[Advanced] Red Wedding Mafia - Post Game, MakersMark

[Nolder]

 

 

Oye, none of you are a bloody god compared to me so listen up. You dont use a bloody thing outside this game to determine anything, I dont give a rats arse if youre highborn or the stableboy.

 

Also, bloody vote count incoming. Bleedin women wont even allow a man a good nights sleep, thats treason to my ears.

You know it's **** like this that totally justifies the stereotype at JN.

 

 

Not even going to pretend I know what you're talking about 

 

Go take a nap.

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

 

Shh, I'm in character.

Yes, we are Roslin Frey.

 

How does that make you town exactly? Shes a Frey, you know, the family who murdered everyone at the wedding? So what if your the bride, that doesnt auto town you.

 

 

YUPPPPP Lenlo is scum. Book it. Tress never made it seem like she was autotown because of the character claim. Blatant misrep right thur Lenlofinger

 

I never said she made it seem like that. I didnt feel like quoting everything everyone said about it so I said my general feelings towards it. Besides anyone character claiming is most likely hoping it will make them autotown, such as when someone called her LOCKCLEAR with her claim earlier.

 

So no im not misrepping anything. If I wanted to misrep it btw why would I quote it for everyone to see right there? Makes it rather hard to misrep if everyone can read the original. Would be much better to just say it so that the lazy people dont go back and read it. So you and your book are wrong.

 

As for you disliking my catchup posts thats natural. I have you/Wombat as leaning scum along with people you might think are town. You dont care about the points, just that I am aiming at dif people than you.

 

 

lol nope Lenlo you're outing yourself more and more with every post. You said "that doesn't autotown you"... why point this out in a game in which Darthe made it clear he would give scum team fake claims?

 

Obviously NO character claims will "autotown" someone. And you OBVIOUSLY were trying to make it seem like she did think she was autotown.

 

Keep howling Lenlo. I LERVE watching you squirm as scum!

 

#notcreepyatall

 

Wait he gave them fakeclaims? Did I miss this? Or was this in the rules section and I just forgot it?

 

Also Des, trust me I would be doing whole lot more if I /finally/ got scum. I want it so much.

[Nolder]

 

 

That sort of outside-of-the-game wager is against the rules on other sites and is against the spirit of the game in general, but for the sake of fantasy, what is it you want to bet?

I dunno that I've seen much of this kind of thing here but it makes sense that it would be against the rules in general.

I wonder if Verbal could be persuaded to make a thread addressing this.

 

 

 

 

I'm sorry I've been posting. I was sick and was at the hospital till now. I'm feeling better. I'll read tomorrow for sure and definitely post. Sorry about it.

The hospital? Must've been a mean cold. Glad you're ok and welcome back to the game.

 

 

 

 

Oye, none of you are a bloody god compared to me so listen up. You dont use a bloody thing outside this game to determine anything, I dont give a rats arse if youre highborn or the stableboy.

 

Also, bloody vote count incoming. Bleedin women wont even allow a man a good nights sleep, thats treason to my ears.

You know it's **** like this that totally justifies the stereotype at JN.

 

 

Oh look, three more posts from Nolder about just stuff in general, and nothing actually relevant to this game.

 

Why aren't we lynching this guy again?

 

HURR DURR DURR UR SO FUNNEH

 

Seriously you pick out three posts of mine that aren't directly related to the game at hand and want to lynch me for them?

You'd have to lynch everyone else first because no one is staying entirely on topic. And no one would want them to.

Games without any humor or casual conversation are just as boring as games with too much.

If you have a problem with what I've said that's just too damn bad.

[Nolder]

 

 

I already know in my heart of hearts that this game is going to be a disaster.

 

My WIM overinflated and popped

 

I feel like this is my home game right now so I'm going to try to give it another runthrough but we've already had people trying to make bets and an asburd amount of #DartheTalk about hydras and other non-game related rubbish

 

Ugh

 

I ran out of steam after my win in the other game. Are we playing CAH or what?

