[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[Andrej]

 

I'm just poking fun a bit since she gave me some shade for not responding to her statement that didn't need responding to.

Yeah, I'm petty.

 

 

All you're doing is making yourself look bad, honestly. And not necessarily game related, even.

 

 

You asked me for reads. I brushed you off and you said... nothing. That's not how I expect you to react.

 

I made an observation about finding your behaviour odd. you addressed it. I have nothing to say about it for now.

 

 

So... yeah... totes the same thing.

It's not really about looking better or worse. You made a jab at me that was silly so I am just pointing it out for you.

 

I'm not sure how you expected me to react but you've been pretty consistently cagey with me so I didn't feel the need to press and you had already explained elsewhere what you were doing.

[Calder]

 

 

 

If town consistently NLed on D1 more games would be won. Townies typically get killed D1. Huge advantage day for scum. But, no lynching is boring to people.

 

My last seven town games here:Tarmon Gaidon -- wolf D1Overwatch failDisney -- wolf D1Julius Caesar -- wolf D1Lost failDragon Reborn -- wolf D1Warcraft -- wolf D1So no.

That is too small of a sample size of handpicked games you cherry picked to present.

If someone slips of course you pounce. But, town gets in this mindset that they have to lynch someone even when they are spinning in circles. No lynch is an underutilized tool.

 

If "Shad randing villager" is the cherry pick key then go me?

 

But it's really not.

 

It's villagers trying hard, and forcing each other to adapt their reads as the phase progresses, and lynching from the pool that can't put out.

I am not interested in arguing this further bc I know we dont disagree. My cherry pick comment was made bc you excluded your scum games (scum influence lynches equally if not more on D1) and you presented a small sample size.

[Andrej]

 

I'm agreeing with Sooh's lol. Could be bop laying down cover for Eldrick after he was called on his posting.

That's a pretty paranoid way of looking at it. Eldrick was getting more positive feedback than negative, so it's not like he needed to be bailed out of anything.Eldrick is very likely a villager in this game, and Bop's a good wolf but seems entirely villagery so far.

I thought it was a bit of a stretch personally. I think voting Eldrick when you're not familiar with him is probably more null than anything. See Calder in Hackers as an example. I agree irt to the other two.

 

You've played with Bop before too?

[Calder]

I like when Shad gets fiesty btw

[Andrej]

Well you're a glutton for punishment so I'm not surprised

[Calder]

 

 

I'm agreeing with Sooh's lol. Could be bop laying down cover for Eldrick after he was called on his posting.

That's a pretty paranoid way of looking at it. Eldrick was getting more positive feedback than negative, so it's not like he needed to be bailed out of anything.Eldrick is very likely a villager in this game, and Bop's a good wolf but seems entirely villagery so far.

I thought it was a bit of a stretch personally. I think voting Eldrick when you're not familiar with him is probably more null than anything. See Calder in Hackers as an example. I agree irt to the other two.

You've played with Bop before too?

This is a good post. Andrej moving up the townie rankings.

 

DPR feels exactly like me on D1 of Hackers as I couldnt unlock off reading Eldrick as scum.

[DPR]

 

 

 

 

I'm agreeing with Sooh's lol. Could be bop laying down cover for Eldrick after he was called on his posting. 

 

 

 

 

That guy? He's always crying'. Has been since the 70's.

 

For DPR's eyes only... since he was curious earlier....

 

 

 

"DPR's vote on Eldrick pings a little bit... but DPR has never played with him before. So it's kind of a question mark at this point. Definitely gonna be watching him though. He's kinda low key so far."

 

 

 

That's nice, but I liked the one with the garters better.

 

Is anyone else having an issue with their posts loading? I have to refresh like every time.

 

Yep.

 

 

I'm agreeing with Sooh's lol. Could be bop laying down cover for Eldrick after he was called on his posting.

That's a pretty paranoid way of looking at it. Eldrick was getting more positive feedback than negative, so it's not like he needed to be bailed out of anything.

 

Eldrick is very likely a villager in this game, and Bop's a good wolf but seems entirely villagery so far.

 

 

You're a kick.

 

Eldrick seemed nervous to me. I shared the opinion. It's not an overly strong opinion or a game-changer, just something I noticed. I also noticed bop posting multiple times to prop him up (the positive feedback). Now you're defending him, which is confusing because you just said he didn't need it?

 

You can't possibly be criticizing a no-pressure opinion, on d1, from a newly returned player who hasn't played with over half the players - that wouldn't make any sense.

 

We'll see what happens.     

[Shad_]

I thought it was a bit of a stretch personally. I think voting Eldrick when you're not familiar with him is probably more null than anything. See Calder in Hackers as an example. I agree irt to the other two.

 

You've played with Bop before too?

I caught him wolfing in a mash once, but that game was sort of my magnum opus of epic villaging.  He played very well and it was more of a situational read than anything I could take meta from.

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

 

Tiinker is scum if it makes anyone feel better.

[V]Tiinker[/v]

 

Talk to me. Sweet like.

I have stared into her soul and she is scum. She is just existing.

 

Are you talking about him as if he's a girl on purpose? lol

I said it was a soulread. I can't help that his soul is feminine.

 

 

I am offended. OFFENDED. Why would you offend me in such a way. 

[DPR]

 

 

I'm agreeing with Sooh's lol. Could be bop laying down cover for Eldrick after he was called on his posting.

That's a pretty paranoid way of looking at it. Eldrick was getting more positive feedback than negative, so it's not like he needed to be bailed out of anything.Eldrick is very likely a villager in this game, and Bop's a good wolf but seems entirely villagery so far.

I thought it was a bit of a stretch personally. I think voting Eldrick when you're not familiar with him is probably more null than anything. See Calder in Hackers as an example. I agree irt to the other two.

 

You've played with Bop before too?

 

 

Nope. I've only played with a few of the folks here - less than half.

[Shad_]

You're a kick.

 

Eldrick seemed nervous to me. I shared the opinion. It's not an overly strong opinion or a game-changer, just something I noticed. I also noticed bop posting multiple times to prop him up (the positive feedback). Now you're defending him, which is confusing because you just said he didn't need it?

 

You can't possibly be criticizing a no-pressure opinion, on d1, from a newly returned player who hasn't played with over half the players - that wouldn't make any sense.

 

We'll see what happens.

Red, you humored that Bop might have rushed to Eldrick's defense because they're scum bros.  What on earth does me sticking up for both of them have to do with it?

 

Blue, new people rand scum too.  If I don't question you I'm not really sure how you expect me to read you.

[Nynaeve]

Nope. I've only played with a few of the folks here - less than half.

 

Well, if you call that playing...

[Tiinker]

AJ and Nyn need some discipline. I'll fetch the belt.

[Shad_]

You're going to be a learning process in general for me because you tend to make arguments that I personally find highly illogical, but yet you come across as a logic-minded player, and that's my primary shtick so it's how I'm naturally inclined to engage you.  But it's not going to directly get me anywhere.

[Tiinker]

Shad's turning up the heat early. 

[Nynaeve]

AJ and Nyn need some discipline. I'll fetch the belt.

 

Why are you being weird?

[Tiinker]

You're going to be a learning process in general for me because you tend to make arguments that I personally find highly illogical, but yet you come across as a logic-minded player, and that's my primary shtick so it's how I'm naturally inclined to engage you.  But it's not going to directly get me anywhere.

 

Reads as village Shad.

[Shad_]

Shad's turning up the heat early. 

 

rawr

[Tiinker]

C

 

 

AJ and Nyn need some discipline. I'll fetch the belt.

 

Why are you being weird?

 

 

 

Chill

[Nynaeve]

O_o

[Nynaeve]

Excuse you?

[Shad_]

I haven't gone through the game. 30 pages ! :(

 

What's happening?

 

There's literally like 25 pages of 1-line garbage.  Should be a quicker catch-up than most.

[Shad_]

Its weird. First, why mention you read nothing before this point? 2nd, how do you forget that and need reminding? Third, why would you not?

 

I cant put it into words as to what exactly I think it means, but its definitely weird and not something id expect you to do. Red flag is probably abit strong language wise though.

[Andrej]

 

 

 

I'm agreeing with Sooh's lol. Could be bop laying down cover for Eldrick after he was called on his posting.

 

That's a pretty paranoid way of looking at it. Eldrick was getting more positive feedback than negative, so it's not like he needed to be bailed out of anything.Eldrick is very likely a villager in this game, and Bop's a good wolf but seems entirely villagery so far.

I thought it was a bit of a stretch personally. I think voting Eldrick when you're not familiar with him is probably more null than anything. See Calder in Hackers as an example. I agree irt to the other two.

You've played with Bop before too?

 

Nope. I've only played with a few of the folks here - less than half.

I'm aware and that's kind of my point. I don't think it's unreasonable for someone who has never played with Eldrick to think he looks scummy. The buzzsaw defense connection was sort of out there though. I think Bop's read was pretty spot on despite Eldrick's insistence that his post count is null.

[Sooh]

AJ and Nyn need some discipline. I'll fetch the belt.

Interesting selection.