[Basic] The Circle Mafia - Game over

[GoldeneyesND]

@ Cloud - I hardly think voting for two people (on D1 no less) is going with the flow with my votes.  Also, Luci was not in the spotlight at the point that I posted.  Des, AJ, me and dice were all discussed in between her posts and mine.  Your defense of her is noted.

 

Cloud/AJ - The Survivor claiming now/ever unless necessary is a silly idea.  While the survivor isn't anti-town, they aren't town either so they are likely to be a lynch target because it's better than losing a townie.  The Survivor wants to stay alive, so s/he is going to be scumhunting anyway.  Also, claiming when not necessary is not really in the spirit of the game. 

 

Blind lynching, whilst sucks, is often the case on D1.  All of the trains are small ( 3 or fewer) so the point of next highest votes is fairly nil.  Voting an inactive D1 is lazy.  It won't tell us anything and if she's not been here, probability says she's VT because otherwise her scummates would be prodding her to post.

 

This. I was hoping AJ was kidding because it's a flat dumb idea. I understand Cloud jumping on the idea, he seemingly has no clue what he's doing. AJ, you should know better. 

 

Unvote  Vote AJ

[Andrej]

Hm, that's disappointing GE.

 

You say I should know better, but in truth I think it's really just a matter of you not knowing better.

 

Also, just because I asked the Survivor to claim you think that's reason to vote me, or do you think I am scum? Otherwise that's a poor reason to vote me so close to DL. Looks like you're just finding the biggest wagon to put your vote on.

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Aida (3): Luci, Cloud, AJ
Golden (1): Aida
Cloud (1): Kaylee
Hallu (1): Darthe
AJ (4): Des, Hallu, Dice, Golden
Luci (2): Key, Peace

With 13 alive, 7 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (1): Ishy,

Deadline Monday 2AM GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131209T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D1

 

2 hours, 40 minutes, for those who can't be bothered to look at the link.

[_CLOUD]

 

@ Cloud - I hardly think voting for two people (on D1 no less) is going with the flow with my votes.  Also, Luci was not in the spotlight at the point that I posted.  Des, AJ, me and dice were all discussed in between her posts and mine.  Your defense of her is noted.

 

Cloud/AJ - The Survivor claiming now/ever unless necessary is a silly idea.  While the survivor isn't anti-town, they aren't town either so they are likely to be a lynch target because it's better than losing a townie.  The Survivor wants to stay alive, so s/he is going to be scumhunting anyway.  Also, claiming when not necessary is not really in the spirit of the game. 

 

Blind lynching, whilst sucks, is often the case on D1.  All of the trains are small ( 3 or fewer) so the point of next highest votes is fairly nil.  Voting an inactive D1 is lazy.  It won't tell us anything and if she's not been here, probability says she's VT because otherwise her scummates would be prodding her to post.

 

This. I was hoping AJ was kidding because it's a flat dumb idea. I understand Cloud jumping on the idea, he seemingly has no clue what he's doing. AJ, you should know better. 

 

Unvote  Vote AJ

 

 

Yes, just because the Survivor wants to stay alive he should consider claiming because he wouldn't have to be afraid of getting NK'd then. It wouldn't make sense for the Mafia to kill a claimed Survivor. I also know that your vote on AJ was very scumtastic. You think AJ is scum because he brought up the idea of the Survivor claiming right away? Really? Can you think of any mafia motive for suggesting something like that? It would have been less scummy if you just admitted that you were simply bandwagoning, but you trying to pretend that your vote on AJ is meant to be taken seriously is pinging a lot.

[_CLOUD]

I will be going to bed now. Good luck with achieving a lynch.

[keyholder21]

Yes, just because the Survivor wants to stay alive he should consider claiming because he wouldn't have to be afraid of getting NK'd then. It wouldn't make sense for the Mafia to kill a claimed Survivor. I also know that your vote on AJ was very scumtastic. You think AJ is scum because he brought up the idea of the Survivor claiming right away? Really? Can you think of any mafia motive for suggesting something like that? It would have been less scummy if you just admitted that you were simply bandwagoning, but you trying to pretend that your vote on AJ is meant to be taken seriously is pinging a lot.

 

 

 

Please explain to me how the bolded is good for town?  You should WANT the survivor to eat the NK.  That would mean a townie lives in place of the Survivor dying.

 

If you had to choose between voting someone you think is a townie and the Survivor, who would you choose?  Having an outed Survivor means a lynch magnet if there is no other agreement on scumminess. It would be an easy way for scum to vote for someone without looking scummy.  Because, hey, not a townie.

 

Golden's vote is pretty thin reasoning though, with everything else that we've all been discussing.

[Luciena]

If I came off as patronising I apologise it was not my intent.

 

I was trying to put my point across, I was a bit vexed because Peace just jumped in after your post and without even bothering to explain anything tangible.

 

I am town. That is the truth.

 

If townies don't get loud and active to try and hunt mafia how else will the mafia be discovered? I have had one previous game before this one, (and before someone jumps on this, no I am not playing up to being a newbie) just explaining how I see things. The ones I have played with that are in this game, were AJ, Kaylee, Darthe, Peace, and Dice. 

 

What I have noticed though is that after Darthe explaining his readings to me, he has reverted to one liners like dare I say it Ishy.... Something there maybe?

 

Darthe has gone quiet, Ishy has gone quiet... 

 

I do not like this, it's getting me edgy. 

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Aida (3): Luci, Cloud, AJ
Golden (1): Aida
Cloud (1): Kaylee
Hallu (1): Darthe
AJ (4): Des, Hallu, Dice, Golden
Luci (2): Key, Peace

With 13 alive, 7 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (1): Ishy,

Deadline Monday 2AM GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131209T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D1

 

An hour and a half.

[John E. Kelley]

I'm here with the hammer in my hand, will keep it from going random. Still think my Key has been the scummiest today but no one seems to agree.

[John E. Kelley]

Hammer in my hand. Giggity.

 

That has to be a euphamism somehow.

[GoldeneyesND]

Survivor, though neutral is naturally anti-town because they win with either party. As such, the survivor doesn't care which side wins. They won't eat a NK, because scum has no reason to get rid of them. Survivors will vote to remove confirmed town at the end of the game because all they have to do is survive. Survivor is an easy town lynch. This is obvious from a 10 second look at the wiki. I know AJ is intelligent because I've played with him before. This gambit is scummy, he's trying to set up tomorrow's lynch and hoping Aida goes today.

[Andrej]

Meh... my intelligence is debatable

[keyholder21]

Survivor, though neutral is naturally anti-town because they win with either party. As such, the survivor doesn't care which side wins. They won't eat a NK, because scum has no reason to get rid of them. Survivors will vote to remove confirmed town at the end of the game because all they have to do is survive. Survivor is an easy town lynch. This is obvious from a 10 second look at the wiki. I know AJ is intelligent because I've played with him before. This gambit is scummy, he's trying to set up tomorrow's lynch and hoping Aida goes today.

If you're talking about my post when you say they won't eat an NK, I think you misunderstand. They can if they are not outed and are chosen as the NK by the scum team.

[Luciena]

Hammer in my hand. Giggity.

 

That has to be a euphamism somehow.

*facepalm*

[Luciena]

I'm here with the hammer in my hand, will keep it from going random. Still think my Key has been the scummiest today but no one seems to agree.

If you think it why don't you vote for her then?

[John E. Kelley]

 

I'm here with the hammer in my hand, will keep it from going random. Still think my Key has been the scummiest today but no one seems to agree.

 

If you think it why don't you vote for her then?

I had my vote on her the entire day, until about 3 hours ago. No point in wasting a vote on someone that has zero chance of being lynched.

 

You'd know this if you hadn't been skimming the whole time.

[hazelkrs1]

This game's activity got really blah but I do think were at least on the right course for a lynch. AJ asking a Survivor to come forward and claim seems antitown on many levels. Mostly for distracting town however.

[Luciena]

 

 

I'm here with the hammer in my hand, will keep it from going random. Still think my Key has been the scummiest today but no one seems to agree.

If you think it why don't you vote for her then?

I had my vote on her the entire day, until about 3 hours ago. No point in wasting a vote on someone that has zero chance of being lynched.

 

You'd know this if you hadn't been skimming the whole time.

 

I resent that. 

 

I was not skimming, however you are just not posting enough I can't get anything on you

[John E. Kelley]

Methinks you should check the post count.

[michellem]

50 minutes.

[keyholder21]

I don't want this to go random. Since no one else is willing to switch,

 

unvote, vote AJ

[Luciena]

I might have a theory, 

 

Methinks you should check the post count.

yeah... "wow" doesn't give me anything 

[michellem]

That's a lynch! Scene incoming.

[michellem]

Lol no it's not, I had a stupid.

[michellem]

Official Vote Count:

Aida (3): Luci, Cloud, AJ
Golden (1): Aida
Cloud (1): Kaylee
Hallu (1): Darthe
AJ (5): Des, Hallu, Dice, Golden, Key
Luci (1): Peace

With 13 alive, 7 is needed to achieve a lynch.
Not Voting (1): Ishy,

Deadline Monday 2AM GMT+1 http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20131209T02&p0=1375&msg=End+of+D1

 

 

Seven, Mish, not five. Keep your games straight