[Basic]Spirited Away Mafia - Game over mafia wins

[Sili Quirrels]

Just saw the flip. Don't know how it happened, don't really care.

 

I'll read up when I'm home. In the meantine, if you're jumping down anybody's throat for being wrong, just stop. Seriously.

 

Being wrong is not a crime. What matters is why. Based on this post I'm guessing at least Cory was involved - don't chastise him for being wrong. Figure out why the hell he aas wrong, and if you think his approach (not the conclusion ) makes him scum...by all means, state your case. Otherwise dont post about it. Same for anybody else.

what posts give you the impression i'm chastizing cory for merely being wrong?

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Zander and Laine were NOT A CFD, they were a DISCUSSED LYNCH TARGET MOST OF THE PHASE

 

ah, sorry, but i was under the impression darthe was going to be the lynch until you flipped on Z.

 

it's no matter. simple question, would zlanna have been lynched without you?

 

BFG had the most votes when the lynch flipped to Zander. Darthe was no longer a serious lynch target as of 5-6 hours ago when he started posting today.

 

i don't know either of their alignments, so the specific person doesn't matter. i assume that without you zlanna wouldn't have been lynched then.

[Regy Rusty]

The only other person besides BFG and Zalanna there was any chance of me voting for at the end of this phase was Wildfire, and there was very little chance I'd have done so even if Cory had ceased to exist.

 

BFG convinced me to unvote her, not Cory

 

This was not a Cory led scheme this was a reached conclusion by multiple people discussing, and it was wrong. So let's analyze who else joined in, and let's figure out the mafia.

[Darthe]

Zalanna would've been lynched without cory because I'd have done it

 

I'm conf town

 

I was just as wrong

I disagree and this is not a defense based in any valid rationale

[Cory Caboose]

Regy thank you for being in this game and just being you as a human person and player

 

I appreciate you immensely

[Regy Rusty]

 

Zalanna would've been lynched without cory because I'd have done it

 

I'm conf town

 

I was just as wrong

I disagree and this is not a defense based in any valid rationale

 

It's a defense against what Sili was literally just saying

[Sili Quirrels]

i'm going to go back to rereading now.

[Clovdyx]

 

Just saw the flip. Don't know how it happened, don't really care.

I'll read up when I'm home. In the meantine, if you're jumping down anybody's throat for being wrong, just stop. Seriously.

Being wrong is not a crime. What matters is why. Based on this post I'm guessing at least Cory was involved - don't chastise him for being wrong. Figure out why the hell he aas wrong, and if you think his approach (not the conclusion ) makes him scum...by all means, state your case. Otherwise dont post about it. Same for anybody else.

 

what posts give you the impression i'm chastizing cory for merely being wrong?

His.

[Sili Quirrels]

continuing this won't get us anywhere. i've said my 2 cents.

[BFG]

Stopping for dinner

[Sili Quirrels]

 

 

Just saw the flip. Don't know how it happened, don't really care.

I'll read up when I'm home. In the meantine, if you're jumping down anybody's throat for being wrong, just stop. Seriously.

Being wrong is not a crime. What matters is why. Based on this post I'm guessing at least Cory was involved - don't chastise him for being wrong. Figure out why the hell he aas wrong, and if you think his approach (not the conclusion ) makes him scum...by all means, state your case. Otherwise dont post about it. Same for anybody else.

what posts give you the impression i'm chastizing cory for merely being wrong?

His.

 

cory is ate.

 

i'm not trying to criticize him for being wrong. that shit happens. it doesn't seem to me at the moment that he had a very good reason for being wrong, especially when i saw him say he thought zlanna was probably town earlier.

[Darthe]

The only other person besides BFG and Zalanna there was any chance of me voting for at the end of this phase was Wildfire, and there was very little chance I'd have done so even if Cory had ceased to exist.

 

BFG convinced me to unvote her, not Cory

 

This was not a Cory led scheme this was a reached conclusion by multiple people discussing, and it was wrong. So let's analyze who else joined in, and let's figure out the mafia.

We're doing that. One at a time, starting with cory because he was the loudest and really a lot of reasons. Sus earlier this game, rep for being right d1 and saying often I catch wolves or I am one, saltiness that goes in the face of his etjos and town play, etc.

 

This isn't some pitchfork welding mob, much has he would like to characterize it as one, and I'd appreciate you not interfering with it if I want to dog somewhere I think deserves digging.

[Sili Quirrels]

while i think his reason was weak, i do think the way he phrased it was persuasive, so i don't blame people for jumping on zlanna at the end especially if they weren't sure about whomever they were voting at the time.

[Cory Caboose]

i don't think i care about winning anymore, so it looks like that's been beaten out of me

 

which means i'm right on the edge of just peacing out of the game and taking what is probably going to be an L i almost never get to that line but it's right there

 

just excellent work darthe/sili

 

excellent work

[Wildfire Sedai]

 

 

It means......I thought masons were a good thing...cause when reg and sirren claimed you all said "confirmed town" [my words] but the meaning was there imo....so I assumed that masons were considered town...from the wiki [Masons are a group of players who can speak to each other privately and know that everyone in their group is not a member of the Mafia. ] so I assumed they were town.  

 

So you knew they were masons before your reads list here?:

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/98359-basicspirited-away-mafia-day-one/?p=3678356

 

 

Wifi when you show again, make sure to answer this

 

 

Yes, If you refer to last quote in this series you will see where I answered it.

