[BASIC/STANDARD] Warcraft: War of the Ancients Mafia - GAME OVER, MAFIA WINS

[Nolder]

Have we even had competing trains this game? :/

[Nolder]

Nolder, WTL? Reads?

I think the final scum are Shad and Celeste.

[Kaylee]

Have we even had competing trains this game? :/

Yes D1 it was me Pral and I don't remember who else tied or close at one point.

 

Right now Pral is at 4 votes L-2, and I have two votes.

[Kaylee]

I think Celeste wad the third.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I want to point out the last couple times I listened to people's "better understanding of meta" the past several games on this site have all blown up in my face.

 

Like, every single time.

 

Dice is totally not mafia, said Thane.

 

Csarmi is my top villager. Etc.

 

You know because they know your meta and you know theirs, that makes it more likely they can fool you, right?
 

[Kaylee]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

Turin (1): Laine

Wish (2): Zander, Turin

Csarmi (1): Cass

Pral (2): Wish, Lenlo

Kaylee (2): Pizza, Pral

Not voting (5): Shad, Csarmi, Celeste, Kaylee, Nolder

----------

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynchDAY ONE WILL END AT 10:00 PM MST (MIDNIGHT EASTERN) ON WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 6.http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20160106T22&p0=197&msg=End+of+Day+One&font=cursive&csz=1

Correction it waS on Wish

[Kaylee]

I want to point out the last couple times I listened to people's "better understanding of meta" the past several games on this site have all blown up in my face.

 

Like, every single time.

 

Dice is totally not mafia, said Thane.

 

Csarmi is my top villager. Etc.

 

You know because they know your meta and you know theirs, that makes it more likely they can fool you, right?

 

Right.

[Shad_]

I want to point out the last couple times I listened to people's "better understanding of meta" the past several games on this site have all blown up in my face.

 

Like, every single time.

 

Dice is totally not mafia, said Thane.

 

Csarmi is my top villager. Etc.

 

You know because they know your meta and you know theirs, that makes it more likely they can fool you, right?

 

 

It's why I let Nolder drop down into my POE.  Doesn't help that in scum QT last game I basically gave him a list of things he could do to fool me.  I'm trying to be a lot more vigilant in this game.

[Shad_]

 

Nolder, WTL? Reads?

I think the final scum are Shad and Celeste.

 

 

You backed off your reasons for sussing me though.  You have to show me that you mean this.

 

[Lenlo]

The post itself doesn't make sense... Lol To me that's very town Celeste. XDDDD To be entirely blunt, she doesn't make much sense as town. Terrible at defending herself. Please read her and my recent explanations of her read/comparison of Pralaya and Nolder to two players we know.

I read it. I disagree with it. I dont see anything town in there, just a horribad defense.

 

She's a very scummy townie. :/ I tried to lynch her our first few games together as town. It was only after I hydra'd with her that I did learn how to read her.

Well to bad for her then. If your a scummy townie your gonna get lynched. Example: Half my games here before I took a break.

I lynch the scummiest person. I do not believe in TWTBAW.

[Cass]

Aaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!

 

I slept through not one but three alarms to get up early so I could have posting time. Running late for tax appointment, will skim on the way and be on mobile til late this afternoon >.<

[Celeste]

[unvote]

 

[v]Pralaya[/v] I will respond to some posts now but not sure when I will be back.

[Shad_]

That L-1?

[Celeste]

 

The post itself doesn't make sense... Lol To me that's very town Celeste. XDDDD To be entirely blunt, she doesn't make much sense as town. Terrible at defending herself. Please read her and my recent explanations of her read/comparison of Pralaya and Nolder to two players we know.

 

I read it. I disagree with it. I dont see anything town in there, just a horribad defense.

 

She's a very scummy townie. :/ I tried to lynch her our first few games together as town. It was only after I hydra'd with her that I did learn how to read her.

 

Well to bad for her then. If your a scummy townie your gonna get lynched. Example: Half my games here before I took a break.

I lynch the scummiest person. I do not believe in TWTBAW.

I know I'm scummy but just because I'm scummy doesn't mean I should be lynched if the reasons are play style related instead of actual incriminating content scummy.

[Celeste]

 

 

Basically, it would have to be inside my blues, and you'd have to find that person and case them, and have it be correct.

 

I don't see that happening, do you?

 

It's entirely possible and basically I contradict your own godfather theory. I was in almost everybody's lynch pile. I also was pushed a lot by Zander. How does it make sense that I would be mafia?

 

It would be more convincing had you gained votes, rather than just put forth as somewhat scummy.

the thing is there was actual content that incriminated Csarmi. While I am just scummy regardless of what I post to people. Does that not contradict your theory.

