[Advanced] Gods and Demons Mafia - All your souls belong to Shad (Triads win)

[Zander?]

Alanna I need a solid reads list from you.  Can you do that for me tomorrow?

[Zander?]

Zander  995
manbat  488
Lenlo  355
BFG  343
Eldrick4221  251
Hallia  248
alannalynn  228
csarmi  224
Sooh  218
Shad_  212
Calder  90
dicetosser1  84
Celeste  74
Thane Vakarian  13
 

[Zander?]

im also gonna hit my personal goal of 1000 posts this game!!!!

 

lolololololololol

[Shad_]

@Laine, there is a level of effort you occasionally achieve as town which I have never seen you come close to replicating as scum.  If I'm wrong about seeing that here, lolme, but I really don't think you are a wolf and if the majority of other players don't either I'm not going to spend an hour rereading you.  Is that low effort for me?  That's a perception I need to kill, because I can't handle more Warcrafts.  Even if I am wrong about you there are wolves that should be catchable, and we will catch one, tomorrow, and reevaluating you has a pretty low % chance of facilitating that.

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

 

*snip*

 

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell. 

 

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

 

 

 

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

 

I guess what I'm curious about is afaict you used meta for him last game, yet you're ignoring it this game

 

I have never ever claimed to have been good at reading Dice. I haven't even really focused on him this game yet. I can't even remember doing this last game. 

 

*refreshed for new posts*

 

oh yes, I did say his level of engagement was good, and I maintain that it is, but I haven't even really noticed him this game, which is what puzzles me a bit. D0 I remember him. D1 not at all. I'm trying to throw out D0 reads just in case.

 

Perhaps that's why our reads differ so much too. You count D0 and I don't.

 

 

excuse me? how about two mindmelds? and u COMMENTING on said mindmelds???

 

wanna try that again?

 

I REALLY dont perked up on reading that. Not in a good way.

 

 

@ BFG

 

Im starting the shrug jar.  It works the same as the swearing jar.  Every time you /shrug you have to put a quarter in.

 

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort.....

 

The Beer For Zander Foundation!!!!

 

 

lolololololololol

@Zander

 

I'm starting the lololol jar. It works the same as the shrug jar. Every time you lololol you have to put a quarter in. 

 

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort....

 

The Therapy for Mafia Players Foundation!!!!

 

 

THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

 

on page 190

 

 

 

 

Zander  who won the game? the Rumble made my daughter bawl. 

She was NOT a happy fan

[Eldrick4221]

Cop- Monstr

Vig- Len

Lynch- Calder

 

Hillarious part about this list is len is claimed vig. Is he shooting himself?

[Zander?]

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I want to ISO half the thread, and read D1 slowly.

 

*snip*

 

Sooh's the one I may be clearing too easily in that group, but I stand by she's more engaged/involved with the game than I've seen her manage as mafia, so unless someone can point me to a similarly engaged game as mafia I'm going to keep her as town. Slightly disappointing that we don't seem to be on the same page as much as the last couple of games

I'm with you on the ISO idea. I feel like I have a good idea about Hallia, Shad and you now, but yes, it is strange that we're not in agreement. I do listen to your cases as much as I can, but I don't know why you have cleared Csarmi and Celeste. I can see your point on Dice, while I think it's very meta reliant there's really no other way to read him as far as I can tell. 

 

I think I tend to rely less on meta and more on in thread stuff, so that may explain our differences.

 

 

 

I use both, I rely on meta more for low volume posters, and am happiest if I can confidently clear/condemn them. What I'm curious with you about Dice is that last game you were clearing him on early involvement before Cory or I were ready to, and your read was one of the things that made me just go, 'ok let's go with it and keep an eye on him', and honestly it's probably this more than anyone else making me doubt my read the most this time

 

I guess what I'm curious about is afaict you used meta for him last game, yet you're ignoring it this game

 

I have never ever claimed to have been good at reading Dice. I haven't even really focused on him this game yet. I can't even remember doing this last game. 

 

*refreshed for new posts*

 

oh yes, I did say his level of engagement was good, and I maintain that it is, but I haven't even really noticed him this game, which is what puzzles me a bit. D0 I remember him. D1 not at all. I'm trying to throw out D0 reads just in case.

 

Perhaps that's why our reads differ so much too. You count D0 and I don't.

 

 

excuse me? how about two mindmelds? and u COMMENTING on said mindmelds???

 

wanna try that again?

