[Advanced] Monty Python and the Holy Grail Mafia (Game Over)

[Niniel]

I hope you get better soon, Min. *aiel hug*

[Tiinker]

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:37 AM, Jack_D said:

I'd rather not prove my innocence by death.

 

Then seriously.. Find another way to prove it. We're all speculating it and you're not defending yourself really with anything other than "I'm good at this game."

 

A) Power role

B) Symp

C) Mafia

 

Which one is it?

[Tiinker]

I'll be missing for the day most likely tomorrow and probably won't be on till Wednesday night due to work loads. Sorry guys..

[Krakalakachkn]

Night will end Tuesday at 2pm EST (or whenever all the night actions have been received)

[Sedai]

I've defended well enough. I showed the holes in Red's argument. The same argument that would have saw me lynched. I presented evidence against other people attacking me and why their reason was flawed. I'm not going to reveal. I didn't at L-1 and I'm not going to do it at night. That's pretty suspicious of you tiinker. It I reveal as any of the three it would be one To keep myself alive. So those three options are a trap in and of themselves. A situation where all the glasses are poisoned. If my defense wasn't good enough for you well that's both of our problems isn't it. I've said more then I'm good at this game, if you selectively read well that's how you play the game.

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 8:41 PM, Tiinker said:

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:37 AM, Jack_D said:

I'd rather not prove my innocence by death.

 

Then seriously.. Find another way to prove it. We're all speculating it and you're not defending yourself really with anything other than "I'm good at this game."

 

A) Power role

B) Symp

C) Mafia

 

Which one is it?

[Graendals favourite]

Well, personally, I can't make heads or tails of this one, but if Jack isn't guilt, I know nothing.

[Alanna]

I'm so lost with who I find suspicious right now. All I know is:

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 5:04 AM, bgrishinko said:

So how about that 4%. Oh, and I don't blame you for not voting yourself Jack... I wouldn't do it either. I also think that FoSing you for it seems a bit shady...

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 5:19 AM, WWWwombat said:

Anyone saying Jack should have voted himself is wrong. Whether Jack is scum or town, he knows his own alignment and he doesn't know the alignment of who the random lynch will hit (just the odds).

 

Glad I'm not the only one who thinks this. I'd never hammer myself, some mods actually have a rule where you're not allowed to vote for yourself. Because it's ridiculous.

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:32 PM, WWWwombat said:

I don't really have a case on Red. It's more meta/gut. I think something's off about her.

 

I'm getting that too, but I think it might just be because her PR is really getting on my nerves.

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:51 PM, keyholder21 said:

ohmygosh, let's please waste more time talking about the same exact things .

 

inorite? :P

 

All I know is, this Red-Jack back and forth is distracting from everything else, and Red, I mean that on both sides - you keep saying Jack is distracting everyone, but you're doing the same thing. You both think each other are scum. We get it.

 

I think I should do a reread, especially of Day 1, because I feel like a lot of this started there, only all I remember from Day 1 was the crazy quote-fest.

[Sedai]

Someone needs to run a valleygirl mafia. Just saying.

[Leelou]

  On 6/27/2011 at 10:52 PM, Jack_D said:

Someone needs to run a valleygirl mafia. Just saying.

 

All I can think of is the original Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

[Graendals favourite]

I actually think we need to get rid of Moon, Jack, and Min, in that order.

[Graendals favourite]

But I haven't yet gone through my comprehensive review.

[Sedai]

Super Triangle Gambit of Dhoom

[Alanna]

What is the suspicion on Min about? Can anyone give mne a summary? I think that was one of those things I was lost on from Day 1.

[Graendals favourite]

Let me go through the posts. I think Minuet is a candidate, but I need to read.

[Sedai]

GF why get rid of me?

 

Why get rid of Moon?

[Graendals favourite]

These are just hunches. But I've gotten to trust my hunches. Still, I will read on what has happened before tomorrow.

[Sedai]

  On 6/28/2011 at 1:19 AM, Graendals favourite said:

These are just hunches. But I've gotten to trust my hunches. Still, I will read on what has happened before tomorrow.

 

I respect your honesty and your straightforwardness. You didn't try and use someone else's flawed reasoning in different words you shot it straight. It's a safe statement though one you can easily escape culpabilty from, but it seems honest, I guess is the best word for it

[berf]

Jack, you seriously don't see anything scummy about Moons behavior?

