Tainted Minds - A Black Tower Mafia Game: Game over - Town wins

[BFG]

While I would like to see more results given we should probably discuss the contradiction between Sooh and Ironeyes.

So what are the possibilities?

 

1) IE/Sooh are both villager.

2) IE is Villager, Sooh is Sane Cop. Vis Versa

3) IE is Villager, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

4) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

5) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop and Clov was Framed. Vis Versa

6) IE is Villager, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

7) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

8) IE is Insane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

 

And...I think that's it? Maybe? My mind is starting to melt so someone else will have to finish that list if there are more possibilities I'm missing.

Although I think 16 options is plenty to mull over jfc...

Why is this your priority?

[Nolder]

While I would like to see more results given we should probably discuss the contradiction between Sooh and Ironeyes.

So what are the possibilities?

 

1) IE/Sooh are both villager.

2) IE is Villager, Sooh is Sane Cop. Vis Versa

3) IE is Villager, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

4) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

5) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop and Clov was Framed. Vis Versa

6) IE is Villager, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

7) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

8) IE is Insane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

 

And...I think that's it? Maybe? My mind is starting to melt so someone else will have to finish that list if there are more possibilities I'm missing.

Although I think 16 options is plenty to mull over jfc...

Out of these possibilities I've bolded the ones I think are most likely.

I know there's plenty of actions floating around but the odds they collided on N0 are still pretty low I think (anyone want to do the math?).

Odds are someone is lying, and also someone might be wrong.

Given that Sooh was the one with the negative result which in theory could result in Clov being lynched I am going to make an educated guess she is the liar.

Now normally I would put my vote on her and advocate for a lynch but not only do I think we need more results and discussion first I am also not sure of the usefulness of lynching someone right off the bat.

Is it worth sacrificing someone for another round of investigations? We get a lot of info but it is very very unreliable...

 

Basically IDK what to do right now lol.

Anyone got any input on any of that?

[BFG]

 

 

 

Cory :(

No frowns. Its in the game rules

Then come and talk to me :p

I am currently on the road :P

 

But will be home soonish

Okok

[Cory Caboose]

Can someone post the Billy Madison " I award you no points and may God have mercy on your soul" gif in response to nolder's theory crafting post

 

Tia

[Nolder]

I wouldn't even think about the peeks at all. Play the game like a vanilla.

 

Will only be important upon seer flips really, and even then only a certain amount of information will even be useful.

I get what you're saying but in that case we might as well be playing a vanilla game. 

Seems to me not as fun if you don't roll with the theme here which is an abundance of unreliable info with nuggets of golden truth strewn about.

We're looking for needles in haystacks in other words.

 

 

While I would like to see more results given we should probably discuss the contradiction between Sooh and Ironeyes.

So what are the possibilities?

 

1) IE/Sooh are both villager.

2) IE is Villager, Sooh is Sane Cop. Vis Versa

3) IE is Villager, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

4) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

5) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop and Clov was Framed. Vis Versa

6) IE is Villager, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

7) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

8) IE is Insane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

 

And...I think that's it? Maybe? My mind is starting to melt so someone else will have to finish that list if there are more possibilities I'm missing.

Although I think 16 options is plenty to mull over jfc...

Why is this your priority?

 

Seemed like an easy place to start. 

Actually it's not easy to draw any conclusions it's just easy to go through the possibilities lol.

[Nolder]

Can someone post the Billy Madison " I award you no points and may God have mercy on your soul" gif in response to nolder's theory crafting post

 

Tia

Too lazy to find gif here's the YT vid.

 

[Cory Caboose]

Ty nolder <3

[Sooh]

Vote Count

 

Ben (1) - LZM

SK (2) - SK, Dice

Does my vote not count? :(

[Sooh]

 

This is what I've compiled as far as results given so far.

 

N0 Results

1. Nolder - Ben is Innocent

2. BFG

3. Ironeyes - Clov is Innocent

4. Dar'Jen Ab Owain

5. LedZepMan - Leyrann is Innocent

6. Niniel - Refusing to give result for now

7. Leyrann

8. cory caboose - Nolder is Innocent

9. Clovdyx

10. Shitsure Kamimashita 

11. Sooh - Clov is Guilty

12. Gentled Ben

13. dicetosser1 

 

Imagine how easy this game would be if we could trust all those inno results.

[Cory Caboose]

As for " Rolling with the theme" ... ime Lynching people over mechanical speculation tends to work much much worse than just lynching the people who are probably wolves

 

So that's what I'm going to focus on :P

[Sooh]

While I would like to see more results given we should probably discuss the contradiction between Sooh and Ironeyes.

So what are the possibilities?

 

1) IE/Sooh are both villager.

2) IE is Villager, Sooh is Sane Cop. Vis Versa

3) IE is Villager, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

4) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

5) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop and Clov was Framed. Vis Versa

6) IE is Villager, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

7) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

8) IE is Insane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

 

And...I think that's it? Maybe? My mind is starting to melt so someone else will have to finish that list if there are more possibilities I'm missing.

Although I think 16 options is plenty to mull over jfc...

And this, boys and girls, is exactly why theorizing over these results is meaningless at this point in the game at least.

[Nolder]

It's not meaningless! There is ONE RIGHT ANSWER and it is RIGHT THERE! All we have to do is figure out which one it is...

 

All we...have...

 

My head hurts. 

[BFG]

 

I wouldn't even think about the peeks at all. Play the game like a vanilla.

 

Will only be important upon seer flips really, and even then only a certain amount of information will even be useful.

I get what you're saying but in that case we might as well be playing a vanilla game.

Seems to me not as fun if you don't roll with the theme here which is an abundance of unreliable info with nuggets of golden truth strewn about.

We're looking for needles in haystacks in other words.

 

While I would like to see more results given we should probably discuss the contradiction between Sooh and Ironeyes.

So what are the possibilities?

 

1) IE/Sooh are both villager.

2) IE is Villager, Sooh is Sane Cop. Vis Versa

3) IE is Villager, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

4) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

5) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop and Clov was Framed. Vis Versa

6) IE is Villager, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

7) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

8) IE is Insane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

 

And...I think that's it? Maybe? My mind is starting to melt so someone else will have to finish that list if there are more possibilities I'm missing.

Although I think 16 options is plenty to mull over jfc...

Why is this your priority?

Seemed like an easy place to start.

Actually it's not easy to draw any conclusions it's just easy to go through the possibilities lol.

Too much wifom for me lol

[BFG]

I can get you to 14 possibilities :p

[Sooh]

 

While I would like to see more results given we should probably discuss the contradiction between Sooh and Ironeyes.

So what are the possibilities?

 

1) IE/Sooh are both villager.

2) IE is Villager, Sooh is Sane Cop. Vis Versa

3) IE is Villager, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

4) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop. Vis Versa

5) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Insane Cop and Clov was Framed. Vis Versa

6) IE is Villager, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

7) IE is Sane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

8) IE is Insane Cop, Sooh is Lying Scum. Vis Versa

 

And...I think that's it? Maybe? My mind is starting to melt so someone else will have to finish that list if there are more possibilities I'm missing.

Although I think 16 options is plenty to mull over jfc...

Out of these possibilities I've bolded the ones I think are most likely.

I know there's plenty of actions floating around but the odds they collided on N0 are still pretty low I think (anyone want to do the math?).

Odds are someone is lying, and also someone might be wrong.

Given that Sooh was the one with the negative result which in theory could result in Clov being lynched I am going to make an educated guess she is the liar.

Now normally I would put my vote on her and advocate for a lynch but not only do I think we need more results and discussion first I am also not sure of the usefulness of lynching someone right off the bat.

Is it worth sacrificing someone for another round of investigations? We get a lot of info but it is very very unreliable...

 

Basically IDK what to do right now lol.

Anyone got any input on any of that?

 

[BFG]

Do you have reads on anyone?

[Sooh]

Do you have reads on anyone?

Which "you" are you talking to?

[BFG]

 

Do you have reads on anyone?

Which "you" are you talking to?

Nolder?

 

Everything ok?

[Andrej]

Is post editing allowed?

No. I figured most "standard" Mafia rules didn't need to be said because they're universally understood.

 

Also deadline will be Monday

[BFG]

 

 

Do you have reads on anyone?

Which "you" are you talking to?

Nolder?

 

Everything ok?

As in the "you" was Nolder

 

And I'm asking you (Soohgoatyou) if you're ok? :)

[Sooh]

 

 

Do you have reads on anyone?

Which "you" are you talking to?

Nolder?

 

Everything ok?

 

Yes?  Why do you ask?

[Andrej]

Vote Count

Ben (1) - LZM
SK (2) - SK, Dice
Marsh (1) - Sooh

[Cory Caboose]

im home

 

BFG whatcha wanna talk about boo

[Nolder]

Do you have reads on anyone?

Nothing I'd like to share at the moment.

 

 

Is post editing allowed?

No. I figured most "standard" Mafia rules didn't need to be said because they're universally understood.

 

Also deadline will be Monday

 

It's a dumb rule. :P

 

I don't think I have ever witnessed anyone trying to materially change or remove something they've said in games where such a thing was allowed.

And I've been playing Mafia for like 10 years now or something thereabouts.

[BFG]

 

 

 

Do you have reads on anyone?

Which "you" are you talking to?

Nolder?

 

Everything ok?

Yes? Why do you ask?

I dunno

 

Strange (? not sure that's the word I'm looking for) reaction to Nolder