[Advanced] Blackhoof's Cthulhu Mythos Mafia Game- Day 1

[Myndrunner]

[JF80]

[Myndrunner]

Um.....JF80 has replaced Dapianoplayer?

[Nynaeve]

Hi JF80

[Clovdyx]

Hallia, why did you move to Wombat?

[Hallia]

I felt a little better about Des at the time, but that ended.  I'm not on Womby.

[Clovdyx]

I felt a little better about Des at the time, but that ended.  I'm not on Womby.

 

I know you're not, and that's what concerns me.

[Clovdyx]

Can I get somebody to [v]Unvote[/v] Wombat with me?

 

I still think he's the most likely scum (and intend to move back), but I don't want him hanging around L-1 until Dap checks in.  He cased Despot right before deadline, then disappeared and hasn't said anything during this phase.  I think it would be a mistake to not hear from him.

 

I unvote Wombat and ask for support so we can try to have a discussion with Dap.  I declare my intent to move back to Wombat.  That was not done on accident.

 

 

 

Can I get somebody to [v]Unvote[/v] Wombat with me?

 

I still think he's the most likely scum (and intend to move back), but I don't want him hanging around L-1 until Dap checks in. He cased Despot right before deadline, then disappeared and hasn't said anything during this phase. I think it would be a mistake to not hear from him.

This is gospel truth btw. Having this day go by without Dap commenting at all would be a pretty big disservice to town.

 

[unvote]

 

I owed you anyways Clov

 

 

Two minutes later, Despot obliges. 

 

 

Unvote

 

Three hours later, you move off Despot.  What changed your mind to begin with? 

 

 

I honestly think Mynd is telling the truth, I'm going to trust his judgement.

 

[v] wombat [/v]

 

Two and a half hours from unlynching Despot, you move to Wombat and put the onus on Mynd.  Okay...I can sort of accept that...

 

 

Fwiw I don't think there's really anything to support Dap being silenced this phase, since he hasn't been active in my game either

 

So I don't see a problem with waiting till he can show up if he is able

 

Still think I'm scum Wombat? I could go for a CFD on Hallia. She's blatantly ditching responsibility for making any scumreads of her own

 

I also think it's at least plausible that you're in fact town, and that Dawn TMI slipped. Mynd could be lying or Dap scum here.

 

What you think?

 

[v]Wombat[/v]

 

Let's just get this over with

 

 

We have a dream where 1 out of you is def. scum and you want to band with the other, who you think is scum...for...me?  Thaaat makes no sense.

 

Unvote

 

Vote Des

 

 

Those are the only three posts Despot made after you moved to Wombat, putting him at L-2.  Despot went back to Wombat (which makes sense, given that he's probably not going to self-vote, and I should doubt he's going to convince enough people to CFD onto Dap...), dropping him to L-1. You IMMEDIATELY disregard your trust in Mynd - while still fully accepting he's telling the truth about the dream - , your new found confidence in Des, and move your vote back to Des without another word.

 

Give me your thought process on this, because I can't figure out for the life of me what made you change your mind about Despot enough to switch to Wombat, what Despot said in those three posts to make you think he's scum and Wombat is town, or why I'm getting this feeling you were trying to help cause a lynch ANYWHERE but still be able to wash your hands because, hey,  you unvoted!

[Pralaya]

Des is town guys. Trust me, I know.

 

 

Hallia flipping all over the place looks bad.

 

Red is totally wrong, but she looks town. Too much conviction in his posts to fake as scum.

[Clovdyx]

Des is town guys. Trust me, I know.

 

 

Hallia flipping all over the place looks bad.

 

Red is totally wrong, but she looks town. Too much conviction in his posts to fake as scum.

 

You committing to that?

[Pralaya]

Yep, quite strongly.

[Red2111]

[unvote]

 

[v]Dap[/v]

 

 

obv reasons really but imo its the best lynch now.

 

 

womby is lock!clear for me, i refuse to vote him. not only the gift but also the speed of his lynch and his response to pressure rings legit to me.

