Jump to content

DRAGONMOUNT

A WHEEL OF TIME COMMUNITY
Sign in to follow this  
Wulf

Inefficient Seanchan testing

Recommended Posts

Is it ever shown 'how' the Seanchan test women?  How is it that the suldam weren't caught in any reasonable testing method?

 

If they just walked through crowds 'feeling' for women who could channel, they'd find the suldam.  Several Aes Sedai report being able to tell they can channel, so that can't be their method.

 

The most obvious method is to just slap an adam on everybody.  Anybody that can walk a step, you're free to go.  But they obviously don't do that or the suldam would've been found out immediately.

 

I can't think of any test that wouldn't catch both groups at once.

 

On a related note, what's up with the male adam?  Can somebody refresh my memory on their history?  There's the first one in the early books, completely separate from the Seanchan.  In some museum.  They try dump it in the ocean, fail, Seanchan get it.  Which is supposed to matter, but then several books later it's implied that the Seanchan already have a bunch, and Cadsuane's loss of hers didn't matter because they could've just gone to the Seanchan "Male Adams 'N More Bulk Barn" and grabbed a bunch more.  And weren't adam unthought of in the AOL (*you've got mail*), yet Semi somehow understands the functioning of the rarest of the rare, the male "Dominator Band" or whatever she calls it?

Edited by Wulf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
9 minutes ago, Wulf said:

Is it ever shown 'how' the Seanchan test women?  How is it that the suldam weren't caught in any reasonable testing method?

 

If they just walked through crowds 'feeling' for women who could channel, they'd find the suldam.  Several Aes Sedai report being able to tell they can channel, so that can't be their method.

 

The most obvious method is to just slap an adam on everybody.  Anybody that can walk a step, you're free to go.  But they obviously don't do that or the suldam would've been found out immediately.

 

I can't think of any test that wouldn't catch both groups at once.

 

 

They test everyone yearly (for the ages that a woman would have naturally started to channel). The only people affected by the collar are those that have already channeled (hence sparkers, learners won't channel naturally so will always pass the collar test). If they can walk with the collar they test the bracelet to see if theres an affinity (or i guess if the damane can move lol). As they spend time as Sul'dam this effectively comes from the forced bond which is why the collar holds experienced suldam. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The BWB says young women are tested each year for the ability to channel or the ability to wear the bracelet each year until they pass the age of manifestation.  Those who have the ability inborn become damane and are immediately leashed.  So every woman in the empire will get tested every year from say 12 -18.  It will always catch the people like Egwene who was going to channel someday regardless.  It won't catch the people who will only learn to channel if someone taught them how.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think it's ever said but I guess the Male A'dam was created after the strike on Shayol Ghul to control mad male Aes Sedai. I think Moghedien explains some of this to one of the wonder girls I think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 8/9/2018 at 2:45 PM, Wulf said:

Is it ever shown 'how' the Seanchan test women?  How is it that the suldam weren't caught in any reasonable testing method?

 

If they just walked through crowds 'feeling' for women who could channel, they'd find the suldam.  Several Aes Sedai report being able to tell they can channel, so that can't be their method.

 

The most obvious method is to just slap an adam on everybody.  Anybody that can walk a step, you're free to go.  But they obviously don't do that or the suldam would've been found out immediately.

 

I can't think of any test that wouldn't catch both groups at once.

 

On a related note, what's up with the male adam?  Can somebody refresh my memory on their history?  There's the first one in the early books, completely separate from the Seanchan.  In some museum.  They try dump it in the ocean, fail, Seanchan get it.  Which is supposed to matter, but then several books later it's implied that the Seanchan already have a bunch, and Cadsuane's loss of hers didn't matter because they could've just gone to the Seanchan "Male Adams 'N More Bulk Barn" and grabbed a bunch more.  And weren't adam unthought of in the AOL (*you've got mail*), yet Semi somehow understands the functioning of the rarest of the rare, the male "Dominator Band" or whatever she calls it?

