[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

Oh. Past the point and completely irrelevant, but I laughed at the vote count what was

Csarmi (1): Csarmi

And nothing else

self votes are just gross

Oh I know. Agree 100% on that point. It was the aesthetics that made me lol.

鲍勃不是我的名字 · June 25, 2015

Not Lynching

Laine, Salami, Sili, Yates

Unsure

NotBob, Zander, Talya, Dice, Heart

WTL

Wombo, Sooh

I don't think NotBob is scum. Could be SK, if there is one

Not sure about Zander. I thought he was on Leelou's scum list. He is Therbal's "town read". Salami brought up good points about his looking for people that "look bad"

I still don't know how to read Talya. A lot of her posts are those big summary posts that Sooh and Heart do. I'm not as big a fan of those as Laine is. I like the quote/respond approach.

There have been things along the way that have caught my attention about dice. not badly enough that I would lynch him at this point, but he's not clear either.

Same goes for Heart as they do for dice. I will be looking at these two the most in my reread.

ugh....dude again... really. in what world do i vote leelou and thaneballs early and stay as Maf?

and look for people who look bad....maybe i dont know....look towny and i wont think you look bad enough to wolf imo.

Mafia have to leave some wiggle room.

WWWwombat · June 25, 2015

Wombat reads:

WomboCombo

Seph (for when he comes back)

Alannalynn

Csarmi

Dice

NotBob

Zander

Sili

Eldrick

Aiel <3

Talya

Yates

Sooh (Mentored by Pizza)

Bottom 4 are WTL atm, Zander

鲍勃不是我的名字 · June 25, 2015

unless its just part of Sooh's Iso then fine. if not this^^^^^^^

He quoted a post of Talya's from the same day just before -_-

Are you seriously asking me why I'm going through the game thread as if you didn't know? How is it not clear to you? Just sounds like a credibility snipe for me.

I'm asking because it's getting ridiculous and I think it's high time you outgrew it. Scum don't need to snipe your credibility, btw.

In what world is re-reading the game ridiculous?

A world where the game is 240 pages long and there's very little evidence to suggest that you read much of it in the first place? I'm not trying to discredit you, I'm trying to get you to play better. And I think I'm being much, much more pleasant about it than Darthe was. You try my patience.

He'd respect you more if you'd vote him off the island.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

I've been trying to ignore it. I feel like I shouldn't care, and have been focusing on wolf hunting instead.

But I don't want to be mislynched.

Why am I trending down?

鲍勃不是我的名字 · June 25, 2015

Wombat reads:

WomboCombo

Seph (for when he comes back)

Alannalynn

Csarmi

Dice

NotBob

Zander

Sili

Eldrick

Aiel <3

Talya

Yates

Sooh (Mentored by Pizza)

Bottom 4 are WTL atm, Zander

Why Yates?

Stake your best case.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

Wow Wombat. no more yellow, please. Had to get 6 inches away from the screen to read those names

Zander? · June 25, 2015

Wombat reads:

WomboCombo

Seph (for when he comes back)

Alannalynn

Csarmi

Dice

NotBob

Zander

Sili

Eldrick

Aiel <3

Talya

Yates

Sooh (Mentored by Pizza)

Bottom 4 are WTL atm, Zander

k ty.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

I've been going at this for 3 hours now. No wonder my eyes hurt. Time for a break.

Zander? · June 25, 2015

Not Lynching

Laine, Salami, Sili, Yates

Unsure

NotBob, Zander, Talya, Dice, Heart

WTL

Wombo, Sooh

I don't think NotBob is scum. Could be SK, if there is one

Not sure about Zander. I thought he was on Leelou's scum list. He is Therbal's "town read". Salami brought up good points about his looking for people that "look bad"

I still don't know how to read Talya. A lot of her posts are those big summary posts that Sooh and Heart do. I'm not as big a fan of those as Laine is. I like the quote/respond approach.

There have been things along the way that have caught my attention about dice. not badly enough that I would lynch him at this point, but he's not clear either.

Same goes for Heart as they do for dice. I will be looking at these two the most in my reread.

ugh....dude again... really. in what world do i vote leelou and thaneballs early and stay as Maf?

and look for people who look bad....maybe i dont know....look towny and i wont think you look bad enough to wolf imo.

Mafia have to leave some wiggle room.

this ^^^^^^^^

Sili Quirrels · June 25, 2015

I think when someone pushes someone else is a lot more important.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

I'm not pushing you. You have been trending up the more I think about it. The more I read.That's why I asked for other people's opinions on you. It's impossible to notice everything. I didn't notice much about you. All I had recently was that you were saying about your own actions. Extremely biased and not basing a read on that.

FTR I hate rereads. I've never actually completed one. I'm so glad the game has slowed down. I've been able to keep up with what's been said lately.

dicetosser1 · June 25, 2015

Vote Heart

I think Darthe may have had something when he was saying she may have been trapped on the leelou lynch. Iv already said i didntlike her posts regarding the coronered flip. and i will point out that what is being said about sooh kinda applies to Heart as well. Until this day when i noted she started posting more. But iirc they were defensive posts cause she was under pressure

dicetosser1 · June 25, 2015

And those who think there's a wolf between myself and Yates, look at the direction he wants to go in toDay compared to mine. He basically is willing to go anyone over soon when at this point it's pretty obvious she's a wolf.

Once again, food for thought.

@AJ what if we lynch sooh and she flips town?

Andrej · June 25, 2015

Sooh/Heart/Yates is okay with me.

I'd prefer Yates to be town because I hate being opposite alignments but even now I'm not overly blown away by anything he's said or done.

We should lynch Sooh, vig Heart and cop Yates. Pretty much covers our bases and if game isn't over on D4 then we will either have Yates cleared or damned and can go from there.

I'm not going to even entertain the tinfoil ideas or Eldrick's case for us being scum. Our vote came one minute after Seph's iirc which is literally a matter of refreshing the page or not.

You guys are seriously making his harder than it has to be. Stop the BS bickering. Does Salami's attitude suck? Sure. Is he helpful? Not always. Does that make him scum? No. Get over it.

See past the stuff you dislike and look for what's actually scummy.

Lynch Sooh. Get her flip. See who dies at Night. Proceed.

Plain and simple folks. Get with the program

Andrej · June 25, 2015

And those who think there's a wolf between myself and Yates, look at the direction he wants to go in toDay compared to mine. He basically is willing to go anyone over soon when at this point it's pretty obvious she's a wolf.

Once again, food for thought.

@AJ what if we lynch sooh and she flips town?

Ftr I kinda doubt she does - but if, and I've already touched on this, I think my original thought of Talya looking sketchy on D1 for going after Sooh/Zander takes on more meaning.

Andrej · June 25, 2015

And despite NotBob and Eldrick trying their best to look wolfier today I will ignore it and stay the course.

Idk if you guys realize it but this sort of stuff happens when a bunch of wolves are dead and its villagers all over the thread. I would even be willing to gives Yates a pass over Heart because he's at least pretending to be involved.

WWWwombat · June 25, 2015

Wombat reads:

WomboCombo

Seph (for when he comes back)

Alannalynn

Csarmi

Dice

NotBob

Zander

Sili

Eldrick

Aiel <3

Talya

Yates

Sooh (Mentored by Pizza)

Bottom 4 are WTL atm, Zander

Why Yates?

Stake your best case.

You should read the convo I had with him. He hasn't done much scumhunting imo and he keeps defending himself with meta, which is basically WIFOM. I also don't like how he said that he'd either be clear today, or how he said last night phase that he's be willing to claim miller and take a lynch today. It felt all hat and no cattle. That being said, I'm willing to give him another day as I think lynching Sooh is the best play today because she's been worse.

WWWwombat · June 25, 2015

And despite NotBob and Eldrick trying their best to look wolfier today I will ignore it and stay the course.

Idk if you guys realize it but this sort of stuff happens when a bunch of wolves are dead and its villagers all over the thread. I would even be willing to gives Yates a pass over Heart because he's at least pretending to be involved.

Yep. We are almost certainly looking for WiLves here.

WWWwombat · June 25, 2015

We are pretty much never lynching Salami this game btw.

WWWwombat · June 25, 2015

AJ, will we need to direct this personally?

Aiel Heart · June 25, 2015

#4572 @ Talya in a mafia QT when she was scum when they were throwing out people they’d want to get rid of early and Leelou had listed both of us because we know her well and can read her. Can not for the life of me tell you what game that was though… I want to say it was recent as the memory seems fresh but maybe that’s a random file that stayed from long ago…?[/size]

#4574 @ Laine—“acting cleared” as in acting confident and leading. “Cruising” I’m having a harder time defining. Like when you’re cruising in a car—keep going on with the speed you have and letting the game play out itself for the time somewhat? Idk it’s a good thing. You’re using the momentum you have. I’m not describing it well.

#4582 @ Sili re not sure how I feel about you saying what Yates “usually” does—to be honest, I don’t know what I was referring to either. I can’t find anything referring to it in my notes on you… If I find it I’ll let you know. Otherwise it might be misattributed

#4633 @ Laine just because I trust you doesn’t mean I trust your reads to be correct. Town =/= correct and you know that

#4653 @Laine—you said you were comparing people’s lists. Did this turn up anything interesting?

#4689 quoted from Yates

And I was wrong. Sili was not around. So then the next question is; does Thaneballs try to pull a fake claim like this without his scumbuddy around? Probably not. So this could be a good thing in Sooh, AH and Wombo's favor since they weren't around either...

Zander noted that they might have just claimed because the end was quick. Additionally, we seem to be in agreement that there are most likely two scum left, which doesn’t necessarily clear any of us you listed.

re #4711 Wombat pressuring Eldrick still willing to lynch Sooh but voting Wombat--maybe I'm just not following what you're saying there correctly, but if there are two mafia left (circa my last response) and he thinks ONE of them is between me and the two of you, then why shouldn't he still be looking at Sooh? You can change your mind on who is the better option...

Oh and re:my activity--thought I would be far more active. My grandma usually just leaves me behind and goes places when I stay with her. This time she's taking me with her, and I'm not going to skip out on that for mafia, though I do regret my time away from the game. I'm here and staying caught up.

Would like to hear from Sooh before I put a vote on her, and will be around again before EoD.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

I'm dropping the Yates/Wombo thing from my case. I honestly don't know why people are saying there's a wolf between these two. It was mentioned a lot, so it made it into my case, like a puzzle piece fitting. Looking at it now, I don't know why.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

I still think you're scum, but not for that reason.

Eldrick4221 · June 25, 2015

re #4711 Wombat pressuring Eldrick still willing to lynch Sooh but voting Wombat--maybe I'm just not following what you're saying there correctly, but if there are two mafia left (circa my last response) and he thinks ONE of them is between me and the two of you, then why shouldn't he still be looking at Sooh? You can change your mind on who is the better option...

This. Exactly this. I'm actually contemplating moving my vote back. I want to clear up who is scum on Leelou's list. I just can't believe that all 6 of her non-town reads aren't scum.

But I don't see myself getting the support for a Wombo lynch, so I dunno.

[Advanced] Star Wars Mafia

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook