[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Cass · June 9, 2017

Shad, can you point me to games where Nyn has been less engaged as a hydra? The one that come to my mind haven't displayed much difference from normal activity but I'm mostly thinking of whichever game she was hydra'd with Cory which isn't a fair baseline :p

Cass (and Nyn) gain the brownie points. Need to read Nyn's latest content more thoroughly, although superficially it looks ~good, prior to that 100% fluff/shark is a really bad look for Nyn. Suspect it's less the hydra and more RL, so I'm mostly going to be looking for what happens over her weekend <3

Possiblepocketattemptdenied.gif

Were you actually watching/sus on anyone at that point?

You've been wobbly all game. This looks like you distancing BFG.

Fair on both counts :D

Apart from the fact that in reality it's me being sus of BFG because I didn't accurately read the post I quoted, which I've later clarified.

Are you fully caught up?

Cass, that is actually the most reasonable argument I have ever seen for lynching an inactive player. Usually inactives are just easy townies for scum to take out, but your thought process there is really well developed.

Ta/Do you think he should be lynched today?

DPR · June 9, 2017

This is why I just want to lynch DPR in every game ever.

I know. Ima get one of those machines at the deli counter where you grab a number. Helps with the line.

DPR · June 9, 2017

Shad, can you point me to games where Nyn has been less engaged as a hydra? The one that come to my mind haven't displayed much difference from normal activity but I'm mostly thinking of whichever game she was hydra'd with Cory which isn't a fair baseline :p

Cass (and Nyn) gain the brownie points. Need to read Nyn's latest content more thoroughly, although superficially it looks ~good, prior to that 100% fluff/shark is a really bad look for Nyn. Suspect it's less the hydra and more RL, so I'm mostly going to be looking for what happens over her weekend <3

Possiblepocketattemptdenied.gif

Were you actually watching/sus on anyone at that point?

You've been wobbly all game. This looks like you distancing BFG.

Fair on both counts :D

Apart from the fact that in reality it's me being sus of BFG because I didn't accurately read the post I quoted, which I've later clarified.

Are you fully caught up?

I am. I want to talk both you and BFG a bit before laying out an opinion.

Will you provide a current reads list?

Shad_ · June 9, 2017

@ Shad - why do you think he's scum? You've expressed that opinion quite a bit, so please don't come back with reasons why you can't list reasons. Just lay 'em out.

This was your question.

Shad_ · June 9, 2017

It was in response to this.

I think there's a decent chance he's scum.

It's not like that's a read I can develop further because he's not here.

He was excited to play and then didn't play. Way more people dislike being scum than don't and I've seen multiple other strangers peace out shortly after reading a scum role pm. There's less of a guilt compulsion to stick it out for your team when no one knows who you are anyway.

Or he could just be busy. /shrug The immediate shift in his interest level and his subsequent disappearance is all I have to work with.

@BFG generic apathy about being lynched doesn't really count if the player doesn't care about the game in general. Thoughts on that?

Shad_ · June 9, 2017

Remove quotes from the second post, add roses and a letter of appreciation for the question, gg?

Killashandra · June 9, 2017

Mostly Kronos has been around today and I was a couple pages behind. I stayed up way too late because I finally watched some episodes of that show black mirror. Trippy sh*t right there. Anyway I am caught up now.

Also, can confirm DPR likes to pick on new townies as scum.

Shad_ · June 9, 2017

It's a distraction in that it gets people thinking about me before I had even really showed up yet, as you point out above.

By implying that I could be scum, it takes people's minds off of other player's content, which is what they should be concentrating on. I used the term "distraction" because "fear-mongering" would have been too strong, but it's the same principal.

I actually follow this lol.

I think it makes a mountain out of a null hill but I get it so we have that bby.

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Ok, I have to pause where I am in my re-read because I have wife duties to tend to. Where are we at until eod?

Shanti · June 9, 2017

I'm still having a hard time with people saying I've posted nothing but fluff. Most of my posts have been game related. This is D1 there isn't much to go on. Either you're town who just won't accept a different playstyle, or you're scum trying to discredit me already.

The fact that you keep rementioning this makes me go hmm...

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Less than a minute to go, no time to find it, will do d2

Quoting so I remember to see if you followed through.

Sooh · June 9, 2017

Vote count:

CuthaNyn (2): Shanti, Killanos

Alfred (1): Cass

Not voting (8): Tigraine, DreadPirateRoberts, Alfred Jodocus, BFG, Cuthanyn, Shad, Dice, Adella

With 11 alive it takes 6 to lynch.

