[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

[Sooh]

sooh why are you voting me again?

 

 

also what about heart made you feel better. Or was it just the fact she has posted since then?

I never unvoted. It's not a locked vote by all means, but it's staying until I feel better about voting someone else. 

[Darthe]

You can make a fortune in lies

You can keep a giant alive

You can ride the red until everybody smiles

[seph]

 

sooh why are you voting me again?

 

 

also what about heart made you feel better. Or was it just the fact she has posted since then?

I never unvoted. It's not a locked vote by all means, but it's staying until I feel better about voting someone else. 

 

sooh I want to know what you think about me

[Darthe]

 

sooh why are you voting me again?

 

 

also what about heart made you feel better. Or was it just the fact she has posted since then?

I never unvoted. It's not a locked vote by all means, but it's staying until I feel better about voting someone else. 

 

...So unvote then.  This pings.

[Shad_]

 

 

 

 

Having ISO'd Sooh, before this I like Sooh's posts, she seems more engaged that her last wolf game, and saying what she thinks more. Question in bolded blue below.

 

I didn't like this post (the bolded Green)

 

I'm kinda setting aside Dice/Durin at the moment. I don't think that'll be resolved today anyway, plus they might both be town.

 

Zander is basically always polite. It's rare to see anything else out of him. Also he is the guy who wants everyone to be happy, so I'm not surprised his posts read like that, Talya. He would be careful not to hurt anyone's feelings.  1. I can see him being poilite, it's a little more than that, have you seen him as Wolf? What was his game like then in your opinion?

 

*snip*

 

Re Heart - I think her post coming in and clearly skimming and giving her thoughts is fine. What I didn't like, which may or may not have been a typo since it made little sense, was that she said she'd barely be here next week as well. At this point, even if she is town, how does it benefit town to keep her around? If she doesn't have the chance to make proper reads and ideas she's basically just , excuse the expression, dead weight. If she is scum and we take her out, then great. If she is town and we take her out, then at least she won't make bad decisions at must lynch because she hasn't been able to follow the thread and ask her questions. However, I do see the point that her flip may not tell us much. 

 

That's how I see it anyway. 

 

At this point in the game I'm just waiting for a flip to inform my reads further. I feel a little like I'm banging my head against the wall, and I think a lot of people do. 

 

So you would be quite happy to lynch AH?

 

 

At some point somebody is going to have to explain these references to Mynd and other players I haven't played with before...

 

@ Sooh - thanks for the boy on Zander, I was going to check the other threads to see what he was like. He is s prolific payer here so that's why it might stand out.

@ Sooh again - I don't like the idea of just lunching someone just because you just don't want someone that may oray mot be around. This isn't smells wolfie to me. There was a feel of wanting an easy lynch on someone.

@ Alanna - I'm also a bit suspicious of AJ disappearing, I didn't like how tunnelling he was on Seph, I need to go over Womby's post tonight. Because he is coming across better

I'm not saying that Zander would not do this as a wolf. I think he probably would show the same level of politeness, so if you note something different about it it's probably worth looking into, but I'm not seeing it as of now. 

 

As for Heart I'm not actively pushing her lynch, just saying I'm concerned if she doesn't become more active. 

 

I know you are not at least not directly, but you looked like you would be quiet happy to jump on her train if required. What do you think of Hearts list and vote on Dice?

 

This pinged me too.  I assumed AH made a typo and was saying she would be around more, not less (she later clarified this).  But if Sooh really thought AH had all but quit, wouldn't a replacement be in order?  I would prefer that to a blind lynch.

 

I think I explained this before, but if she didn't sub out and was just slanking as a player then I would consider voting her. Now that she has explained she'll be here more I'm waiting for her to post more to get a better read. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

No, not anymore. From her previous list it looked as though she was pretty much saying she was going to be inactive throughout, and I didn't like that. In the case of inactives I guess the mod would step in. I'm just worried that a slanking villager would  lose the game for us. Now that she says she'll be here more I'm happy to let her show me if she is town or not by her posting. 

 

Her list reads kind of rushed, like she said it would be. It's a lot of commentary on what has been going on and a few thoughts regarding what it might mean. I don't hate her vote on Dice, but I don't think I'll follow her on it today. 

 

 

Ah, you clarified my issue before I ever brought it up.  I hadn't gotten to this post yet when I commented.  Cheers.

[Darthe]

God Sooh I forgot you were playing

[Verbal32]

Salami's internal consistency is strong enough that I'm kind of willingg to let this go but he is easily able to destroy towns from the inside so I'm kind of afraid to not push this through anyhow.

 

Does that resonate with anyone else?

 

No, it is a stupid idea.  Salami is town, and I think you know this (if you're a villager, which I suspect is true).  The only good news is this prob clears you, as you wouldn't be this "forward" with your play if you were a wolf.

 

 

 

 

While I'm catching up - have Verb and Leelou cleared each other yet?

good vibes but not clear I don't think.  

 

Also not clear to practically anyone else.

 

 

This is correct, but I'd put her in solid green at this point.  Only Dice is blue.

 

 

 

 

I’m comfortable voting this route right now:

[v]dice[/v]

I feel like it would be informative and I think there’s a possibility of scum.

 

wat

[Darthe]

Shad why are you clear again?  People got a much better read of you this time and you were a pingy, kind of off kilter townie last game.

[Sili Quirrels]

I have 230 posts and Turin has 27.

 

Anyone sussing Turin that isn't sussing me and yet things we are a wolf is prob 20-30% more wolfy just for doing so.  I'm gonna read back.

objectively, even for villagers, it's hard to make a case on someone as 'peerless' as yourself. turin is like your Achilles's heel.

 

fyi, even though i haven't read half the thread, i would still make a case on you, not turin.

 

i'm not sure what yates is on about.

[Verbal32]

....that was a ~30 page catchup.  Thoughts bouncing in my brain, back in a bit.

[Darthe]

 

Salami's internal consistency is strong enough that I'm kind of willingg to let this go but he is easily able to destroy towns from the inside so I'm kind of afraid to not push this through anyhow.

 

Does that resonate with anyone else?

 

No, it is a stupid idea.  Salami is town, and I think you know this (if you're a villager, which I suspect is true).  The only good news is this prob clears you, as you wouldn't be this "forward" with your play if you were a wolf.

 

 

 

 

While I'm catching up - have Verb and Leelou cleared each other yet?

good vibes but not clear I don't think.

 

Also not clear to practically anyone else.

 

 

This is correct, but I'd put her in solid green at this point.  Only Dice is blue.

 

 

 

 

I’m comfortable voting this route right now:

[v]dice[/v]

I feel like it would be informative and I think there’s a possibility of scum.

 

wat

 

Man I am all over the place right now.

 

Are you a wolf?  You and Thane really haven't impressed me yet and I expect a lot of you two as town.

[Darthe]

 

I have 230 posts and Turin has 27.

 

Anyone sussing Turin that isn't sussing me and yet things we are a wolf is prob 20-30% more wolfy just for doing so.  I'm gonna read back.

objectively, even for villagers, it's hard to make a case on someone as 'peerless' as yourself. turin is like your Achilles's heel.

 

fyi, even though i haven't read half the thread, i would still make a case on you, not turin.

 

i'm not sure what yates is on about.

 

Peerless?  I don't quite get what you mean.

[Sooh]

 

 

sooh why are you voting me again?

 

 

also what about heart made you feel better. Or was it just the fact she has posted since then?

I never unvoted. It's not a locked vote by all means, but it's staying until I feel better about voting someone else. 

 

sooh I want to know what you think about me

 

I think you're looking much better now than at the beginning of the day. You seem more like your natural self, and I like that. I also like that you have more input on other players. I have been considering an unvote for a while really, but I was just looking for someone to move my vote to. At this point I feel a lot like I'm fumbling in the dark and that's not a good feeling. 

 

But oki. Let's do it. 

 

[unvote]

[Yates]

Shad reads like an Alanna alt. Very logical/dispassionate. He's going to be a tough read.

[Yates]

Holy crap! I forgot Lainey was in this game! What's up, chica? I'm on page 54. Hopefully I see some good posting, yes?

[Talya]

 

 

[v] unvote [/v]

 

[v] csarmi [/v]

You have been dying to do that all game...

 

 

 

Talya again with this...seriously?  Its not like ive made my case against him, he hasnt made himself look bad during his post's today or had him a wolf lean on my reads lists.....

 

You keep barking up the wrong tree.  Ive already pointed this out to you that its not a good look on you but still tried to give you the benefit of the doubt.  but that has run its course and others are seeing it as well i believe.

 

Town!Talya doesnt do this imo

 

 

Zander, I don't care that you think it's not a good look, you had posted on him OTT and then voted, did you really expect me not to say something. This is second time you have said something like that, and it sounds like you are threatening me...not sure what with, casing me or what! It just adds to what I think. I may have got it wrong..it's day one, but it's how I'm feeling at he moment.

 

 

*snip*

No, not anymore. From her previous list it looked as though she was pretty much saying she was going to be inactive throughout, and I didn't like that. In the case of inactives I guess the mod would step in. I'm just worried that a slanking villager would  lose the game for us. Now that she says she'll be here more I'm happy to let her show me if she is town or not by her posting. 