 

I REALLY dont perked up on reading that. Not in a good way.

 

 

@ BFG

 

Im starting the shrug jar.  It works the same as the swearing jar.  Every time you /shrug you have to put a quarter in.

 

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort.....

 

The Beer For Zander Foundation!!!!

 

 

lolololololololol

@Zander

 

I'm starting the lololol jar. It works the same as the shrug jar. Every time you lololol you have to put a quarter in. 

 

The money raised goes to my favorite humanitarian effort....

 

The Therapy for Mafia Players Foundation!!!!

 

 

THIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

 

on page 190

 

 

 

 

Zander  who won the game? the Rumble made my daughter bawl. 

She was NOT a happy fan

 

 

Broncos

Panthers

[alannalynn]

Alanna I need a solid reads list from you.  Can you do that for me tomorrow?

Most recent reads list

 

^ this was posted last night(?), I'll give you a more thought out list when I'm up tomorrow though

[Zander?]

 

Cop- Monstr

Vig- Len

Lynch- Calder

 

Hillarious part about this list is len is claimed vig. Is he shooting himself?

 

 

that was by design.  he claim to have no bullet is something i cant get past especially after Nols Town flip.

[Zander?]

 

Alanna I need a solid reads list from you.  Can you do that for me tomorrow?

Most recent reads list

 

^ this was posted last night(?), I'll give you a more thought out list when I'm up tomorrow though

 

 

Thank you, thats what I want reasoning on everyone please.

[Zander?]

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

[alannalynn]

@Laine, there is a level of effort you occasionally achieve as town which I have never seen you come close to replicating as scum.  If I'm wrong about seeing that here, lolme, but I really don't think you are a wolf and if the majority of other players don't either I'm not going to spend an hour rereading you.  Is that low effort for me?  That's a perception I need to kill, because I can't handle more Warcrafts.  Even if I am wrong about you there are wolves that should be catchable, and we will catch one, tomorrow, and reevaluating you has a pretty low % chance of facilitating that.

This is because I completely hate being wolf. I can't get into it the same way and I don't have the same WIM to win the game. Right now I'm barely managing to keep up with this game and I wish I could put more effort in like I did with WoW; I guess I feel like I've been very distracted this game but apparently it's not coming off that way?

[Shad_]

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

 

Less than 2000.

 

You're at least alive until the end of night.

[alannalynn]

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

Zander I'm gonna have to ask you to chill a bit.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Cop- Monstr

Vig- Len

Lynch- Calder

 

Hillarious part about this list is len is claimed vig. Is he shooting himself?

 

 

that was by design.  he claim to have no bullet is something i cant get past especially after Nols Town flip.

 

wow. good point.

 

Yeah vig len

[Sooh]

 

 

Final Vote Count!

 

Celeste - 2 - Hallia, dicetosser1

Turin Turambar - 6 - manbat, Csarmi, Shad, Lenlo, Zander, Celeste

Nolder - 4 - Sooh, Turin Turambar,  Calder, Alannalynn

 

 

If you have a discrepancy with this, PM me with your vote immediately.

 

 

 

 

Vote count!

 

• Nolder - 5 - Laine, Hallia, Zander, Lenlo, dice
• Hallia - 1 - Nolder
• Pral - 1 - manbat

 

With 15 alive, it's 8 to lynch!  Day will end at 8:30 on 1/25, unless majority is reached.

 

 

 

 

 

Interesting to Note

 

Sooh is not following her vote on Nol this time around.  She was one of if not the person calling for the CFD on Nol right before DL.

 

Calder not following on this either....nor has he really been around much at all lately either..

 

Alanna has been consistent with her vote on Nol.  Only thing Id look into possibly is a Nol Town flip.

 

I didn't vote Nol because he was racking up votes pretty quickly and I didn't want an early maj. He was still very much at the bottom of my list, but I really thought I'd get the chance to place my vote today.

 

 

Cop- Monstr

Vig- Len

Lynch- Calder

 

This is pretty much exactly my list. I'd want to be sure about Monstr because he has a pretty loud voice this game. Vigging Lenlo, well, at least he doesn't have his shot anymore, so he's basically VT if his claim was true. Calder has brought very little to the game, so yes, I agree with that lynch.

[Zander?]

 

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

 

Less than 2000.

 

You're at least alive until the end of night.

 

 

 

So if i get to 2000 before this night phase is over I should have the record then.

