[Basic] Shifters vs Hunters - Game Over! Congrats Mafia!

[Alanna]

Yes, it was random. And I'm kind of offended you think otherwise. It's not my fault y'all didn't lynch anyone, but I'm not going to punish the town because of it. The mafia was just as much to blame.

[Sakaea]

1. Ironeyes, wolf

2. Nolder, bear shifter

3. Key

4. Blackhoof, Rat Shifter, Reporter, Lynched Day 2

5. Arez, Otter Shifter, Healer, Random Lynch Day 3

6. Ishy, wolf

7. Sakaea, Bear Shifter

8. Kaylee, Hawk Shifter, vanilla town, NK’d Night 1

9. Lenlo

10. Razen, wolf

11. EP, Rat Shifter, Vanilla Townie, Lynched Day 1

12. Darthe

 

From where we stand now, I think tomorrow we need to lynch Razen, and see how a wolf flips. *goes to sleep in irritation*

[Nolder]

Again, I'd rather lynch Ishy

his unvote shouldn't equate to a claim

[John E. Kelley]

Okay then, let's just disregard the unvote then. What exactly are you basing your desire to lynch me off of? Is there a scummy post or behavior you'd care to offer?

[keyholder21]

.....Did we already lose? If there are four mafia and they kill one of us tonight, I'm pretty sure we've lost because right now there are eight players left. If there are three, though, we have tomorrow too.

[Nolder]

Okay then, let's just disregard the unvote then. What exactly are you basing your desire to lynch me off of? Is there a scummy post or behavior you'd care to offer?

ummm if I ever had another reason for being suspicious I've forgotten it at this point

[John E. Kelley]

Okay then, let's just disregard the unvote then. What exactly are you basing your desire to lynch me off of? Is there a scummy post or behavior you'd care to offer?

ummm if I ever had another reason for being suspicious I've forgotten it at this point

 

Well that's comforting.

[John E. Kelley]

So have we lynched so much scum to this point that we're going to start just firing blindly then?

[keyholder21]

What?

[Nolder]

How is that blind shooting?

It's a reason, a good one IMO

I don't need 50 reasons to lynch a person

[John E. Kelley]

So me unvoting a confirmed townie is a "good" reason to lynch me....

 

Didn't know that, I'll jot that one down in my Mafia strategy guide, I've never heard that one before.

[Ironeyes]

Cut the sarcasm, and I'll show you his side of the issue. From his point of view, you could have noticed Razen's answer to my question and assumed that he gave the right one, then unvoted in order to look like a Wolf. OR all three of us could be a Mafia team working a convoluted scheme.

 

Now, I know the second situation is not true, but you've got to admit that the first one makes sense.

[Lenlo]

Except we dont know the second situation isnt true... We dont have a single scum killed. What better way for them to keep it that way than by vetting each other in public. We have to at least test it on one of you and Razens looking the best bet right now.

[Razen]

If we get to tomorrow, it is guaranteed to be LYLO. So the only people that benefit from testing this theory out of the wolves are scum are the scum themselves. Which makes Lenlo choice numero uno for me tomorrow.

[Ironeyes]

I don't want to lynch Razen. He is the only living person here that I am 100% sure is town. Ishy is at something like 80%. We need to get actual mafiosos now, or they'll outnumber us. I vote we lynch one of the people that hasn't claimed an animal yet.

[Nolder]

So me unvoting a confirmed townie is a "good" reason to lynch me....

 

Didn't know that, I'll jot that one down in my Mafia strategy guide, I've never heard that one before.

when you and others are trying to use that as a reason to confirm yourself yeah I think it's a pretty decent reason

it's like anti bussing lol

[Alanna]

Posted Today, 01:33 PM

Everyone went to bed feeling defeated. It had been four days, and they still had not managed to find and kill any of the Hunters hidden among them. And worse, they had lost their otter shifter that day in a senseless accident. Otter shifters were rare these days, especially in the shifter dimension, which was a shame, given their natural propensities for healing.

 

The guard were growing restess. As the shifter world slept on in their fortress, the bears guarded the city's perimeter. One bear prowled on the southwest side, near the river that ran through the forest and south, out of the Garrett.

 

The bear shifter followed the river south, keeping an eye out for any suspicious shadows or quick movements. He wandered into the abandoned otter settlement, the cluster of huts that dotted the river bank.

 

A flash of movement caught the bear's eye. He turned, peering at one of the huts. Then a shuffle of steps sounded out from behind him, and he whirled, scanning the settlement.

 

He didn't see or hear the next movement. Instead, he was caught unaware as a figure darted in behind him and slid a knife into his flank. Pained and furious, the bear shifter roared and turned, swiping out with a massive paw and knocking his attacker on his back. Before he could finish him off, however, an arrow came from behind and caught him through the throat. The baer slumped to the ground, dead.

 

Nolder, Bear Shifter, Vanilla Townie, has been nightkilled.

 

Day 5 begins. Your deadline is Monday, May 14 @ 11AM CST.

 

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

[Nolder]

dead again!

 

can't remember the last time I saw the end of a game...

 

good luck town

[keyholder21]

Considering this is LYLO I'm torn between wanting to lynch Razen to test the wolves or lynching an unclaimed/inactive. We might have been hurting ourselves worse this entire by lynching active players *sigh*.

[Sakaea]

1. Ironeyes, wolf

2. Nolder, bear shifter, vanilla town, NK’d Night 3

3. Key

4. Blackhoof, Rat Shifter, Reporter, Lynched Day 2

5. Arez, Otter Shifter, Healer, Random Lynch Day 3

6. Ishy, wolf

7. Sakaea, Bear Shifter, vanilla town

8. Kaylee, Hawk Shifter, vanilla town, NK’d Night 1

9. Lenlo

10. Razen, wolf

11. EP, Rat Shifter, Vanilla Townie, Lynched Day 1

12. Darthe

 

Lenlo, Darthe, Key, what are you?

[keyholder21]

I'm a Rat Shifter, vanilla town.

[Sakaea]

1. Ironeyes, wolf

2. Nolder, bear shifter, vanilla town, NK’d Night 3

3. Key, rat shifter, vanilla town

4. Blackhoof, Rat Shifter, Reporter, Lynched Day 2

5. Arez, Otter Shifter, Healer, Random Lynch Day 3

6. Ishy, wolf

7. Sakaea, Bear Shifter, vanilla town

8. Kaylee, Hawk Shifter, vanilla town, NK’d Night 1

9. Lenlo

10. Razen, wolf

11. EP, Rat Shifter, Vanilla Townie, Lynched Day 1

12. Darthe

 

 

Lenlo, Darthe?

[Sakaea]

At the moment, until we hear from those 2, I'm really leaning towards killing a wolf.

[John E. Kelley]

Which wolf would that be sis?

[Razen]

We know that Sakaea was vetted by Nolder, who was town. If she had lied about hers, Nol would have pounced on it. So we can put her in the confirmed town column. Ironeyes and myself too. That leaves Ishy, Lenlo, Darthe, and Key. I don't see why Ishy would have unvoted, as he did it before Ironeyes confirmed my answer as the correct one. If we use that logic, that means that Key, Darthe, and Lenlo HAVE to be the mafia, by pure process of elimination. Vote: Darthe.