mynd, I don't like the 'lynch me to see that I'm town' play, and would have thought he'd be above it. In any case, Blackhoof's post 228 is silly. I've seen townies do such a thing quite often, though often it's just the sort of 'lynch me and you'll see I'm telling the truth' throwaway line. I'm not sure that scum do it nearly so often, because they want to survive, so I wouldn't say that it's not town behaviour. It's certainly not useful town behaviour, but it's not scummy. The part of Blackhoof's case that I don't like is that even though he says exactly why Mynd's play is a bad idea, he then suggests we go for it anyway. In other words, he's okay with lynching a hypothetically-town Mynd for no good reason. That is not just anti-town, but actively benefits the scum, who want to see townies reduced in number. 

 

Unvote, vote: Blackhoof

 

 

(Also, is nobody else thinking that Mynd might just be a jester? Nobody?)

[cosmicpanda]

*To add to the above, I don't think Mynd's trying to WIFOM his way out of anything. He didn't have to put himself into this suggestion, and isn't in a predicament. 

[cosmicpanda]

*and suggestion should be situation

[LedZepMan]

I think i havent slep yet.....

[Darthe]

Official Vote Count:

 

 

Mynd (6/10): Turin, TG, Cloud, Kae, Peace, BH

 

Cloud (2/10): Mish, Mynd

 

Ishy (1/10): Basel

 

Peace (1/10): Rand

 

BH (4/10): Ishy, Dice, Despo, Pandy

 

 

Unwilling to commit to a vote currently (5/19):

 

BG, Kaylee, Len, JLM, LZM

 

 

The blood is the life. - Deuteronomy 12:23

 

A quick reminder, Deadline is in 37 hours.

[Basel Gill]

Okay, it's late, and I'm tired. 

 

Des thinks I'm not playing to my meta. He based that on, what, two posts? But whatever, he can think what he wants. 

 

On Mynd, I don't like the 'lynch me to see that I'm town' play, and would have thought he'd be above it. In any case, Blackhoof's post 228 is silly. I've seen townies do such a thing quite often, though often it's just the sort of 'lynch me and you'll see I'm telling the truth' throwaway line. I'm not sure that scum do it nearly so often, because they want to survive, so I wouldn't say that it's not town behaviour. It's certainly not useful town behaviour, but it's not scummy. The part of Blackhoof's case that I don't like is that even though he says exactly why Mynd's play is a bad idea, he then suggests we go for it anyway. In other words, he's okay with lynching a hypothetically-town Mynd for no good reason. That is not just anti-town, but actively benefits the scum, who want to see townies reduced in number. 

 

Unvote, vote: Blackhoof

 

 

(Also, is nobody else thinking that Mynd might just be a jester? Nobody?)

 

 

Well, it's looking like I won't convince anyone on Ishy today. And I think Pandy could be onto something here. (And I never even thought of the jester possibility.) Unvote, vote Hoof.

[Darthe]

Oye, I have an announcement.  I have finally decided that I will give you each flavor names to make it more entertaining to write scenes.  This isn't an in game change, but rather something I omitted early on because I do not like having to provide mafia safe claims.  In light of this, you will have the names but you cannot name claim or face immediate death.  This is a new rule, you will each receive a name shortly, I hope you enjoy this entirely useless information.

 

 

[Darthe]

Oye, I have an announcement.  I have finally decided that I will give you each flavor names to make it more entertaining to write scenes.  This isn't an in game change, but rather something I omitted early on because I do not like having to provide mafia safe claims.  In light of this, you will have the names but you cannot name claim or face immediate death.  This is a new rule, you will each receive a name shortly, I hope you enjoy this entirely useless information.

 

 

[Darthe]

There!  No affect on the game but it makes me happier!  I hope none of you minds the minor change, remember that you may not name claim.  Rule 10.

[peacesells]

Does anyone remember Hoof being this vocal before?  It's been awhile since I've played with him.  I'm starting to wonder if Hoof and Mynd have something going on.

[Tyler Glembo]

Cool Darthe, I like it.

[John E. Kelley]

Really Darthe? Why am I named I.P. Freely and why do I work for the P.N.A. Bucket company?

[John E. Kelley]

^^^Was a joke before the modkill beast erupts in here.

[Tyler Glembo]

I dunno, sounded like a real claim to me.

[Kaylee]

DM kicked me off earlier and wouldn't let me back on. I agree that Panda made some good points against Hoof. Hoof anything to say? I'd like to hear from him before placing a vote. There is still time and I'll be on later as well.

[Kaylee]

Hoof, if you don't agree with what Mynd is doing, why go along with it? (that was supposed to be part of the above)

 

Panda: No, because when someone used that line, I usually think they're scum trying to look town, or frustrated/giving up townie. (I've done it and it got me lynched). For Mynd being, well Mynd, I could see the possibility of him being jester.

[John E. Kelley]

Can we get a VC Darthe?

[_CLOUD]

Ok so I did a quick reread, had some catching up to do. 

 

Panda raised an interesting question on the previous page, but I think I know why Blackhoof thinks it's an OK deal. Hoof believes that it's a win-win situation. He thinks that Mynd has been acting way too scummy so he believes that the chances are higher that he will turn up scum instead of town. If Mynd turns up town however, then we will have good reads on the players. Who voted against him, who protected him (and why) etc. etc. Of course I can't answer for Hoof, but that's just my opinion on the matter. 

 

I'm not happy with the train on Hoof and I think there is not enough evidence to vote against him. Mynd has been acting way more suspicious and crazy in my opinion than him. I also think that Ishy and Dice are WAY too protective about Mynd, scummy play there. Ishy was focused so long on Mish and me, and then instantly switches to Hoof. I don't like the current situation. My vote will stay where it is atm. 

[_CLOUD]

Besides, what I read Peace has countered every argument Ishy threw at him with good logic. I don't believe that he is scum either, not for now at least. 

[Darthe]

Their has only been 1 vote since the last VC

[cosmicpanda]

So, Cloud and Hoof. Noted. 

[Darthe]

Official Vote Count:

 

 

Mynd (6/10): Turin, TG, Cloud, Kae, Peace, BH

 

Cloud (2/10): Mish, Mynd

 

Peace (1/10): Rand

 

BH (5/10): Ishy, Dice, Despo, Pandy, Basel

 

 

Unwilling to commit to a vote currently (5/19):

 

BG, Kaylee, Len, JLM, LZM

 

 

26 hours til deadline.  Weekend activity gives me a sad.