MAFIA - Streets of NYC - GAME OVER

[cosmicpanda]

I vote [glow=red,2,300]Moggy[/glow].

 

Jelly voted for her, Jelly died, Jelly was innocent. 'nuff said.

[Thorum]

I'm going for [glow=red,2,300]Dsage[/glow]

 

Same reason as yesterday

[Talya]

Vemy I always seem to be high on your list of evils in most games too... ::)

 

Anyway I'm not sure about Moggy, it could be she was set up, having Jelly's vote. Trouble is as the Mafia don't know each other that really doesn't mean that much, she may not have had the night kill, but doesn't mean she is not Mafia.

 

Dsage, I'm not too sure, his reasoning is usually very sound. And I still feel that we need to lynch, I'm sorry FDM was innocent, but no one said this was easy. However 3 days might sound like a long time but, an I will say this again, with different time zones and now the weekend it isn't that long to get a lynch in. Also with no finder all we have are voting patterns to try and find the evils. So lynches are important in this game. Even more so as the game progresses and evils find each other and to give them two NK would be dangerous.

 

Thats my opinion on that. Dsage disagreed, does that make him evil to differ from me...not necessarily.

 

So I will wait at the moment, plus I have a busy day ahead of me to think properly at the moment.

 

[Blig Blog]

I'm not so sure about Moggy...I get this vibe from her that she is trying to hold something back and, therefore, she might be mafia. OR she might be innocent and trying NOT to have everyone think that she is mafia. I'm not so sure... :-\

 

The top 3 that I am going to look out for is Dsage, Moggy, and Vemy.

 

Vemy is too good of a player to be trusted.

 

DSage is always mysterious and no matter what side he is on it looks to me like he ALWAYS holds back, waiting for the right time to pounce.

 

I'm just going to be wary of Moggy for the momment.

 

I haven't made me decision on who to vote for yet and will hold the oppurtunity back...  ;)

 

[Toy and Minion]

DSage is always mysterious and no matter what side he is on it looks to me like he ALWAYS holds back, waiting for the right time to pounce.

 

Just to give your view here credibility, how many games have you played with me in them, including this one?

[Vemynal]

@ talya- ok now *you* have a place to be talking where as nae doesn't XD. True I usually think your mafia and sometimes we lynch each other when good. But we have also called each other out when evil.

 

 

If you want some clarification talya I do find you a bit suspicious but nothing I have on you or nae would make me vote for you guys unless you already had multiple votes on you. Moggy on the other hand I can't understand *any* of her dsage logic which is only furthering my opinion. Seems to me like shes trying to push votes on dsage to live, which doesn't mean evil but the way shes going about it has only made me want my vote on her more.

 

 

@ Blig- ...thank you? lmao wait till you've gotten a game in with DPR, alys, kivam, barm or maybe siryn (sp?) in. those 5 are imo the big guys of this game^^

[Guest nephitess]

LOL...I agree with Vemy...watch out for those 5. *shudders* ;)

 

Ok so here is a little how i see things. the vote on FDM did go fast, i do not feel bad about it though. we had to vote for someone right? anyway...it did go fast, I see Dsage tried to slow it down with his refusal to vote...and in the end did not cast a vote at all. that is a shame..but his choice. if it was me i would have voted an other way just to prove my point. *nods*

 

as for Moggy...i don't know about her..but she did come out strong with her vote on FDM just because of FDM's joke in her post here...

 

I choose the Opera House, and anyone who jumps on my Opera House bandwagon I'm voting for because you are obviously evil and just want to NK me. :P

 

I consider that suspicious, [glow=red,2,300]FDM[/glow]

 

we could think the same of this comment by Moggy in her first post...

 

Check out my groovy sunglasses!  ;D

 

is that a sign to the evils? who knows? We are all going to be extra suspicious of each other because even the evils don't know each other...but as innocents we need to work together. Now this being said...I'm going to continue to watch and observe. I'll cast my vote an other time.

[Moghedian]

Check out my groovy sunglasses!  ;D

 

is that a sign to the evils? who knows? We are all going to be extra suspicious of each other because even the evils don't know each other...but as innocents we need to work together. Now this being said...I'm going to continue to watch and observe. I'll cast my vote an other time.

 

Hmmm... *Points to*

 

12. Moggy - Is the FBI

 

Now, why would a FBI agent ever wear sunglasses??  :-\

 

 

 

 

[Daetirion]

LOL...I agree with Vemy...watch out for those 5. *shudders* ;)

 

I've been reading the Suras war one for entertainment/experience and certain people of those 5 do seem damn scary with just how accurate their predictions can be

 

As to vote - well for now im holding off

[Naeann]

Vemy... though i wasnt overly active in that game.. i rarely am.. I wasnt inactive.  I spammed a bit, i posted a bit.  Stop being hateful about accusing me or go ahead and keep up and ping my radar more.  Sorry im not as good as you or dsage or dpr.  I have just as much room to talk as Talya.. shes right.. we both are almost always on your list of suspects... and often unwarrented.  I merely pointed out that the only time recently I havent been on your radar was when I actually WAS evil.

[Guest nephitess]

hurmmm i did not see that Moggy. thank you pointing that out. *nods*

[Toy and Minion]

So, correct me if I'm wrong, but the only thing you people have against me is my not voting FDM?  Okaaaaaay.  Really, really weak.

 

I rarely vote on Day 1 - mostly because of craplogic like that.  The only reason I voted FDM was because I thought there wasn't enough time.  I unvoted when Wes said we had 9 hours left(not 100% sure on the time).  I kept my vote off because:

 

1) I REALLY didn't agree with the FDM bandwagon.

 

2) I REALLY hate voting on Day 1.

 

Oh, and guess what, FDM died.  Wow.  Guess I made a difference there.

 

And I was NOT trying to slow down the lynch, I was trying to get people to THINK before they voted.  No, there's not a lot of reason in a Day 1 lynch, but there should be logic.  Following blindly after the Lynch Train isn't going to get us anywhere but dead.

 

Oh, and who was surprised by FDM's Innocence?

[Moghedian]

You have a point [glow=red,2,300]Unvote DSage[/glow]

[Alys Kinch]

Ok so here is a little how i see things. the vote on FDM did go fast, i do not feel bad about it though. we had to vote for someone right?

 

but that's my point. that's exactly the same type of issue we are going to have all game. we have no eventual finder outings of the evils. all we have are sharp guesses. so that said, we need to prevent it from happening again by calling it out now! slow down and think. (again, dsage being uber smart is still new and weird to me...)

[Barmacral]

Sorry I've not been around, work's kinda assaulted my life... it should be more normal this week, so I'll hopefully be around more to try and catch up on whats going on. Ahh...

[Moghedian]

*Is suspicious of the exotic dancer (for no reason ;))*

 

slow down and think. (again, dsage being uber smart is still new and weird to me...)

 

Yes, for the innocents to win for every innocent accidentally lynched (or killed) one mafia needs to be lynched. Think peoples!  :)

 

Can mafia be inactive? Just wondering...  :-\

 

[Toy and Minion]

again, dsage being uber smart is still new and weird to me...)

 

I'll take that as a compliment.

[Luthine]

Can mafia be inactive? Just wondering...  :-\

 

Yes, I was wondering about that too, I'd say yes but I'm not sure...

 

And how much time is left?

[Naeann]

Sure they can be inactive.  In most games at least one usually IS inactive.  But that doesn't mean just because one is inactive in a game that they are automatically mafia.  Several innocents tend to be more inactive too.

 

Looking for those patterns is also metagaming... (FOR EXAMPLE- Wow.. He was so helpful and active in that last game and he was our finder.. this game hes really laying low and hardly contributing at all.. he must be mafia!)

[DPR]

 

Current Vote Count:

 

Moggy (2) - Vemy, Pandy

Dsage (1) - Thor

 

With 20 players, it takes 11 lynch. And at this rate, the mafia is really looking forward to two kills.

 

The deadline is tomorrow night (Monday, 7th) at 8:55 pm EST. That is in 31 hours and 54 minutes.

[Daetirion]

hmm

 

31 hours

 

i hate deadlines - haven't really had much more info than day 1, except that Lynch and i really can't decide what that would signify

 

still, ive got net access tommorrow so im going to hold my vote for now

[Toy and Minion]

Whatever anyone does, don't vote in haste because of the deadline.

 

Stay calm, keep a cool head, and think.

 

I'm going to do a small re-read, see if I can find anything.

[Toy and Minion]

A Player has caught my attention:

 

Talya

 

[glow=red,2,300]FDM[/glow] Her post just stood out to me, like she was trying to get other Mafia attention... :-\

 

Even for Day 1, that’s weak.  A feeble excuse to vote for anyone.  “Her post just stood out to me…”  What, like a piece of gum on the sidewalk?

 

I don't know if FDM is innocent or guilty, I only went with her because of what she said, it stood out.

 

Again, “it stood out.”  And you even state that, that is the ONLY reason you voted for her.  Well, to be honest, that screams “mafia”.  “it stood out” is not a reason to vote.  It’s a pile of worthless.  You gave just enough “reason” to slip under the rug and not be questioned.  Until now.

 

Of everyone else, Talya is the most suspicious to me.  She could be innocent.  She could have made a mistake, or it could have all been true.  But of everyone else, she seems the most promising candidate to me. 

 

[glow=red,2,300]Vote: Talya[/glow]

 

I admit, it's small.  But due to the Day 1 Bandwagon, we're pretty much stuck in the same boat.  This isn't Day 2; it's Day 1, Mark II!

 

*goes off to investigate the waxing, again*

[Talya]

Tell me what else was there...absolutely nothing. yeah it stood out to me Dsage, but what about all the others that bandwagoned that didn't give any reason...they are more likely to be mafia. At leasy I had some reason, even if I was wrong...that makes it a little more credible than everyone who didn't have any reason.

 

So you'll be totally wrong, and your reasoning its about the same as mine yesterday. So by your reasoning if I'm evil..so are you!

 

And nn day one...'It stood out' ...isn't as bad as bandwagoning...what else is there to go on. Show me someone who had a better excuse. Because that is the worst I've heard from you.

 

[glow=red,2,300]Dsage[/glow]. what found out I didn't move last night so knew I wasn't one of your colleagues and thought you'd go for Dsage.

[Toy and Minion]

Saw that vote coming.  ;D

 

what found out I didn't move last night so knew I wasn't one of your colleagues and thought you'd go for Dsage.

 

Can you try to make that a little more coherent?  Thanks.

 

I agree, no one had a good reason.  But yours was one of the worst, if not the worst.  "it stood out"?  I don't care if it's Day 1, use common sense.  "it stood out" was a copout!  An excuse.  Not a reason.  Only the dude can use that technique (On player names, I'll point out) and have it work amazingly well.

 

I could point out a number of posts that "stood out" much more than FDM's joke.

 

If you can give me a rational explanation as to why you voted FDM, I may reconsider my vote.  "It was Day 1" and "it stood out" do not fall into that category.