DPR Mafia - The Dark Monocle - Game Thread

[LilyElizabeth]

You know what? He said he doesn't play much till a game picks up. What better way to have it pick up than to have some votes on you. We need to hear more from Verbal.

 

Unvote

Vote Verby

[mmeeshal]

Or we don't follow your leading assumption that automatons don't know who the monacle is. Which means you could be the converter and Ishmael an automaton or original,scum with you.

Just to the bold part, on the airship people asked Nolder (the first converted automaton) a few questions, and one thing that came out of it that I've seen various places is that Nolder didn't know who recruited him and couldn't talk to them; he was given a QT to talk to fellow automatons, but there weren't any before he died. He didn't know anything.

[WWWwombat]

It's always unlikely that any two specific players are scum. Even moreso in a game like this where the original scum probably made up much less than 25% of the players.

[John McClane]

Or we don't follow your leading assumption that automatons don't know who the monacle is. Which means you could be the converter and Ishmael an automaton or original,scum with you.

Just to the bold part, on the airship people asked Nolder (the first converted automaton) a few questions, and one thing that came out of it that I've seen various places is that Nolder didn't know who recruited him and couldn't talk to them; he was given a QT to talk to fellow automatons, but there weren't any before he died. He didn't know anything.

 

So you think Nolder was telling the truth? Okay, lol.

[John McClane]

It's always unlikely that any two specific players are scum. Even moreso in a game like this where the original scum probably made up much less than 25% of the players.

 

I understand the "odds" however this does nothing to consider situational analysis. You were role blocked and a conversion didn't happen. That improves the odds that you could be the converter substantially, thus improving the odds that Ishmael is scum too since he's clearly trying to protect you.

 

So, like I said. NO basis for your implied "unlikely".

[Christine]

I think Nolder had to.

[Leelou]

The dead were required to answer truthfully.

[mmeeshal]

I'll chime in and say it a third time--the dead people were required to answer truthfully any questions put to them during that exercise.

 

So yeah. I think he was telling the truth. lol.

[JenLenaMom]

UGH sorry to be away so long guys. My sister and I did a garage sale today and we were up until 2am sorting then back up at 4 then out there till noon then my girls had softball practice at 1:30 till 3. So *yawn* I think I've caught up and understand where we are in teh game.

 

I would be happy with a Verbal, Wombat or Ishy lynch.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Vote: Christine

 

Return to an old favorite.

[mmeeshal]

@Pilots post #79 (ooh, numbers are climbing there! )--I don't actually trust Christine. For now, it makes sense to me that her role is town, but I don't actually know if that's the case. That's just my own logic. I have been back and forth on her scumminess--Aemon said in the Chemists QT that he felt based on what she said on the Airship that he thinks she's town, and there have been things she's said that do make me feel she is, but on the other hand, there's lots of stuff to make me question her, too.

 

On another note.

 

Glassmakers, in particular the one who posted 127:

 

@Post 86, you said you were gonna do something.

@Post 113 and onward, there was no mention of that, and you did something different. Why?

[mmeeshal]

@Pilots post #79 (ooh, numbers are climbing there! )--I don't actually trust Christine. For now, it makes sense to me that her role is town, but I don't actually know if that's the case. That's just my own logic. I have been back and forth on her scumminess--Aemon said in the Chemists QT that he felt based on what she said on the Airship that he thinks she's town, and there have been things she's said that do make me feel she is, but on the other hand, there's lots of stuff to make me question her, too.

 

On another note.

 

Glassmakers, in particular the one who posted 127:

 

@Post 86, you said you were gonna do something.

@Post 113 and onward, there was no mention of that, and you did something different. Why?

[John McClane]

Vote: Christine

 

Return to an old favorite.

 

Shoot her or Ishmael. Vet yourself, then I will jail wombat again. Then it gives mesh a smaller pool to shoot at. I will jail wombat, and if we see no conversion again, then we know he's the converter.

[Christine]

I don't get how the hell I am a target.

[Christine]

Also, I am a Pro-Wombat Lynch Voter.

 

 

Ishy is trying to derail us and DEFEND Wombat.

 

 

Once again, how am I a target?

[a pale tanned lover]

Vote: Christine

 

Return to an old favorite.

Think there is something you need to do.

[a pale tanned lover]

1. Christine - no claim yet but Meesh says she has reason to trust her

6. Womby - One-shot Strongman, viewed town by Song

8. Tina - no claim but vetted as originally town by Ithi

9. Ishmael - claimed firefighter

10. Pale - no claim, unvetted

11. Leelou - no claim, unvetted

14. Meesh - claimed Hero/Ninja, provisionally assumed vetted by the fact that we were screwed from the start if she is scum.

16. JLM - no claim, unvetted

22. Verbalicious - no claim, unvetted

25. Lily - no claim, viewed town by Song

27. Amegakure / Ape - claimed Jailkeeper, viewed town by Song

28. Sensei - claimed Vig, viewed town by Song

 

The bolded are the four we should be focusing on.

 

I don't think getting viewed once in a dpr game clears you.

 

Id be happy to vote you or verbal

[a pale tanned lover]

Also, I am a Pro-Wombat Lynch Voter.

 

 

Ishy is trying to derail us and DEFEND Wombat.

 

 

Once again, how am I a target?

I think we should give ishy tonight to prove he is town, I think I've pointed him in the right direction

 

Sorry for multiple posts I cant put them all in one on this app.

[Leelou]

I could vote for either Wombat or Verbal today.

[John McClane]

Nob Bob needs to shoot Wombat now, IMO. If wombat flips scum, then meesh can shoot Ishmael. Or vice versa. Shoot Ishmael first, but he's gotta shoot one of them. If he refuses we should lynch him instead.

 

This will get nob bob as Vig, then I can jail him at night to protect him. The RB part of jailing him wont matter because he has a day action.

[John McClane]

I'd also consider a mass reveal right now. Numbers say town is close to end game, everyone playing close to the vest is just enabling scum at this point. Town needs all the pro town info out in the open to make the best decision possible.

[John McClane]

I want Verbal's reveal, most specifically.

[Niniel]

I agree. I want to hear from Verbal too. He said he would pay this game more attention but hasn´t come back. It would be good to hear more from NotBob, not just a vote.

 

As for a mass reveal - I don´t mind sharing my role if the rest of you agree it would be a good idea. Verbal should be able to back me up if he wants to do that. If he doesn´t want to I would be even more suspicious of him.

 

I agree that whoever big boss is he/she will likely have special powers and gf would be likely. That means that we can´t rely on Song´s viewings.

 

Ishy is acting weird. I have also wondered why he is still alive if he is fire fighter. Is he trying to draw attention from Wombat? Maybe.

 

Short version - I don´t know who to vote for right now. I hope to hear more from others.

[Christine]

Tina, I think I mentioned elsewhere why Ishy is still alive. Either he and the Arsonist is Town, or Ishy is Mafia. If the Arsonist was Mafia, then Ishy would be dead.

[Christine]

And, to add to that, Ishy is likely scum. Why?

 

The Mafia can have him constantly cleansing the OS. This way, they can go about killing townies, and not fear losing the recruiter.

 

 

I just see no possible way that Ishy is still alive and NOT mafia.