 

Her list reads kind of rushed, like she said it would be. It's a lot of commentary on what has been going on and a few thoughts regarding what it might mean. I don't hate her vote on Dice, but I don't think I'll follow her on it today. 

 

 

Took a lot out. In your original post about AH you didn't say anything about being replaced, it came across you thought that if she was inactive we should lynch her. She was inactive to begin with last time and we(town) won the game.

 

So enjoyable is the meta that allows me to tell people exactly when they're being dumb and what they do sucks.  

 

Please tell me what I do wrong, I do read your posts and try to make sense of them and I'm trying to update my game all the time. I would like to know where I'm going wrong.

 

I will get round to doing a list of reads soon, still in the middle of ISO of AJ and Womby...and only just got back

[Leelou]

 

So enjoyable is the meta that allows me to tell people exactly when they're being dumb and what they do sucks.  

 

Please tell me what I do wrong, I do read your posts and try to make sense of them and I'm trying to update my game all the time. I would like to know where I'm going wrong.

 

He's being a jerk, ignore him. 

[Darthe]

^That, I said the jerk thing tongue in cheek.  Everyone does there own stuff and I am not the arbiter of "good" play.  That's Cory, he is in office on Tuesdays and Thursdays between 11 and 4.  

[Yates]

ebwop

 

need to work on my grammar skills....lol

It's okay. You speak Canadian. We know English is your second language...

[Verbal32]

 

 

Salami's internal consistency is strong enough that I'm kind of willingg to let this go but he is easily able to destroy towns from the inside so I'm kind of afraid to not push this through anyhow.

 

Does that resonate with anyone else?

 

No, it is a stupid idea.  Salami is town, and I think you know this (if you're a villager, which I suspect is true).  The only good news is this prob clears you, as you wouldn't be this "forward" with your play if you were a wolf.

 

 

 

 

While I'm catching up - have Verb and Leelou cleared each other yet?

good vibes but not clear I don't think.

 

Also not clear to practically anyone else.

 

 

This is correct, but I'd put her in solid green at this point.  Only Dice is blue.

 

 

 

 

I’m comfortable voting this route right now:

[v]dice[/v]

I feel like it would be informative and I think there’s a possibility of scum.

 

wat

 

Man I am all over the place right now.

 

Are you a wolf?  You and Thane really haven't impressed me yet and I expect a lot of you two as town.

 

 

Yes you are.  No I'm not.  Now you know why I've been mostly signing up for small games, and hydra if it is a larger one.  My shoulders slumped when I saw the # of pages I needed to read when I got into work today.

[Hallia]

Yeah, eh?

[Yates]

Yeah, eh?

Sorey. Had to take the shot...

[Hallia]

I love it (almost as much as I love poutine)

[Darthe]

Truly though, if I am critical it's because people tend to either say something that could be said in one sentence in two, use rhetoric non-ironically and for the hell of it, get hung up on inconsequential BS and spam threads with it and formulate inconsistent reads because they don't make it clear what transitions them from one view to the next.  

 

Those things make people hard to read and I tell them that.  The only time I call things dumb/obtuse and really mean it is when people push/create friction based on ??? over content and impartial analysis.  Take Dice flaring up over the Turin thing.  I can accept thinking that is suspect but I disagree about it being meaningful since I understand that it was a joke from Turin.  I find it incredibly dense of him to make the argument that me brushing aside his point (since I do happen to know Turin's alignment) somehow validates his argument.   

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Salami's internal consistency is strong enough that I'm kind of willingg to let this go but he is easily able to destroy towns from the inside so I'm kind of afraid to not push this through anyhow.

 

Does that resonate with anyone else?

 

No, it is a stupid idea.  Salami is town, and I think you know this (if you're a villager, which I suspect is true).  The only good news is this prob clears you, as you wouldn't be this "forward" with your play if you were a wolf.

 

 

 

 

While I'm catching up - have Verb and Leelou cleared each other yet?

good vibes but not clear I don't think.

 

Also not clear to practically anyone else.

 

 

This is correct, but I'd put her in solid green at this point.  Only Dice is blue.

 

 

 

 

I’m comfortable voting this route right now:

[v]dice[/v]

I feel like it would be informative and I think there’s a possibility of scum.

 

wat

 

Man I am all over the place right now.

 

Are you a wolf?  You and Thane really haven't impressed me yet and I expect a lot of you two as town.

 

 

Yes you are.  No I'm not.  Now you know why I've been mostly signing up for small games, and hydra if it is a larger one.  My shoulders slumped when I saw the # of pages I needed to read when I got into work today.

 

If you aren't a wolf we are probably in trouble this round.