[Shad_]

I'm kind of burnt out on this game.  Will to reread people and ISO other games depleting.

 

I might take a breather for a day or two and just stick to keeping up/commenting on new posts.  I'm ok with lynching Pral.  Nolder is making me nervous.  Hesitant about lynching Celeste.  Kaylee and deepwolfing in Wish/Laine/Cass is food for another day imo.

[Sooh]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Kaylee (1): Pral

 

 

Pralaya (5): Kaylee, Laine, Wish, Lenlo, Celeste

 

 

 

Not voting (4): Shad,  Nolder, Cass, Pizza

 

----------

 

Pral is at L-1

 

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

Day 2 deadline is Monday, January 11 @ 9 AM MST (11 AM EST)

http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20160111T09&p0=197&msg=End+of+Day+Two&font=cursive&csz=1

[wish-tree]

Right. Knowing Celeste's meta may mean she's deeply pocketing me, but I won't believe that she's a wolf until I see it.

[Celeste]

Right. Knowing Celeste's meta may mean she's deeply pocketing me, but I won't believe that she's a wolf until I see it.

That is practically what I am thinking for you at this point.

[Lenlo]

 

 

The post itself doesn't make sense... Lol To me that's very town Celeste. XDDDD To be entirely blunt, she doesn't make much sense as town. Terrible at defending herself. Please read her and my recent explanations of her read/comparison of Pralaya and Nolder to two players we know.

I read it. I disagree with it. I dont see anything town in there, just a horribad defense.

 

She's a very scummy townie. :/ I tried to lynch her our first few games together as town. It was only after I hydra'd with her that I did learn how to read her.

Well to bad for her then. If your a scummy townie your gonna get lynched. Example: Half my games here before I took a break.

I lynch the scummiest person. I do not believe in TWTBAW.

I know I'm scummy but just because I'm scummy doesn't mean I should be lynched if the reasons are play style related instead of actual incriminating content scummy.

 

Yeah it kinda does. As I said, I dont believe in TWTBAW. Regardless this discussion gets us nowhere and does nothing. I found the post and you to be scummy this game, your answering by saying your just a scummy villager. Not enough for me. 

[Celeste]

 

 

 

The post itself doesn't make sense... Lol To me that's very town Celeste. XDDDD To be entirely blunt, she doesn't make much sense as town. Terrible at defending herself. Please read her and my recent explanations of her read/comparison of Pralaya and Nolder to two players we know.

 

I read it. I disagree with it. I dont see anything town in there, just a horribad defense.

 

She's a very scummy townie. :/ I tried to lynch her our first few games together as town. It was only after I hydra'd with her that I did learn how to read her.

 

Well to bad for her then. If your a scummy townie your gonna get lynched. Example: Half my games here before I took a break.

I lynch the scummiest person. I do not believe in TWTBAW.

I know I'm scummy but just because I'm scummy doesn't mean I should be lynched if the reasons are play style related instead of actual incriminating content scummy.

Yeah it kinda does. As I said, I dont believe in TWTBAW. Regardless this discussion gets us nowhere and does nothing. I found the post and you to be scummy this game, your answering by saying your just a scummy villager. Not enough for me.

I suck at defending myself but if I'm vigged or lynched I don't want it to be in vain or to not go down without making the explanations that would help with my reads.

[wish-tree]

 

Right. Knowing Celeste's meta may mean she's deeply pocketing me, but I won't believe that she's a wolf until I see it.

That is practically what I am thinking for you at this point.

 

Glad we've mindmelded over that bit

[wish-tree]

 

 

 

The post itself doesn't make sense... Lol To me that's very town Celeste. XDDDD To be entirely blunt, she doesn't make much sense as town. Terrible at defending herself. Please read her and my recent explanations of her read/comparison of Pralaya and Nolder to two players we know.

I read it. I disagree with it. I dont see anything town in there, just a horribad defense.

 

She's a very scummy townie. :/ I tried to lynch her our first few games together as town. It was only after I hydra'd with her that I did learn how to read her.

Well to bad for her then. If your a scummy townie your gonna get lynched. Example: Half my games here before I took a break.

I lynch the scummiest person. I do not believe in TWTBAW.

I know I'm scummy but just because I'm scummy doesn't mean I should be lynched if the reasons are play style related instead of actual incriminating content scummy.

 

Yeah it kinda does. As I said, I dont believe in TWTBAW. Regardless this discussion gets us nowhere and does nothing. I found the post and you to be scummy this game, your answering by saying your just a scummy villager. Not enough for me. 

 

what's TWTBAW

[Lenlo]

To Wolfy To Be A Wolf.

[wish-tree]

To Wolfy To Be A Wolf.

thanks for the clarification