[Advanced] Lily's Mythical Beings Mafia

[ed2funy]

I don't see Vam's train.

And I think Min has already hinted at her role.....

 

She hasn't replied....gah....I think she targetted Ishy last night....

[Red2111]

oh man that feels good

I mean it's crappy that you guys killed our roleblocker (and it is true that they can be just as harmful as useful if used improperly (the same can be said of a vig)) but this is one of the most satisfying "I told you so"'s I've ever had

partially because I wasn't 100% sure Hybrid was innocent

the case against him was decent and that had me worried

but the quick bandwagon with the reasoning that he didn't state he was town was a huge tipoff that this was a mafia lynch

so yeah

that's all I've got to say about that

RIP Hybrid

 

this post reeks. you pointedly stayed on Desp vote, which could have cost us the majority; then you come out directly with a "You guys suck" type post after Hybrids death. this post and yuou actions of not getting on Hybrids vote, as well as a lock of a clear reason for voting Dewp stink of scum trying to distance form the vote and trying to appear town.

I'm sorry I just do not understand what you're trying to say here

can you restate it?

I think you're trying to call me scum because I put my vote on des and defended hybrid but hybrid was town so I don't really get your reasoning

 

it's scummy because it gives the apperance that you knew Hybrid was town, didn't vote him and are using the fact he flipped town to scold us townies and make yourself appear more scummy. Min did the same thing, only she voted for Hybrid.

 

 

I think it's even more important now that someone point out these reveals I appear to have missed

 

also Min, can you tell us the nature of your power?

is it passive or do you have to choose to use? is it a killing power, investigative power? one shot?

 

stop role fishing.

 

 

and i'm surprised no one else is pointing out this obviously scumtastic manuaver honestly.

 

 

normally i'd be against revealing findings, but right now our situation is different. like others said, scum will likely NK any confirmed innocents to keep the air of confusion in the game. but, right now our finder is able to view 2 people. this means, by revealing both people even if they are townie, we still have 1 up on the scum even if they NK a confirmed.

 

Our situation is the same as any other with confirmed innocents. Scum will kill them. I was trying to think of a better way to word it, but Nolder did it PERFECTLY. See below:

 

our situation is not the same because as far as we know theres only 1 kill a night. you go on to suggest multiple klling roles being a possability, even so, if Ishy goes on revealing 2 people each day, we're still 2 up on the scum, because if we're gonna trust Ishy's findings, we have to trust that he's also town himself.

 

 

Oh and for anyone thinking I'm defending Min and going along with her vote at the same time, remember I'm a vetted townie glad we got that out early!

 

your not vetted by any means, no more than i am desp. your assumed to be town. there could be a million things in play out there that woudl render Ishy a false reading on his views, so while it's less likely your scum, the possability stil exists for you to be anti-town.

 

 

Still catching up, but I wanted to interject with a quick question for Amadine:

 

@Amadine: Are you town? Yes or No, please.

 

looks like we have a LD.

 

JIC you get doubled and want to check Yes I am Town.

 

 

On Day 1, there was a series of discussions between Des and Hybrid. I got a gut feeling that pinged my personal scum detector from Hybrid. I voted to lynch him, and it turns out that the lynching of Hybrid revealed that he was a Roleblocker whom was a Dragon on my team, the Town Team. Clearly, everyone of us Town players made a mistake in the lynching of Hybrid.

Now, here we are on Day 2, and the deadline is coming up on Wednesday. I am not getting a scummy feel from anyone right now... at least not a strong enough ping to cast a vote. However, I shall sleep on this, and come back tomorrow. Hopefully, I can return in time to cast a vote before the deadline is reached.

 

this post reeks. first off, you give no thoughts on the things goign on today and there are plenty, 2nd you go through a big effort imo on stating your town, 3rd is that you don't throw a vote out even though the deadline is TODAY and state your not comming back until tomorrow.

 

if your not a skimming scum, your a skimming townie thats goign to be a hinder to us later when we need everyone for a majority.

[Red2111]

at this point, i think the Ed thing is a reach honestly. there are better candidates than ed at this point to have a second train on if we want to go that route (though i agree with Verb that competing trains are best left for the beginning of the day)

 

 

my lynch candidates for today are

 

Min - meesh sums this up rather well

Nol - because his reaching and post after hybrids death reek

Vam - for reasons stated in my last post.

[Red2111]

sorry fo the triple post but i also wanted to say

 

Ama gets a really big FoS from me for ignoring BG's direct question.

 

 

[Verbal32]

I don't see Vam's train.

And I think Min has already hinted at her role.....

 

She hasn't replied....gah....I think she targetted Ishy last night....

