DSage Presents: Heroes vs Villains Mafia - GAME OVER, HEROES WIN!!!!

[a pale tanned lover]

Yeah i think Nae might have some crazy "must" vote role.

[Verbal32]

Nae: Would I seem more or less scummy to you if I simply unvoted and waited until I had more evidence to vote? So far, you, Pandy and Thorum are majorly pinging my radar as being scum. You for jumping on my back and the vote changing (I realize this is Day 1, but come on); Pandy for the miller reveal; and Thorum for the first vote of the game - seems a little bloodthirsty to me.

 

it is definately pretty bloodthirsty on her part. If im not mistaken, the pandy lynch has disintegrated, so we can use him later on. I find the thorum lynch pretty ridiculous, since someone has to cast the first vote. So the only one on my radar now is Nae.

 

These 2 are tops on my list for now.

 

Rose:

1.  the vote changing is unlikely a scum role, and the fact that you posted this after I even voiced concern that it isn't a scum role is.....well, scummy.

2.  Pandy revealing as Miller is not scummy in itself.  As pointed out by others, it is actually a good play for town, and a bad play for a mafia.  He wouldn't take the risk that we lynch him on the spot if he was mafia.  However, for a townie, it is a smart play.  I think he's innocent.

3.  Thorum for voting first?  Really?  I don't buy that one...

 

LZM:

1.  Agreeing with Rose on the Nae vote is opportunistic, but backing down right away after probably seeing Crusher quote my post (did you ignore the original?) is suspicious.

2.  "Use" the Pandy lynch later on?  What does that mean?  He's most likely innocent, as explained.  Why go back?  That's.....scummy?

3.  Ok, I agree with you on Thorum.  That's why you're not 1st on my list.  ;)

[LedZepMan]

Verb, honestly, I noticed you original, hence why I quoted YOUR post on it. It dinged me really scummy that Nae would do that, so I voted for her. After taking teh time to think it over, and inputting your take on it, I have since decided that I really don't know what to think on the matter. Does that ease your suspicions now.

 

And I don't know who said it, but if pandy is the miller, we keep him alive, and if we need to later, lynch him. The post is there somewhere, and it makes a lot of sense.

[peacesells]

 

And I don't know who said it, but if pandy is the miller, we keep him alive, and if we need to later, lynch him. The post is there somewhere, and it makes a lot of sense.

 

It was me that posted it.  I was giving options for both sides of the equation.  That was one of them.

[Talya]

I think Nae has to vote for the person directly before her or at least it looked that way. I think this role is normally town based. I think if she really thought someone was mafia she would get an explaination. I have a feeling she does seem to get these kind of roles. That sucks.

[Verbal32]

Verb, honestly, I noticed you original, hence why I quoted YOUR post on it. It dinged me really scummy that Nae would do that, so I voted for her. After taking teh time to think it over, and inputting your take on it, I have since decided that I really don't know what to think on the matter. Does that ease your suspicions now.

 

No, not really.  ;)

[LedZepMan]

Lol. I have no experience with a role like this. So you guys are saying that this is normally a town based role then?

[Talya]

Thinking back over it all, I now think that Thorum may well be mafia. I think Rose over reacted slightly and was surprised she questioned Nae about what Nae had said after everything else we had said about her role! I dont see it as too scummy though, but worth noting.

 

I think at present I will go for [glow=red,2,300]Thorum[/glow]. I'm sure his lynch will provide some information. Between him and Pandy I think something is going on as I said before. Thorum seems more likely to be mafia than Pandy, but I'm still not ruling pandy out.

[mmeeshal]

I've never been in a game with a role like the one Nae possibly has, but I agree that it seems unlikely that it would be given to a mafioso.  After all, it would be pretty unfair to be forced to draw that much attention to yourself that way if you're mafia.

 

As for the others....  I guess I don't necessarily see a connection between Pandy and Thorum.  Other than their back-and-forth, which I guess could seem suspicious.  And that is a better reason to vote Thorum than for voting first; SOMEone has to vote first.:D

 

Ah, okay, nvm, went back and read your post about Pandy and Thorum, Talya.  It makes more sense then.

[LedZepMan]

MEESH IS A MAFIA SQUIRREL SYMPIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Toy and Minion]

Post Count

 

Thorum (3): mnwhiterose, cosmicpanda, Talya

Naeann (3): Smash, LedZepMan, Crusher

 

cosmicpanda (2): dragonsworn, Thorum

 

whiterose (1): Naeann

 

With 15 alive, it takes 8 votes to lynch

 

Not voting: mmeeshal, peacesells, Pale Merlot, mcs, Verbal, LilyElizabeth

[mmeeshal]

MEESH IS A MAFIA SQUIRREL SYMPIE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Okay, even as a joke, let's dissect this here.

 

Why add "symp" on there at all?  Why not go ahead and just say I'm mafia?  What is the POINT?

 

 

Maybe it's because you're mafia, and you know I'm not. *arch*

[LedZepMan]

oh, calm down meesh, ya know I heart you lol.

 

 

[mmeeshal]

The fact that you "heart" me doesn't count for diddly-squat in mafia games, Zep. :P

 

And it's not going to make me stop suspecting you for that possible slip-up.

[Naeann]

I have no PR saying I must vote in every post.  I just felt like it. ;D

[LedZepMan]

lol. well then. My vote stays on Nae. if its not a pr, then some of my suspicions on Nae are upped now that she said that.

 

Off to work, good night all of yous

[The Crusher]

I have no PR saying I must vote in every post.  I just felt like it. ;D

 

 

 

Do you do this kinda thing often?  Has it impacted your mafia negatively?  If help was available would you be willing to listen?

[Naeann]

I have no PR saying I must vote in every post.  I just felt like it. ;D

 

 

 

Do you do this kinda thing often?  Has it impacted your mafia negatively?  If help was available would you be willing to listen?

 

Aww hiya big bro!!!  I've missed you. :-*

[Verbal32]

I have no PR saying I must vote in every post.  I just felt like it. ;D

 

 

 

Do you do this kinda thing often?  Has it impacted your mafia negatively?  If help was available would you be willing to listen?

 

Hehe...no, she doesn't.  That's why I was sure it was a PR.  She still fools me.....*mumbles*

[Guest dragonsworn1991]

I am [glow=red,2,300]unvoting[/glow] for now. I am also voting for [glow=red,2,300]mnwhiterose[/glow], I think you accusing thorum of being scum just because he voted first. I think that is highly suspicious.

[LilyElizabeth]

I'm still out of town, and not fully participating like I want to. I had some thoughts on Pandy, but I'll save them, since he doesn't seem to be in danger of lynching now, and I want to post them when I have more time. I don't know why [glow=red,2,300]Naeann[/glow] is doing what she's doing, so I'll vote her for now, but when I get home and think things through, I may change my mind. Do you all think maybe she's a jester or something?

 

[a pale tanned lover]

Nae's jumping about on the votes is the main thing standing out for me at the moment, i thought it might have been part of her role,which it isn't, but i can't decide whether this is mafia play or innocent play.

[Naeann]

Is this a paranoid game?  Sheesh.  Just cause I change it up and play a little wild. ;D

[The Crusher]

Nae's jumping about on the votes is the main thing standing out for me at the moment, i thought it might have been part of her role,which it isn't, but i can't decide whether this is mafia play or innocent play.

 

Does seem like the best we have right now.  Though I do have a second and third I could consider.

 

Yet, the thing that bothers me mildly about Naenn is something Kivam aka Teh Doggin always says.  "Lynch all lyers".  Naenn makes a bold play we all started considering it was a role and she said admits it wasn't. 

 

Mafia players goal is to deceit, why would she make the play, sell it and then recant it?  Im new here and maybe you guys are like teh super mafia types that run double and triple wiforms, but my simple calorie lusting self finds this odd.

 

Yet day one is a crap shoot and the goal is to kill mafia or kill someone that provides the most info. 

[mnwhiterose]

[glow=red,2,300]unvote[/glow]

 

reserving my vote for now. My vote on Thorum was as much a joke as his voting first. Nae's vote changing is still confusing me, but at this point my voting for her would seem to be a revenge vote as much as if I voted for Dragon. Pandy is still looking to be guilty to me because of his reveal. I'll need to think on this.