MAFIA - **STARGATE SG1** - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS

[Darthe]

Well I see two issues with that Cindy. Mind control is possible to replicate in games and things of that nature. Red did it to Ithi long ago. However this couldn't fit the scenario. Reasons being that it was something the mod did, not the mafia (right Talya?) and that if it was done by the mod it could have happened to the scummers too.

 

Better to be wary anyhow.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

I was thinking possible cult conversion type thing. they ended up kidnapping ppl and copying and replacing them so right to theme and stage 1 may be underpants but who knows how they get to profit.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Well I see two issues with that Cindy. Mind control is possible to replicate in games and things of that nature. Red did it to Ithi long ago. However this couldn't fit the scenario. Reasons being that it was something the mod did, not the mafia (right Talya?) and that if it was done by the mod it could have happened to the scummers too.

Better to be wary anyhow.

I agree with wariness at all times.

[dapianoplay3r]

they copy people and replace them

I really need to watch more SG1

I watched the whole merlin season

  

I was thinking possible cult conversion type thing. they ended up kidnapping ppl and copying and replacing them so right to theme and stage 1 may be underpants but who knows how they get to profit.

It feels more like a game mechanic rather than a role at this point. If we see more evidence of replicators though ill start thinking cult too

[Lenlo]

If you see a fake darthe roaming around then you'll know shiz is about to get real.

 

Two of me?!

The horror.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

I'm a little more concerned that darthe didn't seem to consider the possibility when I know he's a careful reader. and I couldn't have been any more openly paranoid about it if I tried.

 

but darn it, he's being so pleasant and all.

 

and I'm getting too tired to think.

 

but where's niel?

[Niel an' Tyomn]

BUNKER

 

 

 

 

Ah.  Here we are:

 

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Jailkeeper

 

 

Some Jailkeepers not only protect their target from all kills, but also render its target untargetable by all other actions during that Night. This variant is also known as Alien.

 

 

Interesting role...

 

 

Anyway, I'll go ahead and vote scum.

vote Cindy

 

Oddly enough I have to agree here. Csarmi no matter how scummy he looks may be on to something. Right after the vote against her she immediately gets very defensive and begins to act quite scummily if you ask me. 

 

So, for now, VOTE CINDY

 

 

Okay so get this, I sort of goofed with the mod by putting it in a quote, but ultimately it was enough to affect the result though the mod felt bad about it. Mispelling was not an issue btw.

Silenced til the nect day since I was unconscious.
No vote because I couldn't speak my intentions.
Impervious to NKs since I was in the medical bay.
No affect from NA's since I was in stasis? (Questioning if that's the right term)
Unable to use any ability I might posess because, again, unconscious.
Told to be wary of more severe consequences in the future. Pafo for if this was specufic to me or if the penalties will grow nore severe.


Niel should be able and corroborate.

So yeah this is a lot of stuff dumped on anyone that should incur the wrath of Talya. I got to ask a lot of questions and oddly enough the punishment had benefits. Its all to theme as it can be though, quite brutal.

 

Yup, Darthe's account is accurate. The wrath of Talya was wrought upon us.

 

I'm a little more concerned that darthe didn't seem to consider the possibility when I know he's a careful reader. and I couldn't have been any more openly paranoid about it if I tried.

but darn it, he's being so pleasant and all.

and I'm getting too tired to think.

but where's niel?

 

I'm back! 

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

you need a reread

[Niel an' Tyomn]

What should I reread for? :confused:

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

I got defensive when csarmi voted me?

 

reread, you missed something.

[Niel an' Tyomn]

Just reread it... I'm still standing by my vote for you.  

[Darthe]

Heh.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

lol, ok

[Locke]

BUNKER

 

Okay so get this, I sort of goofed with the mod by putting it in a quote, but ultimately it was enough to affect the result though the mod felt bad about it. Mispelling was not an issue btw.

Silenced til the nect day since I was unconscious.
No vote because I couldn't speak my intentions.
Impervious to NKs since I was in the medical bay.
No affect from NA's since I was in stasis? (Questioning if that's the right term)
Unable to use any ability I might posess because, again, unconscious.
Told to be wary of more severe consequences in the future. Pafo for if this was specufic to me or if the penalties will grow nore severe.


Niel should be able and corroborate.

So yeah this is a lot of stuff dumped on anyone that should incur the wrath of Talya. I got to ask a lot of questions and oddly enough the punishment had benefits. Its all to theme as it can be though, quite brutal.

 

This is fairly significant. I was quite curious as to why Basel was the only to die tonight, given Player's public vig post. Now it seems more likely that they targeted Darthe, Niel, or Healer.  

People I'd like to vote:

 

-Tina: She's gone completely under the radar.  Can't have that.

-Pralaya: A solid bandwagon vote on RTE and, more importantly, a defense to pressure that didn't look good at well. 

-Niel: He's been jumping on bandwagons all day, usually without giving any strong reasoning.  

-Hally: Similar to Niel. Only post of her's I've liked this game is her original vote on Basel. Most of her posts have been more like this though:

BUNKER

 

Why are you really so quick to jump on Cindy?  She's been most helpful to town, and I for one am nearly 100% sure she is town.

 

Vote Csarmi

 

You hopped right onto my townie, I see no problem with throwing a vote on you.  She's been helpful because she's explained about different aspects of the theme, and being active.  

 

There's no reason to be so sure that Cindy is town, especially if your sole reasons are explaining the theme and being active. Your vote on Csarmi requires an assumption that Cindy is obviously Town, and that Csarmi would have seen that as well, but there's nothing concrete to support that.

