[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

DPR · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

Seriously - you think the mafia team shot at Tess, even though they know a Doc is probably in the game and 2 players claimed the role? Would you do that?

DPR · March 27, 2017

Also, Tress, why have you not reported who you watched? Will you go ahead and do that?

Zander? · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

*facepalm*

Which part of my step by step explanation of what I speculate is possible (key word being speculate) is confusing?

Why would you be sketched out by common sense?

I dont know what you think happened.

I dont know why you think Tress wouldnt be targeted.

Sooh was janitored, if she was Town she could have been the Doc for 1 example.

Maybe Im missing a post where you explained what you laid out you thoughts or speculated on this so please show me if I missed it.

Its just a post that pinged me.

Zander? · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

Seriously - you think the mafia team shot at Tess, even though they know a Doc is probably in the game and 2 players claimed the role? Would you do that?

Well im only through page 12 and read the EoD;s

Please tho show me where 2 players claimed Doc before the day started today because if not your point here is pointLESS.

DPR · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

Seriously - you think the mafia team shot at Tess, even though they know a Doc is probably in the game and 2 players claimed the role? Would you do that?

Well im only through page 12 and read the EoD;s

Please tho show me where 2 players claimed Doc before the day started today because if not your point here is pointLESS.

Not claimed, but hinted at... I'm fairly sure you caught at least one of them.

DPR · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

*facepalm*

Which part of my step by step explanation of what I speculate is possible (key word being speculate) is confusing?

Why would you be sketched out by common sense?

I dont know what you think happened.

I dont know why you think Tress wouldnt be targeted.

Sooh was janitored, if she was Town she could have been the Doc for 1 example.

Maybe Im missing a post where you explained what you laid out you thoughts or speculated on this so please show me if I missed it.

Its just a post that pinged me.

Now you do.

So, anybody that takes any interest in game mechanics has already suspected that this is a hybrid recruit game. I'm guessing Darthe had 1 other mate (Wifi/Nolder) and that they were offered the option to skip a NK in return for a recruit. For the sake of balance, this would be a 1x deal.

Talk me through where you are getting this idea like I am Zander.

Anytime you have a novel dynamic (fight hours) you have to compensate for how that might throw the game...

For instance, there was speculation that there 4 mafia. But that makes it too easy for the game to end on the D3 lynch, which outweighs the town, mostly because the fight dynamic is just a distraction that favors the mafia anyway (it favors the mafia by giving each lynch a 2nd chance and by screwing up the time continuum to cause confusion).

So, you have to start off with low numbers of scum. Lower numbers decreases the chance of them getting caught, but also stretches out the time that the game will last. And, by adding in a recruit option to substitute for a NK, you avoid killing them too soon.

It's a pretty standard setup for this type of game and it works well.

Now, this is just my speculation. But it fits with my suspicion on Nolder and his sudden perestoika with Darthe, so I figured I'd put it out there. We need to take into account all angles, but I'm guessing we got a Watcher in place of a Cop and there have been enough VT deaths that it looks like this setup relies more on mechanics than roles.

Does all that make sense?

And, I can't imagine being scum and targeting Tress - again, there is such a strong possibility of it being blocked and there is such a high possibility of killing another player. What would any scum team not take the chance to knock another townie off the board?

Zander? · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

Seriously - you think the mafia team shot at Tess, even though they know a Doc is probably in the game and 2 players claimed the role? Would you do that?

Well im only through page 12 and read the EoD;s

Please tho show me where 2 players claimed Doc before the day started today because if not your point here is pointLESS.

Not claimed, but hinted at... I'm fairly sure you caught at least one of them.

Nope i havent caught ANY that occurred BEFORE today started.

If they werent claimed BEFORE this day started then like I said, your statement is pointless.

Zander? · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

*facepalm*

Which part of my step by step explanation of what I speculate is possible (key word being speculate) is confusing?

Why would you be sketched out by common sense?

I dont know what you think happened.

I dont know why you think Tress wouldnt be targeted.

