DM Will Likely Crash During My Game Mafia - Game thread! [STANDARD]

Zander? · June 22, 2018

Strongest 2 reads 1 of each and why plz?

Zander? · June 22, 2018

Also Luke Cage season 2 dropped today so while I'll be around...i may be somewhat distracted....lololololol

Andrej · June 22, 2018

5 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

@Darthe @Andrej

Strongest 2 reads 1 of each and why plz?

I have a lot of TR I feel good about actually so naming a “top” is kinda hard.

Maybe Sooh? Her tone has just been really good and the stuff she’s talking about doesn’t feel superficial. That’s not to say I think others look “worse” than her, but you made me pick lol

SR is BFG. I love the lady but this is looks a lot like her scum game meta wise. Low interaction, low presence. There’s not a lot of sorting that I can see, and her TR on DPR is too strong for the given reasons imo. Her reaction to my vote was pretty bland too.

Andrej · June 22, 2018

6 minutes ago, Zanatron said:

Also Luke Cage season 2 dropped today so while I'll be around...i may be somewhat distracted....lololololol

Your turn.

Zander? · June 22, 2018

That's a good question. Tbqh

Scum is easier for me. DPR tho admittedly he's come around a tad with his more recent posts and BFG for playing against my recalled Meta on her but I not 100% sold on her being Scum.

Town tbqh Darthe so I'm prolly wrong...hes a skilled player but it's hard to reinvent you're entire Scum in a matter of a couple games. His much more erratic here which is more reminiscent of what I recall from his Town game.

Tripped looked fine so far...nothing really pinging me atp but no Meta to baseline that from so take with a grain of salt.

Sooh I suck at reading so I'm not even gonna assume anything on her till I have some more info to use.

Krak is just FML. I dont know wtf to think I dont remember a lot from him from before other then reading him frustrates me...lol.

AJ not quite what I expect from Town!AJ like just not quite there yet tho his change in style is throwing me off some.

Aquilla has had some good thoughts and others not so much. No Meta to use either.

Too many nulls for my liking.

Andrej · June 22, 2018

So Darthe is Town, DPR/BFG scum, and everyone else is null?

what thoughts of Aquila did you think were good/bad?

DL is less than 2 hours. If you had single control of the lynch who is taking the drop?

TrippedOnReality · June 22, 2018

1 hour ago, Zanatron said:

That's a good question. Tbqh

Scum is easier for me. DPR tho admittedly he's come around a tad with his more recent posts and BFG for playing against my recalled Meta on her but I not 100% sold on her being Scum.

Town tbqh Darthe so I'm prolly wrong...hes a skilled player but it's hard to reinvent you're entire Scum in a matter of a couple games. His much more erratic here which is more reminiscent of what I recall from his Town game.

Tripped looked fine so far...nothing really pinging me atp but no Meta to baseline that from so take with a grain of salt.

Sooh I suck at reading so I'm not even gonna assume anything on her till I have some more info to use.

Krak is just FML. I dont know wtf to think I dont remember a lot from him from before other then reading him frustrates me...lol.

AJ not quite what I expect from Town!AJ like just not quite there yet tho his change in style is throwing me off some.

Aquilla has had some good thoughts and others not so much. No Meta to use either.

Too many nulls for my liking.

How likely do you think it is that scum!BFG gives scum!DPR her only town read? If you had to pick between the two of them, which do you think is more likely to be scum?

DPR · June 22, 2018

1 hour ago, Zanatron said:

That's a good question. Tbqh

Scum is easier for me. DPR tho admittedly he's come around a tad with his more recent posts and BFG for playing against my recalled Meta on her but I not 100% sold on her being Scum.

Town tbqh Darthe so I'm prolly wrong...hes a skilled player but it's hard to reinvent you're entire Scum in a matter of a couple games. His much more erratic here which is more reminiscent of what I recall from his Town game.

Tripped looked fine so far...nothing really pinging me atp but no Meta to baseline that from so take with a grain of salt.

Sooh I suck at reading so I'm not even gonna assume anything on her till I have some more info to use.

Krak is just FML. I dont know wtf to think I dont remember a lot from him from before other then reading him frustrates me...lol.

AJ not quite what I expect from Town!AJ like just not quite there yet tho his change in style is throwing me off some.

Aquilla has had some good thoughts and others not so much. No Meta to use either.

Too many nulls for my liking.

This is just lazy coming from Zander.

TrippedOnReality · June 22, 2018

DPR, what do you think about being BFG's only town read?

