[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Darthe]

Wildfire I'm not even going to address my votes having been "premeditated" because that makes negative sense

It was really cute tough

[monstrman]

Considering my style as a player, nothing is ever premeditated.

 

Trying to use it as reasoning against me is not good

 

Besie being around for EoD but having nothing to say weirds me out. I don't care how strange that sounds bringing it up 24 hours after the fact, it just does

[Darthe]

 

 

darthe can u stick ure mod hat on for a sec and lay something out for me??

 

 

what roles GENERALLY are found in a basic game?

Cop can cc tracker unless we also have a vig which means wolves will have a gf and an rb

 

does this mean that you only find tracker if there is no cop? can they both exist together?

Imho? No, that would be really unlikely.

[monstrman]

I like this discourse mb, means no stone is being left unturned

Yeah I guess

 

It just frustrates me when everyone is at odds with each other all day

 

Especially considering the amount of time I spend in the thread

[Darthe]

Considering my style as a player, nothing is ever premeditated.

 

Trying to use it as reasoning against me is not good

 

Besie being around for EoD but having nothing to say weirds me out. I don't care how strange that sounds bringing it up 24 hours after the fact, it just does

That wasn't against you. It was a thought, that sprung up and fluttered out into the world with imagination abounding

[Darthe]

 

I like this discourse mb, means no stone is being left unturned

Yeah I guess

 

It just frustrates me when everyone is at odds with each other all day

 

Especially considering the amount of time I spend in the thread

I get that, but at the end of the day we just need to lynch a wolfy player, get the result and move forward.

 

Imo it should be believer, laya, wild or sooh. Besie did good under pressure and everyone else I have good reasons to think is town, including nego who seems to be a hot topic for some reason

[monstrman]

Nego has a style where he floats under the radar

 

Usually as a villager Ive seen more from him by now, but I also don't really know what his wolf game looks like and he was in three games at once

[monstrman]

What changed your mind on sooh?

[Darthe]

Poe, same as you. She is who I'd be least comfy with on the list, by a good bit.

[Darthe]

Laya is on his wolf game still.

[Sooh]

Will do a brief catching up before bedtime. I just got home. 

[Sooh]

[V]sooh [/v]

Yeah I can't really do anything with this right now. I'll be happy to discuss my play with you if you'd like tomorrow. 

 

Tomorrow will have to be when I really dig in this phase. 

[Nynaeve]

Savvy Vote Count

 

Believer (1): Darthe

Darthe (1): Believer

Nego (1): Tiinker

Besie (1): manbat

 

Waiting for the opportune moment (7): The rest of you lot.

 

 

With 11 players alive, it take 6 to lynch.

[Believer]

[unvote]

 

[v]manbat[/v]

[Tiinker]

Nego has a style where he floats under the radar

 

Usually as a villager Ive seen more from him by now, but I also don't really know what his wolf game looks like and he was in three games at once

 

Is that literally all you have to say about the major buddying and agreeing with Besie who it seems like you've disagreed with all game? 

[Tiinker]

 

 

So then why wouldnt you vote besie who has some traction tink?

Competing trains and I think Nego seems to have flown under the radar the whole game despite making really scummy posts.

I am very against a nego lynch, he really does this sort of "I'm above this, how did you not see z was town" thing as town but not as wolf imo

 

 

That seems like a very weak reason to dismiss his lynch. Him giving himself false credit to gain town favour is not a town thing to do. 

[Nynaeve]

Savvy Vote Count

 

Believer (1): Darthe

Nego (1): Tiinker

Besie (1): manbat

monstr (1): Believer

 

Waiting for the opportune moment (7): The rest of you lot.

 

 

With 11 players alive, it take 6 to lynch.

 

 

Deadline: 

[Tiinker]

Darthe you seem to be very rigid this game.

[Wildfire Sedai]

Okay so this is my reads list.  I am doing it off the top of my head so that's why there are so many nulls.  I am just trying to get it done before the night is fully over so I will have time to ISO at least 1 of my nulls.  

 

1. Zander - Lt. Gillette - Lynched D1

2. Darthe- null - slightly scummy - first off I wanna start by saying that since I've subbed in as scum with him, I ALWAYS (if you can count 2 games as always) see him as wolfy rotb. That being said, darthe hounded zander all d1.  he never let up on him.  which I guess could be a townie in a tunnel.  However, zander was showing some townieness before the lynch happened....I think a good RL day before.  Darthe knows zander very well.  If darthe is a townie I do not understand how he could not see zanders townieness.  I mean if I could, I believe darthe definitely could.

 

3. Dice - null -  townie - I like the fact that he wasn't going to vote zander and that he is asking the same questions I am asking about roles in a basic game.

 

4. Monstr - null - scummy - I don't know where to start.  However, I believe I have pointed out some of his posts in catch up that I thought were scummy if not, I am sorry.  Anyway, the most damning of evidence is his EoD voting.  I don't see how he could have voted within the same MINUTE without having it set up with open tabs ahead of time, taking into account how slow DM is on reloading.  

 

5. Hellian Wildfire - TOWN QUEENIE

6. Kat/Pral - null - slightly townie - I like pral's posts so far.  Kat has just started to post so will let her do her thing.  I commented on the posts of pral's that I like so will leave it at that.

 

7. Besie - null - I am going to keep besie as null for now.  I know you all will hate it but I am just not sure...I had her as scum in my catch up but more current posts had me thinking townie.  I need to do a full ISO on her to get the two to mesh.  Depends when I get done with this if it gets done tonight or tomorrow.

 

8. Nego - null - another I am going on null for.  Needs a full ISO.  Not enough posts for me to get a good read on.

 

9. Sooh - null - slightly scummy - I didn't like her posts at the beginning of the game.  I believe they were calling for zander's lynch but I am not sure so DO NOT quote me on it. 

 

10. Believer - null - Is he playing this game???  I have only seen a couple of posts from him.  Need to ISO.

 

11. Tiinklove = null - slight townie - by process of elimination (POE) there's gotta be some townies somewhere....I seem to have more wolfies than I do townies and nullls....but nulls will be taken care of tonight (hopefully at least one) and tomorrow.

 

12. Calder- Town Doc - Killed N1

13. Nolder - scummy - I think his tracker claim is fake and that he would only make a claim like that if he was scum trying to get townie points.

 

DISCLAIMER:  this is my FIRST reads list. It WILL CHANGE.  It may have already changed.  It will change according to my emotions and whims.  It just does.   

 

I mean...I am a terrible townie and I have rand townie in all my games except where I've subbed in and Darthe's BTW which doesn't count cause EVERYONE but 3 SK, 2 Masons, 1 Jester were mafia in a 15p game.  I tend to use run on sentences and make weird mafia teams which no one can think of why they are, except me.   and to be honest I forget why they are too usually even as I am writing the explanation.   However, they make perfect sense at the time.  Also people tend to like to put me under the burner all the time.  Usually because they find me confusing. I do not understand this.  I make perfect sense. 

 

The above is JFYI for the new people.  So maybe I don't have to go through what I have had to go through every game, please.  

[Tiinker]

You think Nolder's claim is fake? If you're CCing you may as well just do it or there is no point in saying that.

 

Also, is WiFi scum? lol her town game is usually a lot more sporadic and the logic is difficult for me to follow, however, this list reasoning seems more "crafted" in comparison.

[dicetosser1]

[unvote]

 

[v]manbat[/v]

 

why?

[Tiinker]

Can I get some constructed thoughts on Believer plz if someone can oblige. It hasn't been overly obvious to me why he's being voted 

[Wildfire Sedai]

You think Nolder's claim is fake? If you're CCing you may as well just do it or there is no point in saying that.

 

Also, is WiFi scum? lol her town game is usually a lot more sporadic and the logic is difficult for me to follow, however, this list reasoning seems more "crafted" in comparison.

 

Yes I think Nolder's claim is fake.  And no I am not CC'ng it.  I am VT. However, I believe I know who the real cop is and am respecting that persons wishes to remain anonymous.  Cause if they wanted to CC nolder they would have done it already.  Obviously, with the DOC dead they don't want to paint a target on their back.  Of course if I could figure it out (IF my assumptions are correct and they very well may NOT be) then the scum could too. 

 

No I am NOT scum.

 

Did it ever occur to people that I am trying to develop a game where I have more focused thoughts and people can UNDERSTAND me better.  It took me TWO hours to do that reads list...so yeah it was "crafted". 

[monstrman]

lol I have no idea

 

there is no way I did that ahead of time

 

there is no way any one ever prepares for that

 

lol

[monstrman]

Guess what DM's refresh time is for me

 

.5 seconds

 

lol

 

like I literally don't even know what to say about this