November 7th, 1606: Day 4 (CONCLUDED)

[bgrishinko]

@Dap:  what the hell are you talking about?  Yates flipped TOWN in this thread, not symp.  You reference needing to check T2 - this is T2, silly.

 

I started reading Dap's case and all of a sudden assumed I was in T3 thinking he was making good points.... then you reminded me where I was. Now I am amused.

[Verbal32]

This far into the game, this makes me suspicious.

 

Dap is playing a clean game.  Too clean.

[bgrishinko]

Actually.... you know what, all of his quotes are from T3. So it still stands just for the wrong game. Seems like he just posted in the wrong spot.

 

Dap. Move it over to T3.

 

Maybe you are right Verb that he's been playing too clean here, but I'm going to have to say it was a bit suspicious of you for jumping all over Dap without checking to see if his case was in the correct thread.

[bgrishinko]

Wait... no... I'm wrong again. The vote counts at the beginning seem to be from this game, but the rest of the quotes are from T3.

 

Now I'm confused at Dap's points in general.

[Verbal32]

Exactly.

[Verbal32]

@ serra, pralaya, lenlo, and razen:  you guys plan on playing this thread at all?

[Pralaya]

Yeah, I am already in this thread somewhat. I am waiting for the night actions to end and next day to start.

[Razen]

Yes.  In the morning, if I'm alive.

[serra]

Yes I do, sorry. I'll catch up here and in T1 tonight.

 

Just from this page: I don't think scum-dap would be careless enough to misplace an analysis like that.

[Verbal32]

@ serra, pralaya, lenlo, and razen:  you guys plan on playing this thread at all?

Yeah, I am already in this thread somewhat. I am waiting for the night actions to end and next day to start.

Yes.  In the morning, if I'm alive.

Yes I do, sorry. I'll catch up here and in T1 tonight.

 

Just from this page: I don't think scum-dap would be careless enough to misplace an analysis like that.

Wow, I call out 4 people and 3 of them post one after the other within the hour.  Damn.

 

It is awfully hard to scumhunt and case people with about a dozen posts in a 38 page thread.

 

I'd bet my bottom dollar one of you is a scum lurker.  I never liked the lurking playstyle for scum - lurk at certain times, but the whole game thus far?  Meh.

 

We should perhaps lynch one of you guys tomorrow.

[Pralaya]

And, what is the definition of a lurker? Yeah, I might just have a dozen posts in this thread but if you do have a look, most of it are to the point and explains who i am voting or why. Maybe I should just spam and increase the post count and that would make me "active". 

 

Anyway, I have my suspicions and it is some 35+ hours since night started. I will post my thoughts when the day starts.

[Lenlo]

@ serra, pralaya, lenlo, and razen:  you guys plan on playing this thread at all?

Give me daylight and ill give you posts.

[WWWwombat]

Pretty hesitant to start day here when people are struggling with having day in 2 threads.

 

Everyone needs to be active across the board.

[serra]

The difference is, verbal, that scrolling through the recent page and responding with a one-liner only takes a minute on my phone. Actually going back through everything I've missed requires sitting at a PC for a decent amount of time, which I sometimes have time for, but sometimes don't.

[peacesells]

Some day day will start.

[Verbal32]

And, what is the definition of a lurker? Yeah, I might just have a dozen posts in this thread but if you do have a look, most of it are to the point and explains who i am voting or why. Maybe I should just spam and increase the post count and that would make me "active".

 

Anyway, I have my suspicions and it is some 35+ hours since night started. I will post my thoughts when the day starts.

I suppose. But one of those 12 is this post, and of the 11 others, these 3 were not game related, or barely were:

 

Call them ancient, medieval, modern ! :)

Not game related.

 

 

 

Speaking of playing these games collectively, I noticed this before but forgot to mention it. In T1, Wombat dies. T3, Darthe dies. T2, they both die. I think this could end up possibly being significant... like maybe this thread connects the other two in some way.

