Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[csarmi]

 

 

I told you I'm not Mafia. Any further push without an actual vote will be treated as a scum claim.

 

You disagree?

 

Let's lynch XY.

 

Oh and csarmi is scummy.

 

If you doubt a miller (which you shouldn't BTW) you should get it out of the way asap. Instead of hedging in lynches.

You had the whole day to vote me.

 

Turin stinks.

LOL

[csarmi]

Quote fail.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Thane, Irene Adler, Mafia Symp, has been lynched

 

It is now night.

 

Deadline for night actions is tomorrow, Tuesday June 24th at 9 PM EST.

 

Scene and countdown timer coming in about 6 hours when Basel gets back online.

[Hallia]

Phew! Glad I didn't do him

[csarmi]

Hah.

[Niniel]

Hi Rags! Great to see you again. 

 

Maybe cause this game is one of the last things to give my life any sense of normality right now.

 

I really wish rl will get better for you. 

 

 

Pral - I think I have pointed out clear enough who I am suspicious of. 

[csarmi]

Now that might be very helpful indeed.

 

Question is who knew what and when.

 

Hally, what do you think?

[Niniel]

Thane, Irene Adler, Mafia Symp, has been lynched

 

It is now night.

 

Deadline for night actions is tomorrow, Tuesday June 24th at 9 PM EST.

 

Scene and countdown timer coming in about 6 hours when Basel gets back online.

 

Ninja´d by the mod.  Yay!

[csarmi]

Thanks Tina I'll be trying to stay afloat.

[Hallia]

Turin did just say he really didn't think he was scum

[Hallia]

And oh, look at Tsukis position on the train

[csarmi]

Does that contradict his former reads, Hally?

[csarmi]

He's the last to vote before Thane. So?

[Hallia]

When it gets close, and we lynch scum I'most suspicious of the end of the train

[Hallia]

Does that contradict his former reads, Hally?

I'm going to go do a reread, but I do believe it does

[Turin Turambar]

I guess there is at least some non-canon there based on the Thane situation. Despo gets +5 internets
 

This theme will focus on the literary Holmes canon as written by Arthur Conan Doyle. Holmes stories in other media, and/or written works by other authors, may come into the game but don't count on it.

 

 
Players:
1. Thrax Dice 2.0
2. Len
3. Mynd Wiggins, Town 1-shot Gladiator, lynched D1
4. Dawn NotBob
5. Tina
6. Turin
7. Despo
8. Hally: Governor, KIng of Bohemia
9. ChaeKrak: JOAT, no name
10. IthiRags: 
11. Thane:  Irene Adler, mafia symp
12. Tsuki
13. Dice Toby the Dog, Town 2-shot Oracle, killed N1
14. Charis/BFG: VT, Henry Baskerville
15. Pral
16. Salami: MILLER, Thadeus Stolto

 

Yes, I was wrong about Adler and therefore about Thane. I would say this makes BFG look better but I would still be willing to lynch any of the other 3 claimed people (Csarmi, Hallia, Chrak)

 

Csarmi did soft defend Thane before voting him in a prime bus position. His "confirmed because I say so" line is pure bluster. As is the "if you push me without a vote it's a scumclaim" .My vote will go here in the morning. So I guess that makes me town. I haven't bought the Miller claim from the start so w/e. Maybe now there is enough support to put your non-helpful self down. 

 

Hallia: still don't like any of her plays this game. From the misrep in the way she claimed to her trying to act confirmed to the latest bits in the last few pages. If i had a vig shot it would be on her. 

 

Chrak: Can't believe the logic of bypassing your ONE MAFIA READ of D1 to take a shot at me. At least you didn't kill anyone that could help town. Small victory for me I think. I would still like to get your character name. It now makes little difference as the last flip shows so why not?

[Hallia]

Why not use your NK?

[csarmi]

Do you deny my logic Turin?

 

Please tell me how it would make sense for me to claim Miller in a role madness game there and then if I was Mafia.

[csarmi]

Just think about how stupid is that. The real miller (if any.. and pretty likely to exist one here of all games) cc's and I'd have managed to die and confirm a town hindrance role.

 

In what world that makes sense, I dunno.

[Hallia]

*nodnod* I can't help but agree with you there Csarmeh

[Turin Turambar]

Who already got shot at and lived? Oh yes. Me.

 

I already explained my thought process on your claim Csarmi. It makes perfect sense for YOU to do it as it abuses your early claim meta to a T and also follows the little black book of Darthe Mafia. Therefore you get to coast by early game and it becomes a big risk to lynch late due to numbers. A mafia was found today so we are in a better spot to remove the WIFOM that is your presence. 

 

Plus your play has been bad. Seriously, directing a vig shot onto a nearly consensus town player on D1. Is a lucky thing I didn't die. Of course then you would have been run up immediately today then) You trusted Chae enough to follow blindly onto the Len train but didn't trust her "great instincts" to shoot her lone scum read? 

[Hallia]

Says you and Des who have been constantly trying to direct vig shots?

[csarmi]

Why do you ignore the fact that I'd be say 75% to draw a cc there?

 

And I thought you were scum. I still do in fact.

 

And we found no Mafia. We found a symp.

[csarmi]

And Turin.

 

How on earth would I know Chae was the vig I'm directing?

 

I think I got you there man. You're trying to fit facts to your theory not the other way around.

 

Guess who does that?

 

 

Oops.

[csarmi]

Not gonna bold that from phone for you guys but pls read Turin there carefully.