 

Mynd claims he has scum out of the three, Dap is the only one unaccounted for now. his corner gives us the most info at this point and clears up the most WIFOM.

 

he flips town we know Despo is the scum and Pral is outted.

 

he flips scum he lock!clears Mynd, Despo and Pral.

 

 

also - if Dap is lurking on purpose, which IMO is what he's doing. people saying "i want to hold off until Dap comes in JIC he looks scummy" is only encouraging him to continue lurking. Womby is the lead train, only reason why he hasn't been hammered is people want to hear from Dap. its win-win for Dap to continue lurking in this case.

[Red2111]

also Pral for a 7th time IM A CHICK

you see where the avatar is, the picture of myself and my husband. it has this helpful info

DM Staff
14,458 posts

Gender: Female
Location: MIssissippi

[Red2111]

also, look at my siggie rotation.

 

Far Dais Mar.  Darren Criss is Sexy.  Red as Lucy for In't WOmens Wedd.  May baby siggie has a chick on it.

 

 

 

also, you might notice something else, alot of hints at being a Red Head in there too.  Red Wolf, Lucy, Red Headed chich in the b-day sig.

 

 

Red = nick name for my hair color

[Nynaeve]

Someone is cranky lol

[dawnflower8]

I think I called Red a guy in the Red Wedding game. Apparently I'm not the only one who's done this.

 

But I've also been called a guy a bunch of times, probably because my avatar is Mat.

[Blackhoof]

Vote Count

 

 

Des(3)- Wombat, Dawn, Hallia

Wombat(6)- Pral, Nervo, Nyn, RTE, mynd, Des

Player(1)- Red

 

 

 

Not voting (4)- Player, TGlems, Clov, Tsuki

 

With 14 players alive, it takes 8 to lynch

 

Deadline: 3AM 6 July EST

Countdown Timer: http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20140706T17&p0=1492&msg=End+of+Day+2&csz=1&swk=1

[Myndrunner]

There seems to be a few players playing the nutshell game with their votes.

 

Wombat will give us the most information, but Hally just jumped to the top of my list for obvious vote hopping.  If it wasn't for my vision deal, i'd push for her. 

 

I'm much more confident in Des at this point based on some recent posts.  I don't like Dap's inactivity hurting us; however, we can look at him after this lynch even if Womby flips scum.  Just because Womby is scum doesn't make Dap town; even though the whole Lenlo push before freezing leads me to believe he is likely town as well. 

 

Wombat is the answer.

[hazelkrs1]

There seems to be a few players playing the nutshell game with their votes.

 

Wombat will give us the most information, but Hally just jumped to the top of my list for obvious vote hopping.  If it wasn't for my vision deal, i'd push for her. 

 

I'm much more confident in Des at this point based on some recent posts.  I don't like Dap's inactivity hurting us; however, we can look at him after this lynch even if Womby flips scum.  Just because Womby is scum doesn't make Dap town; even though the whole Lenlo push before freezing leads me to believe he is likely town as well. 

 

Wombat is the answer.

 

 

Wait, what?!

 

Isn't that PRECISELY what it would mean, according to you?

 

After you claimed to have had your Dream, Clov asked you to make clear, and he VERY SPECIFICALLY asked you if ONLY one person out of the three you mentioned could be scum

 

You said yes, that there was ONE scum out of me, Dap, or Wombat

 

Now.... you're saying that if Wombat ends up being scum, Dap won't necessarily be town?

 

[unvote]

 

[v]Mynd[/v]

 

This thing had been sticking at me for a while, I kept thinking that Mynd could be setting this up perfectly to have town cannibalizing itself by faking a "Dream" like this. Was worried that Wombat would flip town, which would make everyone wanna instalynch me tomorrow.

 

Pretty sure I just caught Mynd in his lie.

[hazelkrs1]

Modified scum list:

 

Mynd

Dawn

Tsuki (who Mynd prob claimed the Dream to get heat off of)

Hallia (completely ditched any responsibility for getting out her own scum reads, and her own flip floppiness makes no sense to me)

[nervositee]

I might be wrong here, but from my memory, Mynd specified pretty clearly it was AT LEAST one scum. Could be two, could be all three.

 

Could you quote where he said it was only one? Tired as hell and hitting bed now, will see tomorrow.

 

Agree with Des' list except switching Mynd with Wombat though. Starting to think Red is town led by Wombat. But I don't think they are both town.

[Myndrunner]

 

Mynd, just so we're 100% clear, you are hardclaiming an investigative result that determined exactly one of Despot, Dap, and Wombat is not town.  Is that completely accurate?

 

At least one is scum.

 

 

Despo.  Keep calm and read above.

[hazelkrs1]

Mynd, just so we're 100% clear, you are hardclaiming an investigative result that determined exactly one of Despot, Dap, and Wombat is not town.  Is that completely accurate?

 

 

 

Mynd, just so we're 100% clear, you are hardclaiming an investigative result that determined exactly one of Despot, Dap, and Wombat is not town.  Is that completely accurate?

 

At least one is scum.

 

 

Well I did misremember, but actually I'm still thinking Mynd is scum

 

I think he said "at least" here to cover his bases

 

Straight up, a Dream DOES NOT work the way he's suggesting- that AT LEAST one will be scum or w/e.

 

Hmm....

 

I'm trying to think about the mechanics of what he's suggesting, so see if it would even be valid

 

I just don't see why you'd have to give three names then, if it doesn't work like a regular dream mechanic at all.

 

Damn. Just looked up the role again. I guess I was wrong

 

Dreamer

 

Abilities

 

Will have a dream each night.

The dream can give a list of 3 people, at least one of whom is mafia.

Or, the dream will say one person who is innocent.

Dreamer does not dream if visited at night.

So, Mynd might be telling the truth after all. My understanding of the role was always that ONLY ONE of the three was actually scum

 

[unvote]

[hazelkrs1]

Well then the thing that sucks is that even if we lynch out of Wombat, Dap, and myself, and we get scum, it DOESN'T clear the other two or Mynd like I thought it would

 

Whelp.

 

[v]Wombat[/v]

 

Guess what it comes down to is I see a lot more resistance to his lynch by people I find suspect, so he's def >rand to be scum imo. If Mynd is telling the truth, then Wombat is our best bet for today. I know I'm town, and I think I've proven many times over my intent to #solve. Lenlo's case and vote on Dap before getting silenced didn't look like distancing, so he's likely town. Leaves Wombat.

 

Red's hardcore defense of him doesn't add up. Getting a gift from someone DOES NOT clear that person as town.

 

Dawn might have TMI slipped on him, but could just be trying to save a scumbuddy and went overboard (even called him the most townie looking person in the game, which was ridiculous and she was not able to support that at all when questioned)

 

Hallia has flip flopped like crazy, but overall I see an eagerness in her to save Wombat. She made no reasoning of her own when placing her initial vote today, just said Wombat's responses "looked good" and voted me without saying ANYTHING about me or Dap.

 

Tsuki has been just blech this whole day phase, and if I'm not mistaken has had his vote parked on me all day. Don't remember him mentioning Wombat at all.

[Myndrunner]

I think we can safely lynch Despo at this point.  After last night's "vision", it was between Despo, Womby, and Dap.  I didn't get a mafia read per se, but at least one of them is not town. 

 

[v] Despo [/v]

 

Vos, RTE, and Red are town. 

 

We need to hear from Tsuki as well.  I only had room for three names. 

 

Despo, this was among my first posts out of the gate on D2.  This was before the onslaught of posting.  It stands out to me that you didn't read this at all.

 

You are correct.  Anyone of those three flipping scum does not clear me at all.  Right now, though, we need to go with who is the best lynch for the town.  My gut is saying Womby is scum, but even if he flips town, we get a TON of info on his flip.  I feel the Dap lynch would be a waste due to his inactivity and Despo wouldn't give us as much info.