 

Blind One: try looking below Min's name and above yours. ;-)

[ed2funy]

There is approximately....7 hours to deadline?

[ed2funy]

I don't see Vam's train.

And I think Min has already hinted at her role.....

 

She hasn't replied....gah....I think she targetted Ishy last night....

 

Blind One: try looking below Min's name and above yours. ;-)

 

LMFAO. Not literally. -_-

 

I don't see it....YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN!

[Karasayl]

.htnaL dna taK :era teiuq neeb evah ohw elpoep elbaton oslA .worromot rof hcnyl laitnetop a eb thgim taht os....noitseuq s'gB ot kcab ylper amA raeh ot ekil dluow I .teiuq neeb seh ecnis mih no erusserp erom ees ot dekil evah dluow I tub ,erehwyna og ti ees yllaer t'ndid I ,maV no etov eht rof sA .hcum tib a hsif elor ot mees seod redloN ,dias gnieb tahT .tey tsuj niM no etov a no tnedifnoc leef t'nod llits I ,revewoH .esnes fo tol a sekam ehs kniht I dna ,tsop s'deR ekil I

 

redloN etoV ,etovnU

[bgrishinko]

Unofficial Vote Count:

 

Min (7) – Red, Sakaea, Verb, Ishy, Hoof, Ama, Raena

Vambram (2) – Barm, Karas

Ed (2) – Min, Des

Amadine (2) - Ed, bg

 

Not voting – Vam, Meesh, Lanth, Nolder, Kat

 

10 to lynch

 

 

What is up with the new train on the final day before deadline? A whopping 2 votes on Amadine is supposed to be the competing train? FOS to Ed for suggesting it, and HUGE FOS to bg for following it, especially when his vote had Min at L-2. Without giving reasons to not push the other trains, this is highly suspicious. I can understand Ed not wanting to vote himself (duh), but why not Vam? Why not Min? Why start a new train on the day the deadline hits?

 

First off, I'm not fully convinced on Min. Though I'll admit she's acting odd enough I'd prefer her over a Random Lynch. Second, there is time left, 8 PM MST is the deadline so that is about 10+ Hrs left. Lots of time to change votes back as both Ed and I said.

 

Secondly, look who is getting anxious and pushy... interesting. If we do lynch Min and she is town, you are on my list.

[Red2111]

actually, i'm gonna back Verbal up on this anxiousness over the late 2nd train. with DM how it usually is, even 10 hours to the deadline with split votes could cost us a mjajority and i'm NOT up for a no corner report random lynch.

 

to get info from a lynch we need the corner's report.

 

 

another ting i find odd. Meesh is active, is posting against Min yet hasn't voted for her. could be scum trying to push the lynch but covering her tracks by waiting to vote.

 

while i'm at it, Nol's lack of a vote, even an OMGUS to SHA (save his ass) is rather interesting in itself.

 

 

i'd like a reason from those two especially why they've yet to cast a vote.

 

 

i'd also liek Lanth to start speakign more as well. Rl could have happened, but since the No Lynch debate has dropped off he's dropped with it. i also forget who said it, but i agree that Barm's actions are poke worthy as well. i'd love to press that tree and see what shakes loose; he's faded into the background along with lanth.

[Nolder]

I haven't missed the deadline have I?

catching up now

[Nolder]

And Nolder, please try to review the most current posts before posting so you can gather your thoughts in as small a number of posts. 7 in a row is just kinda crazy, and it reduces the chance that people will remember or even read your first or any of your arguments.

I would put them all in one post but DM doesn't like me putting a bunch of quotes in one post

if you can't or wont read all my posts I'm ok with that

[Sakaea]

No, you haven't. It's 10-ish hours away.

[Nolder]

With a fresher face on Day 1 than everyone else, I want to say Desp doesn't feel scummy to me. Also I'm still not convinced of Ishy's claim, even with the doubler thing...

 

Also I wasn't getting good vibes from Barm and was my #1 on reread, and a lot of others seemed to get scum vibes from him too... then crap hit the fan and he was forgotten oh so quickly and conviently, Vote Barm

I'd like to note that I voted him because his avatar scares me and I didn't want to see it anymore and that was as good a reason as any to vote anyone on day 1

also note that I switched accordingly when the time came

[Nolder]

actually it does, because you defended a townie as if you knew yhat he WAS a townie, to appear innocent when he flipped. it is something any good mafia player would do, but you were perhas a bit too obvious about it.

I DID know he was a townie, remember?

I pretty much staked my life on it

read back, in retrospect my arguments were sound were they not?