 

I love that game.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

So Mynd, which is it? Should we be looking for the person doing the most antitown things this game, or should we focus solely on the hydras like you kept stressing over and over? Or was the hydra thing just something for you to talk about to look like you were being active?

 

 

Lemme try in simple speak:  Which hydra do you see as the most scummy? <-------This is exactly what I just asked you.

 

 

 

I have been very open about my thoughts on various players.

 

How many times can I say I'm not playing your game before you just stop trying to funnel the convo that way?

 

 

@des. Why am I on your list?

 

 

I think you've been hiding this game. You've acted like you're in permacatchup mode, even tho you've commented on recent things a few times. You've done more nudging and parroting than actual scumhunting.

 

Why does everyone want to kill the hydras so much just because they are hydras?

 

Mynd =/= Everyone

 

Stop trying to nudge the idea along further

 

Interesting.

 

 

Here's a conundrum imo.

Her "allegiance" is to Frey, the obvious bad guys here but Roslin herself was not a "bad person" iirc but she WAS aware of the plan and allowed it to go forward. There's also the consideration that she was married to a Tully so would that change anything?

 

How do we consider this? As a "bad" character or a "good" one?

 

 

How about this: I'll pay as much attention to character claims as I normally do. Which is to say none at all. Darthe has given out safe claims. Scum aren't going to claim the obviously bad guys. And everyone's alignment in this series is already somewhat ambiguous, that's sort of the point of it.

 

So basically we have a giant fake scumhunting post alert.

 

 

Nolder is totally playing on the sidelines. Commenting on his own meta here or there, but never really coming down with any firm reads or opinions on anything really. He is def someone that needs to be watched.

What would you call my stance on Red? 

 

 

Oh you mean the stance you pretty much fabricated after I already called you out for sideline play? That stance?

 

 

Yeah, I'm pretty ambivalent about it.

[Nolder]

Scum list:

 

Mynd

Nol

Lenlo

Jack

Krak

and... Nynkat cause there's too much sausage on this list

whoops forgot about Dawn

 

Bout to do this funky thing to assign points for errone tho, will post the results later on

BUT DES WHY AREN'T YOU ON YOUR OWN LIST?!

YOU JUST POSTED MEANINGLESS SPAM!

 

 

Des are you town this time?

 

Look me in the soul and I'll hard clear you

LOOK ME IN THE SOUL

 

 

I'm so town this game my scumhunting gonads are about to burst from too much WIM

 

Do you realize how stupid what you said was now? I sure hope so.

[Myndrunner]

 

It is simple.  I am not voting Red because she hasn't given me any reason to.  The more others press on this, the more likely I feel she is town.

 

Does this make sense to anyone else?

I've read it several times and I don't get it.

If nothing Red has done so far this game warrants a vote then you're blind or ignoring the facts.

The more others press this, this being you not voting Red, the more you feel she's town?

 

Consider for a moment Mynd that there are at least 6 different factions in this game.

Now how do you feel about it?

 

 

Town is the only faction I care about.  Think back to your own games.  The lynch train on Red has built way too fast.  

 

What facts am I missing that warrants lynching Red?

 

 

I'm trying to read up the last few pages and keep getting ninja'd all to Hell lol

 

SERIOUSLY THOUGH, CFD ON MYND IS A GO!

 

Try a larger and more red font next time.   Oh yeah, and how about reasons. 

 

 

Sticking your fingers in your ears and going pfffffft is no way to hunt for scum.  Narrow down your list of suspects and go from there. 

[Myndrunner]

 

 

 

So Mynd, which is it? Should we be looking for the person doing the most antitown things this game, or should we focus solely on the hydras like you kept stressing over and over? Or was the hydra thing just something for you to talk about to look like you were being active?

 

 

Lemme try in simple speak:  Which hydra do you see as the most scummy? <-------This is exactly what I just asked you.

 

 

 

I have been very open about my thoughts on various players.

 

How many times can I say I'm not playing your game before you just stop trying to funnel the convo that way?

