Shadow over Fiddlesmouth Game Thread [GAME OVER, TOWN WINS]

[Quibby]

You'll note that I'm not voting for you, Alys, nor for DPR.  I don't fully believe my own argument there, so I was wondering if anybody else was thinking the same thing; that doesn't seem to be the case.

[Tigraine]

I'm doing rereads of the games I am in so I can make my spreadsheets, I gotta get my kids to bed right now so I will make more posts starting tomorrow.

 

 

No ed...I will not lynch my kids for needing to go to bed  :P

[Alys Kinch]

first, being on cell, no, i cannot note that you are not voting for me.

 

second, people must learn, i don't lie unless i feel forced. i gave my legit reason for removing my vote.

 

third, i argue when i feel justified rather than waiting until misguidance builds an argument too good to fight. lesson learned from the great one, may she haunt us forever.

[Quibby]

My apologies.  I have a bad habit of thinking out loud in Mafia games, so to say.  Helps me keep my prone-to-wandering mind in the same vicinity as the game.

[Kivam]

Nah Lavi.. that honor goes to Mynd.  His first game ever he slaughtered the innocent team.  He was the healer.

 

i remember that.  And then we played the next game with Alts, and he got all upset because people were using "you're playing like Mynd" as an insult  ;D

[ed2funy]

Wow....

You're all wrong. Quibby has parts everyone can enjoy. :D

 

Also...what's with this Nostalgia crap?! I want some..

Is Min in this game? :D

[Quibby]

... Okay, how do you slaughter the innocents as the healer?  It doesn't seem physically possible.

[Kivam]

Vote Count

 

Quibby (3) - Aemon, Lavinya, Thorum

Aemon (1) -  Thorum

DPR (3) - mcs, Al Jenn, Hybrid

Hybrid (2) - Nae, DSworn

Barm (2) - Pandy, Lia

Wombat (2) - Pookie, DPR

Crusher (1) - Ed

Alanna (2) - Jeran, WWWwombat

Thorum (3) - Barm, Quibby, Crusher

DSworn (1) - Alys

Pandy (1) - Anox

 

With 24 players living, it takes 13 votes to lynch.

 

Not voting Danya, Verbal, Tigraine

 

[Pookie]

... Okay, how do you slaughter the innocents as the healer?  It doesn't seem physically possible.

I don't think I read that game, but my guess is probably through leading lynches, maybe through unwittingly healing mafioso a vig/SK is trying to kill.

 

Thanks for the explanation Alys.  I partly wondered if it was like Pete suggested -- metagaming due to being able to read a friend well.  Lots of people seem to have negative opinions on metagaming, but to me it's just another extension of the same instinct people use to figure out what seems fishy.  *shrugs*

[ed2funy]

A Healer led lynches on townies?

Wow.

 

So, we don't have a time limit unless the game stalls?

*shudders at the memory of almost 100 pages for Day 1*

 

 

EDIT: Yea, lynch leading is my idea! :P

[Barmacral]

... Okay, how do you slaughter the innocents as the healer?  It doesn't seem physically possible.

 

He was possibly the best unwitting symp ever.

[Lavinya]

I think I was healer or perhaps roleblocker and managed to use my role to further Sirayn's agenda rather than do any good for the town. That's a sure way to slaughter innocents, or at least ensure they're not as safe as the mafia goddess!

 

I haven't voted for you either Alys, or DPR. Just tossing around possibilities. I think it's highly possible that Quibby is evil. Whether or not he's mafia is yet to be seen, but he is totally evil. :P

[Quibby]

I will not argue the fact that I am evil.  Evidence of years gone by is a bit too telling for me to get away with that.  However, that doesn't apply to this game.

[Jeran]

Didn't Hybrid say something a few pages back about getting on to night so that "we" can kill people?   

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote

 

Vote Hybrid[/glow]

 

I thought I detected a hint by someone which may make them innocent if true, but who knows.  I don't know anything about Cthulhu.

 

P.S. I'm actually pretty busy at work lately...and more importantly I'm actually doing the work.  ;D  I won't be posting much during the day on weekdays as some have already noticed (at least for this week).

[DPR]

 

If I was Tom Cruise, I'd say that somebody was glib.  ;) It's a nice touch, though - not too obvious, but not too subtle (exactly the way Lavinya likes it when you softly blow in her ear.  :-*).

 

The part I liked the most was about how all of the information gained  would tell us about me or about Alys- but no mention of the person who started the bandwagon. heh

 

Don't get me wrong - I'm not OMGUSing - but you gotta admire the player who takes a handful of day 1 silliness and neatly sets up Alys and myself. It reminds me...of me.  8)

[Quibby]

Then I should go ahead and not mention that it was unintentional? :P

[Hybrid]

Didn't Hybrid say something a few pages back about getting on to night so that "we" can kill people?   

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote

 

Vote Hybrid[/glow]

 

Yep.  Here's the quote:

 

Technically Wes.. there are now more than 13 votes.  You didn't specify that they all had to be on one person.

 

Hybrid.  You are on to me.  Curse you for foiling my plan! (Psst.. do you think they will buy that we aren't on a team together?  We are trying to distance ourselves and all by claiming revenge for a past game and all.)

 

Definitely.  We've totally pulled the wool over their eyes.  Watch, now I'm going to shamelessly bandwagon someone so that we can move on to night and start killing people.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote and vote DPR[/glow]

But seriously, DPR has been massively spamming.  Methinks he's plotting something...

 

[glow=red,2,300]Unvote and vote Jeran[/glow]

For taking a joke post, misrepresenting it, and trying to start a bandwagon.

[DPR]

Then I should go ahead and not mention that it was unintentional? :P

 

I wouldn't! I'd push it and go for the badass street cred, but that's just me. Either way, don't stop - I was very much enjoying the subtley interwoven though the spam - kind of like the barest hint of anise in an '89 Beaujolais. By all means, continue.  ;D

[Lavinya]

Oh DPR, it's not even night yet! *sultry look*

 

Hybrid is talking way too much for me to consider him mafia at this point. Quibby has openly admitted to being evil. 'Nuff said. XD

[Quibby]

Probably couldn't recreate it if I tried.  Last Mafia game I played was Lia's BSG game in August.  Doesn't help that I'm sick to the point where my brain doesn't seem to want to cooperate.  It likes fluffy purple bunnies and fields of poppies right now.

[Lavinya]

And that's different from normal how? Sounds like someone is subtly employing a confused act, which I always get accused of. *chants softly* scum, scum, scum, scum...

[Alys Kinch]

as long as quib is in the opiates...

 

loving all the half plays that could be subtle but aren't. so fun.

[Quibby]

Lavi, you of all people should know that I am not a fluffy anything person.  I'm not confused so much as I'm babbling. :P

 

And I love the fact that everybody is thinking that I'm trying to be subtle and sneaky when I have no reason, need, or desire to be.  Apparently "bull in a china shop straightforward" is an unknown play style.

[Liathiana]

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

 

No more need for a silly vote, so I'll wait to vote until I have a *as good as one can get on Day 1* case for someone.

[Lavinya]

THE CHAD! Shhhh! Stop trying to get out of your well deserved lynch!