I'm sorry if it's hard for you to believe but yes I was in fact aware Hybrid was town for reasons that should have been obvious to all players

[Nolder]

.hcum tib a hsif elor ot mees seod redloN ,dias gnieb tahT

can you tell me where I rolefished?

as far as I can remember I've done no such thing

[Nolder]

while i'm at it, Nol's lack of a vote, even an OMGUS to SHA (save his ass) is rather interesting in itself.

I explained my lack of a vote/activity awhile ago

and how can I OMGUS without voting?

this doesn't make any sense

[Kathleen]

Well, my life swamped me this week, and just when I thought I had free time I was pulled away again. I was Modding CB (which is over now), Playing in Ed's game (which I was lynched in *shakes fist at Red*) and doing reports (cause I always do them from the 25-28th so I can have them mostly done, have a break then fill in the blanks of activity between the 25-30th when the new month starts). On top of that, my husband decided this was the week to focus on 'family time' and so we went a lot more than usual, and I was cast in a little filming project that did end up taking me away for few days.

 

Now, I know that I'm done all of those things now, but I've been trying to re read and catch up before deadline and its just not happening. I can't get through the walls of text and I can't retain anything I'm reading now.

 

I haven asked Lily to replace me. I have tried for 3 days to use my free time to catch up in this game and I just can't. I am not going to vote now, as I don't know what is going on, but if it gets close to deadline and we need a hammer before random lynch I will do my best to be here to do that.

[hazelkrs1]

I like Red's post, and I think she makes a lot of sense. However, I still don't feel confident on a vote on Min just yet. That being said, Nolder does seem to role fish a bit much. As for the vote on Vam, I didn't really see it go anywhere, but I would have liked to see more pressure on him since hes been quiet. I would like to hear Ama reply back to Bg's question....so that might be a potential lynch for tomorrow. Also notable people who have been quiet are: Kat and Lanth.

 

For anyone wanting to see translation to Karas' post. He then unvoted and voted Nolder.

 

Red, good point about us not being vetted yet. I find it very unlikely you're scum tho at this point, all in all I'd say all your actions have been very pro-town and you don't seem to discriminate in pointing FOS's at those who are pinging.

 

I also agree with you that 10 hours is def not a lot of time at all for a train to be built, this would have pinged for me coming from BG but tbh I've already noticed he's really bad at voting for outliers at the last second. I mean I guess it can help a little bit for the next day, but it prevents us from applying pressure where it might best be served imo.

 

That being said, I think there are still enough votes on Min that if we need to there should be enough people that can hammer her just to prevent a random lynch. This might seem harsh, but the problem is we got too many people that are pinging somewhat right now.

 

The person honestly who seems to be pinging most to me is actually Nolder now. Especially with his last post; his whole defense of Hybrid was that Hybrid might be pinging in other ways, but we shouldn't have hammered him on account of him not saying he was town in his role reveal. Now all of a sudden Nolder claims he was aware and stating Hybrid was obviously town. MAJOR ping.

 

Unvote.

 

Vote Nolder.

 

Note: Min is still definitely pinging to me, but we still should try to gain more info on other players with competing trains if possible, but either way I wouldn't be completely disappointed about a lynch on Min. Her post saying she wasn't asking for a role reveal but an alignment reveal is re-he-heally scummy looking.

[Nolder]

ok I'm caught up and I'm going to Vote: Vambram

his participation on the Hybrid lynch and his seemingly being on a team with Ish strikes me as scum partners

I might not be back again until tomorrow (game tomorrow not IRL) so here's some reads in case I die

 

Des: town

Kara: town

meesh: town

[Nolder]

The person honestly who seems to be pinging most to me is actually Nolder now. Especially with his last post; his whole defense of Hybrid was that Hybrid might be pinging in other ways, but we shouldn't have hammered him on account of him not saying he was town in his role reveal. Now all of a sudden Nolder claims he was aware and stating Hybrid was obviously town. MAJOR ping.

I only agreed that Hybrid seemed a little scummy after Ama's post but by that point I was already convinced he was town

look at the damn evidence!

the blatant bandwagoning with little reason

hybrid as scum wouldn't claim roleblocker

scum wouldn't bus their roleblocker so easily

 

it's all there if you take a damn second to think

 

but given your vote on such shakey grounds it looks like that might be too much for you

[bgrishinko]

ok I'm caught up and I'm going to Vote: Vambram

his participation on the Hybrid lynch and his seemingly being on a team with Ish strikes me as scum partners

I might not be back again until tomorrow (game tomorrow not IRL) so here's some reads in case I die

 

Des: town

Kara: town

meesh: town

 

 

What the?

 

Only day 2 and 3 town reads already?