Shad_ · June 9, 2017

Going to be infrequent until tonight probably, left off mid p38

Adella · June 9, 2017

Shad, can you point me to games where Nyn has been less engaged as a hydra? The one that come to my mind haven't displayed much difference from normal activity but I'm mostly thinking of whichever game she was hydra'd with Cory which isn't a fair baseline :p

Cass (and Nyn) gain the brownie points. Need to read Nyn's latest content more thoroughly, although superficially it looks ~good, prior to that 100% fluff/shark is a really bad look for Nyn. Suspect it's less the hydra and more RL, so I'm mostly going to be looking for what happens over her weekend <3

Possiblepocketattemptdenied.gif

Were you actually watching/sus on anyone at that point?

You've been wobbly all game. This looks like you distancing BFG.

Fair on both counts :D

Apart from the fact that in reality it's me being sus of BFG because I didn't accurately read the post I quoted, which I've later clarified.

Are you fully caught up?

Cass, that is actually the most reasonable argument I have ever seen for lynching an inactive player. Usually inactives are just easy townies for scum to take out, but your thought process there is really well developed.

Ta/Do you think he should be lynched today?

Not as much as Shanti, and I'm not really willing to get talked out of going with my gut unless we find an equally strong candidate.

Adella · June 9, 2017

I'm still having a hard time with people saying I've posted nothing but fluff. Most of my posts have been game related. This is D1 there isn't much to go on. Either you're town who just won't accept a different playstyle, or you're scum trying to discredit me already.

The fact that you keep rementioning this makes me go hmm...

I respond to pretty much every mention of me for clarity. It kept being mentioned, so I explained.

Adella · June 9, 2017

Less than a minute to go, no time to find it, will do d2

Quoting so I remember to see if you followed through.

Don't event remember what this was about lol. Also don't remember what I had for lunch 3 hours ago so...

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Shad, can you point me to games where Nyn has been less engaged as a hydra? The one that come to my mind haven't displayed much difference from normal activity but I'm mostly thinking of whichever game she was hydra'd with Cory which isn't a fair baseline :p

Cass (and Nyn) gain the brownie points. Need to read Nyn's latest content more thoroughly, although superficially it looks ~good, prior to that 100% fluff/shark is a really bad look for Nyn. Suspect it's less the hydra and more RL, so I'm mostly going to be looking for what happens over her weekend <3

Possiblepocketattemptdenied.gif

Were you actually watching/sus on anyone at that point?

You've been wobbly all game. This looks like you distancing BFG.

Fair on both counts :D

Apart from the fact that in reality it's me being sus of BFG because I didn't accurately read the post I quoted, which I've later clarified.

Are you fully caught up?

Cass, that is actually the most reasonable argument I have ever seen for lynching an inactive player. Usually inactives are just easy townies for scum to take out, but your thought process there is really well developed.

Ta/Do you think he should be lynched today?

Not as much as Shanti, and I'm not really willing to get talked out of going with my gut unless we find an equally strong candidate.

You think I should be lynched?

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

I keep mixing up adella and tigs posts... not sure why.

DPR · June 9, 2017

low effort not current drop is something like

Cass

BFG

Shanti ~feels good so far, if she's a wolf she nailed her town tone from the get-go

Cuth+Nyn ~Nyn needs to step up and play ball because I'm going to reach higher confidence on her one way or another than I'm likely to on Cuth

Killa+Kronos ~in need of a reread

Dice ~Dice has gotten better at Dicing as scum so we'll see, the stubbornness is a good look, needs a lot more content

Adella ~mostly liked how she handled my questions, haven't seen a reply to the last one yet

Tigraine ~lack of anything glaring so far where I would half expect there to be

LedZepMan ~curious about the people claiming this looks like his last town game, because I thought he was pretty unreadable there and then he got peeked town

DreadPirateRoberts ~nothing yet

Darthe ~nothing yet, that pop-in vote and disappearance could be anything

Alfred Jodocus ~distinguished from DPR/Darthe because he seemed eager to get going and then didn't

Terrible list.

I have BFG and Cats as scum, with you in their matrix. You've got LZM & Darthe in your bottom 4, along with me and the new guy. This stinks worse than a gas-station bathroom that's never been cleaned.

Ok. Show me all the super villagery posts you made D1 that I should have read you above null by? And Darthe and LZM?

Cass is town. BFG is not picking up the way I expected and I could tinfoil there but we'll see. Why do you have them as wolves?

No such thing as a "super villager post" on D1. Not really.

Darthe I get - there's rarely a good reason to not lynch him.

LZM was a flub - he didn't do anything but play.

Alfred is just LHF - no reason yet to spend any time there at all.

You've been surfing, very present, but not really laying down the wisdom. It's worrisome.

Can we get a tiered/reads list from you Shad?

low effort not current drop is something like

Cass

BFG

Shanti ~feels good so far, if she's a wolf she nailed her town tone from the get-go

Cuth+Nyn ~Nyn needs to step up and play ball because I'm going to reach higher confidence on her one way or another than I'm likely to on Cuth

Killa+Kronos ~in need of a reread

Dice ~Dice has gotten better at Dicing as scum so we'll see, the stubbornness is a good look, needs a lot more content

Adella ~mostly liked how she handled my questions, haven't seen a reply to the last one yet

Tigraine ~lack of anything glaring so far where I would half expect there to be

LedZepMan ~curious about the people claiming this looks like his last town game, because I thought he was pretty unreadable there and then he got peeked town

DreadPirateRoberts ~nothing yet

Darthe ~nothing yet, that pop-in vote and disappearance could be anything

Alfred Jodocus ~distinguished from DPR/Darthe because he seemed eager to get going and then didn't

Terrible list.

I have BFG and Cats as scum, with you in their matrix. You've got LZM & Darthe in your bottom 4, along with me and the new guy. This stinks worse than a gas-station bathroom that's never been cleaned.

Do you see a reason for LZM and Darthe to have not been in the bottom 4, prior to that post/their flip?

I talked about it above, but to repeat, there's too much LHF in it. Especially in light of Shad's post regarding post counts. There is no real game-solvey effort here, just surfing and the elimination of a player that actually was contributing.

Remove quotes from the second post, add roses and a letter of appreciation for the question, gg?

Okay, but it's still just coasting, knocking off Townies.

Mostly Kronos has been around today and I was a couple pages behind. I stayed up way too late because I finally watched some episodes of that show black mirror. Trippy sh*t right there. Anyway I am caught up now.

Also, can confirm DPR likes to pick on new townies as scum.

Actually, you can only confirm that in regard to yourself as you've not actually seen me "pick on new townies". Accuracy is important.

Adella · June 9, 2017

Absolutely. I'm waiting on your responses to my wall of text before I place a vote, cause I'm patient (for now).

Shanti · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

And I've officially reached my limit with your posts. GG naming a bunch of people green/town though so I can't tell who your scum buddies are.

Adella · June 9, 2017

I keep mixing up adella and tigs posts... not sure why.

Similar style, from the old days.

Adella · June 9, 2017

Absolutely. I'm waiting on your responses to my wall of text before I place a vote, cause I'm patient (for now).

This was in response to Shanti.

Nynaeve · June 9, 2017

Day didnt turn up as expected. Also fos cuth for being a filthy liar and not posting much as promised :-p I'll have to pay more attention when i look for a hydra next time around. The state of the economy just ruins everything.

i skimmed through. I'm not going to qualify mysrlf irt contribution. This is as much as you're gonna get. I wasn't kidding around when i said as much. With that said, i am going to enjoy myself what little time i have cause that's how i blowoff steam. If you dont like it and find it distracting then boo hoo poor you. It's not going to stop. And if you deem it vote worthy then 1. Lolyou 2. You're wasting your vote. 3. You suck.

On the good side of things? Kronos/killa hydra earns a solidified green, added to my previoys good feelz. No way he has the balls to vote me like that as scum. Also there were a couple of adella posts i liked and sounded earnest. So there's that. Still debating dice. Kinda muddled. Where the **** is alf? Good to see dpr jumping in and getting into the thick of it, though addmitedly im taking joy in him ripping into shad. Cass' paranoia and being all over the place seems genuine to me. I think. Hopefylly (dont go breaking my heart cass :-(). Shanti's posts kinda make my eyes glaze over and you can imagine what i think of her lol vote but addmitedly i dont know her and havent played with her so i havent decided yet if the nudge is dirty or misguided. Bfg kinda trending down. I expected her to be knee deep into the game by now being all bfg-like-ish.

This is sorta where I'm at. Unsure where exactly cuth is at reads wise. Like i said, he's gonna get a not so great hydra review when this game is over... sssshhh don't tell

And I've officially reached my limit with your posts. GG naming a bunch of people green/town though so I can't tell who your scum buddies are.

Thank you?

[Game thread]Magic The Gathering

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook