Mafia - Star Wars vs Star Trek - GAME ON - Start Pg. 5

[Guest nephitess]

I have explained myself a few times now, i will not do it again. All i'm going to say is you DO NOT want to lynch me.

[loki redfern]

so your a bomb or have a role. or want to scare us.  since you have what 3 votes? and youve basically just revealed your 'role' . at 3 votes and theres another 7 to go. thats not even half way. so either your an evil mafia who is geting overly jumpy /wants to snarl up the healer. or ..you just revealed ..at 3 votes... yeh [glow=red,2,300]nephy[/glow]

 

if your gonna reveal/fake reveal please do it properly..maybe its just me but i really hate it when people do that ::) :P

[Talya]

lol.....your brother seems to be busy tonight..

[loki redfern]

hehe i think hes kidnaped jucy and is replacing her :D

[Dark Justice]

Well Im gonna stay away from voting a couple of more hours, and then go for whatever I feel like.

[Guest nephitess]

Yes i am concerned about the votes on me. There is absolutely no reason for them. I am an innocent. is that not enough to reveal? I was not revealing anything only that people do not want to lynch me because I'm innocent. is that not enough? 

 

I'll vote later.

[Daetirion]

To me thats someone panicking and covering their tracks...

 

Either you have a role, for good or ill and now don't want to reveal it, or you've had second thoughts about fake-revealing (there must be a better term for it than that but it suffices) as a Mafia - or been instructed by your fellow Mafia not to.

 

I can understand if your our healer or finder not wanting to reveal and having made a slip up, yet i'm inclined to be extremely suspicious - my vote stands and is growing in conviction

[Guest nephitess]

*nods* I understand your thoughts. It does look like I am doing exactly what you are saying. But I am not evil. I am also not panicking. I am simply stating fact. I want the innocents to win and lynching me would be lynching an innocent. Take my words as you want.

[Moghedian]

[glow=red,2,300]Nephy[/glow]

I've already written my suspicions, she could be the arsonist... :-\

[Vemynal]

Guys I'm really worried about how fast the nephy vote stacked on here and I feel like the votes been pressured towards nephy. To be honest, other then fdm i suspect moggy, loki and boyo next most and all three of those people are on the nephy vote...I think this has gone too fast.

 

and as i said before, i think it is moggy who is the arsonist...now especially since she showed no sign of voting nephy but now votes nephy once nephy stressed the point of not lynching her in a way that insinuated a role.

 

nephi (5) - boyo, barm, dae, Loki, moggy

Talya (1) - Jelly

FDM (1) - vem

May (1) - talya

not voting: Verbal, Nephi, FDM, Dark, May, Leelou, Korin

[loki redfern]

I have explained myself a few times now, i will not do it again. All i'm going to say is you DO NOT want to lynch me.

 

yes it preferable not to lynch an innocent, but people that you would capital letters 'DO NOT' want to lynch are people with roles or bombs, and is the classic thing to say just before a reveal. but then there was no reveal . just makes me suspicious

[Moghedian]

and as i said before, i think it is moggy who is the arsonist...now especially since she showed no sign of voting nephy but now votes nephy once nephy stressed the point of not lynching her in a way that insinuated a role.

 

If I was the arsonist wouldn't I have NKed her last night or the night coming up? It would have been easy with no one having a clue. I honestly think that she is mafia.

[Barmacral]

Jelly, would you care to enlighten us on your 10 year old brother's logic? Or was it just him pointing at the shiny thing and saying "stab that!"

 

And Nephi, I'd be more inclined to believe you, except that you keep hinting at reveals, which makes me suspicious. Dae seems to have it pretty much on the money.

 

On the other hand, Vem also has a point, vote are stacking against Nephi, and fast. Thats what makes me hesitate about going all for Nephi. I'm almost tempted to withdraw my vote for now.

 

Btw, when's the deadline? I'm too lazy to go back and check.

[Guest nephitess]

I was mearly stressing that i was innocent. Maybe i should not have. *shruggs* and i do not see my doing that as hinting at revels. Sorry. Would you want me to reveal Barm? I don't think so.

[Moghedian]

Monday 11pm EST

[Vemynal]

why are we voting may and talya again? obviously no one agrees with me about fdm so I'm considering revoting but I don't wanna vote nephy.

 

Or would you guys support a moggy lynch?

 

Moggy the reasoning behind you voting her now instead of last night killing her is because 1) you have a 50% night kill chance. you might have tried and failed. 2) I exist, maybe i healed her and you failed. 3) Nephy did her weird "don't lynch me post" where she acted like she had a role during the day so obviously if she was a good character role you would want her dead.

[Talya]

Okay I'm a little confused. We have an arsonist, and unless they are on the evil team (which I assume not..though could be wrong), then although they have to go, if we waste too much time on finding them and lynching them the mafia will get away scott free. Which would be even worse.

[Vemynal]

what you say is true talya but like I said i don't think nephy is mafia so for me its lynch someone who i think is harmful or lynch someone who i think isn't harmful.

[Talya]

Fair enough...though not sure Moggy is nafia, and we only have you idea that she is the arsonist. I'm not sure about Nephi, she has said and done some weird things, ans I know she has given her reasons I still find her a little off. The only other thing is that she is a symp. It would explain her behaviour, in which case she should she be lynched.. :-\

[Leelou]

Sorry, I was really bogged down with work yesterday.

 

 

[glow=red,2,300]Boyo[/glow] is striking me as Mafia, and yes Nephy is acting odd, but I'm not sure if I'm ready to vote for her yet considering I have til tomorrow night to change my mind.

 

My reason for voting Boyo:

 

He appears to be laying really low, his only real post would be his vote for Nephy, the rest I would consider spam. He voted day one for Vemy but did not place a vote day 2.

 

 

[loki redfern]

i just think its bad to go round hinting that you might  have a role, the only way you can do that and realistically hope not to become the target of a nk is if your mafia. if you want healer protection its much safer to actually reveal, then we can work on looking at the validity a claim. hinting things like that is just going to either snarl up a healer or get you NKed ..which if your mafia will end up in you being protected by the healer, and a free run of the innocents.  and like tyre? said it does look like your leaving your self little things incase you need to refer back later, first you say

I was mearly stressing that i was innocent.

and at the very end you add

Would you want me to reveal Barm? I don't think so.

 

and if you actually are innocent .. well attracting all that attention is silly

 

 

oh and if you i look suspicious vemy you proably want to rule may out, i believe i started that.

[loki redfern]

oh um and yes vote maybe stacking up on nephy and i can see why thats a reason to stop and look at this, but i think for the most part that they are reasoned rather than pure bandwagon

[SBoydW]

He appears to be laying really low

 

That's actually my game style... check any game I've ever played in as innocent or mafia... anywho you're entitled to your opinion.

 

And I think Talya is right it would seem pointless to go after the arsonist since I believe the role would pass on to someone else after they died anyways, right?  So we would just be futilely chasing an untamed ornathoid. (my favorite data line from star trek (wild goose chase))

[Verbal32]

I'm glad we have until tomorrow night, as I don't have enough time right now to properly read everything through.  I do think that Nephi's behavior is suspicious, but I'm not ready to join that lynch just yet.  I'll re-read everything tomorrow, and vote before the deadline.

 

Enjoy the rest of the weekend everybody!

[Guest nephitess]

Was not meaning to attract this much attention Shhesh! Sorry guys.

 

Vemy i would be willing to support a [glow=red,2,300]Moggy[/glow] lynch. I have been getting evil vibes from her and a few others.