 

 

 

Wifi went silent after Cory called her out

 

This ain't happening today but IT WILL BE CONTINUED TOMORROW

Sometime wifi just has to go because RL it's hard to base a vote on that... I have to be honest about that. honestly she's really scummy to me right now but I hate lynching someone that came in so late in D1

 

 

I know and I am nowhere near willing to CFD her in 5 minutes

 

But next phase there will be a reckoning

 

I'm with you... she is really derf sometimes though... I've played with her as mafia and town... lol 

 

 

bold #1: I went silent cause I was eating supper and trying to keep up...you guys are blowing up the thread.... I am not a fast reader...I tend to read everything in the quotes and the stuff under them so I can get a better understanding of what is being said....ttbh I do sometimes skim through the mile long quotes to get through to the meat of it...wtf 11 new replies...

 

bold #2: yeah I am a little slow sometimes....it just takes a while for me to get into the swing of things....I am not used to dissecting posts like you people do here....15 more posts....ok now you know why I haven't been posting a lot of "meat" in my replies...I gotta go catch up...

 

I didn't put it in my reads list cause I forgot....I know I shouldn't be playing the newbie card as this is my third game but in all fairness:

 

I've had one full game: my first where I was town vig and I won....I had a mentor.....lainey

I've had one half game: my second where I was mafia w/ a twist.....I had a brood I was attached to that had a sk and my pack had 1 cpr/doc....I was betrayed died n2

This is my third game: I came in page 70 trying to do a reread and keep current....The first two games were advanced btw.  

 

I am vt here....very hard to prove, I know...so thats where I am...and still got to read 7 more pages to get caught up..

 

I promise once I am caught up and can do some iso's then you will see me in action...

[Darthe]

while i think his reason was weak, i do think the way he phrased it was persuasive, so i don't blame people for jumping on zlanna at the end especially if they weren't sure about whomever they were voting at the time.

Again qft, his rhetoric has been a lot stronger than his reasoning all game and that is,imo, not a sign of town cory

[Sili Quirrels]

i don't think i care about winning anymore, so it looks like that's been beaten out of me

 

which means i'm right on the edge of just peacing out of the game and taking what is probably going to be an L i almost never get to that line but it's right there

 

just excellent work darthe/sili

 

excellent work

i think i'm being very respectful in expressing my suspicion of you.

[Cory Caboose]

yeah it's more darthe, though you've been a little GNAT i guess that's technically your right

[Regy Rusty]

 

The only other person besides BFG and Zalanna there was any chance of me voting for at the end of this phase was Wildfire, and there was very little chance I'd have done so even if Cory had ceased to exist.

 

BFG convinced me to unvote her, not Cory

 

This was not a Cory led scheme this was a reached conclusion by multiple people discussing, and it was wrong. So let's analyze who else joined in, and let's figure out the mafia.

We're doing that. One at a time, starting with cory because he was the loudest and really a lot of reasons. Sus earlier this game, rep for being right d1 and saying often I catch wolves or I am one, saltiness that goes in the face of his etjos and town play, etc.

 

This isn't some pitchfork welding mob, much has he would like to characterize it as one, and I'd appreciate you not interfering with it if I want to dog somewhere I think deserves digging.

 

I'll interfere however I want. You're constructing a narrative that doesn't reflect the facts of what happened and it's my job to point that out.

[Darthe]

i don't think i care about winning anymore, so it looks like that's been beaten out of me

 

which means i'm right on the edge of just peacing out of the game and taking what is probably going to be an L i almost never get to that line but it's right there

 

just excellent work darthe/sili

 

excellent work

Cool so you're in the way and think that AtE, which you've put us ask through before, is recourse to get out of having to answer hard questions.

 

I've no reason to not Drive a lynch on you atm. And your play, if town, is exceptionally poor.

[Regy Rusty]

If I wasn't confirmed town, Darthe, would you still be going at Cory in this exact way?

[Darthe]

 

 

The only other person besides BFG and Zalanna there was any chance of me voting for at the end of this phase was Wildfire, and there was very little chance I'd have done so even if Cory had ceased to exist.

 

BFG convinced me to unvote her, not Cory

 

This was not a Cory led scheme this was a reached conclusion by multiple people discussing, and it was wrong. So let's analyze who else joined in, and let's figure out the mafia.

We're doing that. One at a time, starting with cory because he was the loudest and really a lot of reasons. Sus earlier this game, rep for being right d1 and saying often I catch wolves or I am one, saltiness that goes in the face of his etjos and town play, etc.

 

This isn't some pitchfork welding mob, much has he would like to characterize it as one, and I'd appreciate you not interfering with it if I want to dog somewhere I think deserves digging.

I'll interfere however I want. You're constructing a narrative that doesn't reflect the facts of what happened and it's my job to point that out.

I think it's precisely what happened, you're basically bent over for him any time he says a word

[Cory Caboose]

I tried my best Darthe

I tried a million times harder than you did

What did you do that was constructive at all today?

[Darthe]

If I wasn't confirmed town, Darthe, would you still be going at Cory in this exact way?

And you, probably.

[Darthe]

I tried my best Darthe

I tried a million times harder than you did

What did you do that was constructive at all today?

What did you do that was constructive today? Can you answer that objectively?