Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[csarmi]

@Tsuki: I'm pretty sure I contributed more than you. But go ahead and prove me wrong.

 

Read the thread and come with some decent analysis.

[csarmi]

@Turin: I think I said enough on Despo. Len seems to be adding stuff only when it suits his agenda instead of naturally.

 

Tina wouldn't have disappeared that way.

 

And even without the Thane spew I hate Rags actions.

[hazelkrs1]

No time for a full reread yet atm unfortunately, about to go hiking with the fam

 

But I still feel pretty safe about keeping Csarmi locked in as scum especially after these last two quotes:

 

Pro tip for Mafia.

If you guys wanna mislynch me again, NK Hally now.

 

 

Letting her prove her towniness by stopping another lynch wouldn't be prudent now would it?

 

Trying to act like Hallia has more Governor shots seems to me to be a loltransparent attempt to deter town from lynching him tomorrow

 

Additionally Csarmi is displaying the "stark raving mad" scum defense that seems to be all the rage lately- tells everyone that suspects him that they're terrible at mafia and playing terrible and that ______ are scum because...reasons.

 

Someone have a muzzle?

[hazelkrs1]

@Turin: I think I said enough on Despo. Len seems to be adding stuff only when it suits his agenda instead of naturally.

 

Tina wouldn't have disappeared that way.

 

And even without the Thane spew I hate Rags actions.

 

All you EVER said about me was "Thane spew" which is just turrible reasoning. Thane gave awful reads in general and I called him out for fake scumhunting from the start. Additionally, there's NOTHING that tells us Thane knew who his teammates were, whereas there is a LOT of support for my theory that he knew who the scum roles were so signaled to his teammates that way

[hazelkrs1]

Regardless, I DO want to refresh my grip on this game. Bbl

[csarmi]

Yeah, well, we just lost the benefit, cause tonight a Townie dies, and your team is still at full strength.

You call me a Doofus. Yet you don't even think.

 

Do you understand how Mafia works? Town has to lynch all the Mafia and is given an amount of possible mislynches to achieve that. Tonight the number of mislynches available won't change. We lose nothing and gain info.

 

[This is a simplification cause it doesn't count vig shots]

[Tsukibana]

@Tsuki: I'm pretty sure I contributed more than you. But go ahead and prove me wrong.

 

Read the thread and come with some decent analysis.

 

Why don't you post some real analysis, and something longer than 3 lines that doesn't consist of "FoS on all who don't say I am confirmed town with my bondee-buddy and craptastic Hallia".

[Turin Turambar]

I asked for a gun and some bullets. So I will probably get shot at again.

[csarmi]

Regardless, I DO want to refresh my grip on this game. Bbl

Sure come and do just that.

[Tsukibana]

 

Yeah, well, we just lost the benefit, cause tonight a Townie dies, and your team is still at full strength.

Do you understand how Mafia works? Town has to lynch all the Mafia and is given an amount of possible mislynches to achieve that. Tonight the number of mislynches available won't change. We lose nothing and gain info.

 

 

Explain how being one step closer to LyLo is not changing the number of times? Explain like I am 5 (cause maybe I really don't get it)

[csarmi]

@Tsuki: I'm trying my best but I can only post and read from phone.

[Hallia]

I don't even care.  Lynch me tomorrow.  I'm done with being called names.

[Tsukibana]

@Tsuki: I'm trying my best but I can only post and read from phone.

Since when?

[csarmi]

 

 

 

Yeah, well, we just lost the benefit, cause tonight a Townie dies, and your team is still at full strength.

Do you understand how Mafia works? Town has to lynch all the Mafia and is given an amount of possible mislynches to achieve that. Tonight the number of mislynches available won't change. We lose nothing and gain info.

 

 

Explain how being one step closer to LyLo is not changing the number of times? Explain like I am 5 (cause maybe I really don't get it)

Assume we were 8-4 today. Two mislynches (barring saves and vigs) to lose.

 

Tomorrow it should be 7-4 then. Still two mislynches to lose.

 

See? It doesn't change.

 

Welcome to the realm of the odd numbers.

[csarmi]

 

 

@Tsuki: I'm trying my best but I can only post and read from phone.

Since when?

Since when I can't sit cause of my discus hernia.

[csarmi]

I don't even care. Lynch me tomorrow. I'm done with being called names.

I don't think you were called names.

 

Please play on and add what you can.

[csarmi]

 

 

Letting her prove her towniness by stopping another lynch wouldn't be prudent now would it?

GOD D**** How do people NOT see this - SHE CLAIMED 1X SHOT, DOOFUS.

 

 

All these scum tells, lies, and slips... ugh. You are the second person to imply that she has more shots than stated: Hallia did so, and everyone called me nuts :/

Well I hope she has more shots.

[Hallia]

 

@Tsuki: I'm pretty sure I contributed more than you. But go ahead and prove me wrong.

 

Read the thread and come with some decent analysis.

 

Why don't you post some real analysis, and something longer than 3 lines that doesn't consist of "FoS on all who don't say I am confirmed town with my bondee-buddy and craptastic Hallia".

 

 

It's been a rough week.  I'll take a bit and try Csarmi, but I'm just having a hard time.

[csarmi]

I'm sure Tsuki doesn't mean that. Everyone loves you.

 

#itisknown

[csarmi]

Hally you did the right and protown thing and saved me even though it'd be easier for me to be dead cause this game is poisonous...

 

I'll bear it. Please do the same.

[Turin Turambar]

@csarmi. Disagree. If you are town miller and have unpopular opinions information wise it would be better for town for you to.be dead. Then it gives everyone more reason to read your opinions knowing you are town. I think you would even say so if it wasn't you. A miller should not be kept alive there.

 

A town governor would know that too. It is the same reason she used to not save Mynd. But now it is different?

 

@Hallia, sorry for whatever you are going thru but.look on the bright side. You didn't get called rabid multiple times.

[TheRagnarok]

So the rest of this game is going to be Csarmi acting horrendously condescending to everyone?  Fun times. 

 

I'm actually leaning more towards Hallia being a townie who didn't(imo) make very good use of her ability. 

[csarmi]

No it wouldn't be better. That'd be a mislynch lost. If there were one player more alive maybe.

 

Also this is really the last time I'm gonna mention it and from now on I'll just laugh my ass off @you.

 

I'm the most confirmed and obvious town in this game.

 

If you can't see that you should RTFG.

[csarmi]

Hallt did use her action best.

[csarmi]

But no one cares to. That's be work right. Also ira the scums best interest not to.

 

Get the hell away from me.