Wombat's A Song of Ice and Fire Mafia (Advanced) Game Thread

[Christine]

I have made like three posts? How am I acting weird?

 

 

Since the lynch train seems to be chugging at Tina, and I said that I would throw my vote her way if that's the way it went....

 

 

Unvote, Vote Tina

[Christine]

Gah, and Red posts at the same time I do!

 

 

Really wish there was some kind of warning that lets us know someone else has posted so I don't have to double post.

[trench]

Key I think Thorum was alluding to the fact that some people still have random votes out and we have less then a day to the deadline. To me it also seems that some folks are not paying attention and are happy to let the random hammer fall.

[Niniel]

Unvote. Vote Nolder. He is not my first choice but the only one except me that looks like might get lynched today. My first choice is obviously Soy but I could vote Ape or Chrissy as well. I´m used to this kind of bandwagons that are on me right now. It´s convinient to jump on but in this game you have to think a bit about it. I´m pretty sure one (and probably two) on my wagon is on my own team.

[Niniel]

Didn´t get bold. Unvote. Vote Nolder.

[Red2111]

my read so far ....

 

 

Amega - possible non-faction or on Faction Board. needs major looking into

 

Nol - possibley on Faction board or Facion leader, woulb be a good lynch to get this party started.

 

Chrissy - appears to be claiming Greyjoy or is really intent on the greyjoys; needs more pressure. i think she was reaching hard core on the Boyo thing, so maybe she's trying to mislead us in our hunt for boyjoys to give them cover.

 

Ape - protective against a Nol lynch; me likes this reaction lots

 

Pats - buddying up to me on thread, hmmm dunno if i like this or not. woudl be better if he switched fooseball teams thoguh

 

Ishy - latched onto the Football discussion liek he had a hardon for it, but hasn't been involved much in game discussion. mayhaps he doesn't like either of the lynch leaders.

 

Thorum - that last post pings like tryign to appear to be helpign without really helping. does your name ryhm with Meek??

 

 

 

as for the rest of you ... tbc ...

[trench]

 

 

aw thanks Patsfan, even though the Patriots do sux, cause the Saints are beast

 

Tom Brady is the greatest to eva play in the NFL. I have documented proof to back this up. Also, all Jet fans are delusional.

 

Besides that I pretty much need to make sure you're in my faction. I like your style.

 

Breezus could wipe the floor with Brady any day of the week and twice on Sundays. greatest to play in the NFL pppphhhhfffff. that would be Duce McAllister

 

 

Jets fans are delusional though, along with those stinking Dirtybird fans.

 

 

+1 except for the Duce remark.

[Red2111]

did you not see the game against the Jets back in 07 where Duce ramed through 5 of theri defense men to score a touch down

 

Duce was a beast!!!

[trench]

I can understand why a Saints fan would like him, but that guy was so overrated and injury prone. Then he got stuck taking a back seat Reggie Bush, and never did anything again.

[Christine]

 

Chrissy - appears to be claiming Greyjoy or is really intent on the greyjoys; needs more pressure. i think she was reaching hard core on the Boyo thing, so maybe she's trying to mislead us in our hunt for boyjoys to give them cover.

 

 

 

I think you mean Tina?

[Red2111]

no Chrissy, i mean you.

 

 

I can understand why a Saints fan would like him, but that guy was so overrated and injury prone. Then he got stuck taking a back seat Reggie Bush, and never did anything again.

 

you want to talk about overrated and injury prone, then naming that 12 million dollar piece of glass Regiie Bush is the smart way to go. never seen a Running Back more afriad to take a hit in my entire life only thing the man was good for was making it harder to plan for our offense and punt/kick returns. or i could start in on Trouble Maker Shockey, but i dont' want to get all the Giants fans panties in a twist

 

 

i wouldn't say he got stuck taking back seat, that was more Thomas honestly. Duce was always played a fair amount in games. given how hard he played and the hits he gave and i'm surprised he didn't stay even more injured.

[Thorum]

Thorum - that last post pings like tryign to appear to be helpign without really helping. does your name ryhm with Meek??

Not helping. I wanna know who's inactive without having to go through all those pages full of à"'ç(!à'( before.

And no, my name doens't rhyme with Meek. Nor with Spruce

 

 

Trench, you're right about my reasonings

[keyholder21]

I have made like three posts? How am I acting weird?

 

 

Since the lynch train seems to be chugging at Tina, and I said that I would throw my vote her way if that's the way it went....

 

 

You have many more posts than that, but if you're meaning game related, I suppose it *is* only a few.

 

Weird:

 

Alright, 2 things.

1. Tina is pinging me on the Greyjoy thing. Pushing that just a little hard. I mean, it's one thing to kind of breadcrumb who you are, but you're just going for overkill, as though... There is 32 people in this game, not enough to have all of house Greyjoy as part of the characters. I am betting that the role you were given as a fake claim is a Greyjoy. So, yeah.

 

I don’t see where you would get that she’s fake claiming Greyjoy. Also, why wouldn’t you think that Greyjoy is involved in this game? It’s one of the families that is fighting for the throne, and it’s listed in the beginning as one in the list of “most of the factions in this game.” Sounds like it’s very definitely included to me.

