[Basic] Die Hard for Mafia Game Thread

[Darthe]

 

UNVOTE

 

I'm believing the claim. Scum being run up day one would claim a power role.

Or vanilla town. I agree with you that iT's a good idea to keep a vanilla claim alive, but for different reasons.

 

Let's run up Not Bob and see what happens.

 

VOTE NOT BOB

I can get behind that.

 

unvote vote NotBob

0/10 would kill. Why wifom anyone eoses statement with yiur first remark? And then go on to agree? What are your differenf reasons and if your so contrary to the player then why are you following them with your vote?

[csarmi]

@Darthe

 

I don't believe Peace's argument to be a good one. That doesn't mean I can't have a town read on him (I still do). That also doesn't mean that I shouldn't be voting someone I've been finding scummy either.

 

The reasons for keeping a vanilla claim alive should be quite obvious.

[Darthe]

They are but you say your reasons are different. So I want to heaf them, gives tou less wiggle room.

 

Why do you find Notbob scummmy?

 

What do you disagree with Peace on?

[csarmi]

They are but you say your reasons are different. So I want to heaf them, gives tou less wiggle room.

Safety lynches/shots. Tactical reasons

 

Why do you find Notbob scummmy?

Tunneling on "vote selfvoters" and general FOS'ing Darthe while not backing it up with votes. He looks better lately with his pressure votes. But still someone worth pursuing, methinks.

 

What do you disagree with Peace on?

That maffia wouldn't claim vanilla on D1.

[Darthe]

Do you think it less likely for mafua to claim vanilla?

[csarmi]

Not in general, no.

 

It's a big cup of wine. But probably depends on the player, mostly.

[Darthe]

Good. You are still town.

[peacesells]

Darthe....time to venture an opinion.  We must have a lynch tomorrow.  No time to sit back and watch.

[Darthe]

You're probably not wrong, but seeing as my thoughts and opinions are already out what is left for me to do but push or consolidate?

[dapianoplay3r]

 

UNVOTEI'm believing the claim. Scum being run up day one would claim a power role.Let's run up Not Bob and see what happens.VOTE NOT BOB

Maybe, time will tell I suppose.Unvote

Lol Kaylee

Realised that the train wasnt going anywhere?

[peacesells]

What are you going to do Player?

[dapianoplay3r]

Check the VC first to make sure I don't do something silly again

 

vote not bob

Ill be around all day

[Hallia]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

 

 

Pralaya(4): Lenlo, Cloud, Darthe, Dice

 

Cloud(1): Pral

 

NotBob(3): Peace, Csarmi, Dap

 

 

Not Voting: Quibby, Luci, NotBob, Kaylee

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.  A deadline has been set for Friday, Sept. 20th at 7pm PST

 

[Kaylee]

Peace: I wanted to see reactions to the unvotes on Pral and my lunch break ended.

 

Dap: No, see my comment to Peace.

 

The fact that he wasn't hammered means he's town and scum were already on his train (not saying all of them), or he's scum and they're stalling the lynch. I'm not sure which yet.

[dapianoplay3r]

Peace: I wanted to see reactions to the unvotes on Pral and my lunch break ended.

Dap: No, see my comment to Peace.

The fact that he wasn't hammered means he's town and scum were already on his train (not saying all of them), or he's scum and they're stalling the lynch. I'm not sure which yet.

If you are going to use the reasoning that he wasnt hammered therefore he is town then all the mafia must be on his train.

The whole reasoning hinges on the fact that mafia would of hammered if they could

[Kaylee]

I actually also gave the possibility of him being scum.

[dapianoplay3r]

I know

And that was fine logic. No need for alterations

[Darthe]

I actually think it points to a more experienced mafia that chose to hold back for the right time.

[Andrej]

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

 

 

 

Pralaya(4): Lenlo, Cloud, Darthe, Dice

 

Cloud(1): Pral

 

NotBob(3): Peace, Csarmi, Dap

 

 

Not Voting: Quibby, Luci, NotBob, Kaylee

 

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.  A deadline has been set for Friday, Sept. 20th at 7pm PST

 

 

Okay, got the PM finally.

 

Reading along with the game, I'll give my impressions.

 

Luci is newb.

Darthe is Town along with Peace.

Kaylee bugs me with her over-explanation of everything. I don't like her WIFOM either about Pral's train.

Dice is probably scum. Seems like he's on that meta.

CS rambles a lot.

Pral has been defeated it seems. Kind of surprised he latched so strongly onto Lenlo for his reasons. Could go either way on his VT claim. I think it's bad form to give someone the benefit of the doubt just because of the phase and his claim that everything must be absolute. I would probably have done the same in his shoes if I were scum.

The Dap and Cloud exchange was exhausting. Seems like they like to tunnel each other, but I think both are Town for now.

NotBob seems to be playing the same way I saw him in another game. Short breathed and changes votes sporadically without much explanation. Generally I don't think it's helpful to Town.

 

Pral, NotBob, Dice and Kaylee. Biggest scum reads at the moment.

 

Considering we have D/L tomorrow evening and I might not make it:

 

vote NotBob

 

Let's even out the trains and see what happens.

[Darthe]

unvote vote notbob.

[peacesells]

I'm a bit surprised I haven't received 1 bit of grief for derailing that train.  Very unusual for some of the players here not to challenge me on that.

[Kaylee]

I know

And that was fine logic. No need for alterations

It sounds like you think he's scum. I'd that's the case why vote Not Bob instead?

[Kaylee]

unvote vote notbob.

Why the switch? After your last comment and the post before (I think AJ) voting Not Bob to even the train, the timing of your switch with no explanation feels off.

[Kaylee]

I'm a bit surprised I haven't received 1 bit of grief for derailing that train. Very unusual for some of the players here not to challenge me on that.

Maybe because some have a town read on you.?

[Kaylee]

Csarmi and I both quoted it and commented, don't remember if anyone else did.