DPR · June 22, 2018

Just now, TrippedOnReality said:

DPR, what do you think about being BFG's only town read?

I don’t think I’ve ever played with BFG as scum, so there’s that.

I’m an active and aggressive player - I’m used to being on one reads list or another pretty much all the time.

I get called scum A LOT. Sometimes I am...

Which is to say that my activity and transparency might give BFG a townnlean. Or, because a number of folks have her as scum, she *knows* I’m town and wants to build equity there.

Kind of a basic play for her I’d think, but it is what it is.

TrippedOnReality · June 22, 2018

1 minute ago, DPR said:

I don’t think I’ve ever played with BFG as scum, so there’s that.

I’m an active and aggressive player - I’m used to being on one reads list or another pretty much all the time.

I get called scum A LOT. Sometimes I am...

Which is to say that my activity and transparency might give BFG a townnlean. Or, because a number of folks have her as scum, she *knows* I’m town and wants to build equity there.

Kind of a basic play for her I’d think, but it is what it is.

That's fair. Do you think you deserve the read she's given you? Do you think other people are more deserving of a town read? If so, who and why?

Krakalakachkn · June 22, 2018

I have literally been up all night and my Sooh is voting for BFG

So that's where i'¿ at come at me if you have problem

Andrej · June 22, 2018

Just now, Krakalakachkn said:

I have literally been up all night and my Sooh is voting for BFG

So that's where i'¿ at come at me if you have problem

Dude what?

Andrej · June 22, 2018

Tripped, what are you working towards rn?

Clovdyx · June 22, 2018

Vote Count!

Darthe - 1 - DPR
BFG - 2 - Sooh, Andrej

If you notice any discrepancies, PM me immediately.

Votes marked :00 will count, :01 will not. Day One ends at 8:00 PM Eastern time on Friday, 6/22.

DPR · June 22, 2018

8 minutes ago, TrippedOnReality said:

That's fair. Do you think you deserve the read she's given you? Do you think other people are more deserving of a town read? If so, who and why?

I get what she means by "depth" and it's easy for me to see where someone else would recognize that I'm not playing a scum role (which is to divide the town up with distraction, multiple theories, tunneling here and there and buddying elsewhere.

As I'm town, sure, she's hitting the nail on the head.

As far as other town reads go, I'm a bit of a special case, heh. I very much prefer to look for scum over identifying town - it used to be popular years ago. I see the effectiveness of town reads, of course, but my eye picks out too many "could be scum" traits for me to get comfortable with TR's on D1.

Ima work up an updated reads list real fast and it'll be much more focused on who I think is scum - you'll see what I mean.

TrippedOnReality · June 22, 2018

1 minute ago, Andrej said:

Tripped, what are you working towards rn?

Not sure. I'm torn between BFG/DPR/Krak but I don't really see DPR and BFG teamed rn. Krak seems super not invested in solving the game, but could just be lhf. And DPR has been around, but I'm not feeling great about them either, despite them being around.

I felt slightly better about Aquilla after seeing their interaction with you yesterday, so probably wouldn't lynch there. Zander feels pretty town to me. You feel similar to last game, though more reserved. I have mindmelded with you a couple of times, so I think you're more likely to be town than not. I don't see scum!Darthe doing what he did for the first 1/2 to 3/4 of the day. Seems way over the top. Sooh seems alright, too. I've mindmelded with her a bit as well.

So if I had to order people, it might look something like this:

Townish:

Zander

Darthe

Null-town:

AJ

Sooh

Null:

Aquilla

Null-scum:

DPR

BFG

Krak

Krakalakachkn · June 22, 2018

vote bfg

TrippedOnReality · June 22, 2018

7 minutes ago, Krakalakachkn said:

vote bfg

Why though? Just to sheep Sooh? I mean, you had a list of me, AJ, DPR who were presumably scum reads which you never really explained, but you're voting BFG? And the only reason you've stated for town reading Sooh is because you're intentionally reading Sooh the opposite of how you normally read her which is scum? Walk me through your thought process here.

Krakalakachkn · June 22, 2018

5 minutes ago, TrippedOnReality said:

Walk me through your thought process here.

I'm one stop away from my bed and I'm struggling to hang onto consciousness.

Andrej · June 22, 2018

15 minutes ago, TrippedOnReality said:

Not sure. I'm torn between BFG/DPR/Krak but I don't really see DPR and BFG teamed rn. Krak seems super not invested in solving the game, but could just be lhf. And DPR has been around, but I'm not feeling great about them either, despite them being around.

I felt slightly better about Aquilla after seeing their interaction with you yesterday, so probably wouldn't lynch there. Zander feels pretty town to me. You feel similar to last game, though more reserved. I have mindmelded with you a couple of times, so I think you're more likely to be town than not. I don't see scum!Darthe doing what he did for the first 1/2 to 3/4 of the day. Seems way over the top. Sooh seems alright, too. I've mindmelded with her a bit as well.

So if I had to order people, it might look something like this:

Townish:

Zander

Darthe

Null-town:

AJ

Sooh

Null:

Aquilla

Null-scum:

DPR

BFG

Krak

BFG’s read on DPR does come across like over compensating and I don’t disagree with what the Pirate said about how she could be trying to build equity with him. It’s sorta wifomy though and I don’t hate Darthe’s take that DPR attacking his proposed strat was a roundabout defense of BFG. I wouldn’t rule it out entirely yet.

Z has made some lucid reads in the moment but his last long list was so-so.

I really don’t know what to make of Krak rn.

I feel pretty good saying that I don’t think you, Darthe, or Sooh are scum.

Z is on the cusp. Aquilla is one I’ll have to sort out more but beyond what I pointed out earlier I’m not like alarmed by them. I also haven’t played with them much.

DPR could be Town by default is it’s just BFG/Krak, but never trust a Pirate imo.

BFG · June 22, 2018

vote krak

BFG · June 22, 2018

Deadpool was fun :)

DPR · June 22, 2018

10 hours ago, DPR said:

~ ROSTER THOUGHTS ~

1. Darthe – That OP tho. I’ve said all I need to say about it. I'm basically just watching other players reactions to it.

2. Sooh – So far, so good. Doesn’t feel tense. For that good vibe to grow, I'd like to see more definitive reads (of course).

3. BFG – Waiting on her follow-up. She last posted on Pg. 4 after teasing her "secret TR on Darthe".

4. Aquilla – New to DM. Feels genuine enough. I don't agree with AJ's suss. Play seems to be focused on using standard techniques to clear town. Doesn’t seem to enjoy hunting for scum.

5. Andrej – Hmmm. Needs watching. Could be playing carefully. Could be hiding carefully.

6. Krakalakachkn – As AJ pointed out, humility is not a good look here.

7. TrippedOnReality – Feels engaged. So far, so good.

8. DreadPirateRoberts – Never been a townier towny.

9. Zanatron – So far feeling decent about Zan. Keeping an eye on the Zander/AJ connection.

*** Not liking Krak, need to hear from BFG.

~ UPDATED ROSTER THOUGHTS ~

As we have had another day to see more of each player, and before we go into that silent night...

1. Darthe – He began the game with the controversial post and plan, followed by intermittent clowning along with some serious play. I go back and forth thinking that I recognize what he's doing and then thinking that he has no idea what he's doing. We'll see.

2. Sooh – Wanted to see more insight from her, but she hasn't avoided the thread. I'm fine with her play for D1.

3. BFG – She's underwhelmed with insight into the game, and drawn criticism for her read on me. On the there hand, it is only D1 and nobody has really offered much insight and I've been the most outspoken player. But, I don't have scum meta on her and I truly do not see a world where Darthe and Sooh are scum together, so I have to respect other's reads on this one.

4. Aquilla – Had today to kind of settle in and really didn't. I haven't really like his 1-2-3 approach to the game. I could see uncomfortable scum here.

5. Andrej – Not liking his play at all. Seems like he's going out of his way to accommodate Darthe's antics and then seems irritated when I question that. I didn't like his read on Aquilla and I don't like his fence sitting on the rest of the game. Happy to vote here.

6. Krakalakachkn – He steered the bus back into the Krak lane enough to make me think he's just a little off.

7. TrippedOnReality – Asking good quesstions. Needs to offer solid reads.

8. DreadPirateRoberts – Too sexy for this game.

9. Zanatron – Laze-a-tron has my antenna up. He's sucking up to AJ, making room for Darthe and never in the history of mafia has he ever not read me as scum. Could be low-interest town. Could be scumming.

Vote AJ

Clovdyx · June 22, 2018

Vote Count!

BFG - 3 - Sooh, Andrej, Krakalakachkn
Krakalakachkn - 1 - BFG
Andrej - 1 - DPR

If you notice any discrepancies, PM me immediately.

Votes marked :00 will count, :01 will not. Day One ends at 8:00 PM Eastern time on Friday, 6/22.

DM Will Likely Crash During My Game Mafia - Game thread! [STANDARD]

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook