Fandom Cage Match- Bout 6: Game of Thrones VS Lord of the Rings

[Starrik]

Alright, owing to the popularity of discussion just recently in the Band I came up with an idea for a Fandom Tournament. The way this is going to work is that each week I will post a thread with two Fandoms paired up and ready to battle it out. It's up to you guys, the Banders to vote on your preferred Fandom and post why you voted. If you're not sure, read through the arguments for and against each Fandom. Try to win people over to you fandom! It works in a standard tournament form, with the winner moving up to the next level.

After another pathetic victory of the woeful Pirates over the brilliant yet misunderstood Transformers, we move on. This time, we're heading into the realms of fantasy, pitting the very popular TV show Merlin against the elemental wielding Avatar. I'm not sure who's gonna win this one.

Aaaaaaaand begin!

Overview of the First Round:
Sherlock Holmes-10
Lost -1

Pirates of The Caribbean-8
Transformers-2
 
Merlin-3
Avatar the Last Airbender/Legend of Korra 0


Twilight-0
Dracula-4

Digimon-1

Pokemon-5

Game of Thrones

Lord of the Rings

 

 

Harry Potter
Hunger Games

His Dark Materials (Phillip Pullman)
Gone (Book Series)

Blackadder
Monty Python

Get Smart
James Bond

Mojang (Minecraft)
Maxis (Simcity, Sims)

Blizzard (WoW, Starcraft)
Bethesda (Oblivion, Skyrim)

Marvel
DC

Dr Who
Back to the Future

Stargate
Battlestar Galactica

Star Trek
Star Wars

[Christine]

WTF. Some of these things I don't give a crap about, then you put my favorites together. I reject this Cage Match and deem it unlawful!

[Starrik]

Well, then you'll just have to participate in the ones you want, and make them utterly smash the ones you don't care about it.

Besides, I got Jea's approval, so it IS lawful. Besides, I had to do a wide spread of things, it makes it more interesting.

[Christine]

No. I reject this. All of it. No one should ever put BSG and Stargate against each other.

[Starrik]

Hahahahahaha. Well, it seems like Christine's out. Anyone else interested?

[dicetosser1]

i am but just so you know if transformers lose to the pirates i NOT gonna be happy! scowls

[Starrik]

hehehehe, lol. I got an awesome transformers shirt from an op shop the other day! I would be majorly surprised if Twilight beats Dracula. And saddened.

[The Bard Babe]

SHERLOCK HOLMES FTW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

Lost hasn't got a chance against good old Watson and Holmes. :) Man I love that fandom. Btw Starry, I still have your Sherlock book...

[Andrew the Asha'Man]

Well i used to love Lost, but i get a headache everytime i think about it. Sherlock is great in general and i dont have to take and asprin everytime i think of him. So sherlock form me

[The Bard Babe]

Yayyyy!! *another point in Andy's approval list*

 

That's right people: if you vote Sherlock, you get my approval, and I know you all want that. ;)

[Katiora]

Go Sherlock!!! I never could really get into lost...

[Andrew the Asha'Man]

Go Sherlock!!! I never could really get into lost...

 

I got into it and followed it all the way through... WHY!!!!!!

[Katiora]

Ehhh... Whenever it was first starting I was in high school and I didn't watch TV.. I didn't have time. And by the time I watched TV and tried to watch a few episodes I was so far behind that I didn't get a lot of stuff *shrugs*

[lolguy26]

Goo sherlock , and his awesome *reasonable deducing* skills

[Jeannaisais]

I hated Lost...so confusing....Sherlock Holmes for me as well!

[Andrew the Asha'Man]

Ehhh... Whenever it was first starting I was in high school and I didn't watch TV.. I didn't have time. And by the time I watched TV and tried to watch a few episodes I was so far behind that I didn't get a lot of stuff *shrugs*

 

Yea i was in highschool as well and working but it that was before the writers strike and i absolutly loved the show i would get off work at 830 and make sure i was home by 9 to watch the show. gosh i was you and stupid when it came to that show

[Starrik]

Wow. I certainly didn't think this would be such a one-sided one.

[lolguy26]

Well lost lost

 

*pun intended*

[Starrik]

lol lolguy. bad play on words intended. Well, considering this a very much landslide win, I'm pretty much ready to consider this an early win. If we have 10 people cast a vote, and lost is at 10% (One vote) I'll consider it a win fro Sherlock.

[Basel Gill]

Lost was good... up until the last year. And I might also include the year before that. Sherlock Holmes remains a classic that never gets old.

[Andrew the Asha'Man]

Lost was good... up until the last year. And I might also include the year before that. Sherlock Holmes remains a classic that never gets old.

 

And dont forget the year before that as well

[Starrik]

Awww. That stinks, I'm not up to there yet.

[Ironfishmonger]

I only just realised, my two favourite comedies are fighting.i'm never going to be able to decide on that one

[Starrik]

I only just realised, my two favourite comedies are fighting.i'm never going to be able to decide on that one

I designed it to be hard.

[Jeannaisais]

Starrik - are you gonna be able to change the poll question?

 

If not you should scroll down through the pages and look through how we've set up the It's a KnockOut Threads before and use that format - it works pretty well!