 

I think the implication is that the Seanchan made more from the one that they seized from Domon.  I always figured the damane who could make a'dam were set to make them.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Since the Seanchan simply kill any male they find who can channel it seems unlikely they had any on hand or knew of them beforehand.  My guess is either Suroth or Semi had to known the people who can make the a'dam make these.  Since the Seanchan knew exactly where to find the people who were to dispose of it and tuon knew nothing of it.  My guess is Suroth was ordered to aquire it.  Both Moghi and Semi seemed to know a lot about the item.  

Edited by Sabio

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The "Test" is only effective in singling out women born with the spark, who will channel regardless.  That is why they leap on RM's forkroot tea.  It is far more effective and likely faster.  It seems to work on any woman who can or can learn to touch the source.  There are many references of women fainting or going weak after drinking it.  Most likely never knew they could touch the source or could learn.  The collar is only effective on suldam who have worked long supervising and being linked to channelers.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is the issue then, if the tea works on any who can touch the source or be taught to tough the source.  If they use the tea as the way to test women they will then catch everybody, so who then will be Sul'dam?  Since the people who became Sul'dam because the collar wouldn't work on them will now be discovered by the tea.  I still say one of the lamest things in the series is all the OMG this knowledge will rock the empire and then when it became known it was pretty much no big deal.  Tuon's explanation of so what I choose not to learn to channel so no big deal was pretty weak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sul'dam able to channel isn't widely known still, although I imagine Aes Sedai will spread rumours as soon as they can

 

I suspect it would have been a greater plot point in the outriggers :/

 

It's interesting to consider how much it would matter though. Randlanders likely wouldn't care, and the true Seanchan are ingrained with obeying orders from those higher up, so if Fortuna proclaims it doesn't matter, maybe they carry on as normal?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eg and Fortune spoke openly about it at their meeting. so word should spread.  Just with those around there wasn't any shock.  Suroth was all we need to keep this quiet and Tuon didn't even try to keep it quiet or even seem disgusted she could learn to channel.  It does seem since Tuon doesn't care no one else does.  Maybe just some shock and panic with the Sul'dam, or word some Sul'dam had fled would of made it mean something.  You would think since the collar works on Sul'dam they at least would be worried.  I so wish we would of gotten the outriggers,

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it would be a huge blow overall, but that's why Suroth was trying to cover it up. Tuon is a whole different breed, there's not much that would break her. Most people, especially the Sul'dam would be horrified (and were horrified). I agree it probably would have been a bigger plot point later (and maybe even the end of the Sul'dam and damane as we know them in the future).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Posts

    • My issue with increasing congress to that size is  A) Nothing gets done in there as is and  B) I dont want to pay 46 million more dollars a year to those vipers, not including whatever insurances, lifetime pensions, healthcare and security details they get. I already thinks its ridiculous they get paid during the shutdown, completely, while government employees are forced to work without pay.
    • how can i remove it? or could you do it for me?
    • Sure, I'll post this  again:       The data for the graphs is currently 2 election cycles old (it was run off 04 and 08) but the points stand...though it would be interesting to redo the graphics with 16 and 12 results.   Secondarily, if the porposals listed (somewhere) about "fixing congress" by increasing the size of the body (to somewhere around 800, I forget) would also help by creating more (and distributing more evenly) electoral votes around the country, or more modest proposals to award electors proportionately would also help.   The danger here is the logic of either; system is broken, why fix it or system has always worked (even though it's been broken the whole time), so don't fix it.      The best part of the video is the path to the presidency with 22%  (or said differently, a president could win if 78% of the people voted against them) of the vote, which is, um, not a fair/just/equitable/local/whatever word you want to use system at all.

        ALso    
    • I’ve never really liked the argument that one’s vote counts less using a percentage based on total population to EC votes when comparing states because that’s not how the EC is supposed to work.   Its not a perfect system but I don’t think it’s awful. I’d like to move away from the winner-take-all system the majority of states use, but I dislike the idea of using a straight up NPV tally.
    • As for impeachment; we don't have any hard (or direct) evidence of him committing crimes while in office, and we don't have any hard (or direct) of him committing crimes to get into office, but there is a lot of circumstalial and unproven evidence of both in the public domain.
×