Sherlock Holmes Role Madness Mafia Town wins

[Tsukibana]

His incarnation - He was Town, now he is scum.

[TheRagnarok]

Just finished Lenlo.  Townie lean, Thane and Chae have been his top two pretty consistently, seems to be trying to solve the game.  I did notice the fence sitting, but it came across as a townie who trusts his reads more than a scum acting like they are just so distraught.

 

Working on Chaelca right now as both you and Len have named her as top scum suspect.

 

So Mynd did the gladiator?  That...is hilarious.

 

On Hallia...was she pushed into claiming that or was it out of nowhere?  And how did she act once she claimed?

Why notbob?

[Tsukibana]

Hallia claimed out of nowhere, then tossed the decision to use the pardon into everyone else's hands.

[TheRagnarok]

Decided to read csarmi before Chae.  Something standing out very quickly is how he keeps answering questions asked by Thane and Chae and asking them very safe questions.  Also brings up how Thane plays scummy as town.  And says he thinks Chae truly believes what she is saying.  On the Ithi/Mynd thing, he comes across as overplaying his 'golly gee guys, I'm just so conflicted!'. 

 

Scum lean. 

[Hallia]

@Rags

 

Csarmi claimed Miller right outta the gate

 

Thanes been run up twice but not lynched because Ithi suddenly picked a fight with Mynd and Mynd Gladiatored her. Mynd lost.

 

Lenofinger fence sat during all this pouting cause he didn't wanna vote eith ithi or mynd.

Hallia revealed saying she was a govenor, but did it like she was leaving it up to us to decide if she should save the loser Gladiator. Did a weird sudden shift from liking Ithi to voting Ithi. I dont believe her

 

I was killed. Was Oracle.

 

My scum list consists of Hallia NotBob Chae and Tsuki. Tsuki is recent and is really because of his tone lately.

 

hope that helps

 

The way Tsuki and I are going at it, you think we're on a team?

 

@Rags - It was most certainly not out of nowhere.  There were people saying it was possibly town on town violence between the two of them.  I at the time agreed, and had a way for them both to live, so I said something.

[TheRagnarok]

Got Chae done.  Scum lean with Csarmi and Thane.  Lots of reasons as have been posted already.  Especially the lolvote for herself.

[TheRagnarok]

 

@Rags

 

Csarmi claimed Miller right outta the gate

 

Thanes been run up twice but not lynched because Ithi suddenly picked a fight with Mynd and Mynd Gladiatored her. Mynd lost.

 

Lenofinger fence sat during all this pouting cause he didn't wanna vote eith ithi or mynd.

Hallia revealed saying she was a govenor, but did it like she was leaving it up to us to decide if she should save the loser Gladiator. Did a weird sudden shift from liking Ithi to voting Ithi. I dont believe her

 

I was killed. Was Oracle.

 

My scum list consists of Hallia NotBob Chae and Tsuki. Tsuki is recent and is really because of his tone lately.

 

hope that helps

 

The way Tsuki and I are going at it, you think we're on a team?

 

@Rags - It was most certainly not out of nowhere.  There were people saying it was possibly town on town violence between the two of them.  I at the time agreed, and had a way for them both to live, so I said something.

 

So why did you choose not to?

[Hallia]

By the end of it, I wanted the flip, we needed information, otherwise feel D2 would've just been a continuation of same.

[TheRagnarok]

By the end of it, I wanted the flip, we needed information, otherwise feel D2 would've just been a continuation of same.

But if you knew that it was Mynd who did it, wouldn't the benefit of the doubt go with Mynd being town?

[Hallia]

Not necessarily.  The only other time we've ever had a gladiator (that I've seen) was mafia.  

[TheRagnarok]

Not necessarily.  The only other time we've ever had a gladiator (that I've seen) was mafia.  

Ah ok.  That would make more sense. 

[TheRagnarok]

Reading through Tsuki now.  Doo doo dooooooo.

 

Y'all boring. 

[dicetosser1]

By the end of it, I wanted the flip, we needed information, otherwise feel D2 would've just been a continuation of same.

 

that and the fact she asked people whether or not to do it and most said no.

 

 

@ hally  can you say distancing?

 

 

@notbob  oh believe me i could still vote thane   right now  as said im not liking tsukis posting. suddenly over agressive and now slightly petulant.

 

 

@tsuki  sorry mate but my alignment hasnt changed

[Hallia]

 

@Rags

 

Csarmi claimed Miller right outta the gate

 

Thanes been run up twice but not lynched because Ithi suddenly picked a fight with Mynd and Mynd Gladiatored her. Mynd lost.

 

Lenofinger fence sat during all this pouting cause he didn't wanna vote eith ithi or mynd.

Hallia revealed saying she was a govenor, but did it like she was leaving it up to us to decide if she should save the loser Gladiator. Did a weird sudden shift from liking Ithi to voting Ithi. I dont believe her

 

I was killed. Was Oracle.

 

My scum list consists of Hallia NotBob Chae and Tsuki. Tsuki is recent and is really because of his tone lately.

 

hope that helps

 

The way Tsuki and I are going at it, you think we're on a team?

 

@Rags - It was most certainly not out of nowhere.  There were people saying it was possibly town on town violence between the two of them.  I at the time agreed, and had a way for them both to live, so I said something.

 

 

 

Why avoid the question Dice?

[Hallia]

Just distancing?  I think it goes a little further than that.

[Turin Turambar]

@Turin

 

 

Chae submitted a vig shot on you and it failed.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Seriously tho. That was a bad choice. What happened to her firm view that Lenlo was mafia?

 

She took a shot at me, but I'm still alive.  What are the odds of that?

 

Did the mod really tell you that the shot failed? that seems odd. Usually it is left to you to figure out what happened once your bullet left the gun. I find this a lot odd.

 

 

Since you have claimed JOAT already and were willing to give your used action and target, Can we get your name?

[TheRagnarok]

Just read through Tsuki.  He goes in my happy townie pile.

[Turin Turambar]

 

And then the third alternative is that you and Ithi are both scum.   If that is the case, then I gladly fall on my sword because my body won't even be stiff before the two of you are in the noose.

 

I know I am town. No way in heck you gonna get me lynched. Mafia is gonna have to NK me this game.  So it looks like you will be dead by nightfall. maybe you will convince Hallia to save you, LOL.

I only said that mafia would need to NK me, I never said I would make it easy, LMAO

 

Welcome to the game Rags. Congrats on being town. 

 

 

@Chrak, Since you have read the thread now, Do you agree with Chae selecting me for a shot? When her reason for finding me mafia is Csarmi said so?

 

Anyone want to claim the Dice kill? I am wondering all sorts of things now.

 

Oh Hallia, does a game with multiple potential 1x vigs sound like a game with lots of killing potential?  Or maybe it is multiple mafia teams? or just a good old fashioned Serial Killer. The last two would make more sense than the first to me. But I do have a special thinking hat.

 

WTL: Chrak, Hallia, Csarmi, NotBob, Lenlo.  Not interested in Thane, Pral, Tsuki, Rags   

 

I may have missed some of you. Has been a long three days.

[Turin Turambar]

Just distancing?  I think it goes a little further than that.

Please stop with the combination self meta and "mafia would never..." defenses. The best distancing is over the top. knock down drag out battling because it is supposed to look real. 

[Turin Turambar]

This has to do with Hallia and her claim. The first quoted post is the announcement of the official challenge. On this page and the previous one the ONLY people posting were Mynd, Ithi, Csarmi and myself. Mynd seems to believe that Ithi would be mafia or else why would he challenge her if he was town as he flipped? I thought Mynd was mafia pushing a bad angle on low hanging fruit, I think Ithi thought the same. Csarmi can speak for himself. 

********************** A challenge has been issued. **************************

Today's lynch is a choice now between Mynd and Ithi. Any votes currently on other players will be reset.

***please do not post while the votes are reset***

 

The first person to mention the 1v1 as town vs. town is............ Hallia. 

The last time we had a gladiator they were scum. It's entirely possible Turin put them both up knowing it was town on town violence.

 

The only other person to suggest it is Lenlo. He wants to vote Chae. Why want to vote her so bad? you still wanna? 

 

Her and Len seem to think I'm the way to go - but they haven't managed to place a vote yet.

What ARE they waiting for I wonder.

Stop. Misrepping. Me. I dont think your the way to go, I dont think Mynd is the way to go I WANT TO VOTE CHAE BUT I CANT ANYMORE.

 

 

Hallia immediately pops up with a question of how sure is Len that both are town cause she can "derail the thunderdome" which is in itself a misrep. In thecontext it is given it implies that she can nullify the challenge allowing anyone to vote for anyone. At least that is how I read it.

Len, how sure are you that they're both town? Because I can derail the thunder dome.

 

Len says he is pretty sure. He then gives exactly three scum reads. I would have expected to get 4 mafia spots or for him to say not sure on the fourth. food for thought I guess,

 

Len, how sure are you that they're both town? Because I can derail the thunder dome.

Im pretty sure. I dont think Ithi or Mynd are scum, I still think those spots belong to Chae, Thane and X.

 

 

Again with the implication that she can end the challenge which is not what her role can do. At least if she is being honest in her claim.

I won't end it if I'm not fairly confident that they're both town.

 

Now we get her claim of Governor. Followedlater by her character claim of the king of bohemia. The true bad guy n the Irene Adler story ironcially

A governer can pardon the lynched person.



You were saying?

So IMO the claim was pretty much out of nowhere. Hallia brought up the town v. town aspect. She asked for one person to agree and claimed to be able to stop the challenge if she thought that both were town. She apparently did think Mynd town and Ithi not since she voted along with Mynd but then decided not to save him because she wanted a flip. So I guess she wasn't too convinced Mynd truly was town after all. Otherwise she would have saved him and dealt with the heat. 

 

No She created the discussion and claimed before there was much consensus about both players being town. Then proceeded to paint herself as confirmed town because she claimed governor.

[TheRagnarok]

Got through Turin.  Townie lean, but I just have this bad juju feel.  Dunno how to put my finger on it.

[TheRagnarok]

Got through Turin.  Townie lean, but I just have this bad juju feel.  Dunno how to put my finger on it.

It may just be the mild headache I got at going through so much text.

[Hallia]

I did what I think was best.  Sorry you disagree.

 

By DERAIL, that's what I could've done, no matter how you misconstrue it.  

[Turin Turambar]

Sorry Rags. But you are solid town for me. 

 

 

Have you read Despo yet? He has actually been less verbose so you might not grow your headache.

[Turin Turambar]

I did what I think was best.  Sorry you disagree.

 

By DERAIL, that's what I could've done, no matter how you misconstrue it.  

pardon the loser =/= Derail. 

 

At least to me it doesn't. To me Derail would be to remove the challenge altogether and allow open voting again. Do you wish to deny that you were the one that brought it up as being town on town?