[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[Kaylee]

I'll try to do an ISO or two when the baby's asleep.

[Darthe]

Sure. Who are your top and botom three?

[Kaylee]

Still thinking Des ifs town. Possibly you as well for the reason Luci pointed out. Unsure on everyone else. I'll have tolook back to get a better feel.

[Darthe]

That did not answer that.

 

Kaylee

 

Whoever is online to ask Kaylee que stions next may start.

[michellem]

Krak will be replacing Golden.

 

All votes on and by Golden will be removed from the VC.

[Luciena]

That did not answer that.

 

Kaylee

 

Whoever is online to ask Kaylee questions next may start.

What is this the Spanish Inquisition? 

 

Kaylee who do you think is the survivor?

[Luciena]

P.S Hi Tom and Krak, sorry things got a bit heated, and forgot my manners. Welcome

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Darthe (1): Des

With 11 alive, 6 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (10): Kaylee, Hallu, Ishy, Key, Tom, Dice, Cloud, Darthe, Luci, Krak

Deadline will be a little after midnight Friday (early am hours Saturday), thats Friday afternoon/early evening for the 'Muricans.

[Krakalakachkn]

Lurk mode: engage.

[Kaylee]

Hi Krak

[Kaylee]

Don't know Luci.

[Darthe]

Lol of course.

 

UNVOTE VOTE KAYLEE

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Darthe (1): Des
Kaylee (1): Darthe

With 11 alive, 6 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (9): Kaylee, Hallu, Ishy, Key, Tom, Dice, Cloud,  Luci, Krak

Deadline will be a little after midnight Friday (early am hours Saturday), thats Friday afternoon/early evening for the 'Muricans.

 

 

Ok I'm heading out to see The Hobbit, see ya later lovelies.

[Luciena]

Lol of course.

 

UNVOTE VOTE KAYLEE

red: who's that aimed at?

[John E. Kelley]

Did peoples panties really get in a wad because someone was a little harsh? Grow a backbone people, this is mafia, not Monopoly. I'd happily kill anyone of you, that's how it goes. Just, wow.

[Kaylee]

Think he was referring to the fact that his vote was red and not just bold.

[Kaylee]

Thoughts Ishy?

[Luciena]

My bad.

[John E. Kelley]

Thoughts Ishy?

 

 

I'll give them when I get home, leaving work now.

 

 

My bad.

You're never bad. Unfortunately.

[Luciena]

^^ Rascal 

[Darthe]

Did peoples panties really get in a wad because someone was a little harsh? Grow a backbone people, this is mafia, not Monopoly. I'd happily kill anyone of you, that's how it goes. Just, wow.

In all fairness people have been killed over games of Monopoly too.

[keyholder21]

@darthe & Ishy - Saying there is no need for insults is hardly "taking it to heart" or "getting my panties in a wad", if you're referring to me. Even if you're not, generally insulting play NOT people is how things go on DM.  If he's entitled to insults, then others are entitled to voice their dislike of those insults. He's a big boy, I'm sure he can take someone saying they didn't like he was rude.  Or not, as the case may be. Making it out like those people who voiced their dislike of insults should be ashamed is quite ridiculous.  

 

 

I'll have to give more game thoughts later.  Headed home now and on baby duty (big surprise, I know).  

[Kaylee]

ISO's of those I can...I've added links to most of the posts.

 

Darthe:

 

This is the post I use to say he's likely town...though only recently has he been scum-hunting in this post. Not sure where he got the "based on us having a doc" bit though. We've had 2 deaths so far and both have been VT. (neutral but leaning town)

 

Nothing on Tom as he just joined and hasn't said much...(neatral read as Aida hadn't said much)

 

Was suspicious of Golden...but as he's been replaced will allow Krak to speak. Krak please participate!

 

Hallu:

 

Started off joke voting Snow. Replies to Darthe saying Snow's vote on him was because they are friends. Here He then asks "Since when you were town?" to Darthe..then posts this:

No, but I feel like you will turn out to be mafia. I may be wrong, after all this is my first game. 

 

Unvote: Snow

Vote: Darthe

(I put it in blue to show the part I copied.) He's new so the "I may be wrong" makes sense. (Yes I know I used that too, but he shouldn't be jumped on for it. I knew better but did it anyway). 

Hallu later explains that voting Darthe was better than voting Snow and that he wasn't feeling a town vibe from him. He further explains voting Darthe might not be crazy as there may not be a cop.  Next he says he doesn't know when he'll get solid reads...just going to guess and see what we do. Votes AJ for "mutual thoughts plus taking the place of Snow". His last post was saying he still thinks AJ is scum because he feels like Snow left because of being scum and AJ came in awkwardly. (Could be scum. Not sure since there weren't a lot of posts and he went from not seeming to have a reason to vote AJ to "still" thinking he's scum...neutral read leaning possible scum).

 

Ishy:

Joke votes Key, then two posts joking with the mod. His first game-related post is questioning two quick votes for Aidanna, he asks if it was coordinated. He then tells Aida that she's doesn't need to vote in red. He has a sarcastic reply to Golden. Some fluff posts then an unvote with nothing else. Asks Em what gives, then votes the Mod. He then educates about not talking about on-going games. He asks Hallu what the reasoning is for his/her vote. Then he replies to Darthe saying that he would question anyone who votes without a reason. Next he calls Key's vote, on me I believe, opportunistic and a bandwagon vote and vote Key saying the Kay train stinks. Then a post about an error in VC. After that some fluff. He then says Cloud, Key and Peace are the possible scum team. Then more fluff...Next he says that Luci pings for voting Aida with no apparent reason and leaving himself and Darthe off her list. He then tells Luci she's using meta to justify a vote that doesn't have any. A few more fluff posts...Next he says he thinks Dice's unvote was scummy. Then he says that Kay likes to get the game started and typically the first person to do so gets heat. More fluff. He then unvotes with no comment. His next post asks what the cases are against Aida and Luci. Then he says he's available to keep it from going random...still thinks Key was the scummiest. He chastises Luci for questioning his unvote of Key. He says it's because she wasn't going to be lynch and deadline was close. He then votes AJ and asks if everyone else is willing to let it go random. Chastises Peace for not being around to help achieve a lynch. Does the same to me. Then, when I post the possibility of Ishy being obvious with the NK or being framed he asks if he'd be that obvious. More fluff then a comment about people getting their panties in a twist. He ends with saying he'll give thoughts when he gets home.

(Ishy read: Neutral could easily be scum but the NK has me wondering if scum was trying to frame him. I have a hard time getting a good read on him though).

 

That's all I have time for atm. Will have time for more tomorrow...then I'll place a vote depending on what I find.

[Krakalakachkn]

Was suspicious of Golden...but as he's been replaced will allow Krak to speak. Krak please participate!

 

Honestly, I probably won't read this whole thing until tomorrow. I got off work and am about to go to a friend's birthday party.

[Tommyrod]

The good news: I'm town. The bad news: I was told by the host here that I wouldn't be subbing in so I joined a game on 2+2 that already has 3000+ posts on DAY 2 and runs from 8AM-10PM my local time and the town needs all the help it can get so I've been very preoccupied since I'm at work all day and then play in that game when I get home and then go to bed. Then she told me I would be subbing in, schwoops! So here I am; tonight seems slightly more lax in that 2+2 game since the lead wagon has just been trolling since 8 AM and will probably be finished off whether I'm there or not.

That said, can 2-3 kind people give me a decent summary of what's happened in this game and what the current debate (if there is one coherent debate) is about? Then I can go back, skim this thread based on those players of interest, and give you my reads.