 

You have actively avoided most of the hydras.  Why not answer my question?  Only the mafia fear information.  What do you have to fear if you are town yourself?

[hazelkrs1]

Wait he gave them fakeclaims? Did I miss this? Or was this in the rules section and I just forgot it?

 

 

Also Des, trust me I would be doing whole lot more if I /finally/ got scum. I want it so much.

 

 

... yes, Darthe said he gave out safe claims. But dude, this shouldn't change ANYTHING. Character claims are allowed. Do you think Darthe would mod a setup that could be broken with a mass character claim? Obviousofreakinglutely not. So even if he hadn't specified that he gave out safe fake claims, it would still be ridiculous to assume mafia didn't have safe fake claims.

 

And the second line is too much wifom for me atm, likely to give me indigestion.

 

HURR DURR DURR UR SO FUNNEH

 

 

Seriously you pick out three posts of mine that aren't directly related to the game at hand and want to lynch me for them?

You'd have to lynch everyone else first because no one is staying entirely on topic. And no one would want them to.

Games without any humor or casual conversation are just as boring as games with too much.

If you have a problem with what I've said that's just too damn bad.

 

 

No, I picked out the three most recent posts I saw from you AFTER I had already fos'd you for sideline play. Those weren't selected from the entire game.

 

Trust me Nol, if I wanted to I could have posted a LOT more posts exactly like those I quoted. You have been on the sidelines most of the game.

 

I don't mind offtopic talk, hell I participate in it as well. But trying to skate by on MOSTLY offtopic talk is scummy.

 

And even this post is more just like an outside the game argument, not anything that gives anyone an idea of what your opinions are in THIS game. You say if I have a problem with it too bad... well why wouldn't you be wondering if I'm pushing you from a scummy perspective?

 

Cause you're scum, that's why

[Nolder]

 

Interesting.

 

 

 

 

Here's a conundrum imo.

Her "allegiance" is to Frey, the obvious bad guys here but Roslin herself was not a "bad person" iirc but she WAS aware of the plan and allowed it to go forward. There's also the consideration that she was married to a Tully so would that change anything?

 

How do we consider this? As a "bad" character or a "good" one?

 

How about this: I'll pay as much attention to character claims as I normally do. Which is to say none at all. Darthe has given out safe claims. Scum aren't going to claim the obviously bad guys. And everyone's alignment in this series is already somewhat ambiguous, that's sort of the point of it.

 

So basically we have a giant fake scumhunting post alert.

 

 

Nolder is totally playing on the sidelines. Commenting on his own meta here or there, but never really coming down with any firm reads or opinions on anything really. He is def someone that needs to be watched.

What would you call my stance on Red?

 

 

Oh you mean the stance you pretty much fabricated after I already called you out for sideline play? That stance?

 

 

Yeah, I'm pretty ambivalent about it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'll spell it out for you Mynd.

 

I haven't checked the game all day. Decided to catch up before going to bed. Saw it had twelve pages, wasn't exactly looking forward to going through that while tired. Jumped to the last page to check the mood of thread. Was happy it was still jokes, no need for serious brain activity before bedtime. Decided to post picture I just saw in my tmblr feed. Capiche?

 

 

And it's just Mish, or Mistress if you prefer

 

so let me get this striaght.

 

you didn't do the blue, instead only doign the green and assumed the red because of one page

 

 

Another strangely interesting post here from Red. Adds to the pressure on Mish, goes as far as to make a meme calling her mafia, but still has her vote on Tommy for some weird reason.

 

That's a decent point, I can follow this.

 

##Vote Red

 

 

 

Come again?

[Nolder]

 

 

It is simple.  I am not voting Red because she hasn't given me any reason to.  The more others press on this, the more likely I feel she is town.

Does this make sense to anyone else?

I've read it several times and I don't get it.

If nothing Red has done so far this game warrants a vote then you're blind or ignoring the facts.

The more others press this, this being you not voting Red, the more you feel she's town?

 

Consider for a moment Mynd that there are at least 6 different factions in this game.

Now how do you feel about it?

 

 

Town is the only faction I care about.  Think back to your own games.  The lynch train on Red has built way too fast.  

 

What facts am I missing that warrants lynching Red?

 

It's built over nearly 50 pages, it started near the beginning of the game.

How is that considered fast to you?

 

Facts? Geez plenty, have you not been reading the back and forth at all?

How about her refusal to recognize what GOAT meant and make a big deal trying to spin it as a claim for a known bad guy in GOT? That doesn't mean anything at all to you?

[amegakure]

 

Not liking mynd wallfling on the trains between red and mistress. At the same time tunneling on his hydra/claims concept.. 

 

Not going to wait for a ninja hammer since i havent heard from cloud and not a fan of the case on red either ##unvote red ##votemynd

 

First, it's waffling.  As in waffles.  Like these:

 

 

 

Second, I believe Mishtress claim.  Hence my unvote.  How is that waffling?

 

cause you keep bringing up how you kinda believe red's claim but also think she's scummy. and i've yet to see you settle and place a vote. With mish town in your eyes i think it's time to take a stance. 

 

oh and you cant ##vote hydra's . sorry 

 

and yea i know i was in a hurry. Screw spell check FTW

 

[hazelkrs1]

 

Scum list:

 

Mynd

Nol

Lenlo

Jack

Krak

and... Nynkat cause there's too much sausage on this list

whoops forgot about Dawn

 

Bout to do this funky thing to assign points for errone tho, will post the results later on

BUT DES WHY AREN'T YOU ON YOUR OWN LIST?!

YOU JUST POSTED MEANINGLESS SPAM!

 

 

Des are you town this time?

 

Look me in the soul and I'll hard clear you

LOOK ME IN THE SOUL

 

 

I'm so town this game my scumhunting gonads are about to burst from too much WIM

 

Do you realize how stupid what you said was now? I sure hope so.

 

 

lolwut???

 

Why would I put myself down on my scum list.... what are you smoking Nolderp?

 

 

 

 

 

So Mynd, which is it? Should we be looking for the person doing the most antitown things this game, or should we focus solely on the hydras like you kept stressing over and over? Or was the hydra thing just something for you to talk about to look like you were being active?

 

 

Lemme try in simple speak:  Which hydra do you see as the most scummy? <-------This is exactly what I just asked you.

 

 

 

I have been very open about my thoughts on various players.

 

How many times can I say I'm not playing your game before you just stop trying to funnel the convo that way?

 

You have actively avoided most of the hydras.  Why not answer my question?  Only the mafia fear information.  What do you have to fear if you are town yourself?

 

 

Actively avoided most of the hydras.. how? I gave my thoughts about CrayJay, Mishtress, Halleleeloujah, and even put another hydra (NyanKat) on my scum list. How am I actively avoiding them again?

 

And I'm not playing your silly little game. The lynch pool isn't between hydras. I'm not focusing solely on hydras. If you wanna dig your own grave trying to do so, that's your prerogative. I have been clear in my opinions about other players.

[hazelkrs1]

 

 

Interesting.

 

 

 

 

Here's a conundrum imo.

Her "allegiance" is to Frey, the obvious bad guys here but Roslin herself was not a "bad person" iirc but she WAS aware of the plan and allowed it to go forward. There's also the consideration that she was married to a Tully so would that change anything?

 

How do we consider this? As a "bad" character or a "good" one?

 

How about this: I'll pay as much attention to character claims as I normally do. Which is to say none at all. Darthe has given out safe claims. Scum aren't going to claim the obviously bad guys. And everyone's alignment in this series is already somewhat ambiguous, that's sort of the point of it.

 

So basically we have a giant fake scumhunting post alert.

 

 

Nolder is totally playing on the sidelines. Commenting on his own meta here or there, but never really coming down with any firm reads or opinions on anything really. He is def someone that needs to be watched.

What would you call my stance on Red?

 

 

Oh you mean the stance you pretty much fabricated after I already called you out for sideline play? That stance?

 

 

Yeah, I'm pretty ambivalent about it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'll spell it out for you Mynd.

 

I haven't checked the game all day. Decided to catch up before going to bed. Saw it had twelve pages, wasn't exactly looking forward to going through that while tired. Jumped to the last page to check the mood of thread. Was happy it was still jokes, no need for serious brain activity before bedtime. Decided to post picture I just saw in my tmblr feed. Capiche?

 

 

And it's just Mish, or Mistress if you prefer

 

so let me get this striaght.

 

you didn't do the blue, instead only doign the green and assumed the red because of one page

 

 

Another strangely interesting post here from Red. Adds to the pressure on Mish, goes as far as to make a meme calling her mafia, but still has her vote on Tommy for some weird reason.

 

That's a decent point, I can follow this.

 

##Vote Red

 

 

 

Come again?

 

 

LOL that's not a stance! That's you parroting/sheeping someone else! Bahahaha!

 

 

Stating a stance isn't just voting or saying you think someone is scummy- it's saying WHY you think someone is scummy.

 

Nolder, you wanna thunderdome?

[amegakure]

also i think im going to ##vote tommy the pressure they (tommy and crayjay) are putting on dawn looks off. It could be they just relish in being rude but i think they want her to crack and sell her self as scum in a emotional response to warrant an easy lynch. 

[Myndrunner]

 

 

Scum list:

 

Mynd

Nol

Lenlo

Jack

Krak

and... Nynkat cause there's too much sausage on this list

whoops forgot about Dawn

 

Bout to do this funky thing to assign points for errone tho, will post the results later on

BUT DES WHY AREN'T YOU ON YOUR OWN LIST?!

YOU JUST POSTED MEANINGLESS SPAM!

 

 

Des are you town this time?

 

Look me in the soul and I'll hard clear you

LOOK ME IN THE SOUL

 

 

I'm so town this game my scumhunting gonads are about to burst from too much WIM

 

Do you realize how stupid what you said was now? I sure hope so.

 

 

lolwut???

 

Why would I put myself down on my scum list.... what are you smoking Nolderp?

 

 

 

 

 

So Mynd, which is it? Should we be looking for the person doing the most antitown things this game, or should we focus solely on the hydras like you kept stressing over and over? Or was the hydra thing just something for you to talk about to look like you were being active?

 

 

Lemme try in simple speak:  Which hydra do you see as the most scummy? <-------This is exactly what I just asked you.

 

 

 

I have been very open about my thoughts on various players.

 

How many times can I say I'm not playing your game before you just stop trying to funnel the convo that way?

 

You have actively avoided most of the hydras.  Why not answer my question?  Only the mafia fear information.  What do you have to fear if you are town yourself?

 

 

Actively avoided most of the hydras.. how? I gave my thoughts about CrayJay, Mishtress, Halleleeloujah, and even put another hydra (NyanKat) on my scum list. How am I actively avoiding them again?

 

And I'm not playing your silly little game. The lynch pool isn't between hydras. I'm not focusing solely on hydras. If you wanna dig your own grave trying to do so, that's your prerogative. I have been clear in my opinions about other players.

 

 

Why would that be "digging my own grave" as you say?  What are you afraid of?  Its simple numbers.  If you narrow down your pool of targets, you are more likely to hit a scum.  You are overreacting to my suggestion and refusing to even entertain it.  This, to me, strongly suggests that you and womby have something to hide.

[Nolder]

Trust me Nol, if I wanted to I could have posted a LOT more posts exactly like those I quoted.

That's exactly my point, you could do it with anyone.

I could do it for you even. No one has resisted the temptation to partake in at least a little joking and casual conversation.

 

You have been on the sidelines most of the game.

Yeah I can accept that label.

Like I said to Leelou I don't really do well in big games.

I feel lost in them. Too many people to keep track of.

 

I don't mind offtopic talk, hell I participate in it as well. But trying to skate by on MOSTLY offtopic talk is scummy.

I'm not trying to "skate by". If I was going to do that I just wouldn't post much like Jack or Krak.

I'm trying to improve my game but I'm not going to drop offtopic talk while I do that because that would make the game boring.

 

And even this post is more just like an outside the game argument, not anything that gives anyone an idea of what your opinions are in THIS game. You say if I have a problem with it too bad... well why wouldn't you be wondering if I'm pushing you from a scummy perspective?

 

Cause you're scum, that's why

>Why didn't you OMGUS me?

>Because you're scum!

 

Can you drop the newb level rhetoric?

[Myndrunner]

also i think im going to ##vote tommy the pressure they (tommy and crayjay) are putting on dawn looks off. It could be they just relish in being rude but i think they want her to crack and sell her self as scum in a emotional response to warrant an easy lynch. 

 

This could be why....

 

[Nolder]

 

 

Scum list:

 

Mynd

Nol

Lenlo

Jack

Krak

and... Nynkat cause there's too much sausage on this list

whoops forgot about Dawn

 

Bout to do this funky thing to assign points for errone tho, will post the results later on

BUT DES WHY AREN'T YOU ON YOUR OWN LIST?!

YOU JUST POSTED MEANINGLESS SPAM!

 

 

Des are you town this time?

 

Look me in the soul and I'll hard clear you

LOOK ME IN THE SOUL

 

 

I'm so town this game my scumhunting gonads are about to burst from too much WIM

 

 

Do you realize how stupid what you said was now? I sure hope so.

 

 

lolwut???

 

Why would I put myself down on my scum list.... what are you smoking Nolderp?

 

I thought if I dumbed it down for you you might understand.

Are you back and ready for an adult level conversation? It's a double standard.

You're complaining about me making offtopic posts just as you posted one.

[Yates]

Sure, the scum have fake claims, but none of those claims are going to be Rob or Kaitlin Stark, right? Those fake claims will likely be tertiary characters from the game......LIKE LITTLE SMALL JON.

No. Not right. Not even close to right. Darth comes from mafiascum. At MS, we save major characters for fake claims. In Ghostbusters Mafia, for example, Peter AND Ray were fake claims. In DC Comics mafia, Bruce Wayne was a fake claim. Bottom line, don't read too much into flavor. Games go sideways when you do it. I will happily lynch anyone that suggests a lynch based on flavor going forward.

 

I also strongly dislike what you are suggesting in regards to hydra hunting... For one, you keep saying there are 16 slots. There's 19, so it's 14:5, which is says clearly in the VC that you quoted. This lessens the probability by a good amount of your theory that multiple hydras are on the scum team. While it is still very possible you seem to be saying that we should isolate the hydra teams and proceed in that fashion. I dislike this for obvious reasons, namely the fact that you are suggesting we more or less ignore other gameplay to focus on the hydras because they *could* pose a bigger threat. I also disagree with this on a fundamental level because as others have already pointed out, having 2 heads to one slot doubles the chance that one of them slip up. It also ignores the blatant advantage it gives to town for those hydras because they function very much like a Mason pair in the sense that they are two sets of eyes that are confirmed to each other to dissect the game together.

True story, bro.

 

As I've already said, I'm not "rustled" about being today's lynch. In my experience when I've been run up D1 you spend too much time thereafter unproductively trying to recover. I think it's a bit rude to lynch the bride on her own wedding day, but as we're vanilla town it's no great loss, and all kinds of good info for tomorrow.

Guys. Seriously. It's only cool to premature claim if your name is Yates or it's within your first 5 posts. Did you talk to Mish before barfing up that claim all over the thread?

 

 

 

 

i explained why my vote was still parked there. its a damned if you do and damned if you dont situation

See it's posts like this that convince people you are scum. If you are Town, why do you care how your "vote hopping" is perceived? ESPECIALLY if you can claim a Town power role? If you're Town and you move your vote, and someone challenges you on why you moved your vote, you tell them WHY you moved your vote because - as Town - your reasons are TOWN MOTIVATED. So, again, your "logic" is completely off the farm.

 

This^^

 

I never get why townies are afraid as to how their voting is going to look. It's natural to have your reads change with new information of if you see a slip.

 

Possible TMI slip? How do you know that Red is town? And before you defend yourself simplistically- I realize this was more of a generalized comment. However, in this context... it's obviously involving Red.

 

Bro. Come on. I hope this is a reaction test or inside joke or something.

 

So, ask yourself this. Who has been trying to discredit, distract, and destroy the most so far in this game?

Red. Who you are fence sitting on. How you don't acknowledge that is beyond me.

 

Overlap: Mynd, Jack, Krak, Dawn, Nolder

Overlap: Mynd and Jack. Amegakure is pinging hard lately as well, btw. Take a look at his most recent posts. They wreak. WREAK I SAY!

 

Here's a conundrum imo.

Her "allegiance" is to Frey, the obvious bad guys here but Roslin herself was not a "bad person" iirc but she WAS aware of the plan and allowed it to go forward. There's also the consideration that she was married to a Tully so would that change anything?

 

How do we consider this? As a "bad" character or a "good" one?

STOP IT STOP IT STOP IT!!! GAAAHHH!!

 

How about this: I'll pay as much attention to character claims as I normally do. Which is to say none at all. Darthe has given out safe claims. Scum aren't going to claim the obviously bad guys. And everyone's alignment in this series is already somewhat ambiguous, that's sort of the point of it.

 

So basically we have a giant fake scumhunting post alert.

Can... Can I... Hug you? [nohomo]

[Yates]

Also, I'm going to bed now.  I'm judging at TAP NY tomorrow.  Needless to say - don't expect any posts from me until Sunday at the earliest.

 

I expect to see Red lynched by the time I catch back up.

[Nolder]

LOL that's not a stance! That's you parroting/sheeping someone else! Bahahaha!

 

 

Stating a stance isn't just voting or saying you think someone is scummy- it's saying WHY you think someone is scummy.

 

Nolder, you wanna thunderdome?

So what do you call every person on a train? Don't they all generally agree someone is scummy? Often for the EXACT same reasons? Are they all sheeping? Seriously are you brain dead this game or what? I wasn't the first to point out Red's scummy behavior but I acknowledged it and voted her. If you're going to argue she's not scummy do it, if not then stfu.

 

Also I have no idea what you mean by that last bit.

[Lenlo]

 

 

 

Keep howling Lenlo. I LERVE watching you squirm as scum!

 

#notcreepyatall

 

Oh Des, btw dont say im squirming. I dont squirm. Evah.

 

 

And the second line is too much wifom for me atm, likely to give me indigestion.

 

And here I thought Wifom was your bread and butter, your breakfast and dinner, your first and your last. Well guess we cant all be this awesome.

[Myndrunner]

So basically, the reason several of you are refusing to consider that roles play even a remote possibility in a game called the Red Wedding is because it's just not fit for tea and crumpets? 

 

Its fine to disagree, but the level of violent backlash for even suggesting that it matters is quite intriguing.  I say it very well DOES matter.  To threaten a lynch on those who disagree sounds a lot like mafia to me.

 

All I have read about everyone's claims about why they are voting Red can be summed up in one quote:

 

"I can't believe you don't see why we are voting Red.  She's been scummy and totally scum this whole game!  I believe this because someone somewhere said so!"

 

Show me her posts where she is actually doing this.  What is your logic?  I completely fail to see it.  Not one of you have presented a reasonable or valid reason to lynch her.  You just keep regurgitating the same old rhetoric that someone somewhere may have said, but scrolling back through all 53 pages, the ONLY thing I can see that even remotely suggests that she could be scum is her claim, which is the one thing I actually kinda doubt. 

 

The fact that many of you refuse to even consider any alternative makes me sad for the town.

[Krakalakachkn]

@Despo

 

Considering I've only read pages 1-20, my vote on Red is completely warranted. Also judging from the fact that there were 18 others who didn't feel the need to unvote Red after her claim tells me that your argument is terrible. Tommy too.