 

 

I actually haven't had any reads on Csarmi, so I'm not entirely what the big deal with him is, but I don't like this post:

 

BUNKER
 
Why are you really so quick to jump on Cindy?  She's been most helpful to town, and I for one am nearly 100% sure she is town.
 
Vote Csarmi

But you know what, I'll go ahead and take your points as if you asked me what my problem with Cindy was.
It's a general feeeling - you may call it a hunch, if you will. Something about her posts just bug me the wrong way. I'm playing this game on hunches for now. Not very scientific, I know. I believe that's often the best way to handle games with lots of posts.

Hally - why do you think Cindy's been most helpful for town?

 

Don't like the bolded at all. I know we all sometimes go a bit off of hunches but to advocate them as good when there's more content?  It would really muddle the scumhunting process if we could all vote someone based off of a "hunch" and call it good. 

 

 

. Bunker 

vote dap 

One dead townie at night. Dap claims ro have shot Basel as vig. I doubt that he is vig. Use of shot seems too uncaring. He was gonna shoot an inactive, then switched to Basel.

Also not liking those that appeared to support the decision. Csarmi is top of that list. Also still have eyes on Despo.

Cindy I am reading as town. Her outrage seems true and I further don't really like what appeared to be attempts to spin her up further by wombat and dap.

 

I guess thinking that someone is mafia isn't a good reason to shoot them? (and he certainly wasn't alone in that thought) Regardless, I don't think it makes sense to vote Player. One, his initial claim makes more sense as Town imo (what does he have to gain as mafia?  He had no pressure on him before; now he's being constantly monitored.) Two, if he did, it would have made more sense to claim a single, maybe two time shot. That doesn't look to be the case. Three, the best method of dealing with it is a wait and see. If he's lying, we should be able to tell within a couple nights based on who dies.  

Vote Hallia.

[csarmi]

is ok, I still think you're you

 

pretty sure aliens got to cs tho.

This.

Talya confirmed on thread that my correction was accepted. But you throw out a statement like that yet you don't have the decency to back it up with a vote. You're so scum.

[csarmi]

Okay so get this, I sort of goofed with the mod by putting it in a quote, but ultimately it was enough to affect the result though the mod felt bad about it. Mispelling was not an issue btw.

 

Silenced til the nect day since I was unconscious.

No vote because I couldn't speak my intentions.

Impervious to NKs since I was in the medical bay.

No affect from NA's since I was in stasis? (Questioning if that's the right term)

Unable to use any ability I might posess because, again, unconscious.

Told to be wary of more severe consequences in the future. Pafo for if this was specufic to me or if the penalties will grow nore severe.

 

 

Niel should be able and corroborate.

 

So yeah this is a lot of stuff dumped on anyone that should incur the wrath of Talya. I got to ask a lot of questions and oddly enough the punishment had benefits. Its all to theme as it can be though, quite brutal.

See the bolded: you spoke at night. So, for how long were you silenced?

[Darthe]

Yeahh mod forgave me..

[csarmi]

All praise our forgiving Mod.

[Talya]

Vote Count:

 

cindy (2): csarmi, Niel

csarmi (2): Wombat, hally

Wombat (1): Pral

Lenlo (1): NotBob

Dap (1): Turin

Hally (2): Darthe, Locke

 

Dilemma Count:

 

Bunker (13):  cindy, wombat, csarmi, Lenlo, Hally,  NotBob, Turin, Tina, Dice, Darthe, Pral, Niel, Locke

Stargate ():

 

(I'm sure I have missed someone out on the dilemma, got to go to work so will check later)

 

With 16 left it takes 9 to lynch

 

You have until 2100 on Wednesday BST (GMT+1) just over one and a half days from now!

[csarmi]

Not gonna be around today. Maybe from phone, but DM seems to play funny with the mail notifications these days so I can't promise that either.

[dicetosser1]

 

bunker

 

 

im wary of cindy because of that last inmteraction with dap tho i am leaning town on her. am unsure if i believe dap. i suppose if there is 2 kills tonight i will have to believe him

This looks like a setup. If he was 1 shot you've just justified a vote on him later.

 

 

the way dap is talking im under the impression he has multiple shots. assuming he is  a vig

[dapianoplay3r]

Ive never specified a number of shots

 

i wish i knew who the mafia targetted. If it was either of tge unconcious people they could both be confirmed towb

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

 

is ok, I still think you're youpretty sure aliens got to cs tho.

This.Talya confirmed on thread that my correction was accepted. But you throw out a statement like that yet you don't have the decency to back it up with a vote. You're so scum.

do I really have to explain that to you?

 

it's a joke, csarmi, referencing darthes comment that you've been playing like an alien, acting like you don't understand simple words and ideas.

 

you've taken your omgus on my foses on you yesterday, or your personal feelings based on my calling you out for pretending to be dumb, to a pretty silly level.

 

that's why I didn't bother to get defensive over your vote or your comments about how I bother your gut.

 

frankly you bother mine too.

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

Ive never specified a number of shots

i wish i knew who the mafia targetted. If it was either of tge unconcious people they could both be confirmed towb

how could they be confirmed town?

[Mrs. Cindy Gill]

ok, I could go for a couple other ppl getting votes but right now I'm gonna go for the most likely scum, IMO. nothing he's said has changed my opinion, not sure how he's dropped off the radar.

 

vote pray