[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[Verbal32]

(awkward silence)

[dicetosser1]

throws a shoe at verb

[Pralaya]

Hallia is not scum.

 

Because when Yates did the gambit, there was no need for her to counter him. Yeah, Yates said that she might have said it to trap him. But, most likely, if she was scum, she would have just laughed in her QT , try to get me lynched and after my flip get Yates lynched.

[monstrman]

QUICK CFD TOMMY

[Verbal32]

Hallia is not scum.

 

Because when Yates did the gambit, there was no need for her to counter him. Yeah, Yates said that she might have said it to trap him. But, most likely, if she was scum, she would have just laughed in her QT , try to get me lynched and after my flip get Yates lynched.

 

I don't follow.  Why wouldn't she try for the trap and quick lynch on Yates?

 

 

 

 

QUICK CFD TOMMY

 

RL LOL for this

[Yates]

Day 1 Lynch:

 

VOTE COUNT
 
Berf (6): BFKEY, Alanna, AJ, Thane, Tommy, Sili
BFKEY(2): Dice, Pral
Sili (5): Des, Rags, Lates, Hally, Arsis
Arsis (2): Verbal, Monstr

VOTE COUNT

Berf (3): BFKEY, AJ, Thane
BFKEY(1): Pral
Sili (6): Des, Rags, Lates, Hally, Arsis, Dice
Thane (6): Tommy, Alanna, Sili, Berf, Monstr, Verb

 

Okay.  I think the people that STAYED on Sili actually look better at this point.

Dice making the Sili wagon even is kind of null because he's either Town consolidating or scum who didn't want to be the hammer. But with 9 minutes until deadline? I think he could pile on the larger wagon without much suspicion.

I think what's more interesting is the FINAL vote count here:

 

FINAL VOTE COUNT

Berf (2): AJ, Thane
BFKEY(1): Pral
Sili (4): Des, Lates, Hally, Dice
Thane (9): Tommy, Alanna, Sili, Berf, Monstr, Verb, Arsis, BFKEY, Rags
 
IT'S A LYNCH.

 

Arsis, Key, and Rags made the mislynch go through.
 
The problem here is not knowing the Berf/Sili slot alignment. So let's look at how Day 2 went down...

Sadly, we didn't really have any good wagons. This was about where we were before Sili began to self-destruct:

 

VOTE COUNT
 
Pral (3): AJ, BFKEY, Sili
Verb (2): Rags, Lates
Sili (2): Hally, Dice
Alanna (3): Des, Monstr, Arsis
Hally (1): Berf
BFKEY (2): Alanna, Tommy
 
 
Not Voting (2): The rest of you lot.

 

Were scum hiding off the Sili wagon knowing Sili was going to get HIMSELF lynched?  Or were they already on it?

 

VOTE COUNT

Pral (4):AJ, BFKEY, Sili, Tommy
Sili (7): Hally, Dice, Pral, Arsis, Des, Alanna, Lates
Alanna (1): Monstr
Hally (1): Berf
BFKEY (1):  Rags
 
Not Voting (1): Verbal
 
With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

 

This is the final vote count:

 

FINAL VOTE COUNT
 
Pral (3): AJ, BFKEY, Sili
Sili (8): Hally, Dice, Pral, Arsis, Des, Alanna, Lates, Tommy
Alanna (1): Monstr
Hally (1): Berf
BFKEY (1):  Rags
 
Not Voting (1): Verbal
 
It's a lynch.

 

 

No carry over from the last one but Alanna, Lates, and Tommy made the Sili wagon go through.  

 

Alanna, Arsis, and Tommy are the only three on both mislynches.  

[Arsis]

I only voted Thane because it's not hybrid hammer and I was wrong about Sili. It happens. I still think Hallia and Verb are the most likely scum here. I think new sili is also probably scum with probably pral on the team if we have 4 on a team.

[Arsis]

Maybe Yates instead of sili.

 

 

Manbat has been too quiet lately as well.

[Verbal32]

Maybe Yates instead of sili.

 

 

Manbat has been too quiet lately as well.

 

If Monstr is scum he deserves to win.  Simple as that.

 

 

 

Why do you think Hallia AND myself are scum?  Think I've been pushing others to go for my #1 suspect all game long....but that I'm doing this elaborate bus move?

[TheRagnarok]

 

Maybe Yates instead of sili.

 

 

Manbat has been too quiet lately as well.

 

If Monstr is scum he deserves to win.  Simple as that.

 

 

 

Why do you think Hallia AND myself are scum?  Think I've been pushing others to go for my #1 suspect all game long....but that I'm doing this elaborate bus move?

 

It'd make about as much sense as someone saying that the two of us were scummates.

 

None at all.

[BFG]

 

Pral: you think the Jailkeeper claim was a lie? Or they're a scum RB or somesuch? Why do you think that?

 

Don't believe them as town. Don't see why they would JK manbat as town - no way he was getting targetted by scum. Also, a town JK would try to target scum rather than town so that if ta all manbat is a PR, his power wouldn't be wasted. They would ideally have targetted you instead - because if they thought you are scum, then why not JK you? If you were town, why not JK you and prevent a loss for town?

 

 

 

 

 

im feeling this urge to vote key/bfg

 

 

thoughts?

Nudge more?

 

Yep, this pretty much confirms dice is scum?

 

Town dice would have made a post thinking why tommy wasn;t jailkept. Instead, we have him trying to influence the town against BFKey. Clearly he knew they were blocked and was trying to push the suspicion there.

 

## Dice

 

You don't mention us between these two posts. Why the change in stance?

[Arsis]

 

 

 

 

Maybe Yates instead of sili.

 

 

Manbat has been too quiet lately as well.

If Monstr is scum he deserves to win. Simple as that.

 

 

 

Why do you think Hallia AND myself are scum? Think I've been pushing others to go for my #1 suspect all game long....but that I'm doing this elaborate bus move?

It'd make about as much sense as someone saying that the two of us were scummates.

 

None at all.

Why not?

[Verbal32]

Same reason Hallia and I are an unlikely scum pair.

[Arsis]

Same reason Hallia and I are an unlikely scum pair.

Proper distancing?

[dicetosser1]

so Yates  are you still iffy on me?

[Alanna]

I don't get why dice has to be scum if berf is. I understand that if berf is town, dice likely is, because piling on berf would've been an easy move at that point. But if berf is scum, I think dice could still be scum. Dice seemed adamant about not voting berf. Sure, it was close to deadline , but berf only had one more post than Sili, at that time. He could just be a townie that felt strongly about not lynching berf.

[Alanna]

Should say , if berf if scum , dice could still be town*

[Verbal32]

 

Same reason Hallia and I are an unlikely scum pair.

Proper distancing?

 

 

There's distancing, and then there's overdoing it to the point of being obvious.

[Arsis]

Could everyone do me a favor.

 

Assume I'm telling the truth about being the watcher.

 

 

Who is the scum team if I'm town watcher?

[Arsis]

I'm especially interested in seeing what manbat has to say in regards to my question. He seems good at picking out village.

[Leelou]

Hallia, Berfsili, Alanna/Rags/Des/Pral

[Alanna]

My problem with hallia is that with arsis/bfkey being scum, if hallia is also scum, that might make the town way under powered. Of course, we have not had all the claims but just guessing what we are missing.

They could also be lying about their claims. I doubt BFKey is, because everything they've said adds up pretty well, but Arsis and/or Hallia could just be lying about their roles.

[monstrman]

I'm not scum I've just voiced my opinion and I really don't know which claims to believe tbh

[Leelou]

I'm going to a hockey game soon. 

[Arsis]

I'm not scum I've just voiced my opinion and I really don't know which claims to believe tbh

I'm asking you to do me a favor and assume I'm telling the truth as a hypothetical. If I'm telling the truth. Who is lying? Who is the scum team?