 

I could be over analyzing, but I don't really feel they would drop such an obvious hint/clue unless we were supposed to note it.

Well, it might be over analyzing. But, it would be awesome if it is something like Assassin's Creed. IF you are mafia in T1 and you get lynched, your current role in T2 remembers her previous birth and become mafia too. Heh, that would be chaotic.

 

Setup talk, and not even really that, comparing it to a video game.

 

 

Yeah, I am already in this thread somewhat. I am waiting for the night actions to end and next day to start.

Your response to my ping.

 

 

 

That leaves 8 posts that were specifically game related. A couple of those were you asking what WIFOM was and you unvoting because you needed to look more at stuff. So no casing or questioning involved from you there.

 

That leaves us with 6 true content posts. 6. I would not qualify that as “in this thread somewhat”. I’d qualify that as inactive.

 

I’m not trying to be a jerk, even though I know that’s how I’m coming across. How can people gain a feeling of town or scum on you when they really only have 6 posts to look at? There have been 764 replies to this thread. You account for approx 4% of the playerbase, but your posts account for less than 1%. It is almost impossible to get a read on you as a result.

 

THAT is my point.  Not that timezones suck (they do), or that some people have issues that crop up which impact their free time (I get that - happens to me, too) - my point is that I can't determine anything on your alignment because you are simply not here.  Is it disinterested townie?  Is it lurking scum?  Dunno.

 

So I propose lynching players that fall into this bucket.  If anything, I hope to start a movement of doing this across all games, so people have to actually play the game to avoid suspicion.

[bgrishinko]

I’m not trying to be a jerk, even though I know that’s how I’m coming across. How can people gain a feeling of town or scum on you when they really only have 6 posts to look at? There have been 764 replies to this thread. You account for approx 4% of the playerbase, but your posts account for less than 1%. It is almost impossible to get a read on you as a result.

 

THAT is my point.  Not that timezones suck (they do), or that some people have issues that crop up which impact their free time (I get that - happens to me, too) - my point is that I can't determine anything on your alignment because you are simply not here.  Is it disinterested townie?  Is it lurking scum?  Dunno.

 

So I propose lynching players that fall into this bucket.  If anything, I hope to start a movement of doing this across all games, so people have to actually play the game to avoid suspicion.

 

 

Here Here!

[Pralaya]

 

And, what is the definition of a lurker? Yeah, I might just have a dozen posts in this thread but if you do have a look, most of it are to the point and explains who i am voting or why. Maybe I should just spam and increase the post count and that would make me "active".

 

Anyway, I have my suspicions and it is some 35+ hours since night started. I will post my thoughts when the day starts.

I suppose. But one of those 12 is this post, and of the 11 others, these 3 were not game related, or barely were:

 

 

Most. Anyway, this is my first ever ever mafia game. Still figuring it out. Will post more in the future.

[lolguy26]

 

will this night end?

[bgrishinko]

Okay, so reviewing, I'd like to point out that Mr. Ree has not voted one time in this game.

 

Wait a minute... *checks post count*

 

Actually.... you know what? Mr. Ree hasn't even posted in this game.

[lolguy26]

......mods, maybe a tinsy tiny poke to ree to remind him that there are another 2 threads he isnt dead in

[Darthe]

Yupp, workin on inactive stuff right now.

[lolguy26]

appreciate it 

[peacesells]

lynch all lurkers.

[Verbal32]

 

 

And, what is the definition of a lurker? Yeah, I might just have a dozen posts in this thread but if you do have a look, most of it are to the point and explains who i am voting or why. Maybe I should just spam and increase the post count and that would make me "active".

 

Anyway, I have my suspicions and it is some 35+ hours since night started. I will post my thoughts when the day starts.

I suppose. But one of those 12 is this post, and of the 11 others, these 3 were not game related, or barely were:

 

 

Most. Anyway, this is my first ever ever mafia game. Still figuring it out. Will post more in the future.

 

 

I overlooked the fact it was your first game.  My apologies.  You absolutely get a free pass in your first game - my bad.