 

Ok, seriously, I don't get how others don't see Tina acting wierd about looking for Greyjoys. In my eyes, she is fake claiming and trying to get into their little group, then can ride till the end and claim her real role.

As for why I voted for Nolder, it's because I think his post is odd. And you all say that he seems Day 1 town?

1. What is town in this game? It's all of us against each other, right?

2. Nolder seems town? THIS IS A SIGN!

 

Again, not sure where you get the Tina claiming thing.

Perhaps we all have to get rid of the mafia first before we start cutting off each other. All of us against each other is not necessarily all there is to the game.

Why so intent on nolder if you also think Tina is scummy?

 

And finally, because it’s already been said :

2. I never thought I would agree with Red, but FoS Nolder. THIS post. I have no idea who else is in my faction. I am more than certain that I am not the only one like that. Given that statement, it seems to me as though you must known who is in your faction, which means you are probably a hindrance against others.

 

I agree with you on Tina, but I still suspect Nolder. His line is scummy to me. I would gladly vote for Tina as well, but I can only choose one, and so my choice is Nol, for now.

 

The longer that this continues, I am seeing more defensiveness from Tina over Nolder, so my opinion on who is sketchier is shifting, but I am not ready to make that move yet.

 

Let me see if I get this. You are voting Nolder cause he suggested people should know what faction they are aligned with and yet you unvoted Red when she admitted she knew Nolder was not part of her faction.

 

Contradiction?

[John McClane]

actually you and i were argueing two different points. i was addressing everything concerning Nol, as i didn't like his fishing for info about Factions more so that Tina's fishing about Greyjoys. in this case, yes you are right about me "cheerleading:" others cases on Tina and Chrissy as those are the reason why i'd be willing to move i votes to them.

 

i've not been trying to distract from any lynch, i've been trying to get multiple trains going. big difference there.

 

You are talking out of both sides of your mouth. You don't even know what you were arguing with me about... which is an indicator of making a fuss for the sake of making a fuss.

 

And if you are trying to get multiple trains going, then why were the 3 people you mentioned (Nolder, Christine and Tina) - pretty much the 3 leading trains? How does that "get multiple trains going"? It doesn't. I think you are full of crap.

[The Crusher]

Someone please kick me in my right kankle and wake me when someone dies K?

[trench]

Well I dont think Bush is better then Mcallister, not by a long shot. But Deuce is not even the best RB of all time (Thurman Thomas) let alone best player.

[WWWwombat]

Vote Count:

PatsFanTX(1): Aemon

Vicious(1): Song

mcs(1): Verbal

Verbal(1): Vicious

Aemon(1): Ishy

Nolder(5): Mr. Soy Boyo, cosmicpanda, PatsFanTX, Paperblade, Tina

Tina(15): Thorum, Amadine, Crusher, Song, Ape, trench, Sakaea, Leelou, Perfexionist, Aemon, Pac, not Bob, Keyholder, Red, Christine

Pac(1): Pale

Christine(1): Nolder

John "the Ape" McClane(1): Smash

 

With 32 voting players, it takes 17 to lynch.

[aemonkristen]

Wombat, I changed my vote to Tina awhile ago.

 

Red' pissing match with the ape has my nerves on edge and I'd most like to lynch Red today for what looks like completely ignoring what was said to try and spin it in defense of Tina. However, I don't think that would gain much traction at this point, so I'll

 

UNVOTE

 

VOTE TINA

 

We're not going to figure anything out unless the game starts moving and Tina has the Greyjoy confusion (claiming or looking for the Greyjoys), claiming that there are no scum in this game (any way you look at it, cult is gonna be scum), and the whole mess between Red and Ape that could have derailed the train on her.

 

 

This almost makes me keep my vote where it is:

 

Verb, what's my username and password so I can sign on my iphone. I can't remember it. Thank thou (ye)!

 

Correction is in red,

 

cordially,

 

The Grammar Nazi

[Red2111]

actually you and i were argueing two different points. i was addressing everything concerning Nol, as i didn't like his fishing for info about Factions more so that Tina's fishing about Greyjoys. in this case, yes you are right about me "cheerleading:" others cases on Tina and Chrissy as those are the reason why i'd be willing to move i votes to them.

 

i've not been trying to distract from any lynch, i've been trying to get multiple trains going. big difference there.

 

You are talking out of both sides of your mouth. You don't even know what you were arguing with me about... which is an indicator of making a fuss for the sake of making a fuss.

 

And if you are trying to get multiple trains going, then why were the 3 people you mentioned (Nolder, Christine and Tina) - pretty much the 3 leading trains? How does that "get multiple trains going"? It doesn't. I think you are full of crap.

 

 

i got the Nol train going, i threw my support on the other two trains by helping to keep the pressure on them and voicing the fact that i'm willign to vite them. that does equate to getting multiple trains going. i'm also pressuring you.

 

i'm not slinging crap, i'm beating the grass.

[John McClane]

actually you and i were argueing two different points. i was addressing everything concerning Nol, as i didn't like his fishing for info about Factions more so that Tina's fishing about Greyjoys. in this case, yes you are right about me "cheerleading:" others cases on Tina and Chrissy as those are the reason why i'd be willing to move i votes to them.

 

i've not been trying to distract from any lynch, i've been trying to get multiple trains going. big difference there.

 

You are talking out of both sides of your mouth. You don't even know what you were arguing with me about... which is an indicator of making a fuss for the sake of making a fuss.

 

And if you are trying to get multiple trains going, then why were the 3 people you mentioned (Nolder, Christine and Tina) - pretty much the 3 leading trains? How does that "get multiple trains going"? It doesn't. I think you are full of crap.

 

 

i got the Nol train going, i threw my support on the other two trains by helping to keep the pressure on them and voicing the fact that i'm willign to vite them. that does equate to getting multiple trains going. i'm also pressuring you.

 

i'm not slinging crap, i'm beating the grass.

 

Ha. Slinging crap is beating the grass, if anyone knows this its me.

 

How does me shredding you for talking out your ass equate to you pressuring me, by the way? Are you really this delusional?

[WWWwombat]

Vote Count:

 

Vicious(1): Song

mcs(1): Verbal

Verbal(1): Vicious

Aemon(1): Ishy

Nolder(5): Mr. Soy Boyo, cosmicpanda, PatsFanTX, Paperblade, Tina

Tina(15): Thorum, Amadine, Crusher, Song, Ape, trench, Sakaea, Leelou, Perfexionist, Aemon, Pac, 鲍勃不是我的名字, Keyholder, Red, Christine

Pac(1): Pale, Aemon

Christine(1): Nolder

John "the Ape" McClane(1): Smash

 

With 32 voting players, it takes 17 to lynch.

[dapianoplay3r]

VOTE TINA

 

I think the Greyjoy thing isn't that big of a deal but there being no scum in the game was defiantly a slip up. However the main reason for this lynch IMO is any info from it will be useful, but if we are lucky, her death will help seek out the rest of her faction. Or at least start separating players out a bit (who she avoided or who she fought with) maybe the Greyjoy thing will be more important than I thought but we shall see.

 

Nol's slip up is confusing me a bit. This is my first faction game and from looking them up online, it seems the best way to think of them is to view each faction as a mafia group (except people like cult and survivors but I assume they are similar to a normal game)

If that's the case then won't almost all the players be in some kind of QT or at least know their team members names? OR does each faction work like a cult, recruiting one member per night?

 

I believe that puts Tina at L-1

[John McClane]

VOTE TINA

 

I think the Greyjoy thing isn't that big of a deal but there being no scum in the game was defiantly a slip up. However the main reason for this lynch IMO is any info from it will be useful, but if we are lucky, her death will help seek out the rest of her faction. Or at least start separating players out a bit (who she avoided or who she fought with) maybe the Greyjoy thing will be more important than I thought but we shall see.

 

Nol's slip up is confusing me a bit. This is my first faction game and from looking them up online, it seems the best way to think of them is to view each faction as a mafia group (except people like cult and survivors but I assume they are similar to a normal game)

If that's the case then won't almost all the players be in some kind of QT or at least know their team members names? OR does each faction work like a cult, recruiting one member per night?

 

I believe that puts Tina at L-1

 

 

I don't understand how so many people are only interpreting the Nolder question from one perspective. Not many of you seem to consider that he might have asked a question he does in fact know the answer to, a typical scumhunting "trap" post. Which is I how I arrived at a town read, and I think is how most of the people that have echoed the town read on him are seeing it.

[Pac]

VOTE TINA

 

I think the Greyjoy thing isn't that big of a deal but there being no scum in the game was defiantly a slip up. However the main reason for this lynch IMO is any info from it will be useful, but if we are lucky, her death will help seek out the rest of her faction. Or at least start separating players out a bit (who she avoided or who she fought with) maybe the Greyjoy thing will be more important than I thought but we shall see.

 

Nol's slip up is confusing me a bit. This is my first faction game and from looking them up online, it seems the best way to think of them is to view each faction as a mafia group (except people like cult and survivors but I assume they are similar to a normal game)

If that's the case then won't almost all the players be in some kind of QT or at least know their team members names? OR does each faction work like a cult, recruiting one member per night?

 

I believe that puts Tina at L-1

 

 

I don't understand how so many people are only interpreting the Nolder question from one perspective. Not many of you seem to consider that he might have asked a question he does in fact know the answer to, a typical scumhunting "trap" post. Which is I how I arrived at a town read, and I think is how most of the people that have echoed the town read on him are seeing it.

 

 

considering there isn't a conventional "town" to speak of, your "town read" amounts to a bag of poop.

 

your relentless, whiny, defense of Nolder is noted. Move on before you suffocate from lack of oxygen due to your head being so far up Nolders hind quarters.

[amegakure]

At Red...go ahead and look...all youll find is a very confused person. Are you really gona attack me for supposedly trying to find info about the factions...thats pretty much the point of the game along with killing the cult...i bet the factions have different win conditions.

 

@christine...i guess i didnt see the convo on pats(to much off topic convos)...anyway he keeps talking about it so i will question him if i feel the need.

 

 

it seems to me pats might be a symp.