[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

alannalynn · June 25, 2015

Talya wants to challenge me to a snark contest. I'll whoop you! haha

I am right about Zander; as far as I know, he's never been mafia. And I think it would obviously show in how he plays, and I just can't see it. Therefore, town.

Eldrick has more going against him than just that claim and his odd slip about Darthe

Could this be an annual comp on the main boards with awards?...haha, I doubt it. I would give you a damn good run!

I saw that, I'm assuming that was why he claimed.

But he had NO VOTES! And Sooh was soooo close to being lynched. Besides, we were just as likely to go for you or Heart tomorrow. He drew attention on himself. WHY?

alannalynn · June 25, 2015

10am is my bedtime, so y'all have 17 minutes if you want anything from me

Talya · June 25, 2015

I've been rereading the thread more carefully.

I snipped out the rest of the MQ, but dude.....I'm completely lost on what the hell you're saying here. I showed you that you said Eldrick was null, asked me why I said villager, and then I explained and you later had him as a ~strong village read. Ok, but then I asked if my explanation made you change your mind, and you mentioned a post that did it, and then quoted it.

I then pointed out this post came before you noted Eldrick as null, and your answer is the above. Suffice to say I have no freakin' clue what you're trying to do here, and it frustrates me. I've been getting used to thinking you're a villager when I can understand you.......and I thought I was understanding you up through this instance.

So please help me here. I think you're the villager I've been reading you as, but you need to help me get over this hump. Help me Sili-Q, you're my only hope.

>_>

<_<

c wut i did thar?

Yeah. Actually I'm related to Luke so I even chuckled.

Anyway, basically what you said made sense and I was happy you had your own logic to substantiate the read, and it made me lower the bar for Eldrick. Still, what changed my mind is as I was going over the thread one of Eldrick's posts caught my eye. I thought his interest in game solving was very genuine and spontaneous in the posts I quoted, so I adjusted my read accordingly.

Couldn't find the other post, but found this, ??

Perhaps Sili is Eld's Father?

鲍勃不是我的名字 · June 25, 2015

I think I'm gonna follow you guys' lead on them actually unless my reread comes up with something useful. Not sure I gonna finish it by this evening though (sorry about that )

then put down a vote. you already missed the last one. you gotta play a hand sometime homie.

[v]Eldrick[/v]

there ya go

/laters

Find csarmi's vote here unsettling...looks like the scum team wants to keep sooh around and they prompted Eldrick to out himself. just saying...

Talya · June 25, 2015

Talya wants to challenge me to a snark contest. I'll whoop you! haha

I am right about Zander; as far as I know, he's never been mafia. And I think it would obviously show in how he plays, and I just can't see it. Therefore, town.

Eldrick has more going against him than just that claim and his odd slip about Darthe

Could this be an annual comp on the main boards with awards?...haha, I doubt it. I would give you a damn good run!

I saw that, I'm assuming that was why he claimed.

But he had NO VOTES! And Sooh was soooo close to being lynched. Besides, we were just as likely to go for you or Heart tomorrow. He drew attention on himself. WHY?

He seemed itching to claim something for the passed day, from what I read. I meant the slip...that's why he claimed and did it early, knowing he had slip as he has now gone to bed. But then he seemed to want to say something, with the Darthe business.

Talya · June 25, 2015

I think I'm gonna follow you guys' lead on them actually unless my reread comes up with something useful. Not sure I gonna finish it by this evening though (sorry about that )

then put down a vote. you already missed the last one. you gotta play a hand sometime homie.

[v]Eldrick[/v]

there ya go

/laters

Find csarmi's vote here unsettling...looks like the scum team wants to keep sooh around and they prompted Eldrick to out himself. just saying...

Almosted sounded like Leelou's vote on Alanna Day 1, just to please someone. But I still think CS is town.

csarmi · June 25, 2015

You guys call it bowing under pressure. I see it as realizing I'm wrong. Why would I continue down a path that isn't the right one?

I'm just gonna come out and say it now.

I've been mulling over revealing anyway.

HARD CLAIM

Luke Skywalker, Vanilla Town

(I told Hally being vanilla as Luke was lame. :P)

I'm doing my best to be town. I like to think I'm improving. I speak my mind. Sometimes I don't know when to not say stuff (as in the attempt to rez Durin)

I would like to get through this game with 0 mislynches. Please look elsewhere.

[v] Eldrick [/v]

0 NEED FOR THIS CLAIM. i think he realizes he slipped up and is trying to go into damage control imo.

That has to be the dumbest claim ever. If it's real it sucks.

If he is wolf, would that be a good claim or would you keep quiet, I don't know Eld enough.

Agreed

No meta on Eld. I don't see how/why as town you would do this fwiw.

Just FYI. If i was in his position as Luke vanilla, i would claim here the same way too.

Zander? · June 25, 2015

I think I'm gonna follow you guys' lead on them actually unless my reread comes up with something useful. Not sure I gonna finish it by this evening though (sorry about that )

then put down a vote. you already missed the last one. you gotta play a hand sometime homie.

[v]Eldrick[/v]

there ya go

/laters

Find csarmi's vote here unsettling...looks like the scum team wants to keep sooh around and they prompted Eldrick to out himself. just saying...

imo there has to be a reason Eldrick claims here. there was just 0 need. and to walk away as it was building was not good.

Zander? · June 25, 2015

You guys call it bowing under pressure. I see it as realizing I'm wrong. Why would I continue down a path that isn't the right one?

