[Advanced] House MD Mafia - Mafia Victory!

peacesells · March 12, 2014

Peace, can you explain to me you voting with Tommy yesterday? I still don't get it.

Also, how do you square Tommy as your top scum read with Tommy's going after Wombat earlier in the game?

1 - I had a scum read on Dice. I voted the scum I thought would be lynched. Just because I had a greater scum read on Tommy doesn't mean he is scum. It's just a read on him. Not fact.

2 - I discount his attack on Wombat because the scum team had obviously decided that Wombat was expendable. The fact that Tommy was not at all deterred by Wombats cop claimed is suspicious. It's a great move to gain town credit at the same time outing a real power role.

I will either vote no lynch or Tommy today. No one else.

michellem · March 12, 2014

Problem is that today is an obv no lynch situation. Scum don't gain anything (and potentially have lots to lose) by having to pretend to have scum reads so the easiest thing for them to do is duck and cover.

Not a fan of you trying to push that idea. The mafia wouldn't all duck out and you know that's too easy an explanation. This does not make me trust you any more.

michellem · March 12, 2014

Peace, not digging your tunnel either. I'd like some proper reads from you on all players, not just Tommy.

peacesells · March 12, 2014

Peace, not digging your tunnel either. I'd like some proper reads from you on all players, not just Tommy.

I bet you don't get one.

michellem · March 12, 2014

No because god forbid you'd actually contribute on LyLo.

Turin Turambar · March 13, 2014

Home finally today. Nothing worse than traffic on way home after driving all day. GRRRRRRRRRRRR

Here is where I stand right now with regards to who is left:

MISH: confirmed in my eyes due to BFG flipping town and her basically confirming that she received the gift you said you sent. I don't see any way that could have been faked and I see absolutely NO WAY that a mafia would be giving gifts like that.

LENLO: (cleared by LD) Not much contributed which TG pointed out early game. Had the slight thing with Despo that looked genuine and matched what I have seen of Len. There was a real effort to paint the favorable LD report as a complete town confirmation. Not totally convinced that either Len or Hallia is town

HALLIA (cleared by LD) still hate the early sheep vote. and the jokey tone in most of her posts. See above...

RAGS: came in and looked very town but lost momentum. The only person I recall saying much about him is Tommy who called him town. I don't trust Tommy so am thinking that Rags might be on his team.

TG: I like the questions he is asking right now and most of his play after the bad start on D1. He has in general moved steadily to be more and more town to me. I do disagree about the NL however.

PEACE: That last post about the not providing other reads seems counterproductive to me. Especially since he was strongly stating TG as a mafia read yesterday. Peace has that changed?

TOMMY: He looks very much to me like he did in both the Christmas mafia and the Star Wars mafia games where he was Mafia. The directing of town and not really saying much in his posts. With the exception of going at Wombat. I could easily see the mafia team using Wombat to try to clear Tommy and also see if they could get a town PR to out themselves.

I don't like the NO LYNCH idea personally because to me there is only one completely cleared person so there is little doubt who would be killed tonight. So I see us in the same situation tomorrow as we are in right now.

Preference to lynch: In order

Tommy.

Rags

Peace

Hallia

Lenlo

TG

would vote NL ahead of Mish

peacesells · March 13, 2014

Mish..I was kinda trolling. Basically beating someone else to saying what I said. The past few games I've been getting a lot of that type of statement directed my way.

I've got town reads on everyone but the following:

Tommy

Turin

Rags

If there is a silver tongue it would be Lenlo.

Tyler Glembo · March 13, 2014

Problem is that today is an obv no lynch situation. Scum don't gain anything (and potentially have lots to lose) by having to pretend to have scum reads so the easiest thing for them to do is duck and cover.

Not a fan of you trying to push that idea. The mafia wouldn't all duck out and you know that's too easy an explanation. This does not make me trust you any more.

C'mon Mish, you know better. I was calling them out in thread to try and get them to come play. Guilty conscience would make them worry about actually doing it after I put it in thread. Simple, easy trap triggered by the one confirmed townie.

Mish..I was kinda trolling. Basically beating someone else to saying what I said. The past few games I've been getting a lot of that type of statement directed my way.

I've got town reads on everyone but the following:

Tommy

Turin

Rags

If there is a silver tongue it would be Lenlo.

Peace, what happened? I looked so scummy to you that yesterday you were willing to vote along with Tommy on me. Now I'm not even on your scum list?

michellem · March 13, 2014

Oooooh, it was a trap. Of course :rolleyes:

Turin Turambar · March 13, 2014

TG. Did you just say you were the one confirmed townie?

Turin Turambar · March 13, 2014

Or were you talking about Mish? I need to sleep... When is deadline? Saturday? I will be about more tomorrow evening. maybe a smidge during the day.

Songstress · March 13, 2014

Official Vote Count (unchanged):

No Lynch (1) - TG

Not Voting (7) - Peace, Turin, Mish, Rags, Hally, Tommy, Lenlo

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: Saturday, March 15 @ 2PM CDT

http://www.timeandda...sg=End of Day 5

peacesells · March 13, 2014

Changed my mind Tglems. Really like your no lynch thoughts. Very pro town.

Tyler Glembo · March 13, 2014

TG. Did you just say you were the one confirmed townie?

I was talking about Mish as the townie. And either Lenlo or Hallia, at least one has to be town.

Changed my mind Tglems. Really like your no lynch thoughts. Very pro town.

I see.

peacesells · March 13, 2014

VOTE TOMMY

michellem · March 13, 2014

Dear Mods, I am really, really sorry for how little I'm participating. I hope you know it's absolutley nothing personal towards you or this game, just my own circumstances. You know I :wub: you both and this is a very interesting set-up and theme.

Ok I've been trying to reread. I've been trying to read more ISO's. I cannot for the life of me concentrate. I have never experienced things like this before.

I'm not really interested in a no lynch. It's more or less guaranteed I'll be the NK so you won't be any further, really.

My gut says Turin is our safest bet. And if we loose, well then mafia has played a very good game and deserve the win.

Lenlo · March 13, 2014

Then do so. Ask a pointed question. Like this one.

Lenlo, why are almost all of your posts fluff so far this game? What have you done to contribute to scum hunting? Who are your top scum reads?

Tommy, what do you make of Peace calling you his top scum read and then voting along with you?

1) Cause I enjoy being a smartallick. Also your calling alot of stuff fluff that isnt.

2) Dunno.

3) Turin or Rags

Mish..I was kinda trolling. Basically beating someone else to saying what I said. The past few games I've been getting a lot of that type of statement directed my way.

I've got town reads on everyone but the following:

Tommy

Turin

Rags

If there is a silver tongue it would be Lenlo.

D: Why me and not Hallia?

peacesells · March 13, 2014

cause although you start many games with jokes..you eventually actually play...and you haven't this game.

Tommyrod · March 13, 2014

I'll play this weekend! I'm hosting a complex game and work has been destroying me on top of that.

I'm okay with NL to get to an odd number of players if that's how things are shakin' up

(There's actually no shakin' to be had)

michellem · March 13, 2014

Voting no lynch will only make me go away. It'll make it easier for the mafia to win because there is one less town vote. No lynch is a stupid, stupid idea.

Hallia · March 13, 2014

I'm with you there Mish. There is no gain I think. Some argue that there's more time, but unless activity picks up, it doesn't seem like time is what we need. We need to make a decision and run with it.

peacesells · March 14, 2014

I'll play this weekend! I'm hosting a complex game and work has been destroying me on top of that.

I'm okay with NL to get to an odd number of players if that's how things are shakin' up

(There's actually no shakin' to be had)

This is a tactic that scum tommy uses often. Stating he'll be gone awhile. Notice he says he will play this weekend. The deadline is on Saturday..meaning there won't be much opportunity to delve into his reasonings.

Songstress · March 14, 2014

Official Vote Count:

No Lynch (1) - TG

Tommy (1) - Peace

Not Voting (6) - Turin, Mish, Rags, Hally, Tommy, Lenlo

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline: Saturday, March 15 @ 2PM CDT

http://www.timeandda...sg=End of Day 5

Tommyrod · March 14, 2014

I'll play this weekend! I'm hosting a complex game and work has been destroying me on top of that.

I'm okay with NL to get to an odd number of players if that's how things are shakin' up

(There's actually no shakin' to be had)

This is a tactic that scum tommy uses often. Stating he'll be gone awhile. Notice he says he will play this weekend. The deadline is on Saturday..meaning there won't be much opportunity to delve into his reasonings.

I'm up for a Peace smackdown

It's too late in the game for you to be using such hilaribad thin reasoning

"Tommy's got poopoo in his pants!"

Vote Peace

peacesells · March 14, 2014

That's a fine OMGUS right thar.

[Advanced] House MD Mafia - Mafia Victory!

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook