Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Turin Turambar]

I feel like I'm going to have to reconsider my reads on a LOT of people now. Just a hunch.

Interested to see what changes.

[Krakalakachkn]

Someone kill the Role Blocker tonight.  I'm not meant to be caged. 

 

 

Krak needs to fly freeeeee!

[Turin Turambar]

I think we just lynched him Tbh. Well if you are town anyway.

 

 

Also, it makes good sense to save the first mafia lynched. Numbers are getting close. I think this pretty much confirms hallia and csarmi as mafia.

 

Hallia didn't make a peep about asking if she should save him. And she was absent at EoD.

[Hallia]

Because I think he's town.  I finally felt good about using it.  Lynch me tomorrow if you want, but don't blame me being absent on EoD, tis worktime for me until just a few ago.

[Turin Turambar]

Hopefully someone will just shoot you tonight. Or csarmi.

What did you think of csarmi downgrading his chae town read by 10% after krak voted him?

[Krakalakachkn]

I was pretty surprised even with him being such a Grumpy Gus at EoD.

[Tsukibana]

 

CSarmi, Hallia, Chak, and Pralaya - I said it day one.

 

The wording of the scene doesn't make you reconsider that at all?

 

No, I don't - especially since "The Prince of Bohemia" (Hallia) just impersonated the Queen. Or do you think that Basel messed up on fluff like that?

 

(that was including Tsuki btw, if it wasn't obvious)

 

She lied about her character.

[Tsukibana]

Hmm - quote fail, DM.

[Krakalakachkn]

 

 

CSarmi, Hallia, Chak, and Pralaya - I said it day one.

 

The wording of the scene doesn't make you reconsider that at all?

 

No, I don't - especially since "The Prince of Bohemia" (Hallia) just impersonated the Queen. Or do you think that Basel messed up on fluff like that?

 

(that was including Tsuki btw, if it wasn't obvious)

 

She lied about her character.

 

 

 

Could you explain that a little clearer?

[Tsukibana]

Hallia claimed Prince of Bohemia as character - Pardon scene said that Lestrade got a Pardon from Queen Victoria - do you people not pay attention?

[Tsukibana]

And yet Hallia says SHE did the pardon...

Need I spell it out...

[csarmi]

Yea I don't get to sleep tonight.

 

Seriously no idea what to do. I can't take painkiller cause of my medication and this sort of tension headache has never went away before on its own.

 

---

 

The level of obtuse is hurting me.

 

@Turin - I reevaluated my read earlier. I posted it after Krak's vote (which was quite bad esp the reasoning given) cause that made me the likely lynch.

 

@Tsuki - have you read the scene? Its pretty clear that someone convinced Victoria to give the pardon.

[Krakalakachkn]

The "friends in high places" bit could mean that to be sure.  I don't know about it being "pretty clear"

[csarmi]

Well that's my interpretation anyway. Simple and sensible.

[csarmi]

And yet Hallia says SHE did the pardon...

Need I spell it out...

Please do. Hally claims a character that - with a stretch of imagination - could even be scum. Surely she fake claimed that instead of Queen Victoria (who must be scum I suppose).

[csarmi]

The scene simply doesn't tell us the character of the governor (as it shpuldnt ). Could be anyone in "high places".

[Tsukibana]

Oh please. Just quit it. The only question is who your final team-mate is.

[Krakalakachkn]

Damn.  I wouldn't mind being in "high places" right now.

[csarmi]

Oh please. Just quit it. The only question is who your final team-mate is.

Are you even thinking?

[csarmi]

 

Oh please. Just quit it. The only question is who your final team-mate is.

Are you even thinking?

Reading maybe?

[Tsukibana]

 

 

Oh please. Just quit it. The only question is who your final team-mate is.

Are you even thinking?

Reading maybe?

 

 

Read this: YOU ARE SCUM.

[Basel Gill]

Side note to everyone. Scenes are flavour. Don't try to solve the game going by them. Especially when I'm going to have to write them all without the central character... you know, the bloke that this game is named after.

[Hallia]

Annnnnd Tsuki's whole point goes out the window

[Tsukibana]

Except my whole point started Day One. Nice try. Only one small detail is made irrelevant.

You used your pardon to save a wine-laden Miller (supposedly), who has been playing very anti-town, ADMITTED he is playing like crap due to RL issues and unable to give fulll focus to the game... rather than let him go down and let his lynch provide info on the people who vote him, and get people perhaps focused on others (I know if he had flipped Town, I might have reconsidered my reads on the Scum!Four I got right now), you have ensured that Town spends yet another day filled with wine and BS because he is playing like shit, and needs to be lynched. That is the WORST move I have ever seen. YOU ARE SCUM. And not even GOAT - just goat  - Baaahhhd at it.

[csarmi]

Tsuki you're either Mafia or town playing very bad right now... Your list has zero Mafia on it I think.

 

Recalibrate your scumdar.

 

Also I played decidedly pro-town. You are the one playing like shit.

 

Hally is GOAT for saving me... And almost surely town.