Sooh was janitored, if she was Town she could have been the Doc for 1 example.

Maybe Im missing a post where you explained what you laid out you thoughts or speculated on this so please show me if I missed it.

Its just a post that pinged me.

Now you do.

So, anybody that takes any interest in game mechanics has already suspected that this is a hybrid recruit game. I'm guessing Darthe had 1 other mate (Wifi/Nolder) and that they were offered the option to skip a NK in return for a recruit. For the sake of balance, this would be a 1x deal.

Talk me through where you are getting this idea like I am Zander.

Anytime you have a novel dynamic (fight hours) you have to compensate for how that might throw the game...

For instance, there was speculation that there 4 mafia. But that makes it too easy for the game to end on the D3 lynch, which outweighs the town, mostly because the fight dynamic is just a distraction that favors the mafia anyway (it favors the mafia by giving each lynch a 2nd chance and by screwing up the time continuum to cause confusion).

So, you have to start off with low numbers of scum. Lower numbers decreases the chance of them getting caught, but also stretches out the time that the game will last. And, by adding in a recruit option to substitute for a NK, you avoid killing them too soon.

It's a pretty standard setup for this type of game and it works well.

Now, this is just my speculation. But it fits with my suspicion on Nolder and his sudden perestoika with Darthe, so I figured I'd put it out there. We need to take into account all angles, but I'm guessing we got a Watcher in place of a Cop and there have been enough VT deaths that it looks like this setup relies more on mechanics than roles.

Does all that make sense?

And, I can't imagine being scum and targeting Tress - again, there is such a strong possibility of it being blocked and there is such a high possibility of killing another player. What would any scum team not take the chance to knock another townie off the board?

OK I see it now, you think Scum recruited as opposed to using a NK.

Well that does make more sense to me irt your explanation tho Im not sold yet that there is any recruitment in this game yet.

But why would they kill n1 and n2 and wait till d3 to recruit....seems flimsy to me to say the least.

DPR · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

*facepalm*

Which part of my step by step explanation of what I speculate is possible (key word being speculate) is confusing?

Why would you be sketched out by common sense?

I dont know what you think happened.

I dont know why you think Tress wouldnt be targeted.

Sooh was janitored, if she was Town she could have been the Doc for 1 example.

Maybe Im missing a post where you explained what you laid out you thoughts or speculated on this so please show me if I missed it.

Its just a post that pinged me.

Now you do.

So, anybody that takes any interest in game mechanics has already suspected that this is a hybrid recruit game. I'm guessing Darthe had 1 other mate (Wifi/Nolder) and that they were offered the option to skip a NK in return for a recruit. For the sake of balance, this would be a 1x deal.

Talk me through where you are getting this idea like I am Zander.

Anytime you have a novel dynamic (fight hours) you have to compensate for how that might throw the game...

For instance, there was speculation that there 4 mafia. But that makes it too easy for the game to end on the D3 lynch, which outweighs the town, mostly because the fight dynamic is just a distraction that favors the mafia anyway (it favors the mafia by giving each lynch a 2nd chance and by screwing up the time continuum to cause confusion).

So, you have to start off with low numbers of scum. Lower numbers decreases the chance of them getting caught, but also stretches out the time that the game will last. And, by adding in a recruit option to substitute for a NK, you avoid killing them too soon.

It's a pretty standard setup for this type of game and it works well.

Now, this is just my speculation. But it fits with my suspicion on Nolder and his sudden perestoika with Darthe, so I figured I'd put it out there. We need to take into account all angles, but I'm guessing we got a Watcher in place of a Cop and there have been enough VT deaths that it looks like this setup relies more on mechanics than roles.

Does all that make sense?

And, I can't imagine being scum and targeting Tress - again, there is such a strong possibility of it being blocked and there is such a high possibility of killing another player. What would any scum team not take the chance to knock another townie off the board?

OK I see it now, you think Scum recruited as opposed to using a NK.

Well that does make more sense to me irt your explanation tho Im not sold yet that there is any recruitment in this game yet.

But why would they kill n1 and n2 and wait till d3 to recruit....seems flimsy to me to say the least.

I've labeled it as speculation - I've presented it so that no one overlooks strange behavior from someone they previously trusted.

As mafia, the fewer of you there are, the lower the chances of being lynched. That's just math. Then, you wait until a player gets cleared as town, and then you recruit them. Savvy?

Zander? · March 27, 2017

Also, and I'm not throwing shade at any Doc claim, but given the obvious presence, who in their right mind would still try to NK Tess?

Which means they would have targeted someone else, and with this many people still on the board, chances are very high they would have hit.

I dislike this post.

WIFOM

Dislike it all you want. That doesn't detract from the fact that it would make no sense for a mafia team to waste a shot on a player they know will be protected.

It's not WIFOM if it's straight forward logic.

Well what do you think happened then?

Maybe WIFOM is the wrong term, fear mongering maybe, I dunno this post just sketches me out.

*facepalm*

Which part of my step by step explanation of what I speculate is possible (key word being speculate) is confusing?

Why would you be sketched out by common sense?

I dont know what you think happened.

I dont know why you think Tress wouldnt be targeted.

Sooh was janitored, if she was Town she could have been the Doc for 1 example.

Maybe Im missing a post where you explained what you laid out you thoughts or speculated on this so please show me if I missed it.

Its just a post that pinged me.

Now you do.

So, anybody that takes any interest in game mechanics has already suspected that this is a hybrid recruit game. I'm guessing Darthe had 1 other mate (Wifi/Nolder) and that they were offered the option to skip a NK in return for a recruit. For the sake of balance, this would be a 1x deal.

Talk me through where you are getting this idea like I am Zander.

Anytime you have a novel dynamic (fight hours) you have to compensate for how that might throw the game...

For instance, there was speculation that there 4 mafia. But that makes it too easy for the game to end on the D3 lynch, which outweighs the town, mostly because the fight dynamic is just a distraction that favors the mafia anyway (it favors the mafia by giving each lynch a 2nd chance and by screwing up the time continuum to cause confusion).

So, you have to start off with low numbers of scum. Lower numbers decreases the chance of them getting caught, but also stretches out the time that the game will last. And, by adding in a recruit option to substitute for a NK, you avoid killing them too soon.

It's a pretty standard setup for this type of game and it works well.

Now, this is just my speculation. But it fits with my suspicion on Nolder and his sudden perestoika with Darthe, so I figured I'd put it out there. We need to take into account all angles, but I'm guessing we got a Watcher in place of a Cop and there have been enough VT deaths that it looks like this setup relies more on mechanics than roles.

Does all that make sense?

And, I can't imagine being scum and targeting Tress - again, there is such a strong possibility of it being blocked and there is such a high possibility of killing another player. What would any scum team not take the chance to knock another townie off the board?

OK I see it now, you think Scum recruited as opposed to using a NK.

Well that does make more sense to me irt your explanation tho Im not sold yet that there is any recruitment in this game yet.

But why would they kill n1 and n2 and wait till d3 to recruit....seems flimsy to me to say the least.

I've labeled it as speculation - I've presented it so that no one overlooks strange behavior from someone they previously trusted.

As mafia, the fewer of you there are, the lower the chances of being lynched. That's just math. Then, you wait until a player gets cleared as town, and then you recruit them. Savvy?

This is a lot of fear mongering and wifom, i go back to my original sentiment.

And no, the best chance of winning would be to recruit as many players as possible imo.

But noted because i suck at setup stuffs so I will keep it in back of my mind and will ONLY come back to it if I see a flip that would lead me to do so.

Nolder · March 27, 2017

OK Im gonna do my best to get all read up.

I havent been following along so I need to read the entire game,

Im gonna do my best to get caught up as quick as possible and I will try to be around as much as possible tho RL will not allow me to be as active as I normally am.

I am Town tho and I promise I will try my best!!!!

Anyone wanna be a GOATfrand and drop the cliffnotes for me so I can have some idea of whats up as I try to catch up?!?!?!!?

Ohhhh boyyyyyyy.... ZanderCatchUp underway.... lol

Cliffs:

D1 we no lynched because DPR and Cuth were in the ring and they both thought each other was town, and it seemed pretty possible (turns out Cuth definitely was, and based on how Darthe treated DPR D3, I think probably he is too)

N1 Sooh killed with no coroner. Probably a limited shot janitor.

D2 it got all tangly with Seph, Cuth, Darthe and DPR arguing with a side of Ed thrown in for good measure, and it seemed fairly likely that at least one of those 4 was mafia, so we put Darthe and Cuth in together and Darthe claimed Coroner, so we lynched Cuth instead. Mistake.

N2 Nolder replaced WiFi and said he wasn't planning to read the pages he missed (which he also said in the signup thread, so I guess that's whatever man). Darthe said he was going to use his coroner ability on Sooh. DPR asked Darthe for the details of his role. Darthe wasn't around to answer. BFG killed.

D3 Darthe said he got no result, refused to give details of his role, pushed DPR pretty hard as his top wolf suspect. I had a hell of a lot of fun toying with him before I revealed as town watcher. I watched BFG night 2 and caught Darthe killing her in living color, so we threw Darthe in the ring with DPR. Nolder was the only one who decided DPR was more suspicious than Darthe. Darthe flipped mafia goon.

As for the rest of 'em, Hallia has been super inactive which is kind of worrisome. I'm pretty comfortable with Dice here, as was BFG, so you can probably give him a pass on your suspicion-meter for now. DPR has been up and down on my suspicion list, could possibly be gambiting with Darthe but eh... keep an eye on him, but I think he's probably OK here. When you get to D3 watch Darthe's interactions with him and see what your take is. In fact, if you won't have time to do a full catchup before deadline, I'd prioritize D3, it has some nuggets.

Hallia's super inactivity has been as both alignments recently so Null at best for her imo.

Nolder not saying he isnt gonna read something is also not alignment indicative of him as well. I also have 0 idea how to red Wifi. What was everyone's reads on her before she subbed out?

And do you think the red could be because of the blue?!!?!?!?

ie- Distancing

I'll try to read through everything but I wanted to touch on this first so I have some idea of what's going on!!!!!

There's the question, yeah?

Is it distancing or a legit attempt to lynch a townie?

Strangely, Nolder thinks DPR is mafia but doesn't think Darthe was trying to distance from a teammate.

I am still trying to wrap my head around that.

Maybe my expectations are too high. It just doesn't look like an attempt to distance to me.

I feel like both would come on stronger if that is what they were trying to do.

Maybe it's very light distancing? I guess it could be. /shrug

Does it really matter?

YES

Why?

Songstress · March 27, 2017

I won't be home for another few hours. Work is keeping me fairly busy, will have all the fun after I get home.

DPR · March 27, 2017

@ Zander - The mafia recruit would be 1x. Not unlimited.

Regardless, I'll point out again that it's not fear mongering if it's common sense.

Nolder · March 27, 2017

Are you going to give us your results from last night when you get home Tress?

Songstress · March 27, 2017

Are you going to give us your results from last night when you get home Tress?

Waiting for me for something?

Y'all keep talking.

Nolder · March 27, 2017

Not particularly, just curious since you wont be able to talk for awhile after we pass this stage.

DPR · March 27, 2017

Are you going to give us your results from last night when you get home Tress?

You ask a lot of questions for someone that won't read or answer any.

ed2funy · March 27, 2017

It's a pretty standard setup for this type of game and it works well.

Show me examples, if you don't mind. I can't say I've encountered anything like you're suggesting that I can recall.

I've actually been in a game where I got recruited to Mafia, though truly I can't remember the specifics of the game besides I was the last one standing and almost won the game against two townies. lol

Annnnd best friend missed his flight, so gotta drive up to Denver.

Zander? · March 28, 2017

let's make things interesting: [v] songstress and crusher [/v] I have to go to bed early tonight. not now but I just wanna throw them out there. get people playing.

I know shes not in the game so I cant ask her about this post but knowing I'm Town and feeling pretty damn sure Tress is Town too this seems like a strange call out based on whats bee said thus far,

What was everyone's read on Wifi before Nolder subbed in for her?

hoqueso

darthe jumps into game without much preliminary stuff

one game-related post, one chatting about drinking, and then all game related stuff

seriousish

this tends more towards scum ime, as they, myself included, have a hard time feeling very natural and sliding in thread and being all jokey like town often does

lines up with any perceived difference in darthe's playstyle this game as opposed to the last two without being based thereon

then he votes DPR and says 3p? his first accusation is 3p and not scum

makes 0 scumreads, one 3p

idk

village tends to think scum>3p rather than the other way around

thereafter a soft defense of wifi

after a legitimate point by ed that she was backpedaling, he says he disagrees, but not really

just a soft, open read that leaves itself open to be interpreted any way in the future

does the good old "that's a big leap for page 7 bfg is hard to read" thing, and immediately follows it up with "i want more cold hard reads", however serious that is or not

so several soft defenses and attacks, not hard, very cautious

except for one vote apparently on suspicion of 3p

these things add up in my mind, sooh

they really do

Zander? · March 28, 2017

Ok home and caught up

Darthe is scum, how about that for a nice warm fresh take from the cafe down the street.

[v]Darthe[/v]

and for now [v]Crusher[/v]

but there's really not much of a reason on that one

yeah no reread his posts

he has an intensity, but not his normal jokey persona

the vote on DPR was questionable, but i took even more issue with the "just watch and see if she derps" thing with wifi

you are suddenly shouting for cold hard reads, which is unusual

but then you go around disagreeing with other people's cold hard reads

your tone is so baaaad though

really nothing i can verbalize perfectly yet in a way that would convince anyone

but the guy's scum

I don't dislike this; I find myself expressing my thoughts in much the same way as town; good town vibes on Cuth atm

Reading Darthe from one game to the next is like reading two different people. Even as town he likes to mix things up a ton in my experience.

So do you like Cuth's read? Or no?

I want more Crusherlove and Hallia!

You shall have it - but only the top half of me, the legs are out of commission

I see what you're saying.

I think what you see as him wanting to use others' reads as his own is what I see as him prodding others to give reads which he in turn can read them for, like say I ask you what you think of Dice for example, and you tell me, that gives me an idea about your alignment and not Dice's.

It's a subtle difference, but it was enough for me not to understand what you meant to begin with.

Yeah, no I get that. It's just odd how he's doing it. To me; I don't know how else to explain it at the moment.

--------

Unvote Wildfire

Vote Seph

Honestly just a hunch atm. I do agree with him that we need more content. Lol

Mehhh; Seph normally is super active, and that's good either way, if town he helps solve, if mafia, he would spew more than an inactive, and give us more to work with imo

A Hallia post!!!

QFR

I dunno if its just some lolzander but the red reads awkward to me,

The wording is awkward and I dunno what made Hallia like Cuth that much.

I dont know how much exp Hallia had with him.

Zander? · March 28, 2017

i'm not taking them as 100% serious

but i'm trying to see if they make sense as town, and if they line up with perspectives and such

and as a result i have determined him to be probably scum? :P

Fair enough.

...

and ergo you should vote there :D

A belated good evening all <3

hello

may i suggest a vote on darthe

I thought you were towny until this happened. Little eager are we? [v]Cuth[/v]

I know its hindsight and all but looking back this dont look very good imo.

I know being wrong obv doesnt equal Scum and hindsight bias.,,,but still something I noticed.

let's make things interesting: [v] songstress and crusher [/v] I have to go to bed early tonight. not now but I just wanna throw them out there. get people playing.

Why those 2?

Post like these are why I love Towning with BFGOAT <3 <3 <3

OK I feel pretty comfortable with big and iron as town d1 in just these last few pages.

Hey seph, how did you get to here from the below so quickly....

I was just curious. I think she will be obvious later so I'm not that worried.

I just don't like people I tend to have a hard time reading early on , like her... and you...

I was just curious. I think she will be obvious later so I'm not that worried.I just don't like people I tend to have a hard time reading early on , like her... and you...
Curious though, I can't think of any games where you've struggled to read me?
I make reads all the time but you are one in less comfortable about until you start doing your thing.
Like I'm more comfortable tone reading other people Than yourself so I will be more cautious with how I go about reading you early on until I'm certain.

I feel like as mafia you could take my trust and easily kill me with it :( lol

Zander? · March 28, 2017

Yeah they were just people I disliked the least at the time, I don't really have a case for them. They are just the people in thread who are the least town to me. I actually loved your list you made earlier and agree 100% with it as none of them should be lynched.

Though I would like ed to come try to clarify and talk with me because it confused me on the point he was trying to make as I thought he was trying to twist it to fit his narritive. Besides that I have liked him so fat and would be my lowest town atm.

MEH

seph your progression on BFG is legit sketching me out.

Vote Darthe & Sooh

Darthe because he hit & run, Sooh because she's trying too hard to push her points on D1.

fwiw this would be a pretty safe vote as Scum imo.

Vote Darthe & Sooh

Darthe because he hit & run, Sooh because she's trying too hard to push her points on D1.

This feels extremely random to me at the moment. You really don't have any thought progression in the thread, unless there is something I have not gotten to.

Im not going to lie I feel extremely good about sooh, bfg, dice and wifi. The more I read the more I love them lol

If seph is Scum with Darthe I dont think DPR is.

I dunno if I'm like way too high from the meds or something but #feelz

Zander? · March 28, 2017

Apologies if this is broken

Only thing worth noting is that WiFis votes are actually pretty townie for the timing of them (and I retract the earlier question <3)

DPR & Crushers wagons seem rather baseless, wagons for wagons sakes, most other trains have some reasons, albeit weak

Vote Count!

Songstress - 3 - Ed2funy, Sooh, Wildfire Sedai

DeadPirateRoberts - 3 - Darthe, Seph, Sooh

The Crusher - 3 - Seph, Cuth, Wildfire Sedai

Sooh - 1 - The Crusher

Darthe - 1 - Cuth

Seph - 1 - Ed2funy

Cuth - 1 - Ironeyes

Phase 1 of Day 1 ends at 11:00 PM EST on Saturday, March 18th!

Vote Songstress & Wildfire

Vote Songstress & Wildfire

[v]ed [/v]

Eeyore was always my favorite because of 2 things: he was a horse and he was blue, both things I loved.

Dead giveaway imo.

Vote Wifi

Dae 3p?

[v] DPR [/v]

Vote Songstress & Wildfire
#raisins?

m
They shifty af. The whiskey is telling me they suss.

For now. Not many people posting often enough to interact.

Not enough discussion imo, but I feel good about dice, Ed, Darth and bfg to some extent. [unvote] ed.

I know it's only 9 pages and I forgot how long the day phase is while typing this but [v] crusher[/v] I had some problems with his intro

Was a easy post on a holiday and bounces. We will see but I definitely want a interactive crusher!

[v]dpr [/v] dpr was you post where you voted wildfire a serious one? I read two people viewing it differently.

Vote Songstress & Wildfire
#raisins?

m
They shifty af. The whiskey is telling me they suss.

For now. Not many people posting often enough to interact.

Seems a bit early for a double vote like that. I'd like to think that's towny. Depends on how brazen you are regularly though.

Mild town lean?

Why do say you would "like" to think its towny and then give a mid town lean? If you gave it a mid town lean it seems you "do" think its townie. Seems like you might know they are town and don;t want us to know that.
vote sooh

Darthe is scum, how about that for a nice warm fresh take from the cafe down the street.

[v]Darthe[/v]

and for now [v]Crusher[/v]

but there's really not much of a reason on that one

yeah no reread his posts

he has an intensity, but not his normal jokey persona

the vote on DPR was questionable, but i took even more issue with the "just watch and see if she derps" thing with wifi

you are suddenly shouting for cold hard reads, which is unusual

but then you go around disagreeing with other people's cold hard reads

your tone is so baaaad though

[v]DPR and Tress[/v]

I see what you're saying.

I think what you see as him wanting to use others' reads as his own is what I see as him prodding others to give reads which he in turn can read them for, like say I ask you what you think of Dice for example, and you tell me, that gives me an idea about your alignment and not Dice's.

It's a subtle difference, but it was enough for me not to understand what you meant to begin with.

Yeah, no I get that. It's just odd how he's doing it. To me; I don't know how else to explain it at the moment.

--------

Unvote Wildfire

Vote Seph

Honestly just a hunch atm. I do agree with him that we need more content. Lol

Vote Count!

Songstress - 2 - Ed2funy, Sooh

DeadPirateRoberts - 3 - Darthe, Seph, Sooh

The Crusher - 2 - Seph, Cuth

Sooh - 1 - The Crusher

Darthe - 1 - Cuth

Seph - 1 - Ed2funy

Phase 1 of Day 1 ends at 11:00 PM EST on Saturday, March 18th!

let's make things interesting: [v] songstress and crusher [/v] I have to go to bed early tonight. not now but I just wanna throw them out there. get people playing.

i'm not taking them as 100% serious

but i'm trying to see if they make sense as town, and if they line up with perspectives and such

and as a result i have determined him to be probably scum? :P

Fair enough.

...

and ergo you should vote there :D

A belated good evening all <3
hello

may i suggest a vote on darthe

I thought you were towny until this happened. Little eager are we? [v]Cuth[/v]

I have that feeling like theres Scum on my train.......

Zander? · March 28, 2017

Talk to me about dpr cuth. Why do you have him as town?
mmmmostly because who's voting him and who he's voting :P
This makes 0 sense from a town perspective on day 1 where we are making our own info and nothing concrete.
Please expand a bit on this for me to understand.

Dr voted Darth because he hasn't came back into the thread and has made 0 posts or progression there. How besides he is voting your suspect is that townie?

Your then adding him to town for being voted by your suspect who you have 0 knowledge about.

Cuth this doesn't make sense???

[unvote crusher]

[V] cuth [/v]

i'm not taking them as 100% serious

but i'm trying to see if they make sense as town, and if they line up with perspectives and such

and as a result i have determined him to be probably scum? :P

Fair enough.

...

and ergo you should vote there :D

A belated good evening all <3

hello

may i suggest a vote on darthe

I thought you were towny until this happened. Little eager are we? [v]Cuth[/v]

vote ironeyes and cuth

Where did this come from Dice?!?!?!!?

dicetosser1 · March 28, 2017

Talk to me about dpr cuth. Why do you have him as town?
mmmmostly because who's voting him and who he's voting :P
This makes 0 sense from a town perspective on day 1 where we are making our own info and nothing concrete.
Please expand a bit on this for me to understand.

Dr voted Darth because he hasn't came back into the thread and has made 0 posts or progression there. How besides he is voting your suspect is that townie?

Your then adding him to town for being voted by your suspect who you have 0 knowledge about.

Cuth this doesn't make sense???

[unvote crusher]

[V] cuth [/v]

i'm not taking them as 100% serious

but i'm trying to see if they make sense as town, and if they line up with perspectives and such

and as a result i have determined him to be probably scum? :P

Fair enough.

...

and ergo you should vote there :D

A belated good evening all <3

hello

may i suggest a vote on darthe

I thought you were towny until this happened. Little eager are we? [v]Cuth[/v]

vote ironeyes and cuth

Where did this come from Dice?!?!?!!?

that vote stunk and i didnt particularly trust cuth either. So i wanted them to fight it out

[Advanced] Fight Club Mafia! - Game Thread!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook