Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[Talya]

I'm not going to hammer Dae I need to have a good read on this game before I vote. Once bitten twice shy. I can't add any more to the hammer vote I did. It was one of those moments

 

If I get chance at work today I will try to reread.

 

I don't particularly like Hallia. I know someone said she is quite, but I have seen better from her as town. And only seeing two things that stood out in day 2 is not good imo.

 

Dae I'm not sure on and will have check. Darthe hasn't come in to play this game at all so this is raising suspicion for me.

Not Bob has done nothing but sheep people and has not had anything constructive to add.

 

If Dae is town them wolves are happy now because they have two townies that could go down. If he is wolf then I am the set up lynch for them to protect Dae.

 

I can't claim anything so you will only be losing a VT not a role.

[Sili Quirrels]

I'm not going to hammer Dae I need to have a good read on this game before I vote. Once bitten twice shy. I can't add any more to the hammer vote I did. It was one of those moments

 

If I get chance at work today I will try to reread.

 

I don't particularly like Hallia. I know someone said she is quite, but I have seen better from her as town. And only seeing two things that stood out in day 2 is not good imo.

 

Dae I'm not sure on and will have check. Darthe hasn't come in to play this game at all so this is raising suspicion for me.

Not Bob has done nothing but sheep people and has not had anything constructive to add.

 

If Dae is town them wolves are happy now because they have two townies that could go down. If he is wolf then I am the set up lynch for them to protect Dae.

 

I can't claim anything so you will only be losing a VT not a role.

someone had to hammer. it is a hammer game.

[Talya]

Oops I had cloud flare when I was trying to post and being on phone I couldn't see it had gone through I do apologise.

[Talya]

I agree they do but I'm not going to dive in without giving a him a chance to speak...and also to decide if I think he is wolf. It was in response to Shad.

[Sili Quirrels]

could be as simple as ah, hallia, and dae.

 

book it.

[Talya]

It would be nice if it was that easy.

 

Off to try and sneak a reread whist boss isn't looking lol

[Talya]

Is there no easy way to get to the start of the thread without doing prev page for every page! Arg

[alannalynn]

I'm here, catching up on what I missed.

[alannalynn]

I'm still trying to figure out why Verbal quoted me here? lol

 

Blegh is tough to make a case on mobile. The tldr is that his posts look coached, his standoffishness D1 was player specific and didn't tend to be level across the board and I generally feel bad about the slot.

Could be wrong though, I've got that suspicion too based on how others are treating this from me, entirely the point of my behavior.

What do you mean by player specific, Darthe?

 

Alanna will you always seem off to me? How do I read you?
Verb where you at?

LOL! What exactly is the problem with reading me? I feel like I've been pretty straightforward this game

 

Post 333, Talya's hammer not being ignored, but I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt until I see a wolf flip. Dae and AH (possibly Sooh) are more priority for me right now.

 

 

Unvotes are dumb, not like Darthe
[unvote] [v] sooh [/v]

 

Wait you had nothing on Shad?  

Unvote

Darthe'd.

NB, not sure what game you're playing here.

 

I feel like Laine's response to me wasn't bad. I feel a bit better about her. Notbob's play is standing out to me, in a bad way. But at the moment Tal is my top so I will also
[v] Talya [/v]

What response? I remember being annoying at some point, but not specifically when.

 

Vote Count
 
Dae (4) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili
Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Shad

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch
 
Deadline - Friday noon EDT

 

I'm a little uncomfortable with these two trains. The players I'm leaning scum on are on Talya's lynch train and the players I'm leaning town on are on Dae's train. I'm definitely leaning toward a Dae lynch today, I've been feeling a bit better about Talya lately

[alannalynn]

If your post count is in the single digits, I'm gonna need you to be more active, if you're town. If you're mafia, please say something stupid, and we'll just get this over with.

 

And with that, I'm going to bed.

[Hallia]

What Laine? I said it wasn't bad, why would that imply you were being annoying?

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

could be as simple as ah, hallia, and dae.

 

book it.

 

AH is prolly town...the others i could see.

[Verbal32]

could be as simple as ah, hallia, and dae.

 

book it.

 

I could probably go with this, actually.  I'm usually either wrongly assuming Hallia is a wolf by now, or reading her as a villager.

 

 

 

 

I'm still trying to figure out why Verbal quoted me here? lol

 

Blegh is tough to make a case on mobile. The tldr is that his posts look coached, his standoffishness D1 was player specific and didn't tend to be level across the board and I generally feel bad about the slot.

 

Could be wrong though, I've got that suspicion too based on how others are treating this from me, entirely the point of my behavior.

What do you mean by player specific, Darthe?

 

Alanna will you always seem off to me? How do I read you?

Verb where you at?

LOL! What exactly is the problem with reading me? I feel like I've been pretty straightforward this game

 

Post 333, Talya's hammer not being ignored, but I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt until I see a wolf flip. Dae and AH (possibly Sooh) are more priority for me right now.

 

 

Unvotes are dumb, not like Darthe

[unvote] [v] sooh [/v]

 

Wait you had nothing on Shad?  

Unvote

Darthe'd.

NB, not sure what game you're playing here.

 

I feel like Laine's response to me wasn't bad. I feel a bit better about her. Notbob's play is standing out to me, in a bad way. But at the moment Tal is my top so I will also

[v] Talya [/v]

What response? I remember being annoying at some point, but not specifically when.

 

Vote Count

 

Dae (4) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili

Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Shad

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

 

I'm a little uncomfortable with these two trains. The players I'm leaning scum on are on Talya's lynch train and the players I'm leaning town on are on Dae's train. I'm definitely leaning toward a Dae lynch today, I've been feeling a bit better about Talya lately

 

I don't know why I quoted you, actually.

 

But on the last part there, why are you uncomfortable.  If your town reads are on train A and your scum reads are on train B, and you feel better about the person train B is on.....I'm failing to see why you're uncomfortable.  Actually, I'd say that's a pretty darn comfortable spot to be in!

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I'm still trying to figure out why Verbal quoted me here? lol

 

Blegh is tough to make a case on mobile. The tldr is that his posts look coached, his standoffishness D1 was player specific and didn't tend to be level across the board and I generally feel bad about the slot.

 

Could be wrong though, I've got that suspicion too based on how others are treating this from me, entirely the point of my behavior.

What do you mean by player specific, Darthe?

 

Alanna will you always seem off to me? How do I read you?

Verb where you at?

LOL! What exactly is the problem with reading me? I feel like I've been pretty straightforward this game

 

Post 333, Talya's hammer not being ignored, but I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt until I see a wolf flip. Dae and AH (possibly Sooh) are more priority for me right now.

 

 

Unvotes are dumb, not like Darthe

[unvote] [v] sooh [/v]

 

Wait you had nothing on Shad?  

Unvote

Darthe'd.

NB, not sure what game you're playing here.

 

I feel like Laine's response to me wasn't bad. I feel a bit better about her. Notbob's play is standing out to me, in a bad way. But at the moment Tal is my top so I will also

[v] Talya [/v]

What response? I remember being annoying at some point, but not specifically when.

 

Vote Count

 

Dae (4) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili

Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Shad

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

 

I'm a little uncomfortable with these two trains. The players I'm leaning scum on are on Talya's lynch train and the players I'm leaning town on are on Dae's train. I'm definitely leaning toward a Dae lynch today, I've been feeling a bit better about Talya lately

 

I honestly thought Darthe had a read from a PR.  He voted with explanation and when I challenged him he stated he lynches scum.  When he unvoted I realized he did not but he was just showing off.  

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

* without explanation

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

I'm still trying to figure out why Verbal quoted me here? lol

 

Blegh is tough to make a case on mobile. The tldr is that his posts look coached, his standoffishness D1 was player specific and didn't tend to be level across the board and I generally feel bad about the slot.

 

Could be wrong though, I've got that suspicion too based on how others are treating this from me, entirely the point of my behavior.

What do you mean by player specific, Darthe?

 

Alanna will you always seem off to me? How do I read you?

Verb where you at?

LOL! What exactly is the problem with reading me? I feel like I've been pretty straightforward this game

 

Post 333, Talya's hammer not being ignored, but I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt until I see a wolf flip. Dae and AH (possibly Sooh) are more priority for me right now.

 

 

Unvotes are dumb, not like Darthe

[unvote] [v] sooh [/v]

 

Wait you had nothing on Shad?  

Unvote

Darthe'd.

NB, not sure what game you're playing here.

 

I feel like Laine's response to me wasn't bad. I feel a bit better about her. Notbob's play is standing out to me, in a bad way. But at the moment Tal is my top so I will also

[v] Talya [/v]

What response? I remember being annoying at some point, but not specifically when.

 

Vote Count

 

Dae (4) - Verbs, Notbob, Darthe, Sili

Talya (4) - Dae, Heart, Hallia, Shad

Darthe (1) - Sooh

 

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

 

Deadline - Friday noon EDT

 

I'm a little uncomfortable with these two trains. The players I'm leaning scum on are on Talya's lynch train and the players I'm leaning town on are on Dae's train. I'm definitely leaning toward a Dae lynch today, I've been feeling a bit better about Talya lately

 

Then we prolly got strong competing trains.  

[Shad_]

I agree they do but I'm not going to dive in without giving a him a chance to speak...and also to decide if I think he is wolf. It was in response to Shad.

 

I don't think you understood my question, because it wasn't a question you can answer.  If you are town, I am confident you wouldn't do a fast hammer on Dae.  That would be silly.

 

My question was more: suppose Talya is wolf and Dae is town.  Considering that Talya is getting a lot of heat right now, would it make any sense for her to reveal that she is mafia and finish off Dae?  I don't know if this would be a really dumb thing for mafia to do or if it is a reasonable concern, so I did not give Dae a fifth vote.  I want to give Dae a fifth vote and will if I don't like his response to the current situation.  I definitely think we have more on him than on Talya.

[Shad_]

...I suppose it would be a bad idea for any active player to answer that question.  This is where I start to wish I'd accepted a mentor...

[Talya]

Sorry Eldrick..

 

/snip/

But does this approach make her wolfy, or a really aggressive town trying to light some fires and get this game rolling?  Her [Alanna's] individual posts almost never sit well with me, but when I look at them as a collective I am totally comfortable with her.

/snip/

I was rereading this post, and wondering what this part meant? I feel like I've heard it before recently but I can't quite recall where.

Just a quick note as reading through - Alanna I agree with you, I was in the Middle Earth Game and read the House of Cards one, so it has to be in one of those two. If I get chance later I might go and check

 

 

[Shad_]

[unvote] because players I consider town are downplaying the hammer on Eldrick and that's really the only reason Talya's not in my neutral pile, posts since my vote included.  My question on Dae isn't going to see an answer so I'll sit without a vote until he posts and then make up my mind whether or not to vote him.

[Darthe]

@Laine I mean that Shad chose to interact standoffishly with certain people and not others, which is to say it was inconsistent.

 

 

 

I agree they do but I'm not going to dive in without giving a him a chance to speak...and also to decide if I think he is wolf. It was in response to Shad.

 

I don't think you understood my question, because it wasn't a question you can answer.  If you are town, I am confident you wouldn't do a fast hammer on Dae.  That would be silly.

 

My question was more: suppose Talya is wolf and Dae is town.  Considering that Talya is getting a lot of heat right now, would it make any sense for her to reveal that she is mafia and finish off Dae?  I don't know if this would be a really dumb thing for mafia to do or if it is a reasonable concern, so I did not give Dae a fifth vote.  I want to give Dae a fifth vote and will if I don't like his response to the current situation.  I definitely think we have more on him than on Talya.

 

No wolf ever reveals that they are mafia before endgame.  If it doesn't directly lead to them immediately winning it will directly result in an immediate loss, so no, it wouldn't ever be a reasonable thing to do here.

[Darthe]

BTW Hammer was prob just dumb, not alignment indicative.

 

Why do either of these people have trains?  They're bad, not scummy.

 

[v] Sili [/v] is scummy

[Darthe]

@Mod don't be high on some unvote rule, they're unneccesary

[Talya]

A nice longish post coming up.

 

Alanna

• She's the one that started the push on Eld after his mistake, as we know it is now. Keeps her vote on him
• She does tend to make sweeping statements on how she thinks people play, and isn't too happy when people disagree with her. - not indictative as alignment
• I think the Eld stuff has been done to death, so moving on after that, she thinks Shad,is probably scum with Me and Heart
• Day 2 and she could go with a Shad or Me lynch. But also wants to hear from Heart
• She then says she didn't like my Hammer and that I have been condescending to her (sorry I never meant to be at all...not sure where neither)
• She is then good with Me, AH or Dae as a lynch
• Now she is not willing to vote me and is uncomfortable on the two trains.

Earlier she agreed with sili that she would be happy with either of us on a lynch and now she seems unwilling to put a vote on and is uncomfortable, surely this should be heaven for her. Makes me think she is not willing to put a hammer vote on town (which I know I am), the only other reason not to would be if one of us was a wolf with her (which has to be Dae as far as I'm concerned).

 

I'm going to do this in bits, because I'm off to a spinning class soon, so can whizz off and come back and finish later if need be.

[Shad_]

^ Nullifies my reason for not voting Dae yet and drops my strongest scum read off his train.  [v]Daetirion[/v]