[Sedai]

Berg I see the scummy behavior but I want to see what GF sees. His post seemed like a filler post. He named three people that most found suspicious and I wanted to know why he thought so. I wanted to see if it wasn't a post to seem like a townie

[Sedai]

I would of asked for why he thought Min, but he said he was looking and I didn't want to sound redundant

[Red2111]

*Red continues to poke the fire, it's light reflecting off her black armor*

 

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 7:56 PM, Minuet said:

Moon I have suspected since all the quote fest stopped. She has been pinging me more then Red was. I just didn't like how Red was going after so many people and how she was taking what I did and said out of context because I wasn't using the quote box when I was answering questions.

 

Moon pinged you more, yet you decided to focus in on me instead of helping to build a case on her for the remainder of Day 1?

 

 

Min, i always pressure multiple people; you've never complained abotu it until now and we've played many games together, so this "reason" for wanting to go after me is flimsy at best. besides if you only focus on one person at a time, how on earth do you expect to find scum.

 

 

and i didn't take anything you said out of context Min. my original beef with ou is the Wombat vote and how you felt the need to explain your vote and remove it (with another explination btw) without any pressure on you to do so. as i've said before, we all realized your vote on Womby was a joke, it's the fact you felt the need to explain it twice with no pressure on you that reeks. once again post the proof of pressure you got directly in result of your Joke vote on Womby if you have it and i'll drop it. but when i did my re-read, i didn't see any.

 

 

 

my answers are in Red

  On 6/27/2011 at 10:18 PM, Alanna said:

Glad I'm not the only one who thinks this. I'd never hammer myself, some mods actually have a rule where you're not allowed to vote for yourself. Because it's ridiculous.

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:32 PM, WWWwombat said:

I don't really have a case on Red. It's more meta/gut. I think something's off about her.

 

I'm getting that too, but I think it might just be because her PR is really getting on my nerves.

 

I'm not clarifying whether or not i may or maynot have a PR, but if it's on your nerves then don't read it. it's not like it takes up my entire post, it's generally no more than a sentence at the uppermost part of my post. fairly easy to ignore if you ask me and regaurdless what if i have no choice? should you really base your opinion on someone off of something so easily ignored and that they may or maynot have any control over? i get that PR's or Role Plays annoy people at times, including those that use them; but i can't agree in using that as a reason to suspect them, i mean i've said plenty that scum could attempt to use against me if they're brave enough.

 

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:51 PM, keyholder21 said:

ohmygosh, let's please waste more time talking about the same exact things .

 

inorite? :P

 

All I know is, this Red-Jack back and forth is distracting from everything else, and Red, I mean that on both sides - you keep saying Jack is distracting everyone, but you're doing the same thing. You both think each other are scum. We get it.

 

I agree the back & forth is distracting; i've said so multiple times myself. but you see Jack is still trying to drag it out by responding to my posts and trying to incite a reation either by prodding, mis interpreting what i'm saying or just blantly ignoring parts of my posts. i've refused to argue with him unless something new presents itself and i've pretty much made good on my statement. so who is scummier in this situation, me whose announced that it's beating a dead horse and stopped, or Jack who is trying to continue beating the same dead horse?

 

 

I think I should do a reread, especially of Day 1, because I feel like a lot of this started there, only all I remember from Day 1 was the crazy quote-fest.

 

 

Alanna, plenty has been FoS'd since D1; yet you have yet to give your opinion or even voice an opinion on the Moon situation and Min as well. and it's interesting that you only point at myself & Jack being distracting; what about the Charis/Jack back & Forth which has been goign on since D1. because Jack is tryign to do the same thing to Charis as well.

[Sedai]

Please Red, stop that self righteous line. Everytime you post I address all points you make. You've yet to address any of mine though. So again you are accusing someone of the same thing your doing and then you one up them and call them scum.

 

Red if you don't get reactions how are you supposed to play the game. Yeah I'm trying to get reactions and I've been doing so and will continue to do so.

 

No Red your lying again you refused to respond because you though I was making personal attacks. I just quoted you and highlighted and bolder your own words.

 

Actually Red I think your scummier. A person who won't answer any questions, accuses people of the same things they are doing, blatantly trimming posts and lying to make your self sound better and make the other person sound scummier.

 

I'm not trying to do the same thing with Charis. In fact I've been concentrating on you and then Charis popped in yesterday and brought herself into it. If you would read back you would see that. But I guess it's much more convenient to paint me as scummy because that way the points I've made against you would appear less valid.

[keyholder21]

I really don't know what to think with all of 3 of you going back and forth. I've reread the string and still can't make heads or tails. You will all make a good point that makes me think town and then say something scummy right after, or vice versa.

 

I still think Moon is scummy, her answers weren't good enough imo to tell me why I shouldn't lynch her. The newt thing would make sense for this game, but that doesn't explain her scumminess on day 1.

[Alanna]

  On 6/28/2011 at 12:56 PM, Red2111 said:

  On 6/27/2011 at 1:32 PM, WWWwombat said:

I don't really have a case on Red. It's more meta/gut. I think something's off about her.

 

I'm getting that too, but I think it might just be because her PR is really getting on my nerves.

 

I'm not clarifying whether or not i may or maynot have a PR, but if it's on your nerves then don't read it. it's not like it takes up my entire post, it's generally no more than a sentence at the uppermost part of my post. fairly easy to ignore if you ask me and regaurdless what if i have no choice? should you really base your opinion on someone off of something so easily ignored and that they may or maynot have any control over? i get that PR's or Role Plays annoy people at times, including those that use them; but i can't agree in using that as a reason to suspect them, i mean i've said plenty that scum could attempt to use against me if they're brave enough.

 

It's odd that you took this statement so personally, Red. For one thing, you seem to have misunderstood me; I said 'She's rubbing me the wrong way too, but I think it's just her PR.' Meaning that I don't find you scummy because of your PR, yet you've responded here as if I've said I do. You know me better than that, Red, how stupid would it be to find someone scummy just because you think their PR is annoying? I'm starting to get what Min meant about you twisting people's words. I don't think you do it because you're scummy; I don't think you're scum, in fact. But this isn't the first game I've seen you do this, either.

 

Secondly, I said your PR is annoying, not you, and when I said it, I said it assuming that it is a real PR; I don't really see reason to think otherwise, at this point. So please don't take it so personally. At this point I'm cursing whoever gave you the PR, be it the mod or someone else, not you. It's just weird you got so offended over it.

 

Thirdly, geez, it was a joking statement. You can't even have fun in a mafia game around here anymore.

 

  Quote

I agree the back & forth is distracting; i've said so multiple times myself. but you see Jack is still trying to drag it out by responding to my posts and trying to incite a reation either by prodding, mis interpreting what i'm saying or just blantly ignoring parts of my posts. i've refused to argue with him unless something new presents itself and i've pretty much made good on my statement. so who is scummier in this situation, me whose announced that it's beating a dead horse and stopped, or Jack who is trying to continue beating the same dead horse?

 

  Quote

Alanna, plenty has been FoS'd since D1; yet you have yet to give your opinion or even voice an opinion on the Moon situation and Min as well. and it's interesting that you only point at myself & Jack being distracting; what about the Charis/Jack back & Forth which has been goign on since D1. because Jack is tryign to do the same thing to Charis as well.

 

Maybe you missed the part where I said I'm totally lost and need to do a reread; I wouldn't be surprised, since you're tunneling right now. Let me say it again: I'm lost and need to do a reread, though at this point, I'm considering just asking to be replaced. I've been lost in this game since the ridiculous Day 1 quotefest, which, not having seen much of the movie, was a ridiculous waste of time in the game to me (I don't expect any sympathy with that, though, since you all seem to think it a crime not to have seen this movie ).

 

I didn't want to make excuses, but I was also dealing with some personal things over the past few days, so I was just barely keeping up with the thread. I'm trying to get back into it now, and finding it extremely difficult because of this going on between you and Jack. I don't know that I think either of you are scum, but I do think neither of you are helping the town by tunneling on each other. I'm not the only one to have said it, either, yet, still you're both doing it. I keep waiting for one of you to be the mature one and say, "You know what, you're right, let's move on from this.' Maybe it's because you're so convinced each other are scum, but acting this way is about it is not convincing anyone. It's just making me want to ignore the both of you more and more.

[Sedai]

Alanna your rite. I've said my peace at why I think Ref is scum. It seemed like she was talking at me and not to me and that kinda annoyed me. So moving on...