[Eldrick4221]

 

@Laine, there is a level of effort you occasionally achieve as town which I have never seen you come close to replicating as scum.  If I'm wrong about seeing that here, lolme, but I really don't think you are a wolf and if the majority of other players don't either I'm not going to spend an hour rereading you.  Is that low effort for me?  That's a perception I need to kill, because I can't handle more Warcrafts.  Even if I am wrong about you there are wolves that should be catchable, and we will catch one, tomorrow, and reevaluating you has a pretty low % chance of facilitating that.

This is because I completely hate being wolf. I can't get into it the same way and I don't have the same WIM to win the game. Right now I'm barely managing to keep up with this game and I wish I could put more effort in like I did with WoW; I guess I feel like I've been very distracted this game but apparently it's not coming off that way?

 

You're coming off as town to me fwiw

[Zander?]

 

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

Zander I'm gonna have to ask you to chill a bit.

 

 

 

You know I WANT to do this for you but because Im Zander its actually quite impossible!!!!

 

 

lolololololololol

 

Sorry not sorry.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

Final Vote Count!

 

Celeste - 2 - Hallia, dicetosser1

Turin Turambar - 6 - manbat, Csarmi, Shad, Lenlo, Zander, Celeste

Nolder - 4 - Sooh, Turin Turambar,  Calder, Alannalynn

 

 

If you have a discrepancy with this, PM me with your vote immediately.

 

 

 

 

Vote count!

 

• Nolder - 5 - Laine, Hallia, Zander, Lenlo, dice
• Hallia - 1 - Nolder
• Pral - 1 - manbat

 

With 15 alive, it's 8 to lynch!  Day will end at 8:30 on 1/25, unless majority is reached.

 

 

 

 

 

Interesting to Note

 

Sooh is not following her vote on Nol this time around.  She was one of if not the person calling for the CFD on Nol right before DL.

 

Calder not following on this either....nor has he really been around much at all lately either..

 

Alanna has been consistent with her vote on Nol.  Only thing Id look into possibly is a Nol Town flip.

 

I didn't vote Nol because he was racking up votes pretty quickly and I didn't want an early maj. He was still very much at the bottom of my list, but I really thought I'd get the chance to place my vote today.

 

 

Cop- Monstr

Vig- Len

Lynch- Calder

 

This is pretty much exactly my list. I'd want to be sure about Monstr because he has a pretty loud voice this game. Vigging Lenlo, well, at least he doesn't have his shot anymore, so he's basically VT if his claim was true. Calder has brought very little to the game, so yes, I agree with that lynch.

 

 

Zander brought up a really good point. What about Nol flipping VT makes you think Lenlo was telling the truth?

 

Now answer this. Who lies about being vig?

[Shad_]

 

@Laine, there is a level of effort you occasionally achieve as town which I have never seen you come close to replicating as scum.  If I'm wrong about seeing that here, lolme, but I really don't think you are a wolf and if the majority of other players don't either I'm not going to spend an hour rereading you.  Is that low effort for me?  That's a perception I need to kill, because I can't handle more Warcrafts.  Even if I am wrong about you there are wolves that should be catchable, and we will catch one, tomorrow, and reevaluating you has a pretty low % chance of facilitating that.

This is because I completely hate being wolf. I can't get into it the same way and I don't have the same WIM to win the game. Right now I'm barely managing to keep up with this game and I wish I could put more effort in like I did with WoW; I guess I feel like I've been very distracted this game but apparently it's not coming off that way?

 

 

It hasn't come off that way to me.

 

I mean, I could be wrong I guess.  >_>

 

I really would rather just be right and move on to more likely candidates.  <_<

 

If we're both alive later in the game I'm necessarily going to look at you harder, but I don't think we're so lost yet that I should just scrap everything right now.

[Shad_]

 

 

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

 

Less than 2000.

 

You're at least alive until the end of night.

 

 

 

So if i get to 2000 before this night phase is over I should have the record then.

 

 

See what I just did here is a legit reason to lynch me.

[alannalynn]

OK I'm out for the night. Goodnight y'all, we'll talk later <3

[Zander?]

 

 

 

Zander  1001

 

Whats the record i wonder???!!!!

 

Less than 2000.

 

You're at least alive until the end of night.

 

 

 

So if i get to 2000 before this night phase is over I should have the record then.

 

 

See what I just did here is a legit reason to lynch me.

 

 

Not im my eyes but im sure everyone else will feel that way!!!

 

lololololololol