I'm just gonna come out and say it now.

I've been mulling over revealing anyway.

HARD CLAIM

Luke Skywalker, Vanilla Town

(I told Hally being vanilla as Luke was lame. :P)

I'm doing my best to be town. I like to think I'm improving. I speak my mind. Sometimes I don't know when to not say stuff (as in the attempt to rez Durin)

I would like to get through this game with 0 mislynches. Please look elsewhere.

[v] Eldrick [/v]

0 NEED FOR THIS CLAIM. i think he realizes he slipped up and is trying to go into damage control imo.

That has to be the dumbest claim ever. If it's real it sucks.

If he is wolf, would that be a good claim or would you keep quiet, I don't know Eld enough.

Agreed

No meta on Eld. I don't see how/why as town you would do this fwiw.

Just FYI. If i was in his position as Luke vanilla, i would claim here the same way too.

WHY???!!!!!

WWWwombat · June 25, 2015

The way I read it, it was like she didn't want to talk directly to AJ, which is why she asked Wombat if they were town. Which made me think the "hard feelings" were because of Leelou. Now I dunno.

Leelou probably asked me because she has a better rapport with me. It's something she prob would have done as town too imo. I don't see how Leelou not being in the American Gods game matters btw.

csarmi · June 25, 2015

I think I'm gonna follow you guys' lead on them actually unless my reread comes up with something useful. Not sure I gonna finish it by this evening though (sorry about that )

then put down a vote. you already missed the last one. you gotta play a hand sometime homie.

[v]Eldrick[/v]

there ya go

/laters

Find csarmi's vote here unsettling...looks like the scum team wants to keep sooh around and they prompted Eldrick to out himself. just saying...

So i am mafia with Eldrick AND Sooh? Or how does it work?

Talya · June 25, 2015

Okay, so here's the deal.

Leelou claimed Leia, vanilla.

Eldrick claims Luke, vanilla.

Yet he says he had some resurrect ability

That's not vanilla

and Leelou was mafia

So.. ?

Resurrect can be either alignment, might be a townie role if there is a hated...lose a town before full lynch and have the ability to revive someone. Actually do you know what, no I don't think so, we have a phoenix (why another reviver), may even be something else...nah this is rubbish.

I reckon he was going to claim resurrector, but realised he couldn't because he would only do a mafia player. Has there always been a gap between lynch and result?

Andrej · June 25, 2015

Talya · June 25, 2015

I forgot something

@ Heart - I would like to know which QT that was. I haven't played mafia for well over a year, and I can't remember when Leelou was in a game and mafia too.

Yates · June 25, 2015

I don't understand the resurrect attempt. Some weird talk too.

Claim doesn't make him a wolf though.

I wanted Durin back. It was worth a shot.

and what did you do? message the mod to revive them? How do you do that without a role?

The same way actions are traditionally done. Through my role pm.

I'd quote it, but that's against the rules.

I'm sure this has been answered satisfactorily at this point. Right?

alannalynn · June 25, 2015

Perfect gif usage is perfect

Talya · June 25, 2015

There is a lot of WIFOM with his role claim. but his previous "claim" seemed fumbled

csarmi · June 25, 2015

You guys call it bowing under pressure. I see it as realizing I'm wrong. Why would I continue down a path that isn't the right one?

I'm just gonna come out and say it now.

I've been mulling over revealing anyway.

HARD CLAIM

Luke Skywalker, Vanilla Town

(I told Hally being vanilla as Luke was lame. :P)

I'm doing my best to be town. I like to think I'm improving. I speak my mind. Sometimes I don't know when to not say stuff (as in the attempt to rez Durin)

I would like to get through this game with 0 mislynches. Please look elsewhere.

[v] Eldrick [/v]

0 NEED FOR THIS CLAIM. i think he realizes he slipped up and is trying to go into damage control imo.

That has to be the dumbest claim ever. If it's real it sucks.
If he is wolf, would that be a good claim or would you keep quiet, I don't know Eld enough.

Agreed

No meta on Eld. I don't see how/why as town you would do this fwiw.

Just FYI. If i was in his position as Luke vanilla, i would claim here the same way too.

WHY???!!!!!

Hmm actually not sure i would. But consider it certainly.

He obviously thought it would removw pressure. Thats not a bad thing to do as town or as mafia either. Thats why i would treat the CLAIM null.

Andrej · June 25, 2015

Gif game strong.

Seriously tho - this thread is devolving quickly into AIDS.

Yates · June 25, 2015

imo there has to be a reason Eldrick claims here. there was just 0 need. and to walk away as it was building was not good.

Unless Sooh is a PR and he's a goon?

Zander? · June 25, 2015

Gif game strong.

Seriously tho - this thread is devolving quickly into AIDS.

+1

csarmi · June 25, 2015

Forget the claim. Is he a wolf or a villager?

Zander? · June 25, 2015

imo there has to be a reason Eldrick claims here. there was just 0 need. and to walk away as it was building was not good.
Unless Sooh is a PR and he's a goon?

yes i think someone else mentioned this too.

alannalynn · June 25, 2015

Fumbled is a very kind word.

Because he's been caught in a contradiction and with a similar claim to a mafia member . . .

csarmi · June 25, 2015

imo there has to be a reason Eldrick claims here. there was just 0 need. and to walk away as it was building was not good.
Unless Sooh is a PR and he's a goon?

WiFoM. Not needed. Focus on hunting.

[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook