[Mafia, "The Inn" Edition] Movie Madness: Places everyone.. the show has begun!

[WWWwombat]

It's ok I see why you did it.  At this point we have numbers and I don't have an important role anyway, so it is probably worth the risk to confirm me.  Besides, I always carry at least two handguns with me and I'm sure you can set up some nasty traps for the mafia.  If the mafia doesn't get us I will probably be thankful to you for confirming me because I'm fickle like that ;D

[Tigraine]

Okay, I'm following along but my mind is in slow motion today so let me get this straight...first wombat was really ticked and now he's not...does that sum it up? :D

[Naeann]

There are usually 3/4 rl days to 1 mafia day.  Being drunk one day doesn't excuse the fact that you didn't make a peep at all the entire rest of the time.  Sorry if you don't like that but you had plenty of time to make a post.

[ed2funy]

It was a well written theory, but I am innocent.

 

Let the lie detector if there is one view that statement.

 

Now come on Pete....we all know there are roles that view innocent.

 

Tigs..it seems like it. I am thinking more and more that he is mafia. I agree with Pete's WIFOM's post...of course..Pete could be mafia too.

[WWWwombat]

I wasn't pissed, I was dismayed.

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

It was a well written theory, but I am innocent.

 

Let the lie detector if there is one view that statement.

 

Now come on Pete....we all know there are roles that view innocent.

 

Tigs..it seems like it. I am thinking more and more that he is mafia. I agree with Pete's WIFOM's post...of course..Pete could be mafia too.

 

Not a lie detector, they view statements not the person so they get an accurate reading

[ed2funy]

Perhaps.

A mod may choose to say they are innocent, when in reality they technically are not.

 

:P Yes, I realize I am most likely wrong. :D

[Verbal32]

It was a well written theory, but I am innocent.

 

Let the lie detector if there is one view that statement.

 

And besides Wombat just seems off to me, and I hammered Tyn, when in fact I was more suspicous of Panda. I still don't think that Panda should be free of suspicoun just because Tyn was mafia.

 

I agree with this, but I don't think we should lynch Pandy and let him win if he's a Jester.  We know what happened with you in the PB game, so we'll keep that in the back of our minds, but we should let him live for now.

 

And to the person who asked what the normal ratio is, usually it is 1/3 scum.  That doesn't always mean 1/3 mafia, as there could be solo win and cult thrown in there as well.  But that is a general guideline, and any game could be different, so take that with a bucket of salt.

[ed2funy]

A whole bucket now?

Interesting. :P

 

Ok..thanks. I thought it was slightly less than that. :-\

[Naeann]

Still waiting on some night actions....

[Talya]

It was a well written theory, but I am innocent.

 

Let the lie detector if there is one view that statement.

 

And besides Wombat just seems off to me, and I hammered Tyn, when in fact I was more suspicous of Panda. I still don't think that Panda should be free of suspicoun just because Tyn was mafia.

 

I agree with this, but I don't think we should lynch Pandy and let him win if he's a Jester.  We know what happened with you in the PB game, so we'll keep that in the back of our minds, but we should let him live for now.

 

And to the person who asked what the normal ratio is, usually it is 1/3 scum.  That doesn't always mean 1/3 mafia, as there could be solo win and cult thrown in there as well.  But that is a general guideline, and any game could be different, so take that with a bucket of salt.

 

It's not it's 1/4  if you have 12 players 3 will be scum, that is a quarter. i wiosh people would get that bit right I see too often 1/3 branded around!

[WWWwombat]

29k!

[Talya]

?

[mcs0083]

29,000 POUNDS!

[Talya]

But why out it in the Mafia thread i was meaning!!!!

[mcs0083]

You owe the mafia 29,000 pounds?

[Verbal32]

It's not it's 1/4  if you have 12 players 3 will be scum, that is a quarter. i wiosh people would get that bit right I see too often 1/3 branded around!

 

Excuse me?  There are a TON of examples, on this site and others, of games with 1/3 scum.  Notice how I said "scum" and not "mafia" before you start in on me.  A lot of people attribute "scum" to mafia members, cult members, or solo winners.

 

Each mod is different, and sets their ratios up accordingly.  But I see 1/3 more often nowadays than 1/4.  A few years ago I would have agreed with you, but not anymore.

 

Also, I believe I mentioned taking that with a bucket of salt, and that games can vary.  You come flying in with a definitive statement like that, and I feel like I just got flamed.  I'm surprised that it was you, Talya.  :(

[WWWwombat]

But why out it in the Mafia thread i was meaning!!!!

 

Cuz i noticed it here.

[WWWwombat]

*bats eyelashes at Verbal*

[Red2111]

*sighs&  i wish it was Day already

[Talya]

It's not it's 1/4  if you have 12 players 3 will be scum, that is a quarter. i wiosh people would get that bit right I see too often 1/3 branded around!

 

 

 

 

Each mod is different, and sets their ratios up accordingly.  But I see 1/3 more often nowadays than 1/4.  A few years ago I would have agreed with you, but not anymore.

 

Also, I believe I mentioned taking that with a bucket of salt, and that games can vary.  You come flying in with a definitive statement like that, and I feel like I just got flamed.  I'm surprised that it was you, Talya.  :(

 

On a basic game that is the correct ratio otherwise the innocents have no chance of winning. If there are more than it needs to be balanced out, i have seen too many games on here where it isn't like that and the townies might as well give up straight away. There needs to be balance, so I always looked at 1/4. And I would like to see where scum means something other than mafia, as no one uses it for anything other than that. Cult are cult and solo winners are just that!

Excuse me?  There are a TON of examples, on this site and others, of games with 1/3 scum.  Notice how I said "scum" and not "mafia" before you start in on me.  A lot of people attribute "scum" to mafia members, cult members, or solo winners.

 

 

[Tigraine]

Okay, I give up!  What's a good program to use to make a spreadsheet? 

[WWWwombat]

I use Excel, but if you don't have it and want something free, try OpenOffice.org

[Tigraine]

Thank you!  I didn't expect all of the games to be going on at the same time and I know that I'm slacking on some of them without meaning to.

[Red2111]

i use excel as well, its been a life saver from a mod point of veiw :)

 

also with me being in so many mafia's i can't rave about it being helpful enough :)