[ADVANCED] KaeKey Game of Thrones Mafia - GAME OVER! NIGHT'S WATCH WINS!

[Verbal32]

Explain how my name is getting dragged in there, please.

[Gabriel Kross]

Explain how my name is getting dragged in there, please.

 

 

Because of comments like this every time someone mentions your name.

 

Speaking of Vote Verb

[bgrishinko]

I totally got confused and didn't recognize you there for a sec EP.

[Verbal32]

Explain how my name is getting dragged in there, please.

 

 

Because of comments like this every time someone mentions your name.

 

Speaking of Vote Verb

 

I'm trying to see if it is linked to the lame case you've tried blanketing on me since this game began. Darthe defended me as a scum tactic. Had I been lynched and flipped town, he would have looked better. I'm actually kinda surprised the gladiator thing wasn't done with me - my lynch makes him look good. Either way, that's not relevant anymore.

 

What is relevant, though, is how you've given me nothing more than "gut feels" and casing based on my activity levels. You haven't seen me contradict myself, overly defend people, or anything else that could be associated with mafia tactics. For a bit of WIFOM, I would simply ignore you if I'm scum - your ability to get people to vote behind you is doubtful at best.

[Gabriel Kross]

Explain how my name is getting dragged in there, please.

 

 

Because of comments like this every time someone mentions your name.

 

Speaking of Vote Verb

 

I'm trying to see if it is linked to the lame case you've tried blanketing on me since this game began. Darthe defended me as a scum tactic. Had I been lynched and flipped town, he would have looked better. I'm actually kinda surprised the gladiator thing wasn't done with me - my lynch makes him look good. Either way, that's not relevant anymore.

 

What is relevant, though, is how you've given me nothing more than "gut feels" and casing based on my activity levels. You haven't seen me contradict myself, overly defend people, or anything else that could be associated with mafia tactics. For a bit of WIFOM, I would simply ignore you if I'm scum - your ability to get people to vote behind you is doubtful at best.

 

We haven't seen you give ANY relevant thoughts, your posts have been spam, why me, and "your case is just so bad" type posts from you all game and you continue with the why me... Your comment saying you are surprised that the gladiator thing wasn't done to you is beyond rediculous since Darthe claimed gladiator and defended you hard core, why would he then challenge you? If you're going to play then play otherwise don't be surprised that you get lynched for being the scum you are.

[Songstress]

yes she is but she isnt SONG!!! she is Tress Song is someone all together. Ive noticed it a number of times in the game and am very surprised that she hasnt said anything yet shes usually pretty adamant about it.......that and making sure u dont miss the social orgs!

 

I did say something earlier, Dice... I said I thought it'd be rude to correct the mods

 

Need coffee, then I'mma read back through the Darthe/BG challenge and see what sticks out to me most.

[ed2funy]

Not that we'll listen to you, Song. You're not Town.

[RandA lThor]

Official Vote Count:

 

BG (8) – Cyan, Rand, Red, Despo, Ishy, JLM

 

Darthe (11) – BG, EP, Mish, Eds, Songs, Basel, dice, Kaylee, Razen, Verb

 

 

Not voting (1) - John Snow

 

A lynch has been achieved! Scene incoming.

I took off the deadies. I have a feeling that mafia bussed their partner right after he slipped, at least one since they saw that he was a goner. So this comes down to Razen and Verb. In addition to this, Razen has been acting scummy the rest of the game as well. Don't have time to put up a case right now, but I think Despo put up one somewhere that would be very similar to mine. vote Razen

 

Can you explain what you mean by "down to Razen and Verb"?

 

as I said, you were the ones who bussed him right after he made the big scum slip, an excellent opportunity for scum to bus a teammate.

[JenLenaMom]

Well that was interesting. Bah I was so sure BG was mafia

 

This is scummy.

[Sakaea]

Official Vote Count:

 

 

Razen (1) Rand

Songs (1) Eds

Red (1) BG

Verb (1) EP

 

Not Voting (13) : Ishy, Kaylee, Songs, Razen, Red, John Snow, Verbal, Dice, Misheru, JLM, Cyan, Basel, Despo

 

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

[RandA lThor]

Well that was interesting. Bah I was so sure BG was mafia

 

This is scummy.

 

Not really, scum would probably try and say that they were sure the other person was mafia in some way or another.

[ed2funy]

Rand....that post was liiterally stupid.

 

 

Now go vote Tress. She is scum.

[bgrishinko]

Rand....that post was liiterally stupid.

 

 

Now go vote Tress. She is scum.

 

Still waiting for that full casing you promised.

[ed2funy]

Well, I am at work, and lunch is nap time.

But trust me when I say she is. It's pretty obvious, imo. Lol

[RandA lThor]

Rand....that post was liiterally stupid.

 

 

Now go vote Tress. She is scum.

 

I read it again and It was. I profusely apologize for my earlier stupidity.

[Songstress]

I finished reading back through the Darthe/BG challenge... hopefully my browser doesn't decide to send itself back and eat my post again like it just did, or I'll be late to work.

 

* Rand's vote on BG, citing "he's escaped too many times". Darthe was the one pushing a lynch on BG the whole game, and grumbling about him "escaping" being lynched despite never actually providing a valid case on him. I'm wary of anyone who voted BG with the reasoning "he's escaped being lynched". Rand also highlighted Darthe's character claim and made a point of bringing up that there are no fake claims, noting that we shouldn't discount anyone who "seems important" (post 1862)

 

* Mish used a similar line when voting BG - "he should have been dead yesterday". When EP pointed out BG had claimed Gendry, Enabler, she very abruptly switched to voting Darthe with nothing further about her thought process. Ping.

 

* Red admits to skimming, claims she hasn't seen or heard of the gladiator role before... piggybacks on EP's suggestion that Darthe could be Khal Drogo and insists that Drogo would be town if there's no cult... hence, voting BG. We didn't hear anything else from Red for the rest of the day. I know, weekend. Minecraft. Wedding. The explanations are all out there.

 

* Razen jumped on Ishy's logic about BG's enabler role - despite the fact that Ishy's argument was based around an incorrect assumption (that BG was enabling all *investigative* roles). He even acknowledges that the enabler claim was actually for *blocking* roles, but continues to support the logic. The problem is that Ishy's concern with the enabler for investigative roles was that losing him would basically cripple the town, which puts too much importance on that role, and he didn't think it was likely at all. Losing an enabler for blocking roles would be much less crippling to town, and would also hurt the mafia team since Snow has confirmed they have a roleblocker. Only once I pointed out Darthe's "hammer his town ass" scum slip did Razen switch to Darthe. (Followed by Verb's hammer, with no comment or reasoning.)

 

Vote Razen

[RandA lThor]

I finished reading back through the Darthe/BG challenge... hopefully my browser doesn't decide to send itself back and eat my post again like it just did, or I'll be late to work.

 

* Rand's vote on BG, citing "he's escaped too many times". Darthe was the one pushing a lynch on BG the whole game, and grumbling about him "escaping" being lynched despite never actually providing a valid case on him. I'm wary of anyone who voted BG with the reasoning "he's escaped being lynched". Rand also highlighted Darthe's character claim and made a point of bringing up that there are no fake claims, noting that we shouldn't discount anyone who "seems important" (post 1862)

 

* Mish used a similar line when voting BG - "he should have been dead yesterday". When EP pointed out BG had claimed Gendry, Enabler, she very abruptly switched to voting Darthe with nothing further about her thought process. Ping.

 

* Red admits to skimming, claims she hasn't seen or heard of the gladiator role before... piggybacks on EP's suggestion that Darthe could be Khal Drogo and insists that Drogo would be town if there's no cult... hence, voting BG. We didn't hear anything else from Red for the rest of the day. I know, weekend. Minecraft. Wedding. The explanations are all out there.

 

* Razen jumped on Ishy's logic about BG's enabler role - despite the fact that Ishy's argument was based around an incorrect assumption (that BG was enabling all *investigative* roles). He even acknowledges that the enabler claim was actually for *blocking* roles, but continues to support the logic. The problem is that Ishy's concern with the enabler for investigative roles was that losing him would basically cripple the town, which puts too much importance on that role, and he didn't think it was likely at all. Losing an enabler for blocking roles would be much less crippling to town, and would also hurt the mafia team since Snow has confirmed they have a roleblocker. Only once I pointed out Darthe's "hammer his town ass" scum slip did Razen switch to Darthe. (Followed by Verb's hammer, with no comment or reasoning.)

 

Vote Razen

 

yeah I kind of bought the whole Darthe thing hook, line, and sinker. Probably going to make me look really scummy. Just to throw it out there though, some of these people are probably just like me, especially the newer players like Mish.

[Verbal32]

Explain how my name is getting dragged in there, please.

 

 

Because of comments like this every time someone mentions your name.

 

Speaking of Vote Verb

 

I'm trying to see if it is linked to the lame case you've tried blanketing on me since this game began. Darthe defended me as a scum tactic. Had I been lynched and flipped town, he would have looked better. I'm actually kinda surprised the gladiator thing wasn't done with me - my lynch makes him look good. Either way, that's not relevant anymore.

 

What is relevant, though, is how you've given me nothing more than "gut feels" and casing based on my activity levels. You haven't seen me contradict myself, overly defend people, or anything else that could be associated with mafia tactics. For a bit of WIFOM, I would simply ignore you if I'm scum - your ability to get people to vote behind you is doubtful at best.

 

We haven't seen you give ANY relevant thoughts, your posts have been spam, why me, and "your case is just so bad" type posts from you all game and you continue with the why me... Your comment saying you are surprised that the gladiator thing wasn't done to you is beyond rediculous since Darthe claimed gladiator and defended you hard core, why would he then challenge you? If you're going to play then play otherwise don't be surprised that you get lynched for being the scum you are.

 

You really have no idea what you're doing, do you? I'm not wondering why Darthe didn't gladiator me after defending me so hard - I'm more wondering why he didn't do so in lieu of defending me, or at the beginning. He could have always claimed that it wasn't his role involved in the challenge.....there are lots of ways for scum to spin that. Blatantly defending a teammate like that is not one of them.

 

As for my content, meh. I've weighed in on some prior issues, but have gladly allowed others to be the chatty cathys. I'd rather collect info midgame to use in an endgame rush. That's how I like to roll in larger games. Besides, I'll admit to considering dropping out of the game when you people kept tying the Leelou situation to include me in it. I decided against it, though.

 

Your content appears to be designed to rile people up. You tried it early, with mild success. Maybe that works for you - I prefer a little more finesse, but to each their own.

[michellem]

I finished reading back through the Darthe/BG challenge... hopefully my browser doesn't decide to send itself back and eat my post again like it just did, or I'll be late to work.

 

* Rand's vote on BG, citing "he's escaped too many times". Darthe was the one pushing a lynch on BG the whole game, and grumbling about him "escaping" being lynched despite never actually providing a valid case on him. I'm wary of anyone who voted BG with the reasoning "he's escaped being lynched". Rand also highlighted Darthe's character claim and made a point of bringing up that there are no fake claims, noting that we shouldn't discount anyone who "seems important" (post 1862)

 

* Mish used a similar line when voting BG - "he should have been dead yesterday". When EP pointed out BG had claimed Gendry, Enabler, she very abruptly switched to voting Darthe with nothing further about her thought process. Ping.

 

* Red admits to skimming, claims she hasn't seen or heard of the gladiator role before... piggybacks on EP's suggestion that Darthe could be Khal Drogo and insists that Drogo would be town if there's no cult... hence, voting BG. We didn't hear anything else from Red for the rest of the day. I know, weekend. Minecraft. Wedding. The explanations are all out there.

 

* Razen jumped on Ishy's logic about BG's enabler role - despite the fact that Ishy's argument was based around an incorrect assumption (that BG was enabling all *investigative* roles). He even acknowledges that the enabler claim was actually for *blocking* roles, but continues to support the logic. The problem is that Ishy's concern with the enabler for investigative roles was that losing him would basically cripple the town, which puts too much importance on that role, and he didn't think it was likely at all. Losing an enabler for blocking roles would be much less crippling to town, and would also hurt the mafia team since Snow has confirmed they have a roleblocker. Only once I pointed out Darthe's "hammer his town ass" scum slip did Razen switch to Darthe. (Followed by Verb's hammer, with no comment or reasoning.)

 

Vote Razen

 

 

 

I thought BG had been acting anti-town, and I ment that he should have died instead of Rand 1.0. I still stand by saying that then; and I still think that a JOAT would have helped us more in the long run that blocking-Enabler. I couldn't fathom that a mafia would actively use a role like that, so that compared to my initial pings on BG made me vote him. I wrote my post voting BG while he was posting his claim, so I didn't see it, if I'd seen that post I would've never voted him in the first place. Therefore, unvote and vote Darthe.

 

I have had the same thoughts as you re:Razen though.

[Verbal32]

My top suspicion was Rand, but the more I read about Razen, the more I tend to agree. I think Rand is scum, though, but I won't case him without a re-read of some sections of the game (which is now on the agenda).

 

Vote: Razen

[Red2111]

you guys are seriously mean. seriously, 20 pages over the weekand and from quick glances alot are spam. dudes seriously, the game is now over 100 pages long can we cut out the spam. now it just looks like a tactic to burry posts to make a re-read and quote fetch non-feasable.

 

 

also, had i been on at the time i woudl have unvoted BG and voted Darth on that claim of his. Drogo i would have bought, but not a minor character. he lost me at that.

[JenLenaMom]

Well, I am at work, and lunch is nap time.

But trust me when I say she is. It's pretty obvious, imo. Lol

 

This. I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt for now Ed. Vote Tress

[Red2111]

tried to catch up some today but work just got buisy. up to page 79 to Despos Razen case

 

 

Not defending dice here, but why aren't people understanding what he said?

 

Red was after Strike like crazy before as Red 1.0: ok

 

Red was not after Strike like crazy now as Red 2.0: this is where Dice suggests perhaps being Masons with Strike now

 

 

He is not saying Red was scum or is scum - that would be a contradiction. He is simply saying that she, if she was a Mason with him now, would now his alignment and stop going after him.

 

FOS the people ignoring the obviousness of Dice's statements.

 

the FoS from me on Dice coems from him tryign to paint me as scummy for backign off Strike, linking us together as "masons" and seeing as he was tryign to paint me as scummy i took the choice of using Masons as ping worthy.

 

i still feel that way about Dice.

 

 

 

She would also know his alignment if she was mafia instead. Then she might back off knowing that there were enough people on the train.

 

now this is for Rand and all you other people claiming i'm scummy for backign off Strike liek i did. i know it was scummy to do so, i even pointed out point blank what i was doign and explained why multiple times, i didn't try to hide it.

 

now if i'm scum, why woudl i call that sort of attention to myself. wouldn't i be that more liekly to just roll with it and just support his lynch rather than backing off?

 

 

Vote Tress.

 

A lurking Tress is a scummy Tress.

 

A vocal Tress is a Town Tress.

 

^i agree with this. that and every time someone comments on her, Boom shes active then fades back into lurkdom. its gone on all game thus far, which is suspicious to me

 

 

Not to push here or anything but it takes 12 to lynch and there are 21 hours left.

 

Rand is at L-8 with 4 votes on him.

 

Tress is suddenly at L-9 with 3 votes on her.

 

BG is at L-10 with 2 votes on him.

 

These are our leading people... I do not like the tress lynch because of its' speed. BG is obv scum. Still, we need some consolidation and if you are a power role and one of these three people we are boned if we do not know by early tomorrow.

 

Darthe flipped scum, thsi post stands out to me. part of me is inclined to think that, becuase BG was getting heat, they used Darthes role to try and clear one or the other. notice now the effect of Darthes role that BG is getting less pressure (atleast thats how its appearing from my quick skims)

 

Darthe has been at BG all game. the other point is his mention on Tress. could be a distancing attempt. the point out on Rand feels like framing a townie to me

 

 

Aggressiveness. I must have hit a nerve.

 

And try to claim a sensor role. Or something equally useless.

 

*waits breathlessly*

 

here Ishy is baiting Rand and capitalizing on Rands emo response. this, coupled with his vote jumping up to here and his buddying up to Nol pings greatly

 

 

OK going to sleep, revealing now, might not have time later. I am a JOAT. Each night, I am PMed my role and I get to decide who to use it on. Last night I got a doc which I almost used on EP but then later decided to use on myself. I am Syrio Forel btw. Don't know if this fits canon or not since I have neither seen or watched Game of Thrones.

 

i dunno if JOATs woudl fit Syrio. he was a water dancer, nothign more than that.

[hazelkrs1]

Hey guys, I think I forgot to mention in this thread I was going to be celebrating my anniversary with Niki yesterday and today. Just got back from ATL, had a blast! Even though I kinda got us lost at one point after taking the subway lol. Got pumpkin carving and catching up on On Demand shows tonight!

 

I wasn't able to do an examination of all the voting yesterday like I had wanted, so I'll have to get to that and go further into looking at everything when I get back to work tomorrow night.

 

It seems like people are finally listening to me about Razen, so I'll go ahead and vote Razen for now. Lot of other stuff I saw that kinda stood out, but that's all I have time for right now. Either way he's seemed the scummiest to me most of the game, and I think some pressure on him would give us a lot of info about others in the game

[Basel Gill]

Happy anniversary, Des. Vote Ishy.