[BASIC] Elantris Mafia- Town and Basel win!

[Ironeyes]

No deadline yet, but if it takes more than a week I'll set one.

[hazelkrs1]

What in the world happened to the activity on this thread? Come on peeps, speak up

[Basel Gill]

It must've been the weekend. I want to get this out now because I won't be back home from work for several hours... past experience has taught me that I can pick up the remaining votes needed in that time. I'm the town sensor. I am Adien; I am a savant and have an exceptional ability with numbers. I can examine the day's lynch, and each night I will be told how many scum were on that lynch. You can lynch me, but you would lose that info.

[bgrishinko]

Ooooo... a Sensor. I faked that role once. It was awesome.

 

That being said, the roleclaim doesn't speak to me one way or another.

[michellem]

Adien is a role that would be town for sure, if it's in here

[Sakaea]

Hmmmm....that is not a role we want to lose so early in the game, that's for sure.

 

Alanna, lolguy, thoughts from you 2? Is Wombat being replaced? He hasn't checked in yet still. I know he's got some RL stuff goin on, so idk.

 

Unvote

[randomh3r0]

That being said, the roleclaim doesn't speak to me one way or another.

Question: Are you saying you don't care one way or the other, that you don't believe them one way or the other, or what?

[bgrishinko]

That being said, the roleclaim doesn't speak to me one way or another.

Question: Are you saying you don't care one way or the other, that you don't believe them one way or the other, or what?

 

I'm saying that it is easy to fake claim the data and make things up. So judging by the claim, it doesn't persuade me either way. I'm only tlaking about the role, not the character claim.

[Sakaea]

From the rules:

 

6. Reveal your characters at your own risk.

 

7. If you feel it appropriate to reveal your role, you may. However, do not quote your role PM.

 

Interesting that he took the risk of revealing his character.

[michellem]

His train wasn't building that fast, there had been no actvity in quite some time, I just don't get the reveal. It seems uneccessary.

[randomh3r0]

His train wasn't building that fast, there had been no actvity in quite some time, I just don't get the reveal. It seems uneccessary.

^^ This. Only about 3 votes and maybe 3-4 posts total.

Interesting that he took the risk of revealing his character.

I also find this very interesting. When Kae revealed role, didn't reveal character. Maybe a touch too defensive so quickly?

[hazelkrs1]

I'll admit that I don't like the early claim either. I'm usually not that much against them, since a train can build very quickly all of a sudden, but as others have pointed out, there really hadn't been much activity for a bit. That being said, Basel was pretty much the only one who seemed to be getting attention at that point.

 

I'm thinking we might need to suspend the "don't lynch first-timers day 1" thing, cause TRL still seems very scummy to me, and we really have no other leads and No Lynch isn't an option

 

Vote TRL

[randomh3r0]

I'll admit that I don't like the early claim either. I'm usually not that much against them, since a train can build very quickly all of a sudden, but as others have pointed out, there really hadn't been much activity for a bit. That being said, Basel was pretty much the only one who seemed to be getting attention at that point.

 

I'm thinking we might need to suspend the "don't lynch first-timers day 1" thing, cause TRL still seems very scummy to me, and we really have no other leads and No Lynch isn't an option

 

Vote TRL

 

(bolded) This seems like extremely weak reasoning to lynch. Especially since you agree in principle above the (bolded) area.

 

So far, Despo has done a pretty good job of pointing suspicion at multiple people. Voting Kae, then me, then me again, without truly casing either. I don't know about anyone else, but seems to me like you're pretty quick to jump on anyone just to get a lynch at this point instead of actually reasoning it out.

 

FOS on Despo. Not enough for me to vote yet, but this is setting off my scum radar.

[Basel Gill]

His train wasn't building that fast, there had been no actvity in quite some time, I just don't get the reveal. It seems uneccessary.

 

I don't see why this is odd, Mish. First off, it was D1, with no deadline, over a weekend. Nobody's train is going to build fast under those circumstances most of the time. Secondly, I was the leading vote-getter, one vote away from having 50% of the votes needed to lynch, and I knew I wouldn't be online again for 11-12 hours due to my workday. Generally in mafia, once the weekdays come back, activity picks back up. If I hadn't revealed, I don't think it's that much of a stretch that I could have picked up 4 votes in 12 hours, and town would be hurt by it.

 

From the rules:

 

6. Reveal your characters at your own risk.

 

7. If you feel it appropriate to reveal your role, you may. However, do not quote your role PM.

 

Interesting that he took the risk of revealing his character.

 

It seemed worth the risk to keep town from losing the power role.

[Ironeyes]

Official Vote Count:

 

Basel (2): Mish, Peace

Random (1): Des

Kae (1): John

Kaylee (1): Rand

Mish (1): Lulz

 

Not voting (7): Wwwombat, Random, Kaylee, BG, Alanna, Sakaea, Basel

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Sakaea]

FOS John for still voting for me. Really John? Didn't think you knew that little...

[Ironeyes]

Is Wombat being replaced? He hasn't checked in yet still. I know he's got some RL stuff goin on, so idk.

Wombat has been poked via PM. If he doesn't show up by the time Day 1 ends, I'll replace him.

[hazelkrs1]

Sorry, I forgot there wasn't a deadline set yet. We still have time to pursue other options then. Unvote

 

And TRL, I'm not worried about fos's coming from you right now. Pretty sure you're mafia.

 

Not sure who I want to vote for now tho. Need more activity.

[RandA lThor]

unvote not sure right now either

[John Snow]

unvote

So, Rand, are you mafia?

[Ironeyes]

FOS John for still voting for me. Really John? Didn't think you knew that little...

[peacesells]

UNVOTE

 

MOD QUESTION

 

Marsh. Should this game be considered true basic or more like a standard game?

[lolguy26]

Hmmmm....that is not a role we want to lose so early in the game, that's for sure.

 

Alanna, lolguy, thoughts from you 2?

 

Unvote

 

well if its a true, it would be a loss.

[Ironeyes]

MOD QUESTION

 

Marsh. Should this game be considered true basic or more like a standard game?

I'm not sure what you mean.

[Ironeyes]

Official Vote Count:

 

Basel (1): Mish

Mish (1): Lulz

 

Not voting (11): Wwwombat, Random, Kaylee, BG, Alanna, Sakaea, Basel, Des, John, Rand, Peace

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.