Merlin Mafia [Advanced!]- Town Wins!!!

[dapianoplay3r]

I wish i was drunk

 

bur you talked about a ypubg mafia with a guidibg hand

And you seem on your mafia game atm (bad play lol)

 

So, being arogant as you are, you think you are said guiding hand

[Darthe]

perhaps, but I would not have killed an SK who could provide my team with a quicker victory.  That was rubbish.  You use people like that.

[dapianoplay3r]

Fits with ypur inactivity though

 

no guidance

your poor team lost their way

[peacesells]

I am interested in TG, Mish, and Hally (mostly newer players that I have been mafia with or that showed interest in moderating and considering mafia theory)

 

 

Are you skimming?  Hally has claimed cop and it looks pretty solid. 

[Darthe]

It appears to me as if you are attempting to look like you're distancing from me, which will actually link us.

 

Is the point here to kill me and then use my flip as a way of hailing yourself more townlike?

[Darthe]

 

I am interested in TG, Mish, and Hally (mostly newer players that I have been mafia with or that showed interest in moderating and considering mafia theory)

 

 

Are you skimming?  Hally has claimed cop and it looks pretty solid. 

 

 

I am aware that Hally has claimed cop.  That doesn't mean she is cop and it certainly doesn't exclude her from being looked into.  That is the sort of lackadaisical thinking that loses games.  

[peacesells]

dude..she's claimed cop and character.  No counter claims. 

[Darthe]

I recognize that too peace.  Why not give her... nevermind.  Point is you seem to be white knighting a bit hard.

[dapianoplay3r]

It appears to me as if you are attempting to look like you're distancing from me, which will actually link us.

 

Is the point here to kill me and then use my flip as a way of hailing yourself more townlike?

...

That only works if you flip mafia

[Krakalakachkn]

 

Hell, I think David Eddings even did it to a small degree.

 

 

As for the game, I don't really have anything at the moment.  I just want to reiterate Mish's claim of not being on a mason team with Kaylee, nor mafia with her either.

 

Maybe I'm dense...but what is your point?

 

 

I didn't like it.

[peacesells]

What don't you like?

[WWWwombat]

 

 

Ok..so are you saying that you think that he has power with names and that's why Hallia has been blocked the past 2 nights?

 

Wombat..is my statement here accurate to what you are thinking?

Your statement is correct. But remember that I did use the caveat "crazy theory." Occam's Razor would lead us to conclude that Thorum's asking for a character reveal is probably coincidental as mafia would want to RB a cop anyways and gimping an RBer with a reveal mechanic seems odd.

 

All that being said, I believe Thorum has earned a lynch regardless of the theory I floated.

[peacesells]

ok..thanks.  If you would have said something like that to begin with it would have seemed less OMGUS and convoluted.

 

Also...I have to admit, I don't get Occams Razor..so not sure what you meant there.

 

VOTE THORUM.

 

Darthe and Mish could also garner my vote.  Though..I'm not as high on Mish as I was earlier in the game. 

[Darthe]

Occams Razor is the concept that the simplest answer is likely the correct one.

 

And Dap you have that backwards

[peacesells]

Occams Razor is the concept that the simplest answer is likely the correct one.

 

And Dap you have that backwards

 

Well that's simple.  Sheesh, I remember being in a game a long time ago with Mynd and Bgshrinko as there turned Occam's razon into a thesis in the game.  Why didn't they just say that?

[dapianoplay3r]

I solemly vow to never make that apply in my mafia games

[Darthe]

 

Occams Razor is the concept that the simplest answer is likely the correct one.

 

And Dap you have that backwards

 

Well that's simple.  Sheesh, I remember being in a game a long time ago with Mynd and Bgshrinko as there turned Occam's razon into a thesis in the game.  Why didn't they just say that?

 

 

In part because that is a barebones definition of it.  It is much beefier than this with its implications.  For example, how do you define simpler?  Is that less steps to reach a conclusion?  After all, mathematically less is simpler.  Or is it more logical choices used to reach conclusions and therefore analyze data?  Beyond that, how are you certain of what logic is correct or applicable and how much random/ stratified error are you willing to let slip through when you are inevitably forced to make leaps based on things you simply cannot know?  This is the basis of WIFOM.

 

And of course they probably didn't think to mention it.

 

Dap, you can't create games that do not have logical basis or you end up with... what is driving away experienced players on DM.  A hodgepodge of things thrown in because they look cool that cause the moderator to lose control of their own game.  

[dapianoplay3r]

I was joking

 

but go to the dm inactivity thread

policy lynch pact uou mmight like

[Razen]

Damn. That's not good :(

 

It's not good?  I must have missed something.  Didn't Chuckles flip vanilla town?  Could have been a lot worse.  It seems to me you're making a mountain out of a molehill.  It sucks that he was town, but he wasn't playing a game that was particularly useful to the town, and as such, he was lynched.

 

Vote: Thorum.

[Razen]

I could also vote for anyone who brought up that backup SK theory.  There's no evidence that I've seen for it, and anyone bringing up that possibility is either trying to fearmonger us into believing that there's one out there or is trying to use that as a red herring to cover something up.  I don't care for gaming the mod, and that's exactly what this sounds like.

[Vambram]

>.< Stahp blocking meeeeee

 

Clearly, the scummy mafia doesn't want Hallia to be able to view anyone. 

 

Mafia may have been fishing for an LD but that doesn't say anything about anyone still living.

 

Thorum seems to be trying to act scummy now, which is odd. Also, AJ seems to be less active than she was D1, which is curious.

 

Gonna read a bit.

 

 

Using Google and searching a bit through the mafiascum wiki, I could not find out what an LD is. So, let me ask y'all. What is an LD?

[WWWwombat]

Lie detector. A really boring role that for some reasons hasn't died yet.

[Darthe]

Lol, it is like a cop that has to breadcrumb to get any decent info.  It's main purpose is to sew WIFOM and be fake claimed by VT's so that scum can sh*t themselves

[Vambram]

Lie detector. A really boring role that for some reasons hasn't died yet.

 

Thank you.

 

Lol, it is like a cop that has to breadcrumb to get any decent info.  It's main purpose is to sew WIFOM and be fake claimed by VT's so that scum can sh*t themselves

 

Hmmm, this is pure speculation on my part, but what are the chances that Hallia could be fake claiming in order to allow the real cop of this game to avoid being RB by the mafia?

[Tigraine]

 

 

Lie detector. A really boring role that for some reasons hasn't died yet.

Thank you.

Lol, it is like a cop that has to breadcrumb to get any decent info. It's main purpose is to sew WIFOM and be fake claimed by VT's so that scum can sh*t themselves

Hmmm, this is pure speculation on my part, but what are the chances that Hallia could be fake claiming in order to allow the real cop of this game to avoid being RB by the mafia?

 

You don't think they would've been on her like stink on poo?