[Advanced] Red Wedding Mafia - Post Game, MakersMark

[_CLOUD]

@AJ: Sure he can hide for the majority of the game but sooner or later people will get fed up with his attitude and lynch him anyway. More importantly however it isn't a good idea to be in a "perma-catch-up mode" when you are mafia because you won't be able to influence the other players in the thread.

 

@Mynd: And what if he really ended up forgetting about it? Maybe the dude just has a bad memory. His explanation seemed genuine to me and I find it silly to lynch a person over such a whimsical thing.

[_CLOUD]

^ I meant to say Tom instead of Mynd.

[Andrej]

More scum spewage lol

 

Out more of your team, plz.

[Tommyrod]

If Krak is scum then Cloud goes into the vig rand

[Andrej]

Him not being present in thread fits rather nicely with Mynd's theory that scum hydras can have more influence since they are two players. Krak doesn't need to be present to influence events when you and Amega can, yes?

[_CLOUD]

More scum spewage lol

 

Out more of your team, plz.

 

[Tommyrod]

@AJ: Sure he can hide for the majority of the game but sooner or later people will get fed up with his attitude and lynch him anyway. More importantly however it isn't a good idea to be in a "perma-catch-up mode" when you are mafia because you won't be able to influence the other players in the thread.

 

@Mynd: And what if he really ended up forgetting about it? Maybe the dude just has a bad memory. His explanation seemed genuine to me and I find it silly to lynch a person over such a whimsical thing.

It seems unlikely to me that you could be THAT confident that his reaction was genuine when it looks bad to multiple people.

[Yates]

take what Yates is saying now about me, instead of casing me hes tryign to insight me to argue with him by flinging insults at my intellegence and going all argo at me not being lynched.  i see this as a tactic, not him actually trying to berate me or be mean to me.

Uh... what? What am I saying about you now? This is important because I need you post IN THREAD that you are going to do something and understand that if you don't you will be lynched. Just FYI.

[Cory Caboose]

Cory, I'll be miffed if Jack is scum btw :(

If he is he won't get to endgame anyway :P

 

Mynd pretty much has to be Mafia because of jump into Day 2. He did not know how to react to the Nolder kill and since he knew DesBat was town knew he was next on the lynch list. So he made up a bad story about the NK but forgot to remove his fear of being lynched.

 

He thought DesBat faction killed Nolder so that he would be speedlynched after... Nolder flipped town?

 

He was clearly just afraid of being lynched par DesBat's and flailed a bad theory of DesBat being Mafia trying to game Darthe's flavor.

[_CLOUD]

 

@AJ: Sure he can hide for the majority of the game but sooner or later people will get fed up with his attitude and lynch him anyway. More importantly however it isn't a good idea to be in a "perma-catch-up mode" when you are mafia because you won't be able to influence the other players in the thread.

 

@Mynd: And what if he really ended up forgetting about it? Maybe the dude just has a bad memory. His explanation seemed genuine to me and I find it silly to lynch a person over such a whimsical thing.

It seems unlikely to me that you could be THAT confident that his reaction was genuine when it looks bad to multiple people.

 

 

I don't care. Just because more people believe something doesn't mean that it's right.

[Nynaeve]

 

Cory, I'll be miffed if Jack is scum btw :(

If he is he won't get to endgame anyway :P

 

Mynd pretty much has to be Mafia because of jump into Day 2. He did not know how to react to the Nolder kill and since he knew DesBat was town knew he was next on the lynch list. So he made up a bad story about the NK but forgot to remove his fear of being lynched.

 

He thought DesBat faction killed Nolder so that he would be speedlynched after... Nolder flipped town?

 

He was clearly just afraid of being lynched par DesBat's and flailed a bad theory of DesBat being Mafia trying to game Darthe's flavor.

 

 

*THIS

 

 

 

Nyn

[Cory Caboose]

 

take what Yates is saying now about me, instead of casing me hes tryign to insight me to argue with him by flinging insults at my intellegence and going all argo at me not being lynched.  i see this as a tactic, not him actually trying to berate me or be mean to me.

Uh... what? What am I saying about you now? This is important because I need you post IN THREAD that you are going to do something and understand that if you don't you will be lynched. Just FYI.

Please don't - I can't sit through another of Red's "why everyone in the game is Mafia" posts.

[Tommyrod]

So wagons are Mynd Krak Dawn today?

[Andrej]

Mynd/Dawn/MegaLoud/Krak

 

Best choices for lynch today and then vig for tonight IMO.

 

Verdict is still out on the 5th.

 

X has sort of pinged me lately.

 

He's posted a lot, but a lot of his 'cases' are other people's points. I'm also uncomfortable with how his cases are all on the player with the most scrutiny at the time. I haven't seen anything original from him.

[Red2111]

 

take what Yates is saying now about me, instead of casing me hes tryign to insight me to argue with him by flinging insults at my intellegence and going all argo at me not being lynched.  i see this as a tactic, not him actually trying to berate me or be mean to me.

Uh... what? What am I saying about you now? This is important because I need you post IN THREAD that you are going to do something and understand that if you don't you will be lynched. Just FYI.

 

 

in the beginning of the post you quoted i stated that i was on page 84.  if something happened between this page (103) and that page (84) i've obviously not read it yet and cannot post about it.

 

to the point i'm up to on reading this thread (page 84) the only thing i've seen from you is more pressuring on Mynd and an "EF you guys for not lynching Red, now i have to listen to more of her asnine logic) and goign all argo about me still being alive.

 

just chill, i'll get caught up when i get caught up, my job and my comprehensive finale in Calc 1 takes precedences over this game.

[_CLOUD]

Krak is a strong player and if he was mafia who accidentally slipped up by casing the dead then I don't see him saying that he remembered DesBat dying but not Nolder. I would see him sooner saying that he hadn't seen the Coroner's Report at all. You guys can believe whatever you want though. It has become clear that I'm not able to convince you other wise.

[Andrej]

Red - basically all you need to know is to protect Yates until you die. K?

[Andrej]

With that I must depart for class.

 

BBL.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

 

@AJ: Sure he can hide for the majority of the game but sooner or later people will get fed up with his attitude and lynch him anyway. More importantly however it isn't a good idea to be in a "perma-catch-up mode" when you are mafia because you won't be able to influence the other players in the thread.

 

@Mynd: And what if he really ended up forgetting about it? Maybe the dude just has a bad memory. His explanation seemed genuine to me and I find it silly to lynch a person over such a whimsical thing.

It seems unlikely to me that you could be THAT confident that his reaction was genuine when it looks bad to multiple people.

I don't care. Just because more people believe something doesn't mean that it's right.

CorJay: posts like the above show me that Cloud isn't overly concerned with how he appears ITT. I believe if he was scum and all of CorRayJay was harassing him to drop a read, he would want to slowly back down from it if he knew he would eventually look bad when Krak flips.

[Tommyrod]

Krak is a strong player and if he was mafia who accidentally slipped up by casing the dead then I don't see him saying that he remembered DesBat dying but not Nolder. I would see him sooner saying that he hadn't seen the Coroner's Report at all. You guys can believe whatever you want though. It has become clear that I'm not able to convince you other wise.

Ditto here. He's basically telling us to stuff it. Dunno if he has the balls.

[Cory Caboose]

Cloud is the one thing that me and AJ have (lightly) disagreed about this game. I think he's town here as well, but AJ has brought up some good points.

A Krak scumflip WOULD look awful for him though.

[Hallia]

I mean look at him, he's Frank effin Underwood. He does nothing by mistake

[Red2111]

Red - basically all you need to know is to protect Yates until you die. K?

 

me puttign my ass on the line for soemone on this game (ie: protecting them, since i'd ake their kill and all) depends on if i think their scum or town.  at this point, Yates is one of the last people i'd protect becuase i'm getting a strong scum ping from him.  this may change when i get fully caught up ofcourse.  a lot has likely happened in 20 pages.

[Cory Caboose]

Red, Yates is the Vig.

Please die for town as soon as possible.

[Yates]

Red, Yates is the Vig.

Please die for town as soon as possible.

I know people post things like "lol" and don't actually mean it. I LITERALLY laughed out loud.

 

Good stuff.