[Advanced] Lost Mafia--Game Over!

[BFG]

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/99811-advanced-lost-mafia-day-3/page-128?do=findComment&comment=3741371

Thanks, thoughts on people not me or NB?

[Calder]

@Calder, Prals list is less consensus than mine, why do you have an issue with his and not mine?

I expect your lists to be close to consensus.

[bopolis]

@Bop how many faction/cult games have you played in?

 

i've played in lots with 3p;

 

i've only played in one with conversions and it was miserable and unenjoyable for all

[Calder]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Huh, what is a claim-generator?Anyway, good peek Shad. So, post that this is where I am atShad_TiinkerNot Bob (鲍勃不是我的名字)Wildfire SedaiCalderbopolisLenloDartheEldrick4221Randomh3r0 IroneyesSooh BFG

Last game was my only experience with Pral in my memory. Yet I saw obvious intelligence in his reads and ability to be outside the box with them.

That being said this reads list IS THE BOX. If I was scum trying to give a fake reads list that wouldnt get me into trouble I dont know what I would shift in this. Dont like it one bit.

Can you reword?

In a more succint way of saying it:

 

My view of Pral is that he shows intelligent and outside the box ways of thinking. His posts are usually interesting as he gives lots of info once he catches up.

 

Yet the list he gives in this game is in my view super meh and conservative. He gave kind of a safe/generic list. I dont buy it.

Well, technically I had a lot of those reads much before others started talking about. For example, Sooh. I was one of the first to suspect her for scum.

 

So, meh, if you think that it was just a conservative read list.

Your reads list isnt an issue bc of 1 or 2 names. It is the collective list I dislike.

That doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Like what bop mentioned - he had specific points which he disliked in the list. I don't see the same coming from your pov.

Why would I tell you the specific things that tip me off to you being scum?

 

When you spot someone's tells you keep them to yourself.

[Calder]

 

@Bop how many faction/cult games have you played in?

i've played in lots with 3p;

 

i've only played in one with conversions and it was miserable and unenjoyable for all

Only one cult game?

 

I have at least 12-15.

[bopolis]

 

 

@Bop how many faction/cult games have you played in?

i've played in lots with 3p;

 

i've only played in one with conversions and it was miserable and unenjoyable for all

Only one cult game?

 

I have at least 12-15.

 

 

only one, my main site doesn't really play conversion games since if there are conversions it's pretty impossible to play to your wincon from the get go, but this is more of a theory thing we can talk about later in postgame since its not really relevant to the current gamestate

[Calder]

That is fine

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

@NB why did you vote me yesterday?

 

Partly due to Sooh's reputation as scum, partly due to the need to get more intel (blood in the water).  Providing your character name and making a clear statement saying you have not been turned would help my analysis.

[Pralaya]

 

Why would I tell you the specific things that tip me off to you being scum?

 

When you spot someone's tells you keep them to yourself.

Because I am interested in seeing what "scum" tells I have when I am town, lol

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Why would I tell you the specific things that tip me off to you being scum?

 

When you spot someone's tells you keep them to yourself.

Because I am interested in seeing what "scum" tells I have when I am town, lol

 

 

Do you have a read on Bop?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Huh?

 

Where am I?

 

I'm so lost .

 

The consolation prize is now I actually have to go back and read your posts.  Who did you track and who went where?  Ugh, ironical is ironical.  

[Pralaya]

 

 

Why would I tell you the specific things that tip me off to you being scum?

 

When you spot someone's tells you keep them to yourself.

Because I am interested in seeing what "scum" tells I have when I am town, lol

Do you have a read on Bop?

Likely town.

 

Mostly driven by what I saw from d1 lynch.

[Pralaya]

 

Huh?

 

Where am I?

 

I'm so lost .

The consolation prize is now I actually have to go back and read your posts. Who did you track and who went where? Ugh, ironical is ironical.

He said that already in the thread. He tracked Calder who went nowhere

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

 

Huh?

 

Where am I?

 

I'm so lost .

The consolation prize is now I actually have to go back and read your posts. Who did you track and who went where? Ugh, ironical is ironical.

He said that already in the thread. He tracked Calder who went nowhere

 

 

I agree with Bop...I have a town read on Calder as well.  You?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

dead in thread.

[Darthe]

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

Vig is getting screwed with and looks like a potential mislynch, cop isnt actually a cop, and is helping them sniff out cultists.

 

Makes sense to me to take out the tracker if theyre gonna block me or etc, and continue the WIFOM. Thats not wolfy, it's the result of your/random/elxricks D1 ineptitude causing claims way too early.

[Darthe]

I am still waiting on a mod response regarding a question I posed to him btw.

[Lenlo]

 

 

@Bop how many faction/cult games have you played in?

i've played in lots with 3p;

 

i've only played in one with conversions and it was miserable and unenjoyable for all

Only one cult game?

 

I have at least 12-15.

 

#CultLife

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

Vig is getting screwed with and looks like a potential mislynch, cop isnt actually a cop, and is helping them sniff out cultists.

 

Makes sense to me to take out the tracker if theyre gonna block me or etc, and continue the WIFOM. Thats not wolfy, it's the result of your/random/elxricks D1 ineptitude causing claims way too early.

 

 

Derp claimed with how many votes?  Go ahead and lay that on me.  If I had a gun at least we know who'd get shot.

[Wildfire Sedai]

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

 

IF the town Vig and Cop are true roles? and not given by AJ?!  Would there be a tracker and a cop in one game? I seem to remember this dilemma happening in another game and the tracker was fake.  Maybe the cop is now? 

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

 

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

 

IF the town Vig and Cop are true roles? and not given by AJ?!  Would there be a tracker and a cop in one game? I seem to remember this dilemma happening in another game and the tracker was fake.  Maybe the cop is now? 

 

 

Maybe the Vig is fake?  Strange.  Are you suggesting we lynch Shad?

[Tiinker]

 

Huh?

 

Where am I?

 

I'm so lost .

 

The consolation prize is now I actually have to go back and read your posts.  Who did you track and who went where?  Ugh, ironical is ironical.  

 

 

N1 he tracked Calder and he went nowhere

[Pralaya]

 

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

Vig is getting screwed with and looks like a potential mislynch, cop isnt actually a cop, and is helping them sniff out cultists.

 

Makes sense to me to take out the tracker if theyre gonna block me or etc, and continue the WIFOM. Thats not wolfy, it's the result of your/random/elxricks D1 ineptitude causing claims way too early.

If they have a blocker, wouldn't they have blocked the tracker? Or the cop? Why the vig? Logically, either you are scum or they knew you were on track to hit scum(BFG).

[Darthe]

 

 

Thoughts to ponder...kinda weird that the scum team took out the tracker but left the town Vig and Cop alive.

Vig is getting screwed with and looks like a potential mislynch, cop isnt actually a cop, and is helping them sniff out cultists.

 

Makes sense to me to take out the tracker if theyre gonna block me or etc, and continue the WIFOM. Thats not wolfy, it's the result of your/random/elxricks D1 ineptitude causing claims way too early.

Derp claimed with how many votes? Go ahead and lay that on me. If I had a gun at least we know who'd get shot.

I do lay that on you, on all three of you.

 

15 min to deadline and I had the most votes, it doesnt matter how many that was at that time.