[hazelkrs1]

The person honestly who seems to be pinging most to me is actually Nolder now. Especially with his last post; his whole defense of Hybrid was that Hybrid might be pinging in other ways, but we shouldn't have hammered him on account of him not saying he was town in his role reveal. Now all of a sudden Nolder claims he was aware and stating Hybrid was obviously town. MAJOR ping.

I only agreed that Hybrid seemed a little scummy after Ama's post but by that point I was already convinced he was town

look at the damn evidence!

the blatant bandwagoning with little reason

hybrid as scum wouldn't claim roleblocker

scum wouldn't bus their roleblocker so easily

 

it's all there if you take a damn second to think

 

but given your vote on such shakey grounds it looks like that might be too much for you

 

1. Blatant bandwagoning can happen on anyone, including scum. Blatant bandwagoning does NOT vet someone in any way.

2. We now know Hybrid was townie, but potential reasons for Hybrid to claim RB'er even if he was scum include being worried there would be a lie detector, role cop, or confusing town enough to discourage a lynch on himself.

3. Most important: doesn't change the fact you weren't stating he was obviously town before, you were arguing against the argument saying it was weird he didn't claim town. Now you're trying to make it seem like you were stating he was town the whole time.

[Nolder]

The person honestly who seems to be pinging most to me is actually Nolder now. Especially with his last post; his whole defense of Hybrid was that Hybrid might be pinging in other ways, but we shouldn't have hammered him on account of him not saying he was town in his role reveal. Now all of a sudden Nolder claims he was aware and stating Hybrid was obviously town. MAJOR ping.

I only agreed that Hybrid seemed a little scummy after Ama's post but by that point I was already convinced he was town

look at the damn evidence!

the blatant bandwagoning with little reason

hybrid as scum wouldn't claim roleblocker

scum wouldn't bus their roleblocker so easily

 

it's all there if you take a damn second to think

 

but given your vote on such shakey grounds it looks like that might be too much for you

 

1. Blatant bandwagoning can happen on anyone, including scum. Blatant bandwagoning does NOT vet someone in any way.

2. We now know Hybrid was townie, but potential reasons for Hybrid to claim RB'er even if he was scum include being worried there would be a lie detector, role cop, or confusing town enough to discourage a lynch on himself.

3. Most important: doesn't change the fact you weren't stating he was obviously town before, you were arguing against the argument saying it was weird he didn't claim town. Now you're trying to make it seem like you were stating he was town the whole time.

1. the key part of this is the reasoning. because he didn't say he was town? PAH LEEZ

2. if there was an investigative role that could out him they'd need another night and hybrid himself could have roleblocked them, this makes no sense

3. this has nothing to do with scum bussing their roleblocker so easily so I'll address you below

 

uhhh I wasn't? because I think staking my life on his alignment says I am pretty damn sure

was I absolutely 100% convinced? not really

this is an advanced game and nothing is ever certain in mafia

but I was at least 90%

bottom line is I was right and whoever was on that lynch was wrong

now you're attacking me with the same BS reasoning that got hybrid killed

oh I seemed too sure? oh I wasn't sure before but now I am? HMMM SEEMS SUSPICIOUS BETTER VOTE

 

give me a break

your only case is the too townie argument and it's faulty

[Red2111]

actually it does, because you defended a townie as if you knew yhat he WAS a townie, to appear innocent when he flipped. it is something any good mafia player would do, but you were perhas a bit too obvious about it.

I DID know he was a townie, remember?

I pretty much staked my life on it

read back, in retrospect my arguments were sound were they not?

I'm sorry if it's hard for you to believe but yes I was in fact aware Hybrid was town for reasons that should have been obvious to all players

 

so let me get this striaght, now your claiming that you KNEW he was a townie?? as far as i'm concerned this is a big fruedian slip and is good enough for me to really push your lynch. explain to me how you KNEW Hybrid was a townie.

 

UNVOTE VOTE: NOL

 

.hcum tib a hsif elor ot mees seod redloN ,dias gnieb tahT

can you tell me where I rolefished?

as far as I can remember I've done no such thing

 

he was responding to my quote, where you role fished Min for what type of role she has when she said she wont reveal. it's was blantant role fishing.

 

 

while i'm at it, Nol's lack of a vote, even an OMGUS to SHA (save his ass) is rather interesting in itself.

I explained my lack of a vote/activity awhile ago

and how can I OMGUS without voting?

this doesn't make any sense

 

i was stating that even a lack of an OMGUS vote to save your as since alot of people find you suspicious is interesting.

 

 

i hate moving my vote from min at this point because the deadines so close. but with a statement like "I knew he was town" from Nol, thats too big of a slip to pass up. if the Nol train goes no where i'll move my vote back to Min, i'll